Stopped by here after a wedding rehearsal. Pizza was delicious, gooey melty cheese. Service was nice. I think they need slightly more varied beer choices. There wasn't enough sours for my taste. read more

I honestly do not understand how this place has a 4.2-star rating. Maybe it is because it is a popular local spot, but my experience with the food was terrible. The pizza was absolutely disgusting. Even the basic cheese pizza tasted bad, and I could not understand how something so simple could be messed up. I would honestly choose Little Caesars or Domino's over this place any day. The only positive part of my visit was the customer service--the staff was friendly and helpful. Unfortunately, good service could not make up for the quality of the food. I would not eat here again, even if it were free. read more

Old Town Pizza - Disgusting cheese pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Lincoln, California

We stopped by Old Town Pizza in Lincoln and had a really good experience. We ordered the Classic Pepperoni and the Choo Choo pizza. The Classic Pepperoni was delicious! Our daughter ate the entire pizza in one sitting and said it was one of the best pizzas she's ever had. The Choo Choo pizza was also very tasty. We loved the garlicky cream sauce, the toppings, and the dough. The only reason for 4 stars instead of 5 was that the chicken was a little chewy. Overall, we enjoyed our meal and the experience. We'll definitely be back to try some of the other pizzas and dishes on the menu. The service was good and the ambiance was really open to family. read more

Old Town Pizza - Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Lincoln, California

See all

This is a fourth or fifth time eating here and overall it's OK, but nothing special. It is a great place for families as it's quite casual and many of the tables are large handling a number of diners. The atmosphere is "folksy" with a country appeal, lots of wood, brick walls, booths and rustic touches. There's also many large TVs with sports stations om (I've never understood this when you're out to eat a meal). Service is really good, friendly, attentive, helpful and prompt. We came with friends, for an early dinner, who made the suggestion to come here. It's OK, not my first choice but the prices are fairly good too. Our drink orders were taken in a timely manner and quickly delivered. I had an iced tea. We ordered a large Ceasar Salad which is quite adequate for 4-6 people. Dressing comes on the side. For a salad it's fresh enough but just ordinary. There's not much one can do with a Ceasar, yet this one is tasteless and watery too. For a pizza we chose a large "Legends" Veggie Lovers. It also came in good time, thin crust and an adequate amount of cheese and veggies, with an over indulgence of bell peppers. The tomato sauce was primarily at the crust ends with not much evenly distributed to the center. The pizza was so-so. Tasty enough but I can do as good a job, or better, with a Boboli at home. Bottom line. It's OK but nothing special. What I particularly found annoying was a pugent odor of what seemed like disinfectant when we first sat down. Not a good start to a meal. I appreciate they keep the place sanitized and clean, but UGH! Too much! I do admit it seemed to disipate over time. Yes, I would come here again. Perhaps try something else. It is convenient with good hours of operation. read more

See all

Called in an order around 6:10pm on a Tuesday. They said pizza would be ready for pick up in 20 minutes. Ordered medium caboose. It was ready as promised and delicious as usual! Great pizza! read more

Old Town Pizza - Medium caboose - Pizza Near Me - Lincoln, California

We always enjoy Old Town Pizza for dining in or ordering takeout. The food is always great. The breadsticks are definitely a favorite and something we look forward to every time. It is a bit on the pricier side, so we usually save it as a treat rather than an everyday spot, but the quality makes it worth it. The space itself is really nice, with a large bar area, rooftop seating, and even a separate party room available to rent, which is great for groups or special occasions. Overall, a solid choice when you're in the mood for good pizza and a fun atmosphere! read more

Old Town Pizza - Small pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Lincoln, California

For 100$ it was definitely not worth it. Our waitress didn't come back for refills, the sampler for almost 30$ was totally not worth it. The pizza was great I will say that but the service and the sampler was horrible. Very disappointed.... read more

Good customer service pizza was great and churros were amazing the place is really cute inside too read more

Old Town Pizza - Churros - Pizza Near Me - Lincoln, California

I've ordered from here 3 times now. First two times were okay. It's decent quality pizza. But the cheese pizza I just ordered tonight was unfortunately inedible. And I don't say this lightly... I am not one to ever throw away even bad pizza. But the cheese was SO so so soooooo salty, we had to throw it out and heat up Digorno. Such a bummer. giving 3 stars because the first two orders were okay and we were able to salvage the crust for "breadsticks" tonight lol read more

Great little pizza place. Love the Caboose pizza and the service was great. Will definitely go back.

