This is the restaurant that made me sign up for yelp so I could write a review. Excellent food, service and atmosphere. Loved it.

Really great environment in the Medina square. Food and service were both good. We will definitely go back!

Picked up a Longmire to go and it was really good. The burger was well cooked and came with fresh cut fries.

I love their burgers. The Italian Stallion is my favorite. I think it must be grass fed beef bc it dries out fast so order a little less done than you usually order and you will love it. I wish they had better salads though. We went for breakfast a few times. The sausage was the best I've had in my life!! read more

First time here, definitely coming back. Right from the start the service was great. Our server Krista was very friendly and knowledgeable about the food she said all the burgers were great and she was right we order that Buckeye buck and the Safecracker burgers. Excellent. Before that we started with an order of homemade onion rings, too full for dessert, but they sounded great. Nice atmosphere, right on Medina square. I'll be back. read more

Love it. Our favorite local watering hole. Great rotating beers on tap, great burgers, ok appetizers, but always great daily drink specials.... And the bartenders are fabulous. We always meet new people and just have a great time. read more

Called yesterday to make a reservation for tonight. The man who answered the phone told me that he was "too busy" to take my reservation and that I would have to call back. Called this morning and was told that they only accept "a limited number of reservations" and that there are no reservations available for the time I need; but I could just "show up" and possibly get a table. Never ate here before; but I'm not too sure how I feel about their customer service practices. read more

Beautiful restaurant. Unfortunately, we waited 30 minutes for appetizers, that we ended up returning, because they weren't very good. Our server took our order, and we had to actually get up, and search for her to return our food and get our check. Terrible service, below average food. Will not return. read more

Food looked excellent but taste was just o.k. Service was awesome and kids are welcome. I would be willing to try it again but order something different next time. read more

PJ Marley's is one of the only places on the square that are open past 9 pm so that is a plus. I have never liked their burgers. Their burgers just tasted dry and sad. I do love their fish sandwich their and also their milkshakes are good. I have not had bad service there personally. Its an alright place to eat, just not ideal. read more

I'm not from Medina but stopped here for a work lunch and wow! Found this place on yelp and thank goodness for that!!! The food was just absolutely amazing. I got the donkey grilled cheese and just wow, knock my socks off. The waitress didn't have the best personality on earth. She was all business. However, for the price and the food, definitely worth the trip! read more

I've eaten here twice and each time has been great. While the menu is still somewhat limited, what they offer is of good quality. I've had the Longmire and Patty's Favorite. Both burgers were cooked perfectly and had great seasoning/toppings. Simply, they were delicious. The beet sliders are also wonderful. The servers have all been very nice and were also more than accommodating to my sister, who is gluten free. The atmosphere and decor are clean and refreshing and it's so nice to see the old bank building being used for something again. Definitely will be back. read more

Great new addition to the Medina square! Just moved out of that area and I was bummed that this came along AFTER I left. Oh well. Great burger, great space and very friendly service. The only reason I gave it 4 stars instead of 5 was because I wasn't impressed by the loaded nachos. The canned cheese wasn't too appetizing, would have preferred fresh toppings for the price. Overall, great experience. I'll be back, for sure! read more

The burgers are awesome. Beer is great. Bar staff is ok. Good at serving a drink but not very inviting. Doesn't make you feel like staying for more than a drink. read more

Great burgers and locally sourced meat. Pretty good beer selection too. Do yourself a favor and order the Jimmy Carter burger.

Great spot in Medina. Whole family enjoyed. I especially loved the black bean burger. I don't think it's always available but for a vegetarian like me, I'd say it's the best around here read more

Great Spot. ..on the Truly Beautiful Town Square of Medina in a historic bank bldg ..check out the tin pan cieling and the old bar..and ..the moosehead! Food is outstanding, friendly and attentive staff. If you.re around Medina.....eat here!! read more

I just got a plain burger for take out and let me tell you about it. This burger is not your dad's burger... That is unless P.J. Marley is in fact your father. THIS burger was like an angel came down from heaven and brought a heard of cows with her to make the burger of the gods. Eating THIS burger was like having a conversation with God about how to make the best burger in the world. The pickles tasted as though Jesus pickled them, himself. Yes. The angel also brought down the heavenly Jesus pickes with her too... And pretzel buns... And all the other heavenly burger ingredients too. Then there were the French fries. The French fries were so good I swore that François Hollande, The president of France, cut down a forest of trees with an axe, used those trees to build a boat, sailed said boat across the Atlantic ocean and then walked to the kitchen of P.J. Marley's to hand cut the potatos and fry them himself... With the help of Jesus. If there is perfect form of hand cut french fries that exist, these are them. FACT. But the moral of the story is that this isn't JUST the best burger I have ever had, but the best burger in the world. Amen. read more

