We had a "celebration of life" after-party for my brother at the Nottingham Tavern earlier this week, and I can't say enough good things about the care, accommodations, service, and the FOOD. They set aside the covered Pavilion for us (with just a few days notice) and it was the perfect spot for us and our 40 or so guests. I know it's easy enough to give people a room and a buffet but our guests kept coming up to us during the event and texting us afterwards about how GREAT the food was as well as the location. The stuffed mushrooms and pizza stood out to me, and they were so helpful with putting together a menu that accounted for some guests with dietary requests and kids needing chicken fingers :). I can't say enough good things about how easy they made the event after a hard day. Thank you so much to Sammy and Lucy especially for helping make things go so smoothly, and checking in with us throughout the evening to make sure things were going as planned. It was perfect. I would recommend this spot time and time again for events, and I can't wait to come back and visit on a regular day next time I'm in town for lunch! read more

Atmosphere is cooling bar. Excellent service are good. The old Nottingham cheesecake was out of this room along french fries and onion rings super special. read more

This is the local spot I wish I knew about sooner. What a cozy vibe! We came for pies on the patio which happens Tuesday nights. Great day to be there. Live music playing, heaters on for these cold winter days, drinks flowing -- all in their brand new back patio that reminds me of a rustic ski lodge. We tried their wood-fired pizza. The Hott Nott with hot pepperoni had the perfect kick, and the plain pie was simple but done really well. We got the disco fries made with Guinness sauce which are as good as it sounds. So saucy and cheesy. Then we had their signature wings -- we did buffalo and BBQ -- perfectly crispy and saucy in all the right ways. And you can't skip the cowboy burger -- juicy, messy, and absolutely worth it. Between the food, live music, and cozy pub vibes, plus also the attentive and warm staff, Nottingham Tavern is one of those places you instantly want to come back to. Which I hope to soon, for bingo night, karaoke night, dart night...! read more

See all

The Nott is back. Bar atmosphere on point. Come watch the games with your friends. Stay for the live music/DJs. Damn good apps and food. And oh yeah, pizza is on point. Crispy, little to no flop. I wish the toppings and sauce went more to the edges, but not a bad bar pie! Service team was great. Lots of helping hands and drinks were kept filled! Can't wait to go back. read more

See all

We went to see our friend Jerry Monk perform as well as have dinner. I called to ask whether it would be indoors or out and they said indoors. We arrived and it was outdoors where they illegally allow smoking (NJ laws ban smoking outdoors where food is served) and we had to leave. What a waste of time getting ready, dressed, made up and driving the half hour there! I am severely allergic to cigarette smoke. read more

I'm at about a 3.5 for this homey neighborhood bar. I really felt comfortable in the large bar area and the outside patio looked good too. The menu had ample choices, but tap list is lacking. We shared the zucchini fries as an app, very good! Good portion and instead of the usual red sauce it was a creamy parm sauce, I'd get again. My friend had a grilled cheese and tomato soup( they are known to have good soups) and thought it was good. I did the Nott burger, it had potential with a nice meat blend in the patty and quality brioche roll. But it was cooked past the requested medium and was pretty dry. The huge mound of fries couldn't redeem the burger, because they were stale. I think there are better options here and I'd be open to coming again to try them. I'd like to see a few more selections on tap to entice the hipsters here, but judging by the regulars who were on hand, that doesn't seem to be what the bar is about. read more

Olde Nottingham Tavern - Nott burger (ok) - Bars Near Me - Hamilton Township, New Jersey

Found this place while we were out and about on a Saturday afternoon. The bar had a cool vibe. Bartenders were very friendly. The food was just okay. read more

Super chill, good music, good drinks. The food not super. Super place to have great time.

