Best subs around!! They are always so busy but the service is always so great. Kind and friendly staff. The subs are worth the wait! We always call and order a head. If you haven't had them you must give them a try! read more

I legit hadn't been since I was a kid. I used to BEG to go there for Italian subs, pickles, chips, and soda whenever we went to midway park in the summer. You know how sometimes you try something you liked as a kid and it let's you down (like chef boyardee or sugar bomb cereal)? THIS PLACE DIDN'T! This place is EVEN BETTER than I remember! *Mind blown* I highly recommend the Italian sub with extra oil. I highly recommend their homemade pickles. I highly recommend their buckeyes(chocolate dipped peanut butter balls). I highly recommend their potato salad (I threw some salt on it and omg). I also highly recommend you buy a bottle of their sub oil! This place has been family owned for forever and they truly are still amazing. They hit me in the nostalgia and far exceeded expectations. read more

See all

Quick service and the sub was good . The peanut butter balls were great. Would go back again!

The papoose was perfect, so tender. Roast beef was great as always. Meat is always high quality! Great price for quality. Tried a lemon bar this time, one of the best ever, perfect amount of sweet & tangy. Great chip selections! Homemade ice cream sandwiches in the freezer looked reaaaaal good. Ate to fast to take any pictures! read more

Great sandwich shop. Stopped in here love the sandwiches. Highly recommend this place.

We traveled from VA to NY to see the solar eclipse. We found this deli close to our airbnb, and it's just what we were craving for lunch on Monday. When we walked in, we were happily greeted by nearly every person behind the counter. They told us where the menus are and how to order. While we waited for our food to be made, it was obvious that the staff were having a great day, making each other laugh, and even including customers in friendly conversation. They had a cute little "ohh yeahh" chant when specific sandwiches were ordered. It seemed to be a steady stream of regulars coming in to pick up their lunches. We had the ham & turkey sub, Philly cheesesteak, and "the Larry" sub. They were all GREAT! Highly recommend this place for lunch. I'm sure they can get extremely busy during the summer season, but we noticed they were taking phone orders, so you can call ahead to avoid the wait times. read more

Best sub sandwiches to be had in the Mayville area. Served with an attitude, but nice folks. Some deli items. Very clean!

I've since moved away but this is the only place I will order subs in the area. My one request on my wedding day is I wanted subs from here for lunch! Highly recommend read more

Great place to grab a Sub, sandwiches or deli items. Their quality and service is outstanding, we are a regular. highly recommended

Best custom made to your order subs in Western New York -East Coast. Small dedicated staff who are excellent sub sandwich creators. Super selection of cold drinks, chips homemade deli type salads. You will not go wrong with visit to the Olde Corner Deli!! Just wish they were open all year long!!' read more

My dad went to the deli today. (We didn't get there last year). He was very surprised and extremely happy! He said the sub was great, the people were the friendliest he's ever seen there and the deli was the cleanest he's ever seen. Looking forward to getting over there more this year!!! read more

This is one of our favorite lunch spots around Chautauqua lake. The sandwiches are terrific!!

Lol the BREAD is amazing, stupid autocorrect. Anyways they made it past the covid wave and are still just as amazing. I don't know how anyone could be hungry for a sub or lunch and not have this be your first option. Everything they make is that good. My only complaint would be that they aren't open all the time, but that makes it special. If you're ever on this app looking forward takeout and you see this pop up, order from here. Trust me, I'm a picky eater and however they make the subs tastes amazing every time. read more

Got my order wrong with me saying no cheese twice because I have an allergy. Still made my sandwich with cheese. But they melted the cheese very close to the bread that I didn't notice the cheese will almost the end. Was sick as a dog after that sandwich. read more

I grew up eating at this place every summer because I lived within walking distance. This is by far my favorite little sub place and when I make the trip back to my home town every so often I try to make sure I stop by for a sub. read more

