Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Crosby's

    3.7 (3 reviews)
    Open 5:00 am - 11:00 pm

    Crosby's Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Crosby's

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Crosby's

    You might also consider

    Andriaccio's Restaurant - Buffalo Chicken Wing Pizza

    Andriaccio's Restaurant

    3.6(155 reviews)
    3.9 mi
    $$

    If Andriaccio's were in L.A. (my hometown), I'd probably rate it a solid 4. But given its location…read morenear the Chautauqua Institution - where dining options are limited - it earns a full 5 stars. It's a must-visit for us every year during our week in Chautauqua. Andriaccio's has a large Italian menu, and because we've been several times - sometimes just the two of us, other times with friends - we've had the chance to try a lot of it. I'm especially fond of their pizza, but the pasta and steak dishes have also been consistently good. There really aren't any bad choices on the menu. Service is another strong point. Even when the restaurant is busy, the waitstaff is always polite, attentive, and unhurried. They check in regularly and make you feel taken care of without hovering. It's reliable, welcoming, and exactly the kind of place you're grateful to have nearby when options are limited.

    Such a beautiful restaurant we always get pizza and spaghetti from…read more 2.5 star experience today. We're really sad that we had such a bad visit this time. There were only 2 other tables and we had a long wait time on drink refills because our waitress was talking with friends while the kitchen kept dining the pick up bell for her for about 5 minutes straight. No sides come with the pasta dishes not even a slice of bread. Our food came out luke warm on ice cold plates. The flavor of the spaghetti and meatballs were amazing, but they break their noodles in half which is a sin and it was room temperature. The flavor of the Alfredo was very bland. The chicken had zero seasoning and it tasted like it was from a can or frozen and boiled with chunks of cartilage in it. I told the waitress and asked for seasoning or something to save it. Nothing did. I had 2 bites of it and left it all on the dish in a big pile. When the waitress came she looked right at it and I told her I didn't like it at all. She still charged us the upcharge for the uneaten chicken that I complained about twice. I always tip at the very least 20% everywhere, today I tipped $3.

    Photos
    Andriaccio's Restaurant
    Andriaccio's Restaurant - Eggplant parm

    Eggplant parm

    Andriaccio's Restaurant

    See all

    Cj's Pizza & Subs - Mmmmmm warm crispy but soft bread, gooey cheese and flavorful pepperoni!

    Cj's Pizza & Subs

    4.4(28 reviews)
    6.4 mi
    $

    4.5 star overall experience! Wow! Yummy! $36 getting the…read more$29.99 14 inch pizza 12 wing special adding on taxes, extra cheese, and an extra ranch. 5 star wings! You get 12 perfectly cooked crispy extra saucy delicious wings with a large Delicious ranch or blue cheese. Top notch. Literally finger licking good. 4.5 star pizza! Really great sauce, cheese, pepperoni, and dough. Only slight complaint was it wasn't cut very well and we were eating it as a picnic at the lake with no silverware or napkins so we were just tearing it with our hands. Messy haha. 5 star service from guy. Super friendly knowledgeable guy helped me order on the phone without a menu and it being our first time there. 4.5 star service from girl. She first accidentally rang us up for the wrong special ($50 something) which is an easy mistake, we corrected her and she fixed it. We didn't get any napkins, wet wipes, or plastic silverware in our to go bag which made a picnic eating wings and pizza not cut all the way through in some spots very tricky to eat haha. We were literally sucking the amazing sauces off of our fingers. 5 star cleanliness 5 star location in a plaza downtown(4 1/2 min easy drive from Barcelona lighthouse) 4.5 star prices (pretty fair, especially for 12 wings and large ranches)

    We love ordering pizza from here. Excellent pizza and the customer service is amazing.read more

    Photos
    Cj's Pizza & Subs
    Cj's Pizza & Subs
    Cj's Pizza & Subs - So amazing! We're really impressed by the wings and pizza there!

    See all

    So amazing! We're really impressed by the wings and pizza there!

    Truffle Honey

    Truffle Honey

    4.6(68 reviews)
    6.9 mi

    I'm making a bold but very deserving claim that this is the best culinary experience in the area…read more It starts with the beautiful design of space and layout, but also carried through to carefully chosen high quality ingredients at a very reasonable price, and an excellent service experience. Can we get this in a Michelin guide for those traveling to Chautauqua or Lily Dale? What did we have? A perfectly juicy selection of lobster tail full of its own sweetness resting on top of a bed of pappardelle pasta bathing in saffron cream and sweet summer corn for pops of texture. A lumpy deep fried crab cake that crackled on the outside and then fell apart into juicy flakes upon breaking the fried shell. A sour dough bread with herbed butter that melted between the half sliced folds holding it together until fully pulling apart. Iced tea and lemonade Arnold Palmer with flavors that kept us guessing and curious about the added sweet spice profile. Definitely coming back, perhaps every single meal I can when I'm in the area.

    Great addition to the Institution/Mayville-area. Staff are…read moreprofessional, attentive and pleasant. Owner is really committed to fresh in season local ingredients and creative/elegant preparation. Nice seasonal cocktails, impressively considered wine list. The menu has something for everyone, except maybe for anyone who wants a traditional meat-and-potatoes meal. (But still... They'd probably like their food!) Not for everyone, just perfect for most.

    Photos
    Truffle Honey
    Truffle Honey
    Truffle Honey

    See all

    Grace and Abe's - Hamburger

    Grace and Abe's

    3.7(69 reviews)
    6.5 mi
    $$

    Came here for an early dinner and had a very good experience overall. Our waiter was friendly and…read moreknowledgeable, and we started with the Maple Cream ale, 1 of 2 beers they make there. The giant pizza oven is part of the esthetic, so I ordered the Buffalo Chicken pizza which included smoked chicken on it, blue cheese crumbles and ranch. The pizza was good but it's the type of pizza where there's black soot on the bottom of the crust so it was messy to eat. Their menu is primarily pizza, burgers and sandwiches with a message that states "no substitutions", however they have a build your own pizza option as well.

    We had been visiting wineries and were hungry. We were looking for a place to eat and stumbled on…read moreGrace and Abe's. The garage doors were open in the front of the building so we thought we would stop. As we walked up we saw a few people. And it smelled good. They have a large wood fire oven. So everything has the open wood fire smell. They were out of a lot of items which was very disappointing. They have a craft beer section but most of them were out. And a few menu items were also not available including the wings which I wanted. That is why the score. The hours of the place are only open 3 days so it seems they ran out and aren't going to replenish till next Thursday when they are open again. I guess we are on the backend of the day when they have limited selection. We got the pizza, and someone got the chicken ranch sandwich and a burger. We liked what we got. We also got some of the craft cocktails. It was good. I also have to compliment our server Catie. She was darling. We love her. She is so hung out with us and we had fun with her. She made the whole experience really good. Would I try this place again. Yes, Catie was darling and the food was good. Just disappointing that they didn't have a lot of items.

    Photos
    Grace and Abe's
    Grace and Abe's - Buffalo chicken pizza

    Buffalo chicken pizza

    Grace and Abe's - Side of building

    See all

    Side of building

    Crosby's - convenience - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...