This one honestly hurt my heart…read more..
Y'all... this review hurts my heart to write because I am a Sweet Chick fan.
Not a "I tried it once" fan. A real fan.
I've been going to Sweet Chick since there was only one location in Brooklyn. I was literally traveling from Jersey to Brooklyn just for the food, the drinks, and the experience, and I never minded doing it because it was always worth it.
So when they opened the Ludlow Street location, I was excited because now I didn't have to make the trip to Brooklyn every time I wanted my chicken and waffles.
Back then, Sweet Chick was an experience.
They had the big specials board with rotating waffles, desserts, and seasonal items. Their chicken and waffles never missed. I honestly can't remember ever leaving disappointed.
So this review is really hard for me.
Back on June 26th, after work, my mom and I decided to grab dinner. I work in the LES, and she suggested Sweet Chick. I did tell her my brother Robert had gone recently and said it had changed a lot, but we figured we'd see for ourselves.
We got there around 9-ish.
The first thing we noticed...
It was HOT.
Not warm.
Hot.
Like, "why does it feel like a sauna in here?" hot.
We've had enough hot weather this summer, so walking into a restaurant with little to no air conditioning was honestly uncomfortable. We actually debated leaving before we even ordered, but decided to stick it out.
Unfortunately... it never got better.
The service also wasn't what I remembered.
I'm really big on customer service, and Sweet Chick has always had amazing service whenever I've gone. This time it just felt different. The attentiveness wasn't there, and the overall vibe just felt... off.
Even the menu has changed.
My mom used to love their kale salad, but now it's made differently with things like dates, and she wasn't interested in it anymore.
For drinks, my mom ordered an espresso martini, and unfortunately she really didn't enjoy it. It was pretty bitter, and we couldn't quite figure out what was off about it. If I'm ordering an espresso martini, I have certain expectations, and this one just didn't hit for her.
I ordered the Queen of New York, and I actually really enjoyed my drink. No complaints there.
Now... the food.
I ordered the Maple Chipotle Chicken & Sweet Potato Waffle.
And this is where my heart really broke.
Years ago, when they first introduced the sweet potato waffle as a special, I remember it actually tasting like sweet potato.
This one...
Honestly just tasted like a regular waffle.
I kept looking for that sweet potato flavor, and it just wasn't there.
The chicken itself was crispy and cooked well, but the maple chipotle sauce wasn't evenly coated. Some bites were really good, while other pieces were dry because they barely had any sauce on them.
Another thing longtime Sweet Chick fans might notice is the butter service.
I remember getting three or four different flavored butters, each in their own little container.
This time we got two flavors together in one cup.
It's a small thing, but it was one of those details that always made Sweet Chick feel special.
My mom ordered the Carolina BBQ Chicken with the Grilled Corn Waffle.
I'll be fair--her waffle absolutely tasted like a corn waffle. I tried it, and it was really good.
She enjoyed her meal more than I did, although she also had a few pieces of chicken that weren't evenly coated with sauce and were a little dry.
Overall, she thought it was okay.
And I think that's really the word for this visit.
Okay.
Not terrible.
But not the Sweet Chick we remembered.
Maybe that's why this visit hit me so hard.
When you've loved a place for years, you naturally compare it to what you know it can be.
I genuinely hope this was just an off night because I have so many great memories here, and I'd honestly love to come back one day and have the Sweet Chick experience that made me fall in love with it in the first place.
Because this restaurant has meant a lot to me over the years, and I'm rooting for it.
I really am.