The vodka pizza is delicious. Boxing is solid. Could work on better cutting for pizza. I was to tear mine up. Sharper cutlery is all I would suggest for business otherwise it's a good place to order pizza from :3 read more

Pop in grab a slice! Quick & affordable with friendly staff BIG slices Garlic knots - yum! Picnic bench outside (summer months) Indoor booths available Cooler on site with soda options Variety of tasty treats read more

See all

Great pizza and best garlic knots ever!!! Went back the next day for more garlic knots and a delicious turkey sub!

Have had much better from them before but not today. Wings were cold & dried up. Very disappointing.

Always very quick when ordering. Great availability. Friendly staff. The pizza is very good.

Paid for the Pepperoni Galore specialty pizza. Standard amount of pepperoni at best. Incredibly disappointed with the outcome, especially for the price of the premium pizza. read more

Original Italian Pizza - What the pepperoni galore should be... - Pizza Near Me - Syracuse, New York

See all

The pizza here is underrated. It really is quite good and they have a variety of options. I tried their spicy chicken bacon ranch today. It was large, thick, and full of flavor. I tried their garlic parm wings for the first time. I wish I had chosen a different flavor. I usually like their wings a lot, but these were just alright. read more

This small pizzeria is one that everyone should visit at least once while in the cuse area. The wings can be char-grilled (highly recommended) making them extra crispy and delicious. Don't pass p on trying these wings! The selection of personal slices are great while the pizza itself is thin (but not too thin) and cooked to perfection. The buffalo chicken pizza and chicken bacon ranch pizza have been our favorites so far. We can't wait to try even more food from here. This is a delicious, well-priced, hidden pizzeria in the Syracuse university area. read more

Original Italian Pizza - Chicken bacon ranch pizza slice & BBQ wings char-grilled "to go" - Pizza Near Me - Syracuse, New York

We were craving some classic greasy delicious pizza And tried OIP for the first time. It was perfect! I recommend the tomato pie if you have people in your group that don't like a lot of cheese it was very flavorful. My favorite was the garlic. If you have more than 2-3 people definitely get a large and may need 2 because they are not terribly big. It took a little while but we didn't mind because it tasted fresh out of the oven. Great service. Would try again! read more

Great pizza and wings but they don't list their prices on their website which is a major L

Being from Houston, TX , we do not have too many traditional pizza joints or even wings. This place is awesome. I had a philly steak with everything on it....so good! I ordered medium heat wings and asked if I wanted them chargrilled.. They become a dry wing line a dry rub bbq wing with heat...Best chicken wings I ever have!!! Must stop place for locals or out of towners!!! read more

I previously ordered slices and medium grilled wings. The slices and wings were always very good! The wings were just hot enough. This time we ordered the mediun grilled wings. This time the wings were excellent but lacked heat. We ordered a pizza with sausage, green peppers, onions and mushrooms. The pizza looked wet and some sections were soggy. I asked if the mushrooms were canned. Yep! Yuck! I realize some people like canned but fair warning please. The mushrooms were spongy and made parts of the crust soggy. If you're going to use them please warn mushroom lovers. Also drain and use a paper towel to remove excess water!!! The pizza could have spent more time in the oven or in a hotter oven. The bottom was pale white. Not brown and definitely no char. We took half home and reheated it. Much better! I would order another pizza there but avoid the mushrooms and ask for a crust with some brown and char! 4 stars based on the individual slices I had before and the wing. read more

Hell yes! Eat this pizza. Eat more of it. It's fucking delicious. I grew up in Syracuse. Alki's used to be this good, but I live on the West Coast now and would travel here just for a slice of pepperoni. read more

The pizza is fine but I ordered online and the time given for pickup was 20 minutes after ordering. I arrive at the store at that time and am told my order (three pizzas, nothing ridiculous) wasn't done. Thirty minutes later multiple other parties came and went picking up their orders and mine still wasn't done. The staff were completely unconcerned when I queried why I was waiting a full hour for my order of three measly pizzas. 100% regret not going to Mario and Salvo's like I normally would, this was a huge waste of time, and the pizza isn't good enough to justify such terrible service. read more

I am just visiting Syracuse to see a friend who lives by this place. The pizza was very good. I had one slice of pepperoni and it was fresh and hot. I also had an order of six wings that was the best that I ever have had in a restaurant! What made them so good is the fact that they char-grill them. The employees were very friendly and smiled. That means a lot in today's world. I wish they would open one up in Fort Lauderdale. read more

Don't bother with delivery: On a Thursday evening, it took almost TWO HOURS to get a delivery that they said would be here in 40 minutes.

Breakfast pizza is really good - regular pizza is pretty mediocre. Wings are also mediocre. read more

This is our go-to spot for pizza and wings. Crust is a nice thickness, flavor is great...I don't get the bad reviews.

Flashy adverts, boxes and decor but the food is blah. Pizza is not great at all - the main flavoring is salt and the cheese is the cheap kind that doesn't melt and get stringy, it just swells up a little. Wings are better than the pizza but still just standard hot wings. I like char grilled garlic wings elsewhere, but OIP's say they're honey garlic and I don't like sugar on my meat, so I skipped that. I got carryout and thought it was kind of expensive. BTW, a full order of wings is 10 and a half order is 6. Why not use "small" and "large" order because 6 is not half of 10. $28 for a large roni with ten wings for takeout seems like a lot to me and that was with the online special that I simply had to refer to to get about $3 off. read more

Pizza was missing half the toppings ordered. Was delivered cold. Was told I would be credited; they charged me full price anyways. I will never waste another penny on your crap company ever again. read more

We ordered from OIP tonight and it was as good as I remembered it. Plump meaty wings with honey garlic rub, and French fries. Still warm enough that nothing needed reheating. They do their own delivery and the entire transaction including tip was the least expensive dinner for two we've had in weeks. read more

Pizza and wings just ok..decided to give them a second chance but not worth it overpriced and locals do much better!

This place has great pizza and amazing wings. Online ordering is super easy. Only had a problem with my order once and they ended up giving me my pizza for free that time. It is a bit pricier than other places but it's so convenient that it makes up for it. The only ding I would give them is that they tend to be a bit stingy with the toppings. read more

Original Italian Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Syracuse, New York

Received a coupon from OIP Julian Plaza offering a two topping large pizza for $9.99. Called to order, and asked if we could get broccoli, a "premium" topping, for the coupon price. Price came to $12.49, plus tax. It was not until I looked at the bill that I realized that a $2.00 delivery charge was added to the bill. Of course, I tipped the driver $3.00, which brought the cost, including tax to $16.49. Seems to me as though $9.99 with two toppings should be the same price as a pizza with one topping, premium or otherwise. Pizza was fine, but I have never heard of any pizza place charging for delivery. Not the way I would be endearing myself to new customers. Buyer beware...it's not the $2.00, but the lack of clarity. read more