- Birthday cake scoop on a waffle cone My daughter enjoyed it. Very popular and busy but line went by fast. They seem to have a good system in place. They have benches where you can sit outside to enjoy the bustling view of the main strip at Siesta Key. read more

A whole lot of flavors to choose from and everyone of them is delicious! We went with a Chocolate Fudge and a Strawberry Cheesecake in a chocolate dipped waffle cone! The ambiance of an old time ice-cream shop with a friendly staff made a great way to end our day. read more

Olaf's Siesta Village - Chocolate Fudge and Strawberry Cheesecake - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

See all

Great ice cream! We got a blizzard type treat, chocolate ice cream, and the triple peanut butter.

Great ice cream shop! Wide variety of flavors, rich & creamy. Would highly recommend. read more

Olaf's Siesta Village - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

You can tell Olaf's is a classic spot because of the long line! Everyone wants to get a scoop! Since we were waiting in the line, I wish I could see the flavors and menu sooner to be more prepared when it was my time to order. With the long line I felt pressured to be ready - but I couldn't see the scoop flavors until I got to the ordering part! But overall, chill out! You're in siesta key - you know? Enjoyyyy, relaaaax. It was great ice cream, a great value, and a great area to grab a scoop and walk around :) read more

Olaf's Siesta Village - Chocolate peanut butter and salted caramel! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

See all

I asked the guy who scooped our cones for kid size, since we have never been here before we thought that was very generous. As I went to pay, I told the young lady that I had two separate kid 1 scoop. She rang up two regular. I didn't notice until later my husband told me that she charged us two regular 1 scoop instead of kid's price and that was when I realized why I paid so much. But whatever, just be careful when you pay. My kids enjoyed their ice cream. read more

Olaf's Siesta Village - Strawberry & Cream. Superhero - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

Can't believe this was the first time we had ice cream here. This was great local Amish Ice Cream made by Yoder's. Which you can also visit in Sarasota. I tried several flavors including Key Lime Pie, Toasted Coconut, Blueberry Cheesecake, & Caribbean Rum Raisin. My Fave was the Rum Raisin. I also really liked the Toasted Coconut and the Key Lime was pretty Key Lime. Ordered a two scoop with Rum Raisin and Blueberry Cheesecake. Rum Raisin I could not stop loving and the blueberry cheesecake I tasted the cheesecake more that the blueberry. The person assisted us was there every step of the way and gave us all the samples we requested and ran our order up. We sat inside. Many people sat outside on the long bench. Next door is the Organic Gelato place so you can check both of them out. read more

After 20 years of visit after visit. I finally had a good ice cream here. I always thought this place was overrated, but it didn't stop me from continuing to go year after year after year. I never thought the ice cream had any real flavor but today I had a scoop of triple peanut butter and chocolate peanut butter and that is the magic combination. They consistently have friendly kid to work here which is nice. read more

Olaf's Siesta Village - Ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

Ice cream is so good! We stop here after every time at the beach or if we just come shopping. It's a must! Kids love it and beg us to stop there. Great prices and service is amazing. The workers are so nice and patient! The line is usually out the door but they get people through quickly. Sitting outside eating ice cream taking in the vibe and scenery is awesome! The cookies and cream is my favorite and the homemade banana pie is my wife's favorite! The kids love it all. read more

Olaf's Siesta Village - Mommas banana cream pie I believe is what it's called. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

We stopped here after eating pizza a few stores down and was not disappointed. We were all super full but still wanted to try some ice cream in town. I got the double chocolate fudge ice cream and it was super yummy!!! My boyfriend got the banana something and he liked it a lot. My boyfriends mom got the coffee bean one and she finished the whole thing. The service was great, I will say the girl looked like she was not happy but she wasn't rude or anything. Definitely a cute place to get some ice cream sit down on their benches out front and just enjoy! read more

Olaf's Siesta Village - Double chocolate fudge - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

See all

The best ice cream on Siesta Key! Amazing every time we come Every flavor we've tried is yummy and staff is so friendly read more

Olaf's Siesta Village - Chocolate chip cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

One of the best in siesta. Service is so quick, don't be deterred by the long line. Prices are fair and portions are large. So many flavors to choose from and they're all delicious. Definitely worth making more than one trip to try them all. read more

Olaf's Siesta Village - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

We were visiting Siesta Key today in 90-degree weather. We were thrilled to see this ice cream shop and walked right in! It was nice and cool! There was a big crowd in the shop naturally. My daughter ordered a double scoop of Cookie Monster and Praline Pecan in a waffle cone. I got the Butter Pecan. Both were creamy and good! There are very few parking spaces in front of the store. You may have to drive around a bit to find a spot if it's the weekend or a holiday like today. read more

