Solid pizza and food, but the menu is a bit overpriced for what you're getting. Service is good.

I only like there pizza and cheesesteak sandwiches Don't care for there pasta dishes read more

Located a stones throw away from a beer store so it was a convenient find for grub. The staff seemed like they were related and were very friendly. Unfortunately with the pandemic, the seating area was all closed off, but they had a lot of Friday evening orders for take out. The pizza came out in the amount of time they gave me and it was a great looking pizza. If you like a doughy, thicker crust and sweet sauce you'll like their pizza. I found it to be above average and a good balance of flavors. The sauce was a tad sweet which I prefer. The cheese was stringy and overall the pizza ingredients were fresh. I would definitely repeat, the establishment looked clean and well run and the people are friendly. It also helps when you make a good pizza! read more

Old Mill Pizzeria - Large plain pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sciota, Pennsylvania

Food 4 . Price 1. Ridiculous $34 for 2 cheesesteaks and 2 fry's. FJB. 85 characters shouldn't be required.

First (and last) time. Small meat pizza, doughy, mediocre at best. Wings were inedible. Tasted dry like they'd been deep fried before and refried as our order was placed. The small Greek salad - oh no! ( brown lettuce swimming in water or ?? definitely NOT made today.) $42 lesson learnt. Hope you find good help soon. read more

Veggie pizza with ham was fantastic. Service was quick and the staff was friendly. They even helped with next morning breakfast recommendations. read more

Old Mill Pizzeria - Veggie pizza with ham - Pizza Near Me - Sciota, Pennsylvania

Had a nice meal tonight. Service was great. Had Hawaiian Pizza and onion rings. Crust is very good, sauce is good .

The food isn't horrible, my girl liked the chicken parm and the pizza is good, just don't put dressing preemptively on your salad to go orders, and add some more chicken on your sadwhiches if your going to charge 9 bucks for them read more

Old Mill Pizzeria - Chicken Caesar salad they put the dressing on before giving it to us, its literally drowning - Pizza Near Me - Sciota, Pennsylvania

See all

This place is completely price gouging, I went in today and got a Snapple iced tea and two slices of pizza and it came out to $13.20. really? Last time I go there... read more

This is NOT the pizza place in Arkansas this is an entirely different place that has excellent reviews from everyone who has eaten here

Great local spot with friendly staff. Very fresh ingredients in both the pizza & gyro platter! Will definitely be returning. read more

Old Mill Pizzeria - a platter of pita breads and vegetables - Pizza Near Me - Sciota, Pennsylvania

See all

We have been eating at the old Mill since we moved to the area almost seven years ago. It has remained consistent the entire time. The pizza is always fresh, tastes the same as always and is reasonably priced. They also have other items on the menu that we have tried from time to time and those have been good as well. We keep adding up the pizza coupons and bringing them in when we hit 12 for a free pie! They also have a sit down dining area which is BYOB - I have not tried that out yet but hope to in the near future. read more

Have ordered from this place all the time for the last year. The last 4 orders we have gotten from them have been wrong. It's a shame when you can't get a simple order from a local pizza place correct. My wife and I have complained, they did offer to remake but after you have driven your daily one way commute of 1.5 hours, who is so willing to go back out to get your corrected food....again read more

Good, solid Eastern PA pizza joint. Great owner, service, place to grab a meal. Prices are decent, ingredients are fresh.....solid spot to grab takeout, do pizza with the family, or catch up with someone read more

I've always had decent pizza here. Wouldn't say it's the best but you won't be let down by he choices and taste

We've lived in the area for almost 3 years and found this restaurant right away. It's our go-to pizza shop whether we eat in or take out. It!s clean, the staff is very friendly, food is good and priced right. Tonight our party of 4 skipped the pizza. Two had chicken cheesesteaks, one had a traditional cheesesteak and I had a gyro. The restaurant also has a nice little party room that we used once. Their catering selections were very good and enjoyed by all. We recently discovered that one of our party guests enjoyed the food so much that they regularly visit, even though they live about 15 miles away! They've used Old Mill's catering service too. It's a great place for a casual meal. read more

Best food locally! BLT Sandwich, Hoagie & Pizza's always delicious. The reason i decided to write this review today is because we had their Gyro Plate yes it was $11.95 but soooooo worth it. Best Gyro meat i have ever had, plenty of food to fill you. the pita bread is so frsh. I will definitely be recommending this to other people. read more

I went here today for the first time because i was working in the area. I am from NY and all pizza around taste like shit. I was extremely surprised and pleased with their pizza. Nice thin crisp crust and great flavor. For sure the best pizza i've gotten around the poconos read more

Consistently good pizza from a family-owned business that is always ready before I get there to pickup. The dough stands out as being the best part of the pie. Sauce is not too sweet, but they do get carried away at times and put on too much...especially around the crust. I can't speak for many of their other food offerings as this is mainly a pizza joint for me! read more

Love this place, especially since my parents live a mile away...so convenient! The food is always consistent and portions are more than ample for the price. The pizza is my favorite in the whole world, I look forward to it when I come home from VA :) read more

Like a lot of pizza places....this one's average. Definitely willing to eat pizza here, but it is not going to be my first choice. Staff was nice, service was good and the place is clean, so it's a nice local joint to bring a family to. read more

Always good food, always good service. The pasta dishes are amazing and never watered down like you get elsewhere. They know how to drain spaghetti! read more

Hands down the best pizza around! Consistently GREAT pizza, delicious other foods and salads, and absolutely the most friendly and dedicated staff. We love this place! read more

We love this place. After our first visit, about two years ago, a order from there about three times a month. We have had every pizza on the menu and lots of different sandwiches. Our favorite pizza is the buffalo chicken. The wings are good too! I definitely recommend this place. Ooh and the Greek salad is awesome! read more

Best pizza I've ever eaten. Awesome calzones too. Play pool or video games while you wait. BYOB

We love going to Old Mill Pizza! When you go to Old Mill, you are in for a quality enjoyable experience. The food is excellent, the staff always courteous and professional. They listen to you if you have specific food preparation needs too. People from far and wide come here when there are many other pizza places around. So come check them out, you'll enjoy the visit! read more

Clean place,, decent middle grade food. Nothing wrong with the pizza, just blah, no passion taste. Slices are a little small. Almost like American pizza, not Italian American. But not bad by any means..I hate the plastic cups though.. read more

This place used to be really good. We had not gone back for about a year and it went all downhill. The pizza was so bland, all the vegetables in the calzone were from a can. Everyone is very friendly though but the food was just terrible. read more