Always delicious food at both Filetto's locations - East Northport and Commack. We went to the east northport location and opted in for the pasta night. Pastas were great size portions that left us with leftovers for the next day. Service was attentive and timely, and the food came out quick. Casual ambiance, and quiet for a Tuesday night. We got a cheese pie as well (not pictured) and was delicious and comparable to the Commack location. Consistency is key!!! Will definitely be back to the east northport location. Foodie card accepting, which I love! read more

Filetto's - Tortellini (opted for penne) carbonara - Pizza Near Me - E Northport, New York

See all

Good pizza. Regular, Sicilian and personal pies we love Pasta fagioli is pretty good too read more

What a great spot! My family came for the weeknight special, which came with a bunch of courses for a great price. We tried a few different entrées, including the Eggplant Parmigiana, Filet of Sole, and Chicken Parmigiana, all of which were delicious! We finish the meal off with cannolis, which were also very tasty. Service and ambiance were above expectations. The waitress was very attentive and checked in a bunch. For the deal, this place is worthwhile, but I've certainly had better Italian in the NY/NJ area. read more

See all

Their pizza by the pie and slice is delicious. Their catered half trays, not so much. My family used to order catering from filetto's for parties, always getting the eggplant rollatini, capellini cakes, and chicken parm. Every single time they forgot the tomato sauce for the capellini cakes. We always had to call and remind them to bring it, and still the poor delivery person had to go back and retrieve it when inevitably there was no sauce in our order. The last straw for us was when we got three trays for Christmas Eve and they all felt really light. We opened them up and the eggplant and chicken were only filled up about halfway, and instead of a layer of shredded mozzarella covering them, there slices of barely-melted deli mozzarella cheese. Most of the capellini cakes were burnt, and smaller than we'd gotten in the past. I would say the saving grace of filetto's is the pizza- not the overpriced personal pizza, but their brick oven 18" pies. My all time favorite is the spinach artichoke slice, with little pieces of sun dried tomato and cheese on top. The white pizza is great too. However there is still a very long wait for whenever you want to pick up your pizza, so it's not perfect. read more

I ordered a bolognese tonight and while I was excited to sit down after a long day of work. Come to home I open the bag and lid and see a container of noodles with barely any meat or sauce. The noodles were mostly dry and I ended up having to pull out sauce and make more to enjoy it. Payed 23 dollars and still endedup having to make the other half, crazy.!!!!!!!!! read more

Hours state open till 10pm Walked in at 9:05 and not one single piece of pizza available? And the looks from the counter staff tells it all. read more

I've waited a couple of weeks before I decided to post this. I went to filettos 3 weeks ago on a Friday night at 5pm I was with 2 children with special needs. We stopped in for pizza, I asked if we could sit at one of the "many" empty tables. They said no!! I will never go back there again!! Fast forward 3 weeks we went to chefs pizza and they couldn't be more accommodating! read more

Like all towns on Long Island's what do you have most, Banks, Pharmacies and Pizza places. What makes Filetto's stand out is the entertainment they provide while you dine in on Friday's, which is only secondary to their great food. Counter service and table service are good. The only negative is the espresso and cappuccino not hot and half a cup on the cappuccino. Ciao for Now. read more

Filetto's - Music by Bob Fischetti, while I eat dinner. - Pizza Near Me - E Northport, New York

I called for a large tray of Caesar salad no chicken and they charge $93 before tax!!! I called LaScala and Gino's and they were $65. FILETTO's is a RIPOFF!!!! read more

1 hour and 10 minutes for my food to arrive! 5:50pm ordered 7:05pm arrived Unacceptable and operators seem to mess up orders. Manager didn't even try to fix the situation read more

Service here is pathetic to say the least. Slow even when empty, no communication. Nothing special about this place at all.

Word of advice: check every bag before the driver leaves. Ordered soup, appetizers, salad and entrees and 2 liter bottle of soda. Specifically asked the delivery guy if the soda was in one of the bags and he said yes. I immediately opened all bags and no soda. Slice contacted the restaurant and was told they would NOT be sending out a soda. This is the 3rd time now this place has left off items and has done nothing to resolve! Shame, food is good but they don't treat you right! Stay away! read more

Went with friends for some appetizers during lunch. Delicious food. Served hot and has decent portions.