After waiting 45 minutes to get a table we waited another 45 minutes to get our food. 2 salads and a burger took way too long. We asked for grilled onions instead of raw and got raw anyway. Chicken on the salad was tough(over microwaved?) We were told the kitchen is "really " busy. Terrible excuse for bad service. They did take $2 off the burger but doesn't make up for the experience. read more

This review makes me sad to write because i usually love this place. Service is normally slow, but tonight was a case of being deliberately ignored. We sat in the bar area and were served by Beth, who seemed friendly enough. We ordered our drinks and food at the same time. The jalepeno bites came out very fast. Then, Beth didnt check on us at all. I asked another server to refill our waters and bring another side of ranch (which he was awesome about). Eventually, when my first glass of wine was finished about 25-30 mins later, Beth came to ask if we needed another. I said sure and asked if the kitchen was backed up since our food was taking a while. She had a very long pause and then gave a generic excuse about them being busy. Magically not even a minute later our food came out and all of it was cold. It had clearly all been sitting under a heat lamp for a very long time, to the point where my grilled cheese was soggy. She came to ask how our food was and when i said "its ok..." she said "ok good" and walked away. It is very difficult for me to leave a low tip and i am a patient customer, but tonight i left a very low tip and was very disappointed. Oh and the nice gentleman that brought us extra ranch was the one that ended up having to check us out since Beth never returned to our table after bringing our checks. read more

Love the setting with the lovely old bank vault. Food is wonderful. Highly recommend the fried pickle chips. Light and tasty. I had the Medina Reuben sandwich with sriracha sauce. The staff was great and service was fast. Can't wait to check it out again. read more

Great service from Liam and good food! A nice place for some good food and live entertainment. Liam took special care to avoid my onion allergy. read more

Slow service appears to continue to be a common theme for PJM. Went over the weekend for breakfast and the place was pretty much empty when we arrived. I thought that might help but it actually ended up being the slowest service of any visit. As other people arrived I noticed they were getting their meals and coffee before us. One of our orders wasn't entered resulting in more of a delay. They were kind enough to comp that item but we felt like we were constantly having to track down or waitress for refills, to pay the bill, etc. We really like their menu but the service really needs help. read more

Went here for Father's Day, our son took us there and was here the previous weekend and said it was good. Not so today...service was poor..almost one hour to get our food with the waitress only coming around once to refill coffee. The eggs were over cooked, the bacon undercooked, toast cold but the one good thing on the plate were the hash browns. The place was not even full so there was no excuse. Not sure I will ever give this place another go round!! One star for the hash browns. read more

Ehh not that great, burgers have come a long way over the last few years and this place isn't keeping up in my opinion. If you want a really good burger with great unique combinations of ingredients go to a place like Twiisted Burgers & Sushi or The Rail. One MAJOR pro is the fresh cut fries which needed a little more salt to be perfect but I'm a sucker for a fresh cut fry so that's why the extra star was given. Also, the hostess needs more training. We walked into a full but not packed house, there was no one ahead of us in line and she quoted us a 25 minute wait time which seemed unrealistic so we put our name in and waited, less than 5 minutes later another guy walked in and asked if the bar was first come first serve and she said yes and walked him over to a high top in the bar area. This was frustrating because there were only two of us and she did not even mention this to us. We voiced our disappointment in not being informed to which she replied "well I can seat you now anyways" and did not apologize for the miscommunication. The waitress more than made up for the hostess' attitude problem with a great attitude and prompt service but needless to say we won't be returning, the food simply isn't worth it and realistically that's why we go out to dinner, right? read more

Love this place! Great bar, great burgers. Best fresh cut fries I ever had. The restaurant is in what used to be an old bank in downtown Medina. The bank vault is still in the middle, I guess it's built into the building and would require demolishing the building to remove, but adds great atmosphere to the place. You can even eat inside it. Try the peanut butter burger, it may sound weird but it really works. read more

