We started out with the old town stuffers and they came out piping hot and full of garlic and cheese. I ordered the meatball sub with no sauce and they accommodated my request. Everything is made to order. My younger brother ordered the raviolis and said they were succulent and loved the meat sauce. My Mom and older brother shared the chicken Parmesan. They thought it was really good. My older brother loved his strawberry salad and shared it with us all. It was delicious! The server Paula was amazing and so knowledgeable! Our iced tea glasses were kept full and she was so friendly! The ambiance was like Grandma's kitchen. They already had their Christmas decorations up! We even got a meatball pizza to go for later. read more

See all

Highly recommend the pizza, calzone, salad, and we'll, just about everything. The staff are all friendly and courteous. read more

This is our favorite place for pizza. The staff are always so kind and the food is always delicious. The setting is classic pizza house with a nice warm vibe. We dine here often and plan to continue to do so. Highly recommend the thin crust pizza and whichever toppings you like, they are all good options. The Oprah salad is also a favorite if you are looking for something lighter. read more

Pizza is really good not as thin and crispy as am used to from Jersey but very good and quality of ingredients I am happy to enjoy when I come to Plant City. read more

Local pizza place that packs them in because they do a good job. Have tried numerous pizzas and all have been good. The deep dish does take an extra five minutes versus others, but they usually bring all pizzas together to the table. Also great is the strawberry salad. Big enough to spilt instead of doing side salads. It has great flavor and some fun surprises you don't get in normal salads like sugar walnuts and delicious strawberries. Service is pretty good. They hustle and are pretty intensive. Support your local pizza places! read more

Olde Town Pizzeria - Vegetarian pizza, thin crust - Pizza Near Me - Plant City, Florida

See all

We ordered pizza for pick up. The crust was the same as pita bread. Not much flavor from the sauce or ingredients. I wouldn't order this again. read more

I'd been meaning to try the Brandon location for a while so when we came across this location while in Plant City we decided to stop in for lunch. NEVER again. While the service was good, the food and value will not allow me to come back. I don't mind spending money but almost $40 for what we received was a bit much. The plate that the personal thin crust pizza was on was bigger than the pizza. The small portion of spaghetti topped with 1 meatball that didjt have sauce or cheese on (woth the exception of the shredded cheese dusting the did on top was not worth $14. And the almost $5 side salad (strawberry walnut) which everyone raves about was so drenched in an oily dressing that the lettuce was soaked/soggy. I know this company has quite a few regulars in Brandon but unfortunately we are one and done. There are much better pizza spots with better quality and value. read more

Olde Town Pizzeria - $14 lunch spaghetti and meatball. It's a hard pass for me. - Pizza Near Me - Plant City, Florida

See all

We waited for more than an hour for a supreme deep dish pizza as another waitress, "served our pizza to someone else." This waitress, a different one than our initial one, who made this mistake tried to make things right by offering us bread while we waited. By the time our pizza actually arrived, we were no longer hungry due to being so disappointed in their poor service and poor tasting pizza. Needless to say, no tip was given on this order. Unhappy customers who will NOT return to this dining establishment! Respectfully, Steven Nadon United States Marine Corps (Retired) read more

The service was good. I ordered the lunch special, half bbq chicken calzone, strawberry salad and side of corn fritter. The fritters and salad were good.The calzone was not, tasted frozen with way too much cheese and little to no chicken. I was given a dipping cup of bbq sauce that was cold. I would highly recommend for the strawberry salad only. read more

The very best salad ever! We had a new ce quiet lunch here today. Started with the Pizzeria Salad:aka strawberry walnut salad, it was amazing as always. We also had a thin crust pizza with chz & pepperoni. Perfect too. The tea was perfectly sweet as well. Really fun lunch! The servers were fast, friendly & efficient. Go see what you're missing! read more

Olde Town Pizzeria - Strawberry Walnut Salad - Pizza Near Me - Plant City, Florida

Pizza wasn't bad, but coming from Chicago, I wish they would change their sausage..The crumbled sausage is just not good..Service was wonderful and pizza was hot, just not a fan of the sausage.. read more

Olde Town is one of our best local eateries, especially for the variety of salads & delicious pizzas. Spaghetti, pasta dishes, calzones & sandwiches are great as well. Portions are always more than ample, enough for lunch the next day! read more

absolute treat! only had 3.5 stars but we decided to give a try. holy cow, so deserving of 5 stars. I upgraded the strawberry and candied walnuts to spinach rather than romaine, absolutely fantastic. kids pizza was fresh crust and a hit! also had the gnocchi, equally fantastic!! definitely will be stopping by when in town next time. read more

