I ordered a custom lemon cake with strawberry filling (instead of raspberries), and the entire experience was a disappointment from start to finish. The owner was surprisingly rude throughout the process, which already set the tone, but the cake itself was even worse. The presentation was awful, truly nothing like what was promised. And unfortunately, it tasted exactly how it looked: dry, unbalanced, and just... yuk. For a custom order, the quality was beyond unacceptable. I expected care, flavor, and professionalism, and received none of the above. This review was necessary. I would not recommend this bakery for custom cakes. And the cost was over the top! $60. Smh! I wouldn't mind if it was worth it. Gina's Piece of Cake is my normal go to, but they weren't taking any more orders. Probably due to Good Friday, and Easter Sunday. Next time my alternative to Gina's would be Albertson's. This lady at Orcutt was beyond RUDE and just down right nasty! Absolutely pass her up! Yuk yuk yuk! read more

Orcutt Bakery - Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Orcutt, California

5 stars for the Lemon Glazed Cookie. Soft with a hint of vanilla and a good dose of lemon flavor. Not overly sweet. As a bonus, it was only $2.50. Such a steal!!! I would totally buy a ton of these. Minus one star for the triple chocolate cupcake which was just average. read more

Best bakery in Santa Maria area, hands down. We never go anywhere else anymore. Their carrot cake is top tier if you're into carrot cake.

This is our family's favorite bakery. We always go here for cupcakes. Chocolate cake is delicious. They are cookies are to die for if you want a quick bite or even ordering a custom cake. This is this place to do it in Orcutt/ Santa Maria. Their cinnamon rolls are also good sorry I almost forgot but if you want a place for taste, this is your spot. read more

We got our wedding cake here several years ago. Beautiful, affordable and delicious! Such a great place with delicious food

Love this place and all their sweets are so delicious! Great Service and Great selections. read more

Literally just lost a cake order. Your website says open today (Sunday) 11 to 5. Got the kid packed up to come here and do her bday cake order and you are closed. read more

Great pastries and cakes. Owned and operated by a local family, their pride and commitment are very apparent. You won't be disappointed.

Oh my goodness if this place doesn't have a wonderful treats. Every single thing I have had from this bakery has been divine. I've tried their cookies, cheesecakes cupcakes and bars. Within the first bite you can taste the quality. Wonderful top-notch ingredients used in these tasty treats, keep you coming back for more. I really love how they are on some of the delivery apps so anytime you want a cupcake you can just pop on and order. The owner is so kind and is always willing to take the time to answer any questions you have. If you were looking to get a custom cake made I think this would be your best bet in the Santa Maria/Orcutt area. Her prices are great and you can't be the deliciousness of everything she has to offer. read more

See all

I like the baked good from here, the cranberry and white chocolate chip was surprisingly great. I would come back, just try to come earlier as some goods like chocolate chip cookies can run out, service was nice and quick read more

Ordered a custom birthday cake for my son's 8th Birthday and I couldn't have been more dissatisfied with the result. Besides the atrocious price for what was produced, this has to have been the most low effort cake that this bakery had ever created, based on their advertised cakes from their website. They took their standard cake, slapped a few yellow rings on it, and called it a "Knuckles" cake. I provided the Knuckles toy for the top of the cake, and I think they used that as a crutch for their lack of enthusiasm and creativity. So, if you're in the area for a standard quality cake, I'd highly suggest Albertsons across the street. At least you'll get what you paid for. read more

Orcutt Bakery - Birthday cake from Orcutt Bakery. - Bakeries Near Me - Orcutt, California

I needed 3 dozen gingerbread cookies for a work event on short notice. Danielle was fantastic to work with. Order was ready on time - then I dropped the ball on picking up. Danielle offered a solution so the cookies made it to their final destination on time and they were a big hit! Will definitely call on Orcutt Bakery again! read more

Orcutt Bakery - Gingerbread Cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Orcutt, California

4 stars for the baked goods but no star for the person who was at the till. This is my 3rd time visiting this establishment. The cupcakes are great does not disappoint! So far so good they've been perfectly moist and the icing are in perfect proportion with the cake! My only negative review is the person at the till. The couple of times I've come here I do my due diligence to have a small talk and feel the person out. But I found her dismissive and abrupt. Finally the third time I told my spouse to go inside with me and check what's up. While she was servicing another customer in front of us, She made a small talk etc etc even smiled. So here I am optimistic did some "hi, hello" but again there's the dismissive and abrupt situation. Am I asking too much?! Anyway my spouse said "I get your point. I'm not sure what it is but there's some rudeness. Don't worry we're never going to tip if we go back to this establishment" Too bad because were a huge tipper. Again this is my/our experience. The cupcakes are great! If you have patience with people's attitude you should be good! read more