Stopped in here based on the rating/reviews. The service was great and they have Vernor's ginger ale (the best) in their soda fountain, but unfortunately the wings and burger my friends and I ordered were so greasy they couldn't be eaten. Our female server was great about comping the wings. read more

Stopped in for late lunch, first time here, Good burgers, cold beer, wait staff slow, will try it again soon

Atmosphere is very cool. There were not many healthy options or salads. My husband & son loved the burgers. If you like unique burgers, this is the place for you. read more

My husband and I ate here on a Saturday night about 7:30. Had about a 15 min wait. Not bad! He ordered the burger with Bleu cheese and apples and I had the burger with Mac and cheese. Both delicious.! Nice twist. We chose draft beer. I like my beer really cold. This was cool. Not icy cold. Not a deal breaker. Give it a try! read more

Great place to watch the game! Beer selection and Buckeye Buck Burger were exceptional. Service was very friendly, bartender Morgan was really helpful (and patient) with beer selection. Will return for sure! read more

We LOVE this place. The food is very good, and they make the best, freshest burgers I have ever had. Their other food is equally as good, and the service is very good. It is kid friendly, but it still has a really nice, authentic pub style. Its a real gem in Medina! HIGHLY recommend it to anyone. read more

After having a holiday lunch with my friend, we were informed that the credit card machine didn't work and hadn't been working all day.We ended up waiting over half an hour. We finally got the manager and told her that we had $30 in cash, but the bill was 36.00. we wanted to leave a tip for the waiter because he was very good and thought maybe if they took our two drinks off the bill (12.00) we would have enough cash to pay the remainder of the bill plus give our server a well deserved tip. The manager refused to this idea and said that because we consumed her food we owed her!they suggested that we leave our credit card number and they would run it through later! She said she would also be fine if we ran to the nearest ATM and brought her back cash. In the end, she accepted $30 in cash, not happily, and knowing that we would not have enough to leave the server a tip. We told the post at the door that we suggest they let the customers know that the credit card machine has been not working all day and they should be prepared to pay cash. We will not be going back. read more

Was so excited to try this place unfortunately it's just taking up space in the square. Their menu has like 10 items, no liquor, and their wine selection is very small. I ordered the longmire burger because it sounded delicious. The burger had zero flavor and was very dry. Also our table was literally right in front of the restroom doors. Overall.....not good. Won't be back. read more

We were in town to visit another local attraction, and stopped here for lunch. Lucky us! We were pleasantly surprised by the decor and cuisine. The bar area is beautiful, and the quirky vault room provides a unique experience. The wait staff were friendly and skilled. The food tasted delicious. Loved the fried pickle chips, Italian Stallion, apple and blue cheese burger, bloody marys, and locally distilled bourbon. TV volume was off, so it didn't interfere with converstaion. Kudos to the owners. This place is a gem, and the setting right on the town square couldn't be more picturesque. read more

Went to P.J. Marley's on a Saturday evening for dinner with my friend. We both had burgers and a mixed drink. The service was excellent, our waiter was very kind. Our burgers were delicious and came out just as we ordered them Medium and Medium Well. read more

Love the atmosphere, the food is reasonably priced and absolutely delicious! My favorite is the Safecracker followed closely by the Reuben.

Fabulous burgers. The pickle chips were the best. Friendly service in a timely manner. Nice owner. Great mac and cheese. Wish i would've had room for the bread pudding, but the portion sizes of our meals and appetizer were enormous. Will definitely be back. And did i mention they had $1.99 bud lights on a Saturday evening?? read more

Called to place a carry out order at 7:50pm on a Tuesday (4/26). Person who answered phone placed me on hold for over 8 minutes. I could hear the person who answered phone talking in background during this time. I disconnected phone and called back several times, line was busy. Finally got thru and spoke with the owner/manager. She apologized but provided and excuse that they were busy and indicated that they do not a archaic phone service from the where you could place calls on hold? Surprised they were so busy at 8pm on a Tuesday and they can afford to remodel business but not upgrade phone service or properly train employees on how to handle phone calls. Too bad they offered such a lame excuse instead of accepting ownership of the issue. Beware of ordering take out... you may have to wait 10 minutes for someone to take your order. Not a very good business model :-( read more

Tried it for the second time and I hate to say it but it's just not good. The burgers are small and taste gamy. I know they serve Ohio beef which is great but if the taste is not there then it can be a negative. I had the pickle chips too and they were just oily and uneatable. I want PJ's to make it but there are better spots on the square until it gets better. read more