Perfection is defined as a properly poured Guinness. Fantastic! Ordered the fish& chips only to find they got cleaned out over the weekend. We had two burgers, mine was very good... hers was overcooked and the waiter nowhere to be found. Fries overcooked too. I guess everyone has their off days. read more

Held a 60th Bday Party for my Sister-in Law in the Nott's front party room during May of 2025. From start to finish the experience was nothing short of perfection! Sam met with me beforehand to plan the food options. He is so nice, helpful and great to work with! Originally we wanted the party to be on their gorgeous patio, but the weather ended up being cold and windy. So, we made a last minute decision to hold the party inside and Sam and his team made it happen! John and Logan were our servers and they couldn't have been nicer or more hardworking. There was a buffet with Caesar salad, sausage, peppers and onions, vodka rigatoni and an array of wood fired, delicious pizzas. The front party room is modern and has TVs that were paired with our music. After the party, there was an fantastic band in the main restaurant area to keep the celebration going. Thank you to Sam and all of your professional staff for making my SIL's 60th a night to remember. Looking forward to planning future parties with you! read more

Place is super chill, good music, good beer, and hands down one of the best cheese steaks I've had in NJ. I'm from California and this cheese steak was the bomb! read more

Olde Nottingham Tavern - Cheese Steak, bell pepper, mushrooms, and I added jalapeños. Really hot and fresh - Bars Near Me - Hamilton Township, New Jersey

Good service. Bartender was great. local vibe good cheese steaks only knock was kitchen closed at 8 on Monday. They had bingo on Monday read more

Olde Nottingham Tavern - At the bar - Bars Near Me - Hamilton Township, New Jersey

First time trying this place. Have been seeing a lot of "marketing", so wanted to see what we were missing. I had big expectations. We ordered the classic burger with fries and onion rings with two cokes. I have to say, the burger was very good! The fries and onion rings were nothing special. The soda was typical bar soda with glass filled with ice. Seeing the bill for $56 really through me off. It was just burgers etc? But what annoyed me most for some reason was they charged us for refill on the Coke. Bringing the total for soda with the meal being $12. Yes, eating out these days costs a small fortune, depending where you go, but the soda thing set me off for some reason. Especially when the glass was nothing but ice. This was not a way to attract a newbie back to their establishment. And I really wanted to support local business. Sorry but I have mixed feelings whether I would go back. Maybe I have to stick to entertainment days and just get a beer - "maybe"? The place itself was a nice old neighborhood bar with nice improvements. Will see if we give it another try? read more

Highly disappointed. We wanted to get a beer and a burger on a Sunday evening. No spots at the bar for 2. We sat at a high top. Not sure if understaffed and the bartender was the only one working - no one said Hello, came over to us. We left. Maybe on a Sunday you have order at the bar - who knows - no one acknowledged us. We like to support local establishments. read more

This place was cool. Definitely my vibe, no cover, good drinks, live band, dive bar. i'd definitely come back

last time for us. our waiter was so dismissive. music was good. food was disappointing. we did not get what we ordered. The waiter just forgot what we said; fr food and drink. he never spoke to us until the check came. sad as i want to like this place.... not tonight. read more

Amazing soup. Great Guinness. Perfect pizza. The "new" Old Nott is quite the place & pleasant surprise as an upgrade to an old favorite. Will find many reasons to return. Kudos to new ownership. read more

Wasn't sure what to expect being from out of the area and popping in. What I did find was a delightful experience and surprisingly good food and plentiful portions. Sandwich's pizza salads were great. The wings were amazingly delicious and crispy read more

Last night was my first visit to the tavern, and as a one time Hamilton resident, I don't know how I could've missed this great place. The patrons are second- and third-generation so it's definitely a locals place. And everyone is friendly and welcoming with no airs or nonsense. The staff is attentive and know their stuff. The barkeeps know how to draw a Guinnes precisely correct. :-) I was told the pub was renovated during the pandemic and it's a pleasant and airy space now. I was there for my friend Danny Coleman's Rock On Radio Happy Hour, and that alone was a lot of fun. The music act, Bud B., was very good! I made some new friends and that was a nice gift to start 2022. The kitchen's yet to reopen but word is the burgers will be great. read more

Stopped in for appys and some afternoon brews & everything was great! Sat in the back open area & they had an awesome 80s/90s playlist on. The nachos were delicious, lots of local beers and my daughter had a great burger! Service was good and it was a great afternoon. read more

Wings are phenomenal! Love their signature sauce! Have also tried their NOTT tots and those were good too!