Orcutt Bakery - Vanilla Bean Cupcake - Bakeries Near Me - Orcutt, California

My favorite bakery. I love their cheesecake. It's the only cheesecake I will eat. It's smooth and creamy. I also love their cookies and cupcakes. My go to bakery when I'm craving something sweet. They also make the best Bûche de Noël. I ordered it every Christmas. read more

Delicious cupcakes and mini cheesecakes! This is the perfect place to pick up luxury sweets for my family in Santa Maria. Everyone kept raving about how fabulous these goodies were! read more

I ordered a cake for my significant other and it was terrible. Cake was dry and tasted like it had been left in the fridge for at least a couple days. read more

I have to agree with others sharing that the staff are not friendly. I really like their cinnamon rolls, however, I did find a short hair when I bit into it. That was gross. I realized they do not put their hair in nets or put up. Honestly, they have good baked goods. Hair no extra charge? before this incident, I did order a cake and the fondant tasted like it had been in the freezer for a very long time. Was gross and it was pricey. Hope this helps! read more

Love this little bakery in Orcutt! It's my go to place to get cupcakes and cakes for any occasion. Perfect place to pick up for my kiddos bday for school. Nice people too. Cupcakes are yummy and they have amazing cheese cakes. One of my fave is the New York Cheesecake. Delish!! read more

Orcutt Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Orcutt, California

See all

Our first time ordering from Orcutt bakery was for our gender reveal cupcakes. They did an awesome job keeping it a secret from us and making sure nothing was showing through. But oh man we weren't expecting these basic cupcakes to be so good! We just ordered white cupcakes with white frosting and a basic whipped cream filling and they were so delicious and pillowy soft. The shop also smells divine and is just filled with interesting treats. Excited to go back and try some more! read more

Absolutely Delicious! They make such Delicious Everything! From Lemon Bars to Cheesecake, Cupcakes! You will be Happy! Not the friendliest staff but they can bake desserts! read more

RUDE !!!! We loved this place at least once a week we would get something. But today my wife called and said she was rude on the phone. We just wanted a cheesecake for a graduation dessert, in June. We moved away years ago and thought let's get Orcutt Bakery! So now that's out of the question thanks Orcutt Bakery I just saved 50 some dollar!!! read more

Orcutt Bakery is a hidden gem in Orcutt across from Orcutt Burger. Unfortunately I went too late in the day to get all of the delicious treats but I did manage to snag a raspberry chocolate cupcake, red velvet, chocolate chip cookie, and Brookfield (brownie/cookie combo). All were very tasty and moist, clear that they were baked fresh. Will definitely return earlier in the day to get some of their other treats! read more

Got our wedding cake here and it looked amazing, tasted great, and the delivery was flawless. Only one thing I didn't like was that after spending $800 on a cake, it was an EXTRA charge for a tasting to decide what flavors we wanted to use. read more

Perfection in both the art and baking. Appreciate having this service close to home, specific to school colors and choice of carrot cake which was really good. Thank you. read more

Orcutt Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Orcutt, California

Second time in many years that I have set foot here!This is a place to grab your goodies and go. All items are made from scratch and the cheesecake is airy, melts in your mouth! What can I say? Fresh fruit used on items! Expect to pay more than at a supermarket bakery and yet, so totally worth it because of the higher quality. They only sell pies during the holidays. I would encourage anyone with a sweet tooth to visit this place! Very polite staff and quick service! read more

See all

The few pastry items I got all came out well, and better than chain-store in my opinion. Cookie was soft and had a slight good chew. Cupcake was moist and light, ratio of frosting good with good consistency. The sign on the building is small and difficult to stand-out due to design. The location is in a strip mall and nothing on the door or window is eye catching, so it may be easy to overlook this place. The interior is clean if not a little sparse. I came in an hour before closing but it was pretty minimal on what they had to sell in the displays but everything was well presented. I would recommend since it was good and to me, priced well. read more

See all

We were traveling and visited this bakery to pick up a gift for our host. We purchased a beautifully decorated not to Mention extremely delicious chocolate cake. I couldn't resist their brown butter chocolate chip cookies, brownies, and cake pops to send to our daughter away at school. Wonderful! Thank you!! read more

I heard about this place from a co worker and I am glad I did. The cup cakes are to die for. Fresh moist and delicious. I ordered a half dozen mini cup cakes and I wish I had ordered more. I will definitely be back next time I am in Orcutt. read more

Took my girls in for an after school treat and they were thrilled! Nice variety of fresh baked goods. On this visit we got cupcakes and lemon bars but the Cake Pops looked amazing!!! My girls loved their cupcakes. Perfectly moist and the frosting was delicious! We also got to meet both of the owners and it's so nice to see local people succeeding! Friendly folks and passionate about what they do! Keep it up Orcutt Bakery! You've made fans out of us! read more

