Despite the demand and lines the service is exceptionally fast and friendly...extremely organized...it's a well oiled machine! Of course the line is because the subs are SUPERIOR and downstate AUTHENTIC (without the attitude) ...fresh roll or Italian bread, tons of meat and all the fixings! Don't forget one of the old style deli pickles In the case....!!! Can't say enough about Casa...it reminds me of my old neighborhood grocery store...you'll feel like family too! read more

Tried their whit pizza for the first time and it is absolutely delicious. Top sub and pizza shop in the area. read more

See all

I was so excited to find an authentic Italian deli not far from my destination in Farmington NY. I was especially intrigued upon seeing they use Boars Head products. So I placed an order for 5 sandwiches to sample. I guess my Philly roots compromises my ability to not judge this kind of stuff against the originals, Philly hoagies. Alas, I still haven't found bread or rolls outside of Philly that deserve to be used on a decent hoagie. (Hoagies and cheesesteaks ARE about the roll, the taste and texture, above everything else.) This place is no different. It's hard to judge what is inside a sandwich made with really awful rolls. Sorry, but wherever these slightly crusty versions of white bread come from...not good. That said, they offer a fair quantity of Italian goods, I guess for this area, I should be happy just find some Cento products. Way better than Dario's in Farmington, but not even as good as very mediocre Jersey Mike's, solely on the basis of comparing the rolls used. If you're starving have at it. Otherwise, just a notch above Subway. read more

I looked forward to trying out this place for awhile. We recently made it there for pizza. It was ast the lunch hour crowd and the pizza was good... but not fresh. My disappointment was that the eating area was so basic- a few tables- most dirty and not at all welcoming. I can see why most grab & go. read more

I have been going here since the first day they opened. This business has grown into a favorite spot of mine from pizza to the bake goods. A small treasure in Canandaigua ! Highly recommend!!! read more

Amazing subs! I've stopped by several times when in Canandaigua and unfortunately they were closed every time. Finally I was there when Casa Italiano was open. Their subs have great views & I now can agree. I did a takeout of a small and a large Joe's Special. The bread was very fresh with a generous amount of all ingredients. We added lettuce, tomato, onion to the sub as well. Absolutely delicious! When in Canandaigua, a must try. Do check store hours before you head there. They have several small tables to dine in. There is also a vast selection of Italian import/specialty products. Off street parking. read more

Casa Italiana - Small Joe's Special sub with prosciutto, fresh mozarella, balsamic glaze, roasted red peppers - Delis Near Me - Canandaigua, New York

Loved the pizza, I got a small 12" Meat lovers. (should have ordered a 6" personal size, but thought it was going to be tiny......it wouldn't have been but was glad to have leftovers to reheat from the 12" anyways!) Has a really nice little Italian deli, the subs looked phenomenal. Will definitely come back to try those. They use DiPaolo twist rolls (a regional Rochester bread bakery) you'll find alot of hamburger & BBQ places in the finger lakes use these rolls, with good reason because they are amazing. Counter service was excellent, grabbed a table inside the deli and she brought our pizzas right in to us. I would totally come back and try again. Great find for pizza in Canandaigua area. read more

Casa Italiana - Small Meat Lovers Pizza - Delis Near Me - Canandaigua, New York

My husband and I were visiting Other Half Brewing in East Bloomfield and wanted something to eat on our way home and chose this place in Canandaigua. One side is like an Italian deli while the other side is a pizza place. We wanted pizza so we ordered and asked for a thin crust. They had a few tables and we waited. The pizza came out and it had the wrong toppings (they had pepperoni instead of sausage). They apologized and made us another. They gave us plates and napkins and we ate it there. It was cheesy and thin crust like we wanted. Not much of an atmosphere but I could tell they do mostly takeout. read more

Casa Italiana - Sausage,onion and roasted red peppers - Delis Near Me - Canandaigua, New York

Was in town for a show at CMAC and ordered some pie for post show festivities. Fantastic pizza. Phenomenal Italian hoagie. Based on my small sample size I would say this is a solid choice for pizza and sandwiches. Even the delivery driver was extremely complimentary of this establishment !!! Give it a try and I don't think you will be disappointed. read more

