Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Old Pueblo Grill Cantina

    4.1 (16 reviews)
    Closed Closed

    Order Old Pueblo Grill Cantina Takeout or Delivery

    Old Pueblo Grill Cantina Photos

    Business Info

    OLD PUEBLO GRILL CANTINA ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    More like Old Pueblo Grill Cantina

    Recommended Reviews - Old Pueblo Grill Cantina

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Wow! The chips and salsa really hit the spot!
    Gianna T.

    This place is a hidden gem! The decor is colorful. The menu was a bit daunting but our server was very helpful. We both ordered chimis. Wow! Huge! Flavorful! Presentation was wonderful! Try this place but come hungry! We will be back - often!

    Enchiladas
    Regina P.

    The food was great and they gave pretty hefty portions. The salsa has a kick which was such a nice surprise because Mexican restaurants out here usually don't serve spicy salsa. (I'm from SoCal so I know my stuff haha) The elote bowl was my favorite We sat at the bar and the service was so fast, it's a pretty big space and the music fit the vibe. We'll definitely be back!

    Red and Green Salsa, Guacamole, Queso
    Scott W.

    We are huge fans of Old Pueblo Grill downtown, so we have been anxiously awaiting its opening here in Webster for what seemed like forever. We started with salsa, guacamole, and queso with our chips. The salsas were both spectacular. Guacamole was super dreamy. The queso, however, was odd and something no one in our party enjoyed. We do love the queso downtown, which is what we were expecting but did not receive. Switching to entrees, we were very excited to see Enchiladas Montadas -- stacked enchiladas as we've eaten in southern New Mexico. We found the red sauce one to be really great. The green sauce version was very tasty, though the sauce had broken and/or seized up. Our additional companion ordered Enchiladas Suiza with green sauce. Again, the green sauce had good flavor but was not good consistency and they didn't end up finishing their meal. We are still giving the review a 4 star because this could be some bumps in a new opening. We will definitely return. We will definitely try the green sauce again, however, we will be avoiding the queso.

    Classic margarita and Prickly Pear margarita
    Harrison G.

    I went to the Victor, NY location and recall not being blown away by the food, however, I thought I'd give it a shot with full service experience. We started with chips and salsa and the birria eggrolls. As others have said, the salsas are great. The birria eggrolls were amazing. The eggroll is a great vessel for birria. Great flavor, texture, and presentation. I ordered the "Cali Swag" burrito. The overall flavor was great, however, the carne asada was a little fatty and the fries were kinda soggy but it was still an enjoyable item. My companion ordered a carnitas taco, carne asada taco, and the elote for an entree. She had the same complaints about the carne asada being fatty. But the carnitas were spectacular. Really flavorful and tender. The elote had good flavor but the corn was overcooked and lacked good texture. Service was a bit slow, but I don't blame my server for this as, as far as I can tell, she was also the primary bartender. The restaurant is a bit noisy and they played a weird mix of NBC Nightly News and World Whiffle Ball Championships but it also kinda worked so I can't knock it. This is a new place so growing pains are expected and I will certainly come back to try it again!

    Queso

    See all

    11 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    9 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Gianna T.
    16
    15
    21

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    7 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    5 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Kristin G.
    25
    61
    110

    11 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1
    Photo of Paul R.
    0
    125
    0

    11 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    Ask the Community - Old Pueblo Grill Cantina

    You might also consider

    De Land House On Main - White Wine Cheese Plate. Fresh Goat cheese, Brie, and Gouda.

    De Land House On Main

    4.3(4 reviews)
    7.0 mi

    So, we wanted something special for a Wednesday, so we re-visited what is basically a little…read moregastro-wine-pub in Fairport. In sum, it was kind of meh and overpriced. We started with a flight of mediocre (as it turned out) red wines; a Grenache, an Italian varietal, and a Cabernet. 3x2 or 6 ounces for $15.00. None of the wines were very good. We like to sample wines by the flight so we can drive up to Georgetown liquor and get a bottle. None of these were even close to prompting a visit there. For food we had a peach, tomato, quinoa, goat, and kale salad. We also had a cheese flight and I had the spicy meatballs. Expensive and very small portions. My meatball app was $15 and was 1 and 1/2 small meatballs doused in Frank's with a squirt of blue cheese. It was spicy as advertised but meager. Cheese flight was ok, but also $13 for not a lot. Spoiler alert: if their menu says 'shareable', it's not, unless one of you (or both) are fasting. Service was adequate and we got to enjoy the live music entertainment sound check (we got there before the actual performance). Guy banging on the percussion box: yes, it's way too loud for the tiny space. Usual server upselling of their overpriced menu items and drinks, but not delivering much in the way of hospitality or warmth. I don't think we would go back unless one of our friends wanted to. I think if you just want to drink and listen to live music, this place will work for you.

