Don't let the old run down restaurant betray the good food that we were served. Someone needs to take the time to clean the window. The lettering has seen better days. I found the rest of the restaurant very clean. I thought it was strange that the restaurant was empty on a Friday night. The lasagna was okay but they were out of salad so we really can't review the salad. The bread knots were delicious. The Supreme pizza was great. People online complaining that the sauce was light but I thought it was the perfect amount. We also got the chicken wings. They were delicious. We will definitely come back. Our waitress Bridgette spoiled us. The prices were very reasonable. Update: I got a brownie as I left. It was flawless. I hate when brownies taste like sugar. This did not taste like sugar. Chocolate all the way! The bill was $62 for two people with tip but we ate like pigs. Hopefully the next time that I also have salad. read more

Stefano Pizza And Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

Sat at the counter. I was immediately serviced. Ordered a small antipasto salad with house dressing, a plain slice and a drink. Then the counter person told me that I was getting the two slice/Drink special. Yay. Not exactly what I ordered but I rolled with it. For a Friday late afternoon the place was not busy, but started to get busy before I left. Notes on the pizza: Sauce tastes more like tomato paste and less like sauce. Cheese was melted but could have used better coverage. Crust was good but oily, not sure what that's about. If they used a less pasty sauce and a little more cheese coverage it might serve them well. It is a solid crust. Notes on the salad Salad was loaded with cheese! Veggies were fresh and dressing is fine. Herbs were overloaded a bit, but were fresh. Plenty of meat in the salad as well. All in all not bad. The staff is super nice. I'll be back and maybe will try a sandwich next time. read more

Stefano Pizza And Pasta - Antipasto salad - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

See all

I was honestly blown away that this place had so many 5 star reviews :( and I hate to say that about a small business but dang it's true. From the moment we sat I noticed bugs in our general vicinity (dead and alive), my husband ordered the special (2 slices of pizza and a drink) and I pulled a long black hair out of the cheese and sauce. I got the chicken parm and it was the wateriest spaghetti I've ever had, the chicken itself was okay. The garlic knots were dry. Service was okay. read more

Looking for a bite to eat for lunch and staying near the fairgrounds. This place popped up on my Yelp app. A definite Hole in the Wall vibe. Had a small Cesar salad, which was enough for the both of us to share! Ordered a small meat pizza with a couple added veggies (onions & Jalapeños). Perfect size for us to split. Two generous slices each. Waitress was awesome! Even gave us cards for free knot bread on next trip, since she it was our first visit. Will definitely be back! read more

Stefano Pizza And Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

Don't judge this place by its looks. This is your classic hole in the wall with delicious food and even better service. Very 'vintage' diner-like interior, with vinyl booths and counter dining. We ordered pizza and salad to go. The Greek salad was made with fresh greens and lots of olives, peppers, feta, and onions. The 'works' pizza was made fresh with lots of toppings. The crust was cooked well, nice and crisp on the bottom with a tender interior. If you're ever on this side of town - please try them, you won't be disappointed! read more

See all

Service was amazing, garlic knots amazing but the pizza was disappointing. Hardly any sauce or toppings. We had ours cut in square and there were quite a few pieces that had no topping and hardly any sauce so basically was eating crust. Unfortunately we probably won't eat here again. read more

Stefano Pizza And Pasta - Garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

See all

Short on meatballs in sandwich, roll cut all the way through, had to ask for sauce, real salty. Waited almost an hour. We went there about two months ago and it was great, I recommended it to friends. This time it was very disappointing and they have just lost 3 customers read more

Absolutely will be ordering from here again! Excellent customer service and fresh delicious ingredients! read more

Stefano Pizza And Pasta - Meat Lovers Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

Pizza is very tasty, quality ingredients. It just needs a little more sauce for my liking.

Great food and Service in this clean casual Italian eatery. Counter, tables, booths available for inside eating. Cheesesteak the best I ever had, heavily filled with meat, mushrooms, onions and 1/2 order enough to satisfy. Prices fair. Good find in an area not populated by many restaurants. read more

Simple small pizza joint that has good food & good prices, I'd go again John Johnson read more

Stefano Pizza And Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

First time at this unique little spot. Found it on YELP. We ordered to go and the food was ready on time. I added a Greek salad on site and rushed that out to me. Our pizza was delicious. White pizza add chicken . This was 5 dollars so I wasn't super happy about that for the overall price and toppings. It was flavorful. They do a lot if take out business , no one in the restaurant. I'm glad we gave it a try. It just wasn't a super great value for over $40.00 dollars . read more

Stefano Pizza And Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

Food is wonderful and the pizza is real Ny style. It's just a little hole in the wall diner that's serves up good quality food. Fast friendly service too. Give it a try for yourself and you'll see. read more

Walked in to a warm welcoming and great hospitality. The food was delicious. My family and I were not disappointed with one thing. The customer service was excellent! Will come back to dine here again. Highly recommend!! read more

Met the wife for lunch here. 12 noon. Sat and waited a while for us to finally be able to order. Tried to order spaghetti. She came back a few mins later saying they have no pasta......at an Italian food based restaurant. That's half the menu and the only reason I came here. So forced to order the fried shrimp. read more

See all

Came in today, greeted with a warm welcome from Janice. Service was quick and friendly. Most dishes made fresh, in house. Excited to try her recommendations!! read more

Staff is awesome and loves to see their customers. Everything on the menu is delicious especially the Stromboli and pizza! read more

Stefano Pizza And Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

Very good pizza.! Never had anything from here before since we are only in town for work. Close to the hotel and good reviews so we gave it a try. Glad we did! We ordered a large meat lovers with xtra cheese and mushrooms. Best pizza I've had in quite a while. Fast and friendly service, nice atmosphere. read more

Such a great place. Food was great and the service was even better. We had a meat lovers and garlic knots. So glad we were able to eat here for the first time. Must have!! read more

Stefano Pizza And Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

Very good pizza and worth the money. We are from Illinois and it was a great pizza. And the salads can be shared by a least 3 people. read more

Stefano Pizza And Pasta - Meat lovers - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

Stefano's Pizza in Tampa serves fresh, cheesy pepperoni pies with bold flavor and a nice garlic crust. The garlic knots were good as well as the service. read more

This place is your go to BBQ spot in Seffner or if you are traveling to Tampa. Family owned and consistent.