My name is James Corbett Jr. I am a Navy Veteran that lives in Farmington. I love coming to shop for Italian pasta and sauces here. The employees are very helpful and polite. They have great pizza and homemade Italian sausage. They have the best quality pizza with the freshest ingredients than any other pizzeria in Canandaigua. read more

Fantastic, had an 8" spicy Italian with everything and the kitchen sink. Not only a flavorful sub but a great value at the price. Highly recommended and a great atmosphere, will stop my next trip through Canadaigua! read more

Really great pizza and house salad! My husband and I drove in and arrived late to the Lake House and looked for a local place to pick up pizza and stumbled upon Casa Italiana and were pleasantly surprised! Ordered a pepperoni pizza, chicken parm pizza and a house salad with house dressing. Delicious!! read more

Great Buffalo chicken wrap! So flavorful and the perfect amount of spicy. Loved the store, had lots of cool imported items and a good deli menu. read more

Casa Italiana - Buffalo chicken wrap - Delis Near Me - Canandaigua, New York

This deli is a treasure. Amazing food, especially the subs and the deserts. Very clean. Service is excellent.

I go there WAY too frequently.....BEST FROSTED BROWNIES EVER!!!! Amd they serve them with a smile....

Easily the best pizza in the area, always cooked perfectly and the crust is my favorite I've ever had. They'll make literally anything you ask for however you ask for it. The "wedgie" isn't even on the menu but I get it every time. read more

Casa Italiana - Italian "Wedgie" - the perfect marriage between pizza and sub - Delis Near Me - Canandaigua, New York

Bomb as always I highly recommend the subs and pizzas. Wings on point every time ! We hit up some cannoli before leaving

Super friendly place with great soups & pantry staples. The location and parking is very convenient if you live in Canandaigua or are just passing through. We are grateful to have them in the FLX. read more

We ordered takeout from both the subs side and the pizza side. I'm not usually a big person for pizza, but these had very thin, crispy crust and were not greasy or over-salted at all. Those in our party who had subs just gobbled them up. This place was a win! read more

Got to give another five star review but this time, it's for the pizza. I grew up in NJ and my favorite pizza style, is a extra thin and crispy crust known as a bar pie. Finding that style is almost impossible in this area. That said, I can't thank the pizza crew at Casa for accommodating my request for a cracker thin crust. They made an exceptionally delicious pizza and exactly like I wanted it. Extra thin, light on the sauce and with cheese that goes up to the crust line. These guys are making pizzas with fresh and quality ingredients. Thanks again guys! Not only do your make a great pizza but you are always so friendly and accommodating whenever I call. read more

Casa Italiana - Extra thin, light on the sauce with fresh garlic cooked well done. Outstanding! - Delis Near Me - Canandaigua, New York

Great service and the best subs in town! Clean store. Very popular Italian store! Will be back!

Great sandwiches. Great staff. One of the best sandwich shops in the area. Their sub rolls are the best.

Very disappointing Bread was at best a Walmart brand No texture / no flavor. Very greedy with meat Also tasted bleach on sub Over rated / under performing. Tried this place 3 years ago and was very good The ratings are way wayyy over rated Maybe a 2.5 read more

Place was awesome very good food and dessert. Pizza and the subs where great. Fast friendly service! read more

See all

Best subs in town plus big deli and great pizza. you'll love this local favorite. order ahead and pick up your food, snacks and drinks to go on the boat or picnic at lake. Tip; ask for subs to be cut in quarters. Mac read more

The best sausages. Period. Just make sure they are fresh as I got a batch that was a little old, the color could tell, and my tummy wasn't happy. Service is a hit or miss. Must depend on the tides or the moon phases, or just the Italian way. I need to try the cheeses. Not into subs but it looks like a lot people go there for that reason. I'll continue to go back until I break that Italian charm into my favor. read more

Best pizza and wings ever GREAT CUSTOMER SERVICE!!Prices are excellent all the help is great!! Fast service too!