I was warned by people about the proprietor of this deli. Although the sandwiches were not bad I would not call them exceptional. I decided to give them a try anyway. It seemed OK and as I was leaving I forgot my railroad shirt that I had had for 40 years. After I got home I realized that I didn't have it and called and told them that I had left it they found it and said that they would hold it for me. I told them that I had to leave town that day and I wouldn't be back for three weeks to a month, as I was having my fourth grandchild and had to fly to Florida for the birth. Again I was assured it would be fine. It's not as if this is a large place with lots of employees were someone could accidentally lose it so I trusted them. When I returned from Florida I went back to the store the next day and they were looking for my shirt but somehow could not find it. I asked the proprietor and she said oh we have students who are working, And it may have gotten thrown away when they were cleaning up. They continue to look around and then I asked if possibly it was in the back and she seemed perturbed and she said "that's where I live". I was thinking to myself well that would've been a good place to put it if you really cared about your customers. I also think she knew exactly what happened to it as she was not saying very much. She seemed very self oriented and not concerned about anyone else. I had come prepared to get more sandwiches and other things as a thank you to them for holding onto it but apparently they are not very good at protecting your belongings. I just wonder if there's some sort of underlying problem that I am not aware of that the proprietor was having. I was very disappointed because of this and wondered if this is the way to keep customers. Not only that and I was not expecting anything but nothing was offered as well such as possibly a sandwich or anything to make up for it. Obviously I lost faith in this business and I would not recommend them. As I said food was mediocre but I don't trust the establishment. Normally I don't fill out one of these unless it's really really good or really really bad but under the circumstances I felt I needed to share this. read more

This place is super nice. Real good subs, I suggest the Cajun turkey. This has really cool, step back in time vibe to it. Great family run business. read more

Olde Corner Deli - Delis Near Me - Dewittville, New York

everyone there is so nice and friendl. they are happy to help with what ever you need and most importantly the food is AMAZING

Decided to try this place again after a bad experience last year. Sub was average at best. Not worth the price ($10) or the drive. I was in the neighborhood & hungry. So I gave it a whirl. Sub was very dry & the roll was extremely chewy. Last year I tried to order a Turkey & roast beef sub but was denied. The owner said we dont mix our beef with other meats. I tried to order a Turkey & ham sub but with Cappicola instead of ham. Denied again. I said cappicola is "hot ham" that should count, right? This sent the owner in a tizzy. She went on & on about why cant people just order from the menu. We dont make custom subs. We 20 subs on the menu, order one of those. I did but at another sub shop. read more

Best subs around. Reminds me of my childhood in New Jersey They only take cash though.

This is a local favorite and for good reason! Subs are excellent and there is even a genuine pickle barrel where you can snag one as a side to your sub! My favorite is Joyce's Heart Smart sub with thin sliced turkey, peppers and Joyce's special sauce. Their selections are many, each with devoted fans! The sub menu is a large one so you will have no trouble finding one to please you! They also offer a variety of drinks, chips and you can even pick up an ice cream treat or Hartfield Deli sweatshirt! Visually, the Deli is a funny old building with charm to spare, and has a porch that would challenge the most determined player of marbles! Go ahead...I dare you! read more

Honestly the worst experience I have had at a deli in years. Went in there after a day of hiking and once in there was told by the owner that they were out of rolls for the day. I asked what kind of bread they had an the manager rudely said to me, "weren't you listening?" However, they said they could make me one on white bread for a discounted price. So I just went with it. What this sandwich turned out to be was a thinned out sandwich between two pieces of wonder bread for the absolutely ridiculous price of $9.75. Never going back. Do yourself a favor and drive 10 minutes to somewhere else. read more

Want to experience an updated version of the Seinfeld soup nazi? This is the sandwich edition. Pretty decent sandwiches and salads for very decent prices. Service seems a tad slow. The entertainment or quandary about this place is the complete unwillingness to accommodate the customer's request. Don't even think about asking for an additional condiment. ..you're told NO! Phone in order had requested cheese on a meatball sandwich &the owner stated there wasn't room. Seriously? If you want some fun while you wait, read the featured sammies & what to not ask for as extra. Seriously ! read more