Pizza is great. Hands down. But.....I ordered chicken sorentino and it was gross. The chicken was submurged into what looked like gravy/soup. If it's gravy then it shouldn't be drowning the chicken because literally it was soup. The mozzarella was actually floating to the top. It looked awful and I bit into the chicken and it didn't taste like chicken. Who's cooking back there? I didn't ask for my money m back. I just took two bites and threw the whole thing in the garbage. Someone has to seriously check that cook. He needs monitoring. I threw my money right in the trash. ...but their pizza is the best in town. read more

Have had their regular pies a few times now and they are pretty good. But today when I decided to grab their specialty wood burning brick oven pies, I died on the inside when I saw they were making them in the same gas oven as their original pies. Considering you are paying a premium for the brick oven pies, you expect it to have that char and smoky flavor, though the flavor was there from the ingredients used, it lacked that authentic wood burning oven taste. The wood burning oven was covered up as if it was out of order. But why not mention this to your customers when they are placing the order... read more

Filetto's - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - E Northport, New York

Filleto's pizza, slaps. I am surprised too. I've ordered their Margherita pizza and it is so, so good. I've had a lot of pizza in my life and this pie is done right. The flavor is insane, it's crisp enough, ingredients taste fresh, not too salty, just super enjoyable. Their seafood bisque is also really tasty. That's all I've had from them so I can't comment on anything else but if you're getting those two things right, for me, I will definitely be back. Can't speak to their service, I've only ordered take out but each time it's been 100% so that counts for something in my book. Check this place out!! read more

We were the first party to dine in and waited over an hour, never receiving our food. Others were being served before us. The kitchen was horrible. The waitress was doing all she could but what a horrible experience. Never will we dine or order from Filetto's again. read more

Filetto's - a row of parked cars in front of a pizza and pasta restaurant - Pizza Near Me - E Northport, New York

I moved from Long Island to Dallas Texas, but my kids and grandchildren still live here. When I return to the Island, they ask me where I want to eat. I tell them lets go to Filetto's. I try something new every time and I have never been disappointed. We had dinner there Friday, July 26th with a party of 6 and everyone enjoyed their dinner. Their waitstaff is fantastic. They are friendly and very attentive. I normally do not write reviews but I was compelled to do this because of the great food, great service and really good Friday night entertainment! read more

Had a delicious seafood bisque soup with chunks of lobster and scallops. Husband had thin sliced, lovely chicken sorrentino. Waitress was love and attentive. Will definitely try again read more

This place was over the top for out party of 50. The food was terrific and the desire for the staff to create dishes for one of our vegan and one of our gluten free friends was so appreciated. The girls that waited on us were so pleasant and accommodating. We highly recommend this place for a dinner or for a special party. Thank you to Richie and his staff!! read more

The best pizza spot around! The grandma slice is always cooked and made perfectly. I recently tried the new pork loin slice and it was a whole meal in one (look at pic), highly recommend. read more

Filetto's - Pork Loin Slice - Pizza Near Me - E Northport, New York

Two of us walked in on a Wednesday night. It wasn't busy at all. The waitress at my area chose to serve those walked in after us and completely ignored us (a woman and a child). Regardless I waved my hand or said, "Hello" multiple times, I got no attention or response. All other waitresses stood around chatting. After wasting 15 minutes of my life sitting there, I saw the guy (coming in 5 mins after me) sitting across was already served with a glass of water and his order was taken, we decided to get up and leave. I could have walked to talk to someone by the cashier and "beg" my order to be taken. But why? With tips and all the up charges fees (3.5% if using credit or debit card), they just don't deserve your money if they don't respect their customers. read more

I'm really not this person, but I moved to East Northport two years ago and for two years I've been trying to give this restaurant a chance every time we walk in it smells like dirty towels I even ignore it at times but I stopped when my father-in-law seen a roach when I told the owner which is very mean by the way, he told me my father-in-law was lying and he started getting a attitude with me besides all of that when I first walked in there was a girl about 17 and he was making her cry I asked if she was OK she told me yes I just hate him every time. I tell them to heat up the food. It's always cold. The owner is very mean they need to start cleaning their restaurant. read more

We're regulars here, they have great pizza and great food generally, the reason I'm giving 4 stars is that they play games with credit card fees. I paid them $50 cash and $11 on my credit card but they charged me 35% for credit card fees. Definitely a little shady so just be careful and review your bill. read more