A split experience! The deli side is awesome and they have the best Italian cookies ever (I swear they stole Gruttudauria's recipes). A must place to visit. The pizza side has THE WORST Buffalo Chicken wing pizza. The others didn't look much better either, but maybe someone can rate them better? The crust was good anyway. read more

My most favorite deli in town, its authentic and they make the best subs, have the best cold cuts.I remember when they hadbthr site where the creamery is now. I always feel like Im in Italian Heaven. read more

My husband and I have been here several times for takeout. We like the menu and options ...wanted to love it. But last two times, the butcher preparing sandwiches refused to wear a mask (?) and next time, the young woman taking my order and about to make my sandwich had a mask covering her mouth but not her nose. Really?? Ok so I tried to hint, pointing to my nose. She was clearly annoyed. I ordered the special sandwich with prosciutto mozzarella, red peppers and balsamic glaze. I asked for a small roll, which she dud not understand. Apparently if you don't use their lingo then YOU make no sense. Their 3 options are: "roll, small and large" (Aren't the small and large "rolls" too? No, while I consider them "sub" rolls, better not call them a "roll" in this place! This took five minutes to communicate. It tasted good but I had a terrible time biting it and chewing through the fatty meat. Was this a fluke or did she get "even" with me for asking her to correct her mask or not using the right lingo? Anyway this is the meat I pulled out of my sandwich that was inedible... read more

Casa Italiana - Inedible meat in my sandwich - Delis Near Me - Canandaigua, New York

WOW. So this is the third pizza joint we tried during our Week of Moving (TM). We actually found this one on Yelp, and decided to try it based on other reviews. ALL TRUE BY THE WAY! The first thing that blew our minds were the prices. I haven't seen pizza this cheap in ages. And that is no joke! You can get a large pizza here for $13.99, or a large specialty pizza for $16.99 (at least at the time of this review), and that is insane! So we placed an order for a large Hawaiian pizza and an order of breadsticks to try them out. Staff was incredibly friendly, the turnover time was quick, and the food was absolutely amazing. We have been two more times since that first pizza, for more pizzas, and to check out the attached store and deli. I love everything about this place! Today we picked up some sugar cookies, and one of their specialty brownies. Next time I may try one of the salads. I tell pretty much everyone I know about Casa Italiana now, and it MAY be my favorite pizza place so far! read more

See all

Great Subs for take out only. There is one table for eating or waiting for an order. You can shop the Deli items on shelves and the coolers have lots of drinks to choose from. read more

Stopped by here on the way to a friends boat to grab some food for the day. Top tier sandwich menu made fresh to order. Place was PACKED on a Saturday at noon...definitely a great sign!! read more

Fast and friendly service. Huge portions for the price. Nothing magical but easy pick for a usual spot.

Awesome homemade pizza - I can't get over how delicious it is and I had an Italian assorted sub and it was made perfectly. Not a lot of places get it right but this place does. The deli staff are fun too and very professional. They make you feel at home. It's pretty impressive. The owner definitely knows his stuff. read more

Funny staff and great subs/pizza. Love coming here to shop and get a bite to eat. Warm and friendly employees - very hardworking and attentive as well. I highly recommend this place. Probably the only place worthy for deli/subs/pizza in Canandaigua. read more

Great Italian deli/pizzeria with plenty of options to choose from the menu and a lot of stuff in the deli store. Pizza was on point! A lot of different toppings you can pick. First time here and will be my new spot for now on. Highly recommend! read more

Casa Italiana - Oreo brownie and chocolate chip cookie. Both amazing - Delis Near Me - Canandaigua, New York

See all

Ordered 4 large pizzas for me to pick up. Order was placed 3 hours before and still had to sit and wait for them to finish baking them .

My wife and I were in canandaguia today. We had leftovers at home, but decided to try their pizza. We ordered a small pizza with both sides to our own specifications. The pizza was a little undercooked, so we drove the 45 minutes home and put it in our oven. The pizza was delicious! The flavor was some of the best I've ever had. Loved my pizza! read more

I can't say enough about the white pizza with tomato and artichoke. Perfect. I haven't really had enthusiasm for pizza in many months but this has me gushing about Casa Italiana. I've also enjoyed their tasty subs, with the right ratios of ingredients to my liking. Oh, and the bakery cookies: I can and have made most of them at home but why would I? Their's are wonderful and I don't have to clean up after the baking. They are costly but they are not lunchbox cookies; there is art involved in a special dessert cookie. read more