The pizza was excellent and the service as well. Four of us shared a large "caboose". So yummy! First visit and we will be back! read more

Came up to Old Town for my aunts 80th birthday and we were in the big room in the back. The space is very spacious with real nice wooden features and dim lighting. Barn like style if you will. The service was amazing, the staff were so helpful and timely. Asking multiple times if we needed anything. The food was amazing! We got pizza, salad, wings, and cheesy bread. Everything was made to perfection. Down to their sauces. I had a seltzer that was also very good. Overall it was such a great dining experience and a great place to hold your next event! read more

Old Town Pizza - Pepperoni slice, classic salad and cheesy bread - Pizza Near Me - Lincoln, California

See all

Highly disappointed. We had high hopes, but the execution fell short. The pizza dough was soggy, and the toppings lacked freshness. Combined with slow service, it was a frustrating dining experience. We definitely won't be back. read more

We have been here a few times from out town. The ambience is great and the service is fantastic. We were there for a wedding party. They served pizzas, wings, cheese bread and salad. Everything was hot and fresh and the pizza is always fire. They handled our large party with ease and keep the food coming hot. They kept the drinks refilled and was a great experience. We highly recommend this place for a date night or a group event. I failed to get any photos this time :( read more

Bumping up to 4 stars based on several dine-in experiences. The pizza is really good when eaten fresh in the restaurant. No soggy crust issues like they had with delivery. The "small" green salad is plenty for 2 to share, or maybe even 3. Service is friendly but can be slow. On a personal note, we prefer Coca-Cola to Pepsi. But no biggie. The pizza is the star here. We'll be back! read more

Thrilled to see Old Town available on Door Dash. We are major fans of Old Town and are disappointed everywhere else because they are our benchmark for the best pizza. By far the best pizza in Placer County however when we got our first delivery, it wasn't even comparable to eating in the restaurant. Very little Italian sausage which Old Towns has amazing flavor, they scrimped with the sauce and linguica which we love on the Old Town Caboose pizza. It may have been a flaw tonight but one slice was basically only cheese. On the delivery, everything was safety sealed which is awesome when you use a delivery service. Thank you Old Town for doing that which most companies don't do based on the extra cost. Finally, we will try delivery again and we hope this was a flawed night but this post to let Old Town know, we want the same experience at home as we do when we visit. read more

Old Town Pizza - Caboose Pizza in the restaurant- huge pieces of sausage ( the best!) and linguica. No comparison to the delivery version. - Pizza Near Me - Lincoln, California

See all

We love Old Town Pizza in Lincoln, CA the pizza is delicious and you can order dough to make pizzas at home. Since there are lots of pizza pictures on here already I thought I'd share on this visit we had a calzone, the bbq sandwiches and a dessert pizza. Service is always great, the staff is always friendly and attentive. We love the location and feel of the downtown Lincoln area, it is quaint and cute. read more

See all

Pizza dough! I love OTP. I haven't found another pizza joint I am more fond of. When I found out OTP sells dough and I have been making subpar pizza with my Ooni, I had to try it using OTP dough. The price is super cheap and you can get it in small, med, large and XL. A small dough is only 2 bucks. I got home and topped the dough with my favorite ingredients and was not disappointed. It tasted like an OTP pizza but come on, not a quite as good. I will get my dough from OTP rather than making it at home as it makes a way better home pizza. read more

Great Pizza it's just that simple! Very nice setting and good atmosphere. I have eaten here many many times and they have yet to disappoint. All the staff are very friendly and eager to help. Looking forward to the next time I go there. Oh Yea, Excellent beer selection too. read more

Old Town Pizza - Great combo pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Lincoln, California

See all

Ordered from app, picked up at the pick up counter. Used the gc they so kindly donated to a local fundraiser. Hearty pizza with generous toppings ! Perfect ! read more

Old Town Pizza - Conductor (no sausage, add fresh jalapeno, w/white sauce Choo choo chicken - Pizza Near Me - Lincoln, California

Spencer is the greatest most personal waiter I have ever had! Fantastic pizza, great beer and vibe! Thanks again we love OTP. Tony is another gem. read more

Came in with family after a day out at the ballpark. We ordered a large Caesar salad and two large pizzas (caboose and bbq boxcar). Everything came out quickly and fresh. Our wait staff did a great job meeting our needs for refills and ranch for our pizza. The vibe is good and it's quaint and cute inside. I definitely recommend coming in for some pizza. There is also a side room that can be rented out for private parties. read more

Old Town Pizza - Caboose - Pizza Near Me - Lincoln, California

See all

Delicious ALL MEAT PIZZA (Small). It was cooked perfectly with just the right amount of red pizza sauce. Toppings were pepperoni, sausage and mushrooms and black olives and yellow onion. The crust was crispy which is just the way I like my pizza! Grace was my server. She was friendly prompt and accommodating. I will return! read more

Old Town Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lincoln, California

See all

Really good pizza and wings. Good beer selection as well. Server was really friendly and service was quick. Love the look and ambiance of this place. Definitely coming back. read more

Old Town Pizza - Pizza was great. - Pizza Near Me - Lincoln, California

Service was nice, interior was clean and nice aesthetic. Pizza was delicious. Crunchy yet airy dough. No hard liquor sold.