If you wish to experience the Olde Corner Deli, begin with a few questions: do I like to make choices? Do I want to be treated with respect? If you don't and would like an experience more akin to the Seinfeld Soup Nazi mentioned by another patron, this place is for you. If you like choices and respect, treat this place like the dark, shadowy place in The Lion King. When my friends and I walked up the steps on a Saturday afternoon, we were greeted by a sign declaring that there were no more sub rolls until Monday. Okay, this could still work. When a friend asked, what I assumed to be the proprietor, if the famous Larry Special could still be made on some other form of bread, she reacted as though she had been verbally sucker-punched. She essentially stated that such a feat could not be accomplished, but she would try anyway and rattled off choices of the bread that she did have. This seemed like a strange answer. What was the reason for the hesitation? After all, isn't a sub just an elongated version of a sandwich on a roll instead of slices of bread? But hey, what do I know. A little while later, another friend asked for the bread choices again. The same woman asked him: "weren't you listening?" This probably should have sent us running for the door. After all, when is the last time that you had an employee commit such a bold act of effrontery. We were promised a reduced sandwich price and decided to hang around. If you are fortunate enough to go on one such day in which the shop is out of rolls, don't worry; you'll be treated to a discount, alright...of a paltry $0.75. Then you can pay $9.41 for the coveted Larry Special between two thin pieces of white bread; you know, just like the ones you used to get for lunch in kindergarten. The only real tragedy is that Yelp doesn't provide the option of giving negative reviews. Do yourself a solid: go somewhere else. Anywhere else. Like Wegmans, for example. They like it when you tell them what you want. And they probably won't even insult you. read more

I went to the sub shop and order a meatball sub the way I want it myself and the The owner who I thought was very unpleasant informed me that they would not put lettuce and black olives on their meatball sub which I was quite surprised I was the one going to eat it not her anyway I ordered it not happy sub sucked would never go there again worst service ever they can keep their dried out subs hell I can make a better one at my house read more

Been a regular for years and love the subs here. The rolls they use are exceptional. The size and quality all speak to care in preparation. I live in LA and travel a lot. This place and Capt. Nemos in Chicago are the best I've encountered. Jersey Mike's makes a comparable product, but the rolls in downtown Hartfield or, as they call it, Dewittville are superior. So stop by if you're around the Chautauqua Lake NY area and picnic in the scenic rural surrounds. Yup, this is the place. read more

Still a decent deli. Not as good as long ago, but hey they pay more for supplies so do we. But I'm telling you this...the Smoked chicken on Rye is a deal and delicious. As filling as a whole sub but alot cheaper. Support local small business and stop in!!! read more

Best subs in all of western New York. Reminds me of the great Deli's of New York without the price. Rolls are amazing. Never tasted bread so good. My favorite is the spicy turkey with pepper jack. Meatball sub and sauce is also amazing. The place is stocked with some healthy drinks too. Don't forget to read the historic articles of life in the area. Don't be nervous if you see e Sheriff there- they are there for lunch - they know where the best eats are too!!! read more

Absolutely no regard for customer preference or service. Their menu is literally set in stone, so don't think about asking if they have banana peppers or other basic sandwich additions. My fiancé and I tried asking if they had any for our sandwiches and they responded with "we ain't no fancy place. We're not Subway, honey." The worst deli experience, period. read more

Excellent value in every way! One of the first things my family does when we arrive in the area is order subs as we have for over 40 years! They are individually prepared filled with generous helpings of anything you order. Be sure to get the delicious peanut butter balls or ice cream sandwiches. Most desserts are homemade daily. Regarding some of the other reviews that cited an impolite manager: if she appeared cranky, it is because she is on her feet all day, every day. She not only runs the entire operation, but works alongside her staff tirelessly. We have not ever experienced the claim that you cannot order extra condiments. Also, if you were privy to some of the rude customer demands I have overheard, it would be easy to understand impatience after a long day. I highly recommend this deli. read more