In a nondescript plaza is this new pizza joint. Small from the outside. They only make pizza. They know they are good at it so stick with that. And they do like the guy in Niagara Falls, "makes it until the dough is gone". So better to call ahead and have it waiting for you. They have one size. It's big. No single slices. No small. No wings. But it comes with your choice of a few toppings and is well made and cut. So easy eating from that view. They had some cookies that looked good too. They don't make them (best maid does). And they sell liters of soda. This is a very good sweet sauce Buffalo style thick pizza. I can easily see coming here in the future, even though it's out of the way for me. read more

See all

I've been to One Pie twice. Once at their new location, and once at the old. Each visit, the employees have been so nice. I really appreciate that. The pizza is phenomenal. They say that the pizza is fresh, and I believe that - You can taste it! The crust is a thick and fluffy Buffalo style, the sauce is sweet, and the cheese is delicious. It's not over cooked, but not too gooey. I'm a traditional cheese pizza type, so I didn't get any toppings. One pleasant surprise is their homemade blue cheese. You have to try it to understand what it tastes like. It probably tastes fantastic with chicken wings also. This place is definitely a Buffalo gem. I can't wait to return. read more

One Pie Pizza - Awesome box. - Pizza Near Me - West Seneca, New York

See all

I always pass this pizza joint and never stop. I decided a few weeks ago I would grab the lunch deal. Two slices and a pop for $7 and some change with a side of blue cheese. Can't forget the blue cheese! The owner has a sense of humor and seems genuine. The pizza was alright. I'm a pizza snob. I wasn't sure if it needed to be cooked longer or if it was the cheese. I order two cheese slices. You def get your moneys worth. I might go back and try them again. What another shot? It's reasonably priced and locally owned. read more

Always produce a very solid pie! We love that they include a blue cheese with your pizza!

Surprised how much I like it. Sauce was great. Was first time going there! Will head up again for sure!

Was in town visiting family and typically try to have a different pizza on each visit: I'm convinced all pizza in WNY is good, however, this place is fantastic! Pricing is more than fair in todays economy for what you get. Pizza is thicker than typical however is not doughy and rather tasty. The homemade red sauce is over the top; should be a staple ingredient served on all pizzas everywhere! I ordered The Italian 1/2 sheet, my only knock would be that the sausage was rather scarce. Highly recommend! read more

Long time customer, well before covid, but things have changed. This is the 2nd pizza that was noticeably thinner and completely lacked overall taste. To me, the sauce, cheese and dough all seems different. Used to love this place and the best pizza in buffalo. read more

Excellent pizza. I like the two pep conversion and the cherry bomb with sausage. I live 40 minutes away and make the trip every couple of months for something a bit different compared to what is around us. read more

This place is nearby and per the reviews I've been wanting to try this place out for sometime now...well yesterday evening we finally did lol the pizza was pretty darn good, ordered a half sheet cheese and pep with their homemade blue cheese and yes while it was $17 it was worth it because the quality was solid ! Cheese and pep ratio was perfect, I'm a big sauce guy and I enjoyed their sauce and we have enough left over for the next few days. Overall I'd say it was worth it and we will be ordering from here again ! read more

Great customer service ! Our pizza was SO good, perfect amount of meat, cheese and sauce . I love the idea of them making it a 1/2 a sheet. It's 10 slices and they always include a side of blue cheese. So glad we finally tried this place! Our new "go to" pizza shop! read more

One Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - West Seneca, New York

See all

Cannot go wrong with One Pie Pizza. This is the go-to place for me and my friends while watching sporting events. It is a little pricey, however, you pay for what you get. The quality of the ingredients is unmatched and the sweet sauce they use is spectacular. Do not hesitate to get a half sheet from this place, you will not regret it. read more

The pizza here is delicious and the staff is super friendly! It's pickup only and the only pie I've tried so far is a half-sheet of cheese and pepperoni ($15). It was delicious! Classic Buffalo pizza with a sweet red sauce and they gave me a side of blue cheese to go with the pizza. The blue cheese was high quality and seemed to be made in house. The pizza was delightful. The squares in the half sheet were cut fairly large so you could get more out of it if you cut it a bit smaller if you're feeding a larger group, but all in all I was very pleased with the pizza. Super pleasant and helpful on the phone and in person as well. Would be glad to order from them again! Thanks for the delicious pie! read more

This establishment focuses on the pizza so it was the only option available menu wise. And I guess it's available until it's gone as I'm assuming limited quantities are available for their extremely limited business hours. One downfall because I don't decide to order my pizza until at least 10pm most times and they close at like 8?? And I do usually like wings with my pizza but could always get elsewhere however it's the convenience of it all... This time I didn't mind because I wanted to try their pizza. Very good pizza, is one of my favorites, however the sauce or cheese does not like my acid reflux very much so unfortunately not the best pizza option for myself unless I want to pay the consequences once said and done. If you love thick dough and unique sauce, this is the pizza for you. It had a bitter sweetness to it that I enjoyed...Not to mention you get a free side of homemade bleu cheese along with every pizza. I'm not a dipper but it was that good that I did it anyway. Best part of this place is that sales tax is already included in the prices listed on the menu so no change necessary everything is rounded to dollar amounts and no hidden up charges that I tend to have to figure out at most pizza places as I'm picking up and get a new total. read more