I've been here so many times and each time I think the same two things: 1. The strawberry salad is fantastic. 2. Any form of bread here is bland. I never salt food when dining out but I consistently have to salt the mozzarella stuffers, calzone, pizza. The rolls can get by but are on the cusp of needing salt. This was my first time having a calzone and it was decent with some salt added. read more

Olde Town Pizzeria - Pepperoni Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Plant City, Florida

The food was delicious! All three kids had the cheese pizza, my son ordered the meatball calzone, my daughter in law chose the White House pizza and I tried the cheeseburger calzone. All were well worth the price. Our server, Jen, was extremely nice and personable. It was truly nice experience after the trauma of Milton! Inside the restaurant is very warm and inviting. read more

Olde Town Pizzeria - Spinach loaf - Pizza Near Me - Plant City, Florida

Always a must go-to when in Plant City! it's the beat strawberry salad from a town known for their strawberries!

Ordered a Lg pepperoni thin crust pizza. It was not cooked enough and it did not have enough pizza sauce. So, I give it 2 . The strawberry salad was great and I give it 5 . Disappointed and I feel the quality has slipped. read more

Nice Decour place is spotless very clean! Service was right on never lacked for anything! My only complaint was that we had a deep dish pizza and it was not hot, our server reheated it but still wasn't that hot ! I'm assuming it's hard to cook a Deep dish pizza ? But it was delicious !!!!! I will try a thin crust next time seen some come out and they looked fantastic! Had a salad it was very fresh one regular is a enough for two people to share , which we did . ! Rolls very hot ! And the meal for all reasonably priced! read more

Olde Town Pizzeria - a slice of deep dish pizza - Pizza Near Me - Plant City, Florida

The Island Salad is to die for!!!! I love how fresh it was. I was over the moon there was crunch in my salad. I can't even tell you what was in it because all the flavors meshed so well. I will definitely make this a regular spot. read more

When I first when I moved to Plant City in 2017 to get menu for the apartment to order. When I first walked in with my New York hat on they insulted me cause this place was Chicago Style Deep Dish pizza! Making fun of my New York Style Pizza! I do not appreciate a behavior like that! I'm from New York City I'm entitled to where I come from and I love my New York Style! I'm never ordering or eating here ever! read more

The pizza is delicious as always. I also love the Oprah salad with ranch. Always enough pizza for leftovers.

Hello Italiano!!! Really good pizza & pasta! I'd only complain about when u go in and sit down, the portions of pasta are much smaller than when u order to go. But the food is all super yummy!! All they need are some desserts! ((: read more

Olde Town Pizzeria - Chicken parmigiana pasta ((: - Pizza Near Me - Plant City, Florida

See all

Mom and I come here every time I visit. The strawberry salad is always a must! We ordered the deep dish garlic chicken pizza and it was delicious but also the reason I only gave 4 stars. The menu describes the pizza as "Tender chicken breast, roasted garlic, and a touch of smoked bacon with butter garlic sauce." However, the pizza was SMOTHERED with bacon on top. We couldn't taste any garlic or chicken because of it. Mom asked me if they forget to put the chicken on it and I lifted the cheese to show her there was actually chicken. We could not taste it. We have gotten this in the past and the garlic smell was evident and welcomed. This pizza was not what we wanted. Still a good pizza but if you have ever had the regular roasted garlic chicken pizza you will understand why we were so disappointed. read more

Nice little pizza joint with fast and friendly service. Kid and family friendly, we tried the thin crust pizza but they have deep dish too for those who like that kind of thing. read more

I got pasta to go multiple times during Covid. Excellent quality, and very good portions. A lot of places, Togo seems to skimp a little, but not here. Fantastic value. The fettuccine Alfredo with chicken, and Pesto Chicken are both top notch read more

Felt rushed and portion was extremely small for the price. Tried to ask the server Summer for a refill and could not get her attention. Sat with an empty cup 1/2 of my visit. Also tried to ask for a menu to order more food and was not able to get her attention. read more

I really enjoyed lunch here, went with a few co-workers. We ordered pizza 1 Cheese & Pepperoni, had stuffed breadsticks. The best part was the garlic bread best I have ever had! It was really busy for lunch time but there were quite a few people that stopped in before going to the Strawberry Festival Worth the wait staff was nice and food was served in a decent amount of time. Will definitely return soon! read more

My favorite pizza and pasta place in town! The staff is always friendly and they give great service. If you come and don't get a strawberry salad, you're robbing your taste buds! My go to is their pizza. The deep dish is absolutely heavenly, and the thin crust is always perfectly cooked and loaded with toppings. The menu is large and they have really fun and different combinations! Not feeling pizza? The pasta dishes will not disappoint. Recently, I got the ravigetti & sausage! It was amazing. It's cheese filled ravioli over spaghetti and served with sausage (or meatballs) If your around Plant City you will not regret stopping in for lunch or dinner! read more

Olde Town Pizzeria - Ravigetti - Pizza Near Me - Plant City, Florida

See all

pizza was mediocre and service was horrible, they should be happy there isnt a jburns near by.