This is our SPOT! RAVING FANS , WERE DOWN WITH OTP! We have supported OTP Lincoln for about 7 years now! We have youth sports parties, family nights, friends nights, had them cater our party, ect. We are pizza conasuers, and Afficionados!! This pizza is so consistent, delicious and always on point. Honestly, the people make it great. The staff is always super professional! Over the top kindness and consideration, we get treated like Family! Steven, Spencer, Tony, Brenda, and all the staff, too many names to list, Rock.. They just know what it's about, the owners run a fine oiled establishment, that is service and customer oriented! You must try all the pizzas, they even have a Happy hour daily 2-5pm and after 8pm. They are so affordable and have a superb product. Try breadsticks and winds, also . There bbq chicken is out of this world. Their beers on tap are refreshing, so many options. You can always go to the connected sister brewery, SLICE! Pre game! The have TV for sports, a roof top, as you can see they offer alot. It's a local community staple! Catch us there 2x a week! read more

See all

Not as good as before. Much disappointment! Stars going down to 3. I gave them that rate as I noticed not many meats/vegetables on pizza. Looked like they were trying to cut something down in order to keep the cost low. read more

Food was amazing and our server Dan made it an enjoyable experience! He let us taste a few beers before deciding and was attentive the entire time. The wine was the cherry on top of a perfectly made pizza. We got the steam engine pizza and it was divine! Favorite spot in town! read more

Old Town Pizza - Cab and steam engine! Both Amazing - Pizza Near Me - Lincoln, California

I moved to Lincoln February 2008 and lived there for ten years. One of the first places I discovered that was fantastic was Old Town Pizza and that was at their old location. All of their food is excelent and in the sacramento Region they are one of the best pizza food places that exists. Okay here it goes ... My favorite is their calzone and in their new location I don't know what it is but it is amazing. Their pizza buritto is a unique option as well. Anyone who knows me understands that I appreciate bussinesses that give back to the community. For 10 years I coached as the Defensive Coordinator for the Lincoln Fighting Zebras and we could always count on Old Town Pizza suporrting our students and program. I highly recommend this place for your family or if you are a group. read more

My love for OTP dates back since they first opened and I can't believe I haven't written a review?! We loved it when they were across the street at the brick building. We love it even more since they've expanded the restaurant and added a rooftop dining area (which I heard will be closing) at the new location. Our favorite pizzas are the Steam Engine, Caboose and Lincoln Luau. Their wings are great and their salads are always so fresh! OTP is a great supporter of our town and you can always count on them at almost every function! Thank you, OTP for giving back to our community! read more

See all

3.5 stars. This visit we got the vegetable pizza too and it's hot since per request it came direct from the oven and it's good, a bit salty. The restaurants response to my previous review is funny. It is like a sports bar and like the last visit it's nice to watch part of a game. The 'perhaps' is condescending. read more

So as you can see I'm at Old Town Pizza once a week or even more at times I truly really enjoy and crave the pizza when I don't have it ! I been to the old location and when they first opened this one and let me tell you I love this location I loved when they moved to a bigger place . To me this is the best pizza in town how can anyone campare it to any thing else in Lincoln lol ! I have walked out of pizza places in Lincoln and no I'm not saying names but at the end of the day this is the best in town ! Everything looks clean and organized I trust them making my pizza . If a place looks dirty I can't eat there . The pizza slices are great portions for the price now a days food and fast foods are so expensive this place is very reasonable priced . Also if you sign up for the raving fans on their website you can get a discount . They have an amazing happy hours during the week . They have amazing lunch specials as well . They have rotating craft beers to choose from. Which are all from great breweries. They have a rooftop that has heaters for the winter and fans for the summer . They been having live music up there pretty fun ! They have a staff that is out of this world!! They treat me and my family like we are family we love coming in and seeing faces that know us from Tony , Spencer , Jade , Austin ,Chris , Joshua, Steven that hosted my party last year with the fab party coordinator, Jess - yes they cater also .. They must spend a lot of time training all employees and have a great environment because everyone looks happy and very professional which I knows comes from the top store mangers ect thanks !! At the end of the day I love this place I highly recommend it !! If you want great pizza with great staff of people come here ! I come at least once a week I crave it if I don't ! I will be going to OTP tonight for dinner super excited !! read more