The 3 ladies bartending on Saturday night when I went with my husband to see a band were terrific. Always moving and helping customers. Wish the dance floor was a little bigger, tables made it difficult. Would love to see more live entertainment there. read more

As of late, been at karaoke night and WOW. It's like a completely different place. Packed wall to wall, but the fact that other coworkers from the local Amazon warehouses were there definitely added to the experience. Kitchen still has no improvement but at least the DJ had both newer (think 2010) and classics to pick from. It's a first come, first served but it was efficient. Runs until midnight every Thursday, and if you're looking for a mob scene with on-tap specials, this is the place to go! Only problem is parking is quite tight! So either plan to go early or prepare for a little hike. read more

New food is AMAZING! It has a huge soccer following (Liverpool), and great live music!

Clearly homophobic staff. The "food" they had were pretzels sitting on the bar in clear plastic cups. Tried to say I didn't have a tab open and had to ask 3 times. read more

Local, but haven't been in awhile. Heard they has food now so, had the Nott burger and was pleasantly surprised, was a tasty steak burger covered w/ blue cheese.yum. Crispy fries served hot and quick. Still great prices and great drinks As ALWAYS. Pleasant staff!! Who could ask for more. Parkings a little sticky but park across the street or round' the corner. Hope to see the menu expand. Still the so much of the old left it feels the same as ever, and better. read more

A great townie bar. Two American dart boards, shuffle bowling, Golden Tee, a great jukebox (now digital) and zero pretentiousness. This place is part of historical Hamilton Square and has been around a long time. I was told that "The Nott" was once a stop on the Underground Railroad. You will not find any fancy beers here. Yuenling and Coors Light on tap and a very easy going atmosphere. read more

Fun place to go. Great music and drinks. Love the atmosphere. Love when bands come to play.

Solid place to grab a pint. Cash only which is a little let down but theres ATMs on site and a bank across the street. If you like soccer, head here to watch the games. Prem league, MLS, Liga MX, they have em. Some people would be intimidated by it from the outlook, honestly dont be. Great people and good prices read more

Way to overbuild the tavern. I can't get a permit for a shed just around the corner. This build is out of line with what it was and a sore eye. Like to know how this was approved. read more

Historical building, but has been modernized with a nice back patio. Great place to see a band, even though it is a small venue. Good service read more

Quiet place to stop by and get a quick drink. Mostly locals but very nice people if you are in the area you should stop by.

Something or someone just a little bit off happens after 10pm in this place. Excellent venue for the unexpected.

So here's the scoop - somehow this place was listed as a restaurant, which is unfair to some poor traveler who's looking around for a place to feed his family (maybe they'll make you an egg salad sandwich or hot dog in the back, I don't know), so I've submitted a change request to "nightlife". (Yelp, you need a few more categories.) Great place to hang out if you want to get drunk cheaply and hear ignorant locals yammer on about a dozen worldly topics they know nothing about. (I find this supremely entertaining, personally.) Nice people run the place, good prices, plenty of booze, toilets work, what more can you ask of a locals dive bar? Four stars, baby. read more

Great watering hole to sit in and pound a way a few beers. I like to drink and this is what this place is for. You can drink and throw darts..... not at people but at the dart board. Beware the bathroom gets a little lively sometimes read more

Casual old fashion bar, friendly people, live music, relaxed atmosphere and good prices! A good find, I will go back!

Was just there. The place is open. Great place. Good drinks and good prices. The place is loaded with character. The inside is clean finding the parking is a chore but it's well worth it. read more

If your into getting attitude for asking the bar tender for a drink then this is your place! Maybe she was having an off night but won't be going back here again. We picked this place for my friends 35th birthday and ended up getting thrown out before they closed because some other regulars got in a fight with themselves and thrown into our table. Our half full drinks were promptly removed and we were told the bar was closing even though they were still open for another 30mins. Very odd as we had nothing to do with it. Note for your bartenders even though you were horrible. Clean up your tips quickly because the locals were taking them and buying drinks for themselves. read more

Does not disappoint! As according to the title, there were a ton of elderly people there. It was so funny to laugh at their stupidity and watch then struggle to feed themselves! The employees occasionally even pull a few pranks! That guy had no idea he wasn't actually a woman! read more

Unfortunately with the recent death of the owner, the fate of this bar is unknown. When it was under the old ownership however, it was a great quick place to grab a few drinks and to just relax. It was a nice bar with regulars who continued flooding in business generation after generation. No food however and no credit cards were accepted. I wonder what the fate of this bar will actually become. read more