This place was packed and I guess it's always this way. For good reason. The pizza...had to try it, right...was fantastic. We got a large thin crust and for two people who are hungry this was enough with a little left over. Next time a medium will do us but the toppings of green pepper mushrooms sausage cheese....awesome. as busy as it was I thought we would wait a while but we didn't. Bathrooms were clean and all in all I would say I would love to come back to try their extensive menu some more read more

Olde Town Pizzeria - a pizza on a pan - Pizza Near Me - Plant City, Florida

Our favorite little place in Plant City. The Olde Town pizza is great and the strawberry salad is amazing.

This pizza place in Plant City is a very nice, clean, and friendly area. I love thier pizza's and calzones. Today I simply ordered a pepperoni calzone. Very delicious and filling. Everyone that I have talk to say thier deep dish pizza is really good as well thier strawberry salad. I did see someone order a deep dish pizza and it did look pretty thick. I don't come often here, but I do recommend the place, if you're looking a for good pizza in Plant City. read more

Olde Town Pizzeria - Pepperoni Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Plant City, Florida

We have visited Olde Town Pizzeria in Plant City and in Brandon several times through the years after finding it on Yelp during a road trip. The Strawberry Salad is their signature menu item and their claim to fame that will keep you coming back. I'm not a big salad or vegetable eater but this salad is always the first thing I have in my mind to order. Tonight we ordered one large one ($9.99)to share and I ate half of it (split between the two of us). Normally I'd have a small amount of a good salad. It is a pretty simple salad with romaine lettuce, fresh chopped strawberries, fresh shredded mozzarella, candied chopped walnuts and a strawberry vinaigrette dressing that they make in house. I cannot truly describe how tasty this salad is. We also ordered the Chicken Parmesan Dinnerwith linguini and a slice of garlic toast ($12.99) for one meal and a medium thin crust roasted garlic pizza ($14.75) for the second meal. The chicken Parmesan is enough to share or take home leftover. It is served with marinara and a baked on Parmesan and mozzarella. The Roasted Garlic Chicken pizza does not have a red sauce and it is nicely garlicy, not too much, it is just right. The thin crust isn't quite as thin as I'd like but it is nice. I was hoping for a crisp cracker like crust and this one is a bit thicker and a bit more doughy, but still very nice. Our server tonight is Courtney and she is friendly and just attentive enough. I drink a lot of iced tea and my glass hasn't stayed empty long at all. The restaurant is fairly small and the tables have remained filled throughout our meal. They are able to accommodate larger groups as well as small groups like the two of us. We definitely recommend that you experience Olde Town Pizzeria even if you only order the Strawberry Salad. I would have been just as happy if we only ordered the salad. read more

See all

I called to order takeout and 3 times in a row I was hung up on. I was asked to wait on hold which was reasonable but after a couple minutes they hung up the phone. After 3 times of this I gave up. They clearly don't care about customer service. read more

Menu is deep and the food is good, however, don't waste your money on adding mushrooms to your pizza as they are shredded so thin you can't taste them. read more

Olde Town Pizzeria - Pepperoni and mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Plant City, Florida

Excellent food, great prices and large portions. Service is always great. Great atmosphere.

Service is awful. Friday night and there are two waiters for the whole restaurant. Pizza took an hour. I couldn't remember the first time why I didn't return, now I do. Maybe they should hire some more people:) Strawberry salad was very good tho.. read more

I think this place is great! I love there pasta and boneless buffalo tenders. They always have great service and nice employees! The ambiance and decor are great and overall is a great restaurant. read more

Fist time trying this pizza place. We were excited to try their deep dish (Chicago-ish) pizza. What a disappointment. Ordered the supreme, added black olives. I swear to you we found one pice of pepperoni on the XL Pizza! Found two pieces of sausage (each about the size of a quarter coin). Pizza was close to $30. We won't be back. It was just a bunch of dough covered in a decent tasting tomato sauce. So sad. Run away from here is my recommendation. read more

Love this place! Great pizza and I must say strawberry salad is a MUST!! Try it!!! Reasonable price! Great service! Nice clean place and clean restrooms!! Servers are top notch!!! read more