One Pie Pizza - Mushroom and pepperoni half sheet - Pizza Near Me - West Seneca, New York

Most amazing pizza in Buffalo, hands down. If you like a thick crust with sweet sauce and all the toppings, this is your place! I get mine well done and it comes out perfect every time. Thank you for creating the best pizza I've ever had. read more

Finally got my second pie from here a few start ago. It was just as good as the first which shows this joint's consistency in making a great pizza! This time we ordered our pizza with pepperoni and cherry peppers, yum!! I also signed up for their points program, and a day later they sent me a coupon for $3 off a pizza. Awesome! Looks like I will be ordering again this week! Please keep up the great work and don't cut corners, you make the best pizza I've ever eaten! read more

Bottom crust was a little to hard for me, and the sauce just didn't pop enough. Could use more flavor. Cheese and topping were standard. Overall your middle of the line buffalo pizza joint. read more

One Pie Pizza - slices of pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - West Seneca, New York

Excellent all around- the pizza is delicious and homemade blue cheese is a great addition. Here's a new picture of today's pie! read more

One Pie Pizza - Half eaten pie...yum! - Pizza Near Me - West Seneca, New York

See all

Only tried them once, but omg they definitely leave you wanting more. The customer service was a miss but the food for sure made up for it.

Really nice pizza pie. Real nice owner. Tastes much different than other buffalo pizzeria's. Must try

Spoke with the owner today. Super nice customer service, when the order was taken. Great smile and presence of customer service when walking in. Extremely clean, well designed pizza place. The pizza was awesome! The sauce is a sweet sauce, the dough was perfectly baked the crust was present but just about to hide on the edge of the pizza. They follow up with what they say they will, the best ingredients is their watchword. They nailed it. Will will be repeat customers. read more

One Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - West Seneca, New York

See all

My new favorite Buffalo pizza place! I have had their pizza a couple times in the last few months. If you like "tray pizza" as I call it with the sauce all the way out to the edge, golden crust, and a sweet sauce, this place is for you. I do not have one style of pizza in Buffalo I favor, but I like this to mix it up. They are only open 3-8pm on weekdays, or until they sell out, and just focus on the 1/2 sheet sized pizza, so if you are looking for appetizers, wings, etc, they don't have it (usually). I have seen some specials they will run for gnocchi or meatballs, but those are not regular menu items. They have point system tied to your phone that sends coupons (I just got a $4 off pizza+1 topping, making it $12!) and easy location across from Dick Rd Wegmans next to Valu. I have ordered 3-5 pm and my pizza has been ready in 15-20 minutes. Their toppings are very fresh and plentiful. I've mainly gotten veggies as topping so far though, though got pepperoni once and it was great too, and I only eat pepperoni pizza about once a year. For the vegetables, they have fresh red onions and large covering of mushrooms. Would love to see red peppers as a topping/mixed with the green. Lots of cheese and the sauce is sweet, but not too much. The crust is cooked evenly with a buttery, golden finish thanks to the tray + conveyor ovens. They do only slice the sheet into 10 larger pieces which are very filling, but cut into 20 pieces, they would still be plenty big enough for a crowd. They feature a homemade "secret ingredient" blue cheese which they include one container with each pizza. I love blue cheese, but I have to say I personally don't like this. It is way too salty for my taste, and seems closer to ranch than blue cheese. I've tried it a couple of times, but I will pass. When I have said I didn't want the blue cheese, they were kind enough to offer me a pop. Not a big deal, I come here for the pizza! I totally recommend checking them out, One Pie is my "One Pie" in town for right now! read more

See all

Outstanding PIE! The sauce is a bit sweet but what a fantastic flavor and they obviously use all fresh, high quality ingredients! They make their own blue cheese which is outstanding, they really should sell it seperatly in a larger container, just as good if not better than Rooties! Owners and staff there are always friendly and helpful, great run business! read more

Favorite pizza place right now. Their toppings are fresh, their tomato sauce is sweet and chunky, their dough is chewy and delicious with a crispy edge. They are not skimping on quality to make bigger profits. I would recommend this place for pizza without batting an eye. I even love their blue cheese sauce, which I thought was super weird at first. Then I started grabbing a bag of carrots from Wegman's across the street and have never looked back. It's legit good blue cheese with chunks of the real stuff in it! I think I'm done trying new places for pizza now. read more