See all

When you first arrive you'll probably see a long line out the door, but trust me its worth it. The ice cream is better than the ice cream you can get around in Siesta Key. I had ice cream 3 different location, this was by far the best. It the line wasnt so long. I'd have gave it 5 stars. read more

I love a good cup of ice cream after a stroll on the beach. Cute ice cream shop with a smell of homemade waffle cones you can smell a Mike away. It's minutes away from the beach. So many flavors to choose from. Great customer service. I got mint chocolate chip. My family got a mixture of flavors. All were delicious. Love the cream texture. Nothing like ending your evening with some fresh homemade ice cream. Looking forward to visiting again soon. read more

Olaf's Siesta Village - Mint Chocolate Chip - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

Visited 27Apr25:: My girlfriend and I love ice cream we chose this place because she loves Cookie Monster ice cream and I love mint chocolate chip. Hand scooped ice cream is the best! Got them in fresh waffle cone and bowl. Not stale or soft at all, def the best ones we've had. Lots of flavors to choose from. We also picked out two pieces of fudge, peanut butter chocolate and Twix. Service was fast, they def have it down to a science. We loved the seating options, inside or outside. Outside provided either benches or you could sit on their ledge and look out at the road or face the people sitting on the bench. We will def be back! read more

Lots of choices of ice cream and fudge. Conveniently right in the mix of restaurants. The staff try to keep the line moving.

Our little one adored her waffle cone and giant scoop of mint chocolate chip. Very tasty and the texture was perfect! Clean and airy little store with great staff. read more

A must for delicious ice cream every time I'm on Siesta Key!! Also friendly staff, and so many great flavors to choose from.

Good service. Asked an employee for any suggestions and he recommended the strawberry cheesecake. I love the cheesecake pieces inside!! Sometimes the strawberry sauce in it was a little too sweet but it was still good. read more

Olaf's Siesta Village - Strawberry cheesecake - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

My family and come to Siesta every 2 years and we ALWAYS make a couple trips to Olaf's each time. Their cookies and cream is THE BEST! But I got birthday cake this second time, and it's good too! read more

Olaf's Siesta Village - One scoop Birthday Cake cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

I had the soft serve with chocolate and vanilla mixed. The vanilla was ice cream, but the chocolate was frozen yogurt, which (for me, anyway) is a step below ice cream or frozen custard (and the reason for the 4 stars instead of 5). My wife had the triple peanut butter (hard) ice cream, which she said was fantastic. She gives the hard ice cream 5 stars. We went after lunch, so it was not crowded. However, the place does get packed in the evening. read more

Definitely great ice cream, they've been in the village a long time!! It's a great place to sit out front and people watch.

Yes, there were 12 of us so we basically tried almost all of the flavors toasted coconut. Keylime was awesome combo Chocolate fudge brownie awesome everyone was pleased the kids love the Cookie Monster ice cream. service was awesome and the servers were so patient. We had six kids. read more

The ice cream was awesome , definitely got our money's worth! A small was perfect to satisfy the ice cream craving ! The staff were friendly and helpful during the whole visit, Ambiance was inviting and fun. Definitely recommend this place to anyone looking for a place for a late night sweet! read more

Olaf's Siesta Village - Front of building - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

Back for the second time. My kids love the ice cream so much we had to go twice during this vacation. As expected, this place does not disappoint and we enjoyed their great selection of ice cream flavors. While in Siesta Key, is a required stop. read more

Ice cream was great. Service was absolutely wonderful. And prices are fair. Ice cream is also locally made in Sarasota Florida. read more

Olaf's Siesta Village - Chocolate chip mint - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Siesta Key, Florida

BEST ice cream. I love coming back here for the best scoop and service around. The staff is so sweet !! They have a large variety of flavors and cones and sundaes- pretty much anything you can think of. I have tried a few flavors and they never disappoint. The waffle cones are delicious! And the banana splits are divine. Plenty of indoor and outdoor seating. The decor is charming and is very clean! Seriously, the best ice cream. Cannot wait to come back! read more

We visited again a few weeks ago and once again Olaf's did not disappoint! We cannot wait to bring our son next year when he joins us on vacation! read more

Everyone wants ice cream from here, my first visit with 12 grandchildren, quality ice cream, PATIENT staff while some kids asked for samples! (Ugh) and each order filled happily, correctly and allergy questions answered and taken care of (tiny. Parking if you can find it) read more

False advertising. The brownie Sunday did not have a brownie. It had brownie crumbs. Crumbs! And the heath bar ice cream had no heath bar. How can you mess these up? But they did, and I don't think they care. read more

Great ice cream! Usually a long line but very quick service! Love the old school feel to it!