One of our favorite local pizza places! Strangely enough, we drove past this restaurant for years…read morebefore finally stopping in for a quick lunch in 2025. Over the past year, this has become one of our go-to destinations, and we either eat in or take-out at least twice a week. The staff is friendly, the food is great and the prices can't be beat. We love the option of ordering online and have never had a problem. The owner loves his customers and gives us a wave whenever he's in the shop. A nice little local pizza place!

I've been a customer here since they opened and I have mixed feelings about my experiences. Some…read moretimes the food is amazing and others, well, not so much. I've had instances where fries are stale/very dry, the food is rubbery, the cheese dip is lumpy/old, or there's more bread than there is burger on my sub. And when I place an order for delivery, the driver always forgets something!

Glad i finally had a chance to stop by and check this place out a few times now…read more Great pizza, sandwiches have been excellent and the various specials are great values. The staff has always been friendly and attentive even when they're busy. The interior was clean and reminiscent of your classic pizza place.

We often order their desserts when we have a late night sweet tooth and they deliver every time!…read moreThe pistachio cake is light and tasty and my son loves the banana pudding!!

We have been dying to try this place and yesterday was the day…read more We were immediately greeted and seated with menus. We started off with the Arugula salad and then ordered the Tavern style pepperoni pizza and two diet sodas. The salad was fresh and delicious, and a nice large portion. The pizza, was honestly the best pizza we have had in a very long time. The thin crispy crust, the cheese, and the cupping pepperoni was excellent. We have finally found our new favorite pizza spot! We cannot wait to come back here. The staff were very friendly. The restaurant is tiny but clean, including the spotless restroom. The parking is tight out front, but plenty of parking out back with a second entrance. Don't hesitate to check this place out. You will be glad you did!

From the first person answering the phone to the pickup and to eating the pizza it was a perfect…read moreexperience! Ready when I got there. The eat in space is small but comfortable. The pizza is now our favorite!

We've wanted to visit Cavola since hearing many positive reviews. We really enjoyed the experience…read moreon a beautiful day in Lititz. We started with the olives and white anchovy appetizers. Very tasty. We split the Prosciutto and arugula pizza. Very generous amount of prosciutto and a nice crispy crust. Nice beer and wine selection and efficient service. Looking forward to a return visit.

Went with a large group and these pizzas did not disappoint! We were able to taste most of the menu…read more- Margherita, bolognese, eggplant, sweet pea, mushroom, Ferrari and all were super flavorful with perfect char on the crust. The interior is cute and comfortable and there was plenty of room for our reservation. I tried their soft serve as well and it was a great texture. Would happily recommend!

Top shelf pizza and wonderfully friendly proprietor and staff. Fantastic authentic pizza, perfectly…read moreseasoned and inventive varieties. Best pizza in Gettysburg to be sure, and a competitor that would hold its own anywhere.

Food was delicious- we ordered "to go" and the staff were very personable and friendly!! We ordered…read moremozzarella sticks, white pizza, and cheese pizza. Ingredients super fresh on the white pizza. Loved the crust. Can't wait to go back and try more items!!! A Must Stop when you are in Gettysburg!

Visited Ferrante's with colleagues during a business trip. It was walking distance to our hotel so…read morean easy choice. Among the 5 of us we ordered several pizzas and Stromboli. I will say, if you're ordering for yourself, get the half Stromboli, they're HUGE! Everyone enjoyed their meal and had some leftovers. Our server was fantastic. She kept drinks flowing and was great. The restaurant is clean and you can smell the wood fired oven when you walk in. I love that! Due to Pennsylvania laws, their drink menu is somewhat limited but we worked around it. Thanks for a great meal! Would definitely return next time we're in the area.

Disappointing takeout experience. Ordered pizza, toasted sub, fries and salads. Arrived at…read moredesignated pickup time, paid, but there was no pizza because "the ticket didn't print out". Waited another 15 minutes for pizza to be made & baked while fries and sub got cold. Arrived home to discover pizza crust undercooked and no cheese on sub. All in all, not good. Jon W

Pupatella is easily the best pizza spot in the Howard County area. Everything tastes legit and well…read moredone! The happy hour deals are great, and the pizza flights are a must if you're going with a group or just want to try a few different pies. Super family friendly too, I'll be back again!

it's been a little over a year since my first review. I'm not sure what happened in that time, but…read morewow, that may have been the worst pizza I've had in recent memory. I went during a weekend afternoon and there were very little customers there, so it's not like it was very busy. We sat outside and some of the tables were noticeably not cleaned with pizza bits already there. We ordered a couple of basic cheese pizzas and they must have forgotten to put it in. I had to check in myself because the server was MIA and it was clearly a rushed job to try and get the pizzas done. The pizza crust was burnt, but also the dough itself was somehow still underdone. The little bits of mozzarella they used had so much moisture that it was creating little pools on the crust and made the whole thing soggy. By comparison, this was not how I remembered the pizza a year ago, but wow, I would've been much better off just ordering at like a Domino's or something.

Our pick-up food order was delicious! Husband had the small cheese Calzone and it was delicious and…read morevery big for a small! Will definitely order again! I had the Philly cheese steak hoagie, delicious!! Amy & Walt Sener

Great pizza place! We were down here in Palmyra poking around and shopping and deciddd to get…read morepizza. Super good and huge pizzas! Clean place and fast service.