    Small Wine bar located in the basement of the building where Mr. Dominics was. Very attractively…read moredesigned , ceiling,walls, furniture. and carpeting all blend together. They also have several outdoor tables. It has a great menu, many wines and small plate food items. We had a nice salad and a Panini that was very good but there are also numerous cheese , meat, Olives , meatballs etc available. Service was excellent.

    Photos
    De Land House On Main
    De Land House On Main - Chocolate Salami! A yummy chocolate roll, with pistachios, amaretto, and cranberries.

    Chocolate Salami! A yummy chocolate roll, with pistachios, amaretto, and cranberries.

    De Land House On Main

    See all

    Avvino - Flat bread: onion, gruyere, and mustard aoli.

    Avvino

    4.5(424 reviews)
    5.8 mi
    $$$

    Our family was visiting Rochester from out of town to celebrate our son's college graduation. We…read morebooked the private room at Avvino (Meyer's Den), which turned out to be a great choice. While planning our dinner party months in advance, the communication from Janine was excellent. She helped us develop a 4-course menu that was sure to have something for everyone, including vegan and allergy friendly options. Amy was our server for the evening, and she ensured we had everything we needed to enjoy our evening. The chairs in the Meyer's Den are wide and comfortable, the decor is dark and classy, and being in the basement away from the dining room made it very quiet and easy to converse with family. The room is rather spacious for 12 guests, but could also accommodate a few more people without feeling cramped. Out of the appetizers we selected, the Charred Octopus was very popular and everyone enjoyed it...even those that had never previously eaten octopus. The baby cauliflower dish was also a beautiful presentation, and quite large and enjoyable. The salads, particularly the Charred Hurricane salad, were nice light courses before the entree was served. As for the entrees, the filet mignon was a little on the dry side, but we really enjoyed the light and crispy spinach fritters that accompanied the beef. The salmon was a generous portion of medium rare fish, and there was lot going on with that dish - spicy cauliflower and za'atar potatoes that had some mixed reviews. Folks who ordered the duck breast seemed to enjoy the complex preparation, which had asparagus, green beans, and two pureed sauces - cauliflower ginger and cherry-rhubarb. The doughnut bread pudding with apple pieces and vanilla ice cream was a delicious, decadent way to end the meal. We left rather stuffed, and delighted with the overall experience that allowed our family to celebrate together.

    One of my favorites in Roc. Always have a fantastic meal here with something new and creative on…read morethe menu.

    Photos
    Avvino
    Avvino - Filet mignon and spinach fritters.

    Filet mignon and spinach fritters.

    Avvino - Decor

    See all

    Decor

    El Greco by Mike - Roasted beet salad

    El Greco by Mike

    4.9(21 reviews)
    5.4 mi

    Rarely do I take time to write reviews. For El Greco by Mike, I make the exception…read more I have had the pleasure of dining here several times, and feel there is enough personal experience to develop a fair and honest review. If you enjoy Greek cusine, this is hands down the best Greek restaurant experience I have ever encountered in the greater Rochester area. Consistently fresh food. Reasonable service time. Attentive staff with great timing and not overbearing. (The owner makes time to visit my party every time I am there). The atmosphere is modern and classy without being tacky. It's a great restaurant for a first date or a special occasion. I like the quality and service so much I will go solo after a long days work and enjoy a glass of wine with some Spanakopita and Dolmades. The attire is casual (you could show up in a nice shirt and jeans and feel welcome), but business casual is where you would land most comfortably. I could spend more time on the menu, but I haven't tried everything quite yet, however I plan on trying everything here. The specials always distract me from getting what I had originally had in mind. I rarely write reviews, and moreover, I rarely give five stars...

    We came here because we had a gift card. I had not known about this place before so we were…read moredefinitely curious to try it out. We were not disappointed! The service was excellent and the food was even more so. We sat in a nice intimate area by a window which made for a special date night. We will definitely come back again!

    Photos
    El Greco by Mike - View from the entrance

    View from the entrance

    El Greco by Mike - Complementary bread service

    Complementary bread service

    El Greco by Mike - Appetizer consisting of blistered tomatoes on a nest of roasted peppers, topped with feta cheese.

    See all

    Appetizer consisting of blistered tomatoes on a nest of roasted peppers, topped with feta cheese.

