I love this spot for a nice bagel sandwich. The bagels are fresh and soft. I got a lox bagel with tomatoes and onions. The veggies and lox were very good. The cream cheese was not as light and fluffy as I wished (tasted good but heavy - but this might be because I requested my bagel be toasted, causing it to melt slightly). The order came with a macaroni salad and pickle. The most stand out aspect is the price of the sandwiches. My bagel was $10.75 but most other places would be at least $13 without any toppings (such as Long Island Bagel Cafe). The ambiance of this place is not as brightly lit and as other bagel shops but the quality of the food cannot be understated. The service is always friendly and efficient. Good find and I will be back! read more

Old Town Bagels - Lox Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Port Jefferson Sta, New York

David is so handsome and nice! He is so attentive and has awesome customer service!! I will definitely come back!

Used to love their food and bagels, everything seemed good till I noticed a roach in the bagel display case... never again!

Great tasting bagels, great breakfasts and lunches, not to mention a very friendly owner. I always call and pre order my food and I've never had an issue. Everything's perfect. read more

I love Old Town Bagels! David's attentiveness to quality and customer service really shines through in every aspect of his business! The cream cheeses are my favorite and are always so delicious. If you want an authentic Long Island bagel shop with a great environment, this is a perfect spot. read more

Their bagels are awesome and so is everything else on the menu! The breakfast wrap with egg whites and veggies is a great healthy option. Weekly specials are always delicious. This is my go to spot read more

The service is great! The owner David is so nice and the place has a good vibe. Definitely a great spot for a weekend bagel.

Chan... Serving fresh...... hot/cold.... whatever your taste bud desire perfection..... A family loved bagel store..... Hard work.. dedication= SUCCESS IN OUR BELLIES...& COMMUNITY!!!!! We love it here!!!! read more

Don't order mixed bagels they give you the ones no one wants. Not even a single everything bagel forgot the 1/2 lb butter so we got a bunch of kids with dry onion bagels. Thanks no thanks read more

I love Old Town Bagels! Great food. Great service. All that I could ask for before I start my day.

One of the worst bagel stores and if they weren't so close to my house would have never gone back today. But this was the last time. My boyfriend went and got bagels & I asked him to get lox and raw onion... they charged us $25 for rotten, crusty lox & a rotten onion- not to mention not even cut! Wtf is this. Never in my life. read more

Old Town Bagels - Disgusting!!!! - Bagels Near Me - Port Jefferson Sta, New York

I go here all the time. The gentlemen at the front is always respectful, courteous, and helpful. I've never had my order incorrect or missing anything. Overall fantastic bagel store and they are good people. Thank you. read more

ordered a turkey sandwich and drove home for lunch. when I opened it the turkey was so old it was brown and smelled. do not recommend.

a bug in my food and a roach crawling on the counter when i went back to complain i'll never go back again !! so many bagel places in he area just avoid this one at all cost ! read more

Absolutely outstanding bagels, sandwiches, and service. Best bagels on Long Island, without a doubt.

You'd never guess by walking by how awesome this place is. You can always count on good tasting food, great portions, quick service, all at a fair price. What does it for me is the pleasantry of the owners and staff. Been going here for over 3 years and was always greeted by the warmest and kindest older Asian fellow. His son is just as warm and just makes the experience that much more enjoyable. If you're looking for a reliable place to give business to, this is the one! read more

Came in an hour before closing for an egg sandwich after my workout. As I watched the three girls behind the counter argue as to who was going to make my sandwich, one girl stormed off to the grill, cursing under her breath that she was closing the grill and how unhappy she was to make my sandwich - totally unprofessional and rude! Store has a dirty and old look to it- needs to be updated and cleaned. Also workers need to change their attitude and mindset read more

Horrible .... The place was very clean I have to say which really took me off guard... ok so I mean 1 job to make a great bagel ...I ordered a bagel with cr cheese. Was completely OVER COOKED hard and Not at all acceptable ..... we threw it out waste of three dollars! Plus going to my favorite bagel store to get a great bagel... i will never be back!!!! I should've read the reviews before going there. Giving this place a 0 out of 10. read more