Orcutt Bakery - Happy girls loving their after school cupcakes! - Bakeries Near Me - Orcutt, California

I ordered a custom cake from this bakery and it turned out excellent both esthetics n flavors Among with other pastries Will now be my fav bakery read more

See all

I ordered a cake for my son's 8th birthday in Heaven. I went in a week beforehand and talked with the male owner and showed him pictures and described what I wanted. He assured me it would be no problem and asked me to email the pictures I showed him and any others I found. I emailed him the pictures I showed him that day, plus 4 or 5 more. I never heard back, so 2 days before I was going to pick up the cake I called to check what time I could get it. ( Just to make sure things were on track since I never heard anything.) He said everything was great and I could pick it up between 11 and closing. The day I picked it up ( My son's birthday), the wife was the person out front, she never greeted me and I pointed at what seemed like what might be my cake in the refrigerator and said I was there to pick up my cake. She walked over to it, put it in a box, asked if I needed help carrying it out ( a 2-tiered cake!?), then walked away. Mind you, there was no lid on the box, and my hands were full of my car keys, wallet and the '8' candle I had just purchased. Yeah, guess I got this? Through all my tears, the rudeness of this lady, and trying to figure out how I was going to transport this cake, I didn't notice until I got to my final location and could really take a good look at the cake that it wasn't really what I had asked for or what was discussed with the husband or in the pictures I sent. Hopefully it at least tasted good. I cut a slice, up to the cardboard between the tiers anyway ( why it was still in there, who knows ‍), and the disappointment quickly set in. Then I took a bite. Had they made the cake the say I ordered it and it had been in that refrigerator for a week? Did they just forget to simple syrup the cakes? They were dry as the Sahara. It was supposed to be a coconut cake with lemon curd or lemon custard inside. It was a white cake with lemon buttercream. I even said in my email, cream cheese frosting inside would be great, I'm willing to pay extra, I don't like any other frosting! I was so sad. My baby passed away, I was sobbing when I ordered the cake, trying to compose myself, I told them in person and in the email this was so important to me and just needed it to be right for his birthday and no one could even bother to contact me to ask questions? Really? It took me 5 days to even be able to post this. I'm not surprised by the negative feedback they have gotten and I wish I had looked at it beforehand. I just thought I would support a small business during these difficult times. Guess I will research a little better next time. read more

My son wanted a raspberry cheesecake for his birthday and to be honest there's not that many bakeries that sell cheesecake. (Read: good cheesecake) and I didn't want crap Costco cheesecake. The gentleman that helped me was very polite and helpful. And they use real raspberries not the frozen stuff!! If you want a good tasty cheesecake that's not super rich and sour tasting visit this bakery read more

Orcutt Bakery - White chocolate raspberry cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - Orcutt, California

Stopped by to get some cupcakes for my Mom's birthday and couldn't help adding a chocolate chip cookie and lemon bar as well. Everything tasted amazing and the person who helped me was friendly and helpful. I will definitely be going back again! read more

I purchased a pecan pie for the holidays and it was the best pecan pie I have ever tasted. I will definitely be purchasing again.

I have tried everything from cupcakes, cookies, and cheesecake. Everything is top notch and love that this is a locally owned bakery.

Have had cupcakes from here before that were good, then ordered a pumpkin cheesecake for Thanksgiving that was delicious! Also, I didn't sleep well the night before and missed our pick-up time. My husband, who's a disabled vet, has a tough time remembering things and he'd forgotten to go pick up our order. I woke up a half hour after we were supposed to pick up (and after they closed). They were so kind and accommodated us, which we appreciate so much. Highly recommend! read more

I live out of town and tried contacting the business to make us something and no one got back to us! Very unprofessional!

If you want cheesecake minis avoid these!!! The cookies and cake pops were good but I can't say the same about the cheesecake cupcake size portions. I ordered one of them and couldn't even take the wrapper off should have use the foil kind instead of the paper kind abs they wouldn't have stuck so bad. Also the Grahm cracker crusts when you finally were able to get to it was a powdery mess they did not put enough butter to bind it into a crust. I would not recommend cheesecake from them but their cookies are moist and chewy and cake pops are kid approved. I have not purchased cake from them so I don't really know what their cake is like. Also I forgot to add the lady there was rude like as if we were doing her no favor shopping there. I this place does not deserve 5 stars... from anyone especially for the attitude you get when you go in there. It's not like stuff is free or people are getting things at discounts. We paid for our items and left but probably won't return due to the stuck up her butt! read more

They made the cutest Batman cake for us! My kids loved it. Made his birthday special. Super tasty as well read more

Orcutt Bakery - Custom Batman cake. - Bakeries Near Me - Orcutt, California

Best cheesecake moist and delicious. Cupcakes and cakes are moist great with flavor and frosting is perfect. Great service and awesome for family and friends. read more