Went in for lunch slices. The deal was great but the pizza was awful. Looked and tasted like a frozen pizza. Pepperoni covered the entire thing, cheese and crust seemed frozen. The crust also looked and tasted like it was a pre made ordered crust. Would not go back read more

Easily my favorite local pizza place now, after trying it once (and I have since been back more). My wife and I have been experimenting with as many pizza places as possible around us, a mission which usually ends in tears and regret, but this is definitely the winner so far! Great, friendly service, with an efficient menu (other pizza places take not: focus on the pizza -- you don't need an entire menu of other junk!), and always quality ingredients as toppings. The house bleu cheese sauce adds another unique element to the mixture. I hope they can grow and expand to maybe lengthen those hours and days they are open - they'd make a killing! read more

Checked out this place for the first time tonight. Ordered a pie around 4 for pick up at 6. We eat pizza pretty often. Love so many pizzas around town. Leonardi's and Imperial are my top 2. This honestly is right up there. They keep it simple and do it well. Bravo! I will be back time and time again! read more

One Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - West Seneca, New York

Very good pizza the blue cheese was a delicious addition for the pizza and no extra charge. The pepperoni was a bit greasy but all in all a great pizza pie read more

Updated! I had another pie from here and it was just as good if not better than the first! This pizza is addicting! Sooo as I have mentioned the blue cheese being so good...well this time I ate the leftover blue cheese on Pringles ( reduced fat! Don't judge me! lol) and then I proceeded to scrap the leftover out of the container with my finger. So. Good! Sweet, unique and delicious! If you don't like a really sweet pizza sauce this is not for you but I do so more for me. I've tried a lot of pizza places in my time and this ranks near the top of my list. It was unlike any I've ever had. The crust is golden brown and delicious, the sauce is thick, garlicky and sweet mmmm! Even the pepperoni is tasty! I love the free container of blue cheese as well. It was so good that I literally ate a spoonful of it once I was done with the pizza. This place is a must try! read more

This place is amazing. Regular Cheese Pep Pizza is great, bleu cheese made in house is awesome too. If you sign up for their company card you get notifications once or twice a month for special deals with the purchase of a pizza. We scored some gnocchi with red sauce once and it was to die for. Definatly recommend this place. Bummer they're not open on the weekends! read more

Ate this pizza many times while it was located in Depew (has now since moved to West Senenca). What can I say? Some of the best pizza in Western New York. Here's the kicker about the place, they only make pizza, nothing else. And you know what? I respect it. I wish the place also made chicken wings, but, I'm not complaining. Their dough is made fresh daily, and the ingredients they give to their consumers tastes quite fresh. The pizza sauce has a sweet and tangy flavor, with good creamy mozzarella cheese. And the pepperoni are delightful curl and burns. This is real classic Buffalo style pizza and it's a real best kept secret. Forget Bocce, La Nova, Imperial, or Jay's Artisan, One Pie is the best. Half sheet pizzas for 17 bucks. Worth the price. read more

Good pizza, but they have a policy of only making so much dough and closing when sold out, so they are normally closed early on Friday and Saturdays. Like closed at 6 pm !!! This is really making me not want to do business here, because it seems that I can't do business with them because they are CLOSED!!!! read more

Want a good pizza at a reasonable price. Look no further. Ordered a pizza last night, the pizza was really good and the homemade blue cheese was good as well. My only complaints are blue cheese container was small and I forgot to get another pizza for breakfast today. read more

The pizza is just ok, they try to copy Bocci sweet sauce but not even close, the dough is way too thick, I know Buffalo pizza is thick but this was ridiculously thick. read more

Just moved to Kaisertown and can't believe I lived 30+ years without knowing this was a real place. EASILY the best pizza in WNY! If You have not tried One Pie Pizza do yourself a favor and make it happen. You're life won't be the same. You'll find yourself day dreaming about this pizza. read more

Tried this for the first time - loved it. The sauce is the game changer. Slightly sweet. Crust well done. Worth the drive. We will definitely be frequent patrons. read more

I only wanted a couple of slices, upon arriving, I was offered a whole pie (the whole slice pie) for just the price of my slices. I really dig your business plan guys...No waste. Wasnt charged for my extra toppings on the pie, and by God did that make my day. I will FOREVER return to One Pie. You guys make Buffalo, Buffalo read more

The pizza was amazing!! You can taste how fresh the ingredients are! The staff was courteous, fast, and friendly. Can't wait to go back.

I found a coupon so we tried the 1/2 sheet. It is excellent. Sauce is sweet, thick crust. Homemade blue cheese is excellent as well. You gotta try it! read more

One Pie Pizza - This place is great.. Excellent pizza. - Pizza Near Me - West Seneca, New York

This place is the bomb. I've been there 5 times and it's been delicious every time. I've lived around here most of my life and have had many local places. This one is among the best. read more

They have the best pizza in town! My favorite is cheese & mushrooms; they don't skimp on the mushrooms as some places do.