If I could give no stars a would. I recently moved to selden. My landlord recommended I go this bagel spot. I've gone here 5 times including this morning every time I go into this place and walk up to the counter the guy looks down with a distasteful look because it's clear I'm gay when I walk when I speak my hand gestures and I know this to be true because I've watched his interactions with heterosexuals and it's clearly and obviously different. Above this my biggest problem with this place is every time I order the price changes every time one day it could be $8 the next it would be $10 for the same item every time which is a sausage bacon egg and cheese on a roll with extra mayo and a large coffee. These guys are crooks and are biased towards the LGBT community! read more

Never had any trouble with our breakfast order-eggs and bacon on egg everything bagels and coffee. Gentleman at counter always pleasant.

Incredible bagel spot! Just go! They have such fresh bagels with great prices! Customer service was outstanding as well, will definitely go back! read more

I read the previous reviews and did not experience any of that from them. The bagels were fresh! My daughter loved the blue berry bagels. I walked in and got prompt service right away! The Asian gentleman was very friendly. I would go back there again! read more

Decent bagel shop with 18 flavors of bagels in their case. I get excited that they have the super onion bagel as I'm an onion fan. Right next to old Town laundromat so I like to get food when dropping off my clothes. Staff seems nice, never had an issue. read more

Possibly under different ownership since the previous rather negative reviews. Now run by a very sound Chinese gentleman. Service very good and fast. I go there twice a week at 7 am and have no issues. Egg and bacon on a roll and a free coffee for $5. Quite well frequented. Bagels also fresh and good. read more

Slow took 20 minutes to get a bagel. The girl didn't speak English well everyone had to repeat there order over, and she still got it wrong stay away from here. read more

Manny T's review is dead on when he visited, but since then it has been taken over by a korean family and they are FAST. I used to NEVER go there since it was slow, a rip off, and it plain sucked. All of this has changed. They make my brother's egg sandwich the minute he walks in the door. It will take a while to change the horrible rep they had when that stupid guy owned it, but I think they have a winner. read more

The service is horrible with staff standings around having conversations while one girl works the counter the bagels are ok but with all of the other bagel stores around its not worth the trip read more

Grumpy, attitude ridden owner blew me off on the phone and while in his store. He was rude, unkind and not apologetic when he not only gave me the wrong order but also made a substitution with a food order without notice. I had to return to his store and he kept telling me, "I'm too busy" when I tried speaking to him. I understand he is busy but it's not the way you speak to customers or run a business. Perhaps he could hire more help and treat his customers with respect. I will not return. His store is over priced and you get no small drink to accompany an egg sandwich after such and such a time or if you don't ask about it before the time. No apology or way to compensate for his screw up and me having to drive back and forth. Poorly ran business! read more

One Star is pushing it ... Such rude customer service . Just called to place an order of egg breakfast sandwiches for 15 people . Couldn't get passed hello . The woman that answered the phone mocked me and got mad because I didn't hear her say hello? Put me on hold and talked shit that I overheard . Well guess what you lost my families business forever ... We were a long time customer . read more

This location is conveniently close to my house but I won't be going back. The bagels are good, big, soft and chewy. The coffee is just ok, no better than coffee I'd make myself at home. The service is awful though and is the reason I won't be returning. Last time I went, I paid with a 10 dollar bill, but the man at the register gave me change back as if I'd paid with a 5. I politely told him, oh I gave you a 10. I got an eye roll and a disgusted snort with my additional change, like I was being difficult. If you don't mind crappy service with an attitude, go ahead and grab a bagel. read more

I go here about every week enjoying a wonderful bagel and the workers there hard working as there ever be

The owner, the grumpy old man mentioned below, is extremely rude and acts like he is doing you a favor to serve you. You're lucky if you get your order right and if you're wrong good luck explaining it to him. You'll get an attitude and blown off. Prices are insanely expensive for the quality of food and appearance of the store. Ex. Two egg sandwiches (2eggs bac chz) and a nesquik was $14.50 no mention of free coffee even tho it's offered. I'll be going elsewhere for now on and suggest you do the same. It will not take long for anyone to experience this subpar experience shopping here. read more