See all

OTP is so hit and miss. Some days the pizza is great and other it is just okay. This time I ordered a small garden salad, it was $6.50 and two other pizzas. The garden salad was seriously pathetic! It came in a 5inch container that looked like they used 1 leaf of iceberg lettuce 1 cherry tomato and pinch of mozzarella cheese. $6.50 for this thing?!?! I don't mind the container size, but come on at least give the consumer more lettuce! The pizza was just as pathetic! The cheese on the pizza was only in the middle of the pizza not all over it. I get times are tough, but penny pinching quality is not a good look. Will not be ordering the salad again and might be going elsewhere for pizza. read more

So after years of hearing how great OTP was after moving to Lincoln. I finally pulled the trigger today and ordered some pizza and wings. I always thought they were on the pricey end but since the reviews were so good, must be worth it. Ordered the medium Conductor and medium Royal Hawaiian with 12 piece buffalo wings. Pizzas were so bad, very bland no real flavor in the sauce, the dough was raw and doughy, no color or crunchalmost raw. Wings had no sauce, it was more like a dry rub but again without any flavor or kick. Think Dominoes would've been better price better flavor and that's saying a lot. Very disappointed read more

Great food. Amazing service! the place was spotless. I really loved the food here and i reccomend it !

I like their beer selection as much as I like their pizza. Can't go wrong at OTP. It's one of, if not the best pizzas in Placer County.

Food was great. I accidentally ordered the wrong pizza topping and the young man helped me out and made another one. Very good business and great food read more

The cheese pizza reminded me of Costco with a bigger price tag. Service was quick. Having the brewery next door is awesome. If I were to go back I would be getting pizza with more on it. Their cheese pizza is not great. read more

Old Town Pizza (OTP) makes the best pan pizza in the Lincoln and Roseville area! I love getting the Lunch Specials that are offered every day from 11 AM to 4 PM. Changing daily, the Specialty Pizza Slice, which could be the popular Caboose or Choo Choo Chicken, is my favorite. The one time I ordered a slice of cheese pizza, it had been sitting out too long, so take a peek at the pizza offerings before ordering. I suspect the Specialty Pizza Slice is more popular and turns over faster. The Side Salad is a generous portion, and you are allowed to choose what kind of salad you'd like. I can recommend the Spinach Salad with feta, dried cranberries, and red onion. Here is a list of some of train-themed pizzas: Caboose = combination pizza with pepperoni, sausage, linguica, salami, mushrooms, yellow onions, and black olives Choo Choo Chicken = white garlic sauce, chicken breast, garlic, mushroom, and yellow onions Conductor = meat lovers pizza with pepperoni, sausage, linguica, and bacon BBQ Boxcar = BBQ sauce, chicken breast, pineapple, red onions, and bacon Lincoln Luau = Hawaiian pizza with Canadian bacon, pineapple, and CASHEWS Steam Engine = sausage, green and red bell peppers, jalapeno If you sign up to be on their email list, you can get a free dessert pizza on your birthday. The pizza is topped with cinnamon streusel crumble and vanilla icing. This is meant to be shared because it's the same pizza dough and about the size of a small pizza. One slice per person is plenty of dessert. This location has 3 large dining areas with door separators, so it would be great for families, large groups, or a private party. I like the rich, dark wooden interior. Lots of booth seats. There is even an outdoor patio upstairs that is open when it's busy, most likely weekend evenings. This is an easy, relaxed place to watch a NBA or football game. Several TVs set to sports. This is a great place to drink craft beer. There are about 15 beers on tap, and the selection changes over time as beers run out and new beers are supplied. You are allowed to sample before buying, and I believe the prices are lower than other local bars. What wonderful service! I'm a fan of the light, fruit-flavored ciders and chocolate or coffee-flavored stout beers. There are also bottles and cans of craft beer available: Check out the beverage fridges on your way in. I also noticed the menu prices have remained steady for many months, so that's considerate of management in this economy. Pizza for the people! Being in downtown Lincoln, you'll need to look for street parking. I haven't had any difficulty given I usually go in the afternoon. OTP is located on Lincoln Blvd on the corner of 6th St. If you want great pizza, order from Old Town Pizza! read more

See all

Delicious food. A little expensive but I don't go here for cheap pizza. A dine in experience can be slightly irritating. With staff not properly trained on good customer service, you better hope you got one of the good servers/hosts or prepare for nothing past the bare minimum. I understand high schoolers need jobs, but they should also be shown what proper customer service looks like. I don't blame the kids for that, I blame leadership. As far as ambiance goes, I believe the theme is "pizza restaurant". But honestly, that's what I go for. read more