Highly recommend The food was enough for two people, they are NOT greedy. They went above and beyond on my order and being away from home they brought it directly to me. What a great service! read more

Stefano Pizza And Pasta - Baked ziti and more - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

See all

Super delicious food and friendly servers! I got the steak and cheese with raw peppers and extra raw onions then a side of fries, everything was so good! I love how the steak and cheese has mozzarella as the cheese on it, I'm very picky with steak sandwiches and this one was great. Thank you! read more

Amazing sugar powdered dessert! The customer service is amazing! The meatball parm sub is one of my favs but the whole menu is chefs kiss honestly. Everything is always so fresh to order and delicious! Very clean and welcoming energy. My night has been made! read more

See all

The food is very good. They are just short staffed. Only 1 waitress and 1 cook. I would still recommend it. The waitress worked very hard and was pleasant. read more

Nice little restaurant. Was Mary's Miracle Restaurant then a Hoagie place. We went in for our first time tonight. Very quiet we were the only ones there. We noticed a lot of people picking up their orders. The a family came in to eat. The have good prices on a lot of their food. We got the fried pickles, which were very good. A toss salad very fresh. A 16" meat lovers pizza. It was loaded down with meats. A light sauced thin crusted delicious pizza. Then we had a piece of Bakalava. It wasn't super sweet but had a delicious cinnamon and spice flavor. It was very well balanced. Will I go back, yes indeed I will. read more

See all

Great food, quality, prices and service! We decided to eat here after seeing the review rating and it was well-earned. It's a nice casual family style eatery. The pizza & salad is delicious. Ashley was friendly and a great server, too. Will definitely be back! read more

It may not look like much, but I was pleasantly surprised by this pizza and pasta place! The inside is definitely in need of a remodel, which can be a bit off putting, but they definitely make up for it with the food! I ordered a large white pizza and added chicken to it. It came with spinach and tomatoes as well and was soo good! The pizza is HUGE too, so it's perfect in feeding everyone! We ordered some stuffed shells, which were stuffed with ricotta and topped with a flavorful marinara sauce! This came with a side salad and garlic bread too- which was unexpected, but definitely a great deal! I ordered this for pick up and it was hot and ready in 20 minutes. I don't know if I'd enjoy eating inside at the restaurant itself- but I will definitely be ordering some pizza for pick up again! read more

Nice, old Italian diner vibe, authentic pizza with fresh dough and cheese. They let us pick our own seating and pay whenever we wanted, the waiter was very nice as well. They had large portions, ordered an 18" works pizza and 8 pc. BBQ boneless wings with fries and it was good enough for 5 people. Could've used a little more sauce on the pizza but overall a great pizza place. read more

Stefano Pizza And Pasta - The Works Pizza and BBQ 8 Boneless Wings with Fries - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

I needed a pizza for my kids while I was staying at a nearby hotel. I called in my order for a medium half pepperoni and half cheese pizza. The staff was friendly and told me when the pizza would be ready. The place was very convenient and a short drive. I got there and the staff said my pizza was ready. It looked great and was done right on time and nice and hot. My kids report that the pizza was an 8 out of ten on the pizza meter which is pretty high for them as they eat a lot of pizza. The cost was a pretty good value. I didn't get to eat any of the pizza as the kids even ate all the leftovers the next day. I would not hesitate to get pizza here again. read more

I had their pizza and wings special and it was good, the food was cooked quickly while I waited, tasted very good, and all of us enjoyed it. I got carry out, but they have a nice sized dining room area too. It was not busy when I was there, but it was an odd time of day. I'll be back for more. read more

See all

Ordered take out on our way back from a day of golf. Chicken Parmigiana with salad and garlic bread. Cooked to perfection. Staff could not have been more friendly and accommodating. read more

We're from NY, so have high expectations of our Italian food, Stefanos definitely exceeded those expectations. The best Italian food we have had since moving to Tampa. Our server Janice was also AMAZING, she gave great recommendations and went above and beyond service wise. This is going to be our new spot, definitely going to be back soon! read more

It's the best pizza I ever had in Florida, meets New York City standards'! I was amazed of the quality and taste of the sauce and toppings.

I had driven by this spot a hundred times and decided to give it a try for lunch one day. I ordered a salad and it was fabulous. I liked the salad so much that I ordered a Greek Salad platter for my office. The prices were extremely reasonable. The owner was especially courteous and helpful. read more

Spaghetti and meatballs were a 10/10 so was the chicken Alfredo and awesome customer service!

Great food and service! Both takeout and dining in have been good. Very much NY style pizza and can't go wrong with any of the salads offered. read more

Stefano Pizza And Pasta - Meat Lovers pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

Awesome food. Love the chicken Parm with a salad and garlic bread. Very yummy, very Italian and very filling.

Great Italian Greek restaurant. Family owned, generous portions and consistently delicious. My friends and I love to meet there for lunch or dinner frequently. read more