    ROUX - Roux burger with fries

    ROUX

    4.0(282 reviews)
    4.9 mi
    $$

    Standout restaurant from top to bottom. Absolutely lovely hostess, bartender, and our waiter Joey…read morewas so nice and chill. We ordered the mussels that came with crusty bread, a cheese plate, salad, bougie fries, 2 drinks each and the crème brûlée. Everything was seriously so delicious. Cute restaurant and I see how they could get super busy on any given night. For my first time here, I was impressed by the quality of food and the authentically nice service. It was easy to make reservations the night before for a Tuesday dinner at4:30. Honestly there was no other party there but us for about a good 30-40 minutes so I would say a walk in on a Tuesday early on before 5:15 would entail in zero wait. Today was a gorgeous day but we sat inside for maximum vibes. Can't wait to come back!

    Went for dinner…read more Service was friendly and helpful. The cocktails, which I remember really digging, fell flat this time. I got one w rye and rubarb, and it just tasted like a mike's hard lemonade. The mussels were delicious, fat and tender, swimming in a delicious broth that tasted more Thai than French, but really good. Came with a little baguette. The salmon was good, but should be listed as an appetizer. It's under the word 'grand' on the menu which literally means 'big.' Besides being a tiny portion, the sides were only for aesthetic purposes, not for feeding humans. The plate was pretty but not fulfilling. No need to return.

    Photos
    ROUX - Bar area

    Bar area

    ROUX - Biscuits and gravy (& cute coaster)

    Biscuits and gravy (& cute coaster)

    ROUX - Enjoying a Transatlantic while our food was being prepared

    See all

    Enjoying a Transatlantic while our food was being prepared

    Lemoncello Italian Restaurant & Bar - Creme brulee (delicious)

    Lemoncello Italian Restaurant & Bar

    3.8(383 reviews)
    5.4 mi
    $$

    The food was delicious and the service was excellent! I loved my lemon cello chicken. The sauce was…read moreawesome. I also had a delicious chocolate martini and it was made to perfection. If you go ask for Kathy as she was an excellent server. I enjoyed my meal and time at the bar. I will definitely be back again.

    We made reservations for dinner to celebrate my birthday, just my husband and I. We were 5 min late…read morefor our 5:30 reservation but did call from the road prior to being late and luckily we were still able to get a table. There seemed to be ample tables still open. We were seated promptly at a nice table and brought water immediately. Our server Ryan came and told us about the specials and took our drink order. She returned several minutes later and took our orders for dinner. I was looking forward to the risotto because they always have a good risotto special, my husband had the limoncello chicken. Drinks came out and then the bread, nice and warm. The salads seemed to take a little longer than usual but the greens were fresh. Unfortunately that's where the good ended. We waited and waited for dinner. Tables around us that arrived after us were being served their meals. We waited patiently, making conversation trying not to feel annoyed. Ryan returned asking if we needed more to drink or more bread, no we still had bread. She apologized for the delay and said she would check with the kitchen. She returned 15 minutes later and said the kitchen was working on our orders. We were at 1 hour at this point, 10 minutes later our food finally arrived, it looked beautiful. The shrimp placed decoratively on top of the risotto, scallops lightly seared. The chicken in a creamy white sauce with linguini and fresh herbs on top. My first bite of the risotto was a disappointment, it was undercooked, more than a little al dente (risotto is not supposed to be any al dente). I tried different places around the dish to see if maybe there was some way to save this dinner, sadly not. We waited well over an hour for our dinners and it was undercooked. The scallops were good as were the shrimp so those were eaten. Our server did not return to ask how our dinners were. The chicken dish was good and my husband enjoyed it, brought half home as it was an ample portion. When Ryan returned she offered boxes, I declined since you cannot fix undercooked risotto. I explained what was wrong and she said she would let the owner know because he was helping in the kitchen. She returned with the wrapped up chicken and offered a free cannoli to compensate for the problem. We accepted, my husband ate it because I don't care for cannolis. We paid our check and left. I was surprised that if the owner was working in the kitchen and alerted to the problem that he didn't come out. I found that a bit strange, if it was my restaurant and someone said the special that was priced at $42 was not cooked properly I would come out to apologize for the problem. He did not, we paid the check and left. We have eaten there twice before and our meals were good. We do not eat out at nice restaurants often but because it was my 60th birthday we decided the occasion was worth the splurge. Sadly I don't think we will return based on the long dinner preparation time and the quality/price of the risotto. We don't mind paying extra for good food but this was disappointing.

    Photos
    Lemoncello Italian Restaurant & Bar - Outdoor patio seating.  Perfect on a rainy Sunday

    Outdoor patio seating. Perfect on a rainy Sunday

    Lemoncello Italian Restaurant & Bar - The lobster Florentine

    The lobster Florentine

    Lemoncello Italian Restaurant & Bar - Risotto with scallop special

    See all

    Risotto with scallop special

    Old Pueblo Grill Cantina - mexican - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...