It could have been a contender for a 5-Star. Explanation... 5-Star Stuff: * Chicken Parmesan * Comfortable booth (one of the round ones where you feel like a NYC crime boss) * Service * Stuffed Shells In regards to service, our waitress took a picture of six of us and my mother said, "Thank you. Now I can send it to my creepy daughter." This was immediately after I asked my mother why she had blue hair. My sister (a different sister) followed that up with: "Yeah. What product are you using?" My 10-year-old son answered for her with: "Crayola." Like father, like son. People are either going to love him or hate him. 4-Star Stuff: * Salad * Bread I should have gotten the pasta with my meal instead of the salad but, "It's not about the pasta!" ;) read more

Filetto's - Chicken Parmesan. - Pizza Near Me - E Northport, New York

See all

Not even edible, does inflation mean using lower grade quality cheese and every other ingredient also? Steer clear !!!!

I ordered the Greek salad & a side of spaghetti with meat sauce from Filetto's in East Northport to take home. The salad was the worse I ever saw, all the lettuce edges were brown, the feta was of very poor quality, as was the olives. The dressing wasn't even a Greek dressing. The spaghetti it self was okay, but the meat sauce really lacked in flavor. I will never order from them again read more

I was shocked that we were fully charged for soda refills. At $2.99 per drink, it adds up and is wrong. If you are not offering free refills at the table service restaurant then you need to lower price per drink. Next time, I'll ask for tap water. read more

Typically their food is really good. But when I ordered tonight the pizza was here in like literally no time. And when I opened the box. It was like it either flipped over upside down, or they had 16 other pizzas stacked ontop. The girl who answered the phone when I called back said they would send another pizza "right out" to us. But unfortunately it took them like an hour to send the new pizza right out to us. read more

Filetto's - Bad sloppy pizza - Pizza Near Me - E Northport, New York

Great specials. Friendly service. Good food. It is a pizzeria with a dining area, so there's not much ambiance but it's worth a repeat visit. read more

This place is great. The food is absolutely delicious and the staff is kind. The atmosphere was inviting and my husband and I had an amazing dinner. Will definitely be going back. read more

We go there for diner & drinks. food is always hot & great. Service is fast people are very friendly. Thank you Rich & Carol

We recently went to Filetto and tried out their new Sunday through Thursday menu. It offers a choice of soup salad a rice ball choice of several entrées, dessert and coffee for 2395. The portion size was great. The selections were delicious and we were very happy with the service. I think there's new menu is going to be a real hit, and would highly recommend everyone to try it . It has something for everyone. read more

Not sure what's going on lately. Been going here for years now. But recently they started going downhill. Service is slow. Seems like people working there just want to hang out with their friends. Ordered a chicken panini last night and it came on a toasted Kaiser roll. Things get forgotten in orders. One time I called in an order came around the time they told me to, went to pick it up and they hadn't even started the order. read more

Get the deep dish....if they haven't already run out. It's amazing. Won't even go with another slice

Honestly, very impressed with Filetto's. Their brick oven pizza was perfect for a chilly Sunday night. Also, they're $20 bottle of wine made it even better. The service was very friendly and the place is very cute and clean. The margarita pizza was delicious. Will definitely be returning :) read more

Filetto's - Pizza Near Me - E Northport, New York

The other night we ordered a couple of chicken cutlet Parmesan hero's, personal pizza, a large bbq chicken pizza and salad. The food was delicious and everything was prepared perfectly. My whole family enjoyed their food. Thank you so much to the staff at East Northport Filetto's. See you soon. read more

Had a great lunch today. My sister in law and I took 5 girls to lunch. They had a big selection of fresh pizzas and garlic knots, capellini cake. We got a great salad with veggies. The staff was very friendly and Richie the owner came out to greet us and make sure everything was good. I def reccomend this place. read more

See my photo below for my review. It's my review from Grubhub as that's who I ordered through. All I wanted was a Buffalo Chicken Salad and this is what I had to go through??? The worst customer service ever! I will never order anything from them again. And the salad was terrible too! But even if it was any good I wouldn't have noticed after having to go through this !! Smh read more

Filetto's - Pizza Near Me - E Northport, New York

Pizza and Chicken Parmesan are great. I also love their sauce. Meatballs are hit and miss. Sometimes you see the parsley in it, which I appreciate. I think it shows a good quality recipe. Sometimes they lack this. The side bread is terrible. Zero taste other than flour. I wish they'd change the recipe. Cost is so-so. I've seen better, but I've also seen much worse. read more