Fantastic, stopped why on motorcycle ride with my son, grandson and a friend, all 4 of us were…read morevery pleased, Food was good and the service was Fantastic. I will be making trips back on a regular basis.

Disappointed this visit. Wednesday steak night. $2 Yeung's…read morebut beer had no head. The steak good price but not the quality. Ribbon fries were plentiful but I don't like ribbon fries. They go cold too quick Beans came with it. Salad OK nothing special. Service was good friendly. There was live music. I heard it had gone smoke free but it was not. I doubt I will be back.

Made a reservation for 10 people a few days out. They were super accommodating, and we even bumped…read moreit up by one like two days before. More kind and accommodating on the phone than just about any restaurant I've ever called. We came in like a half hour early, over the course of 20 minutes, cause we were traveling in multiple vehicles from ways away... I called ahead, but they said it was no problem at all. They were super helpful, I got drinks started while the rest of the party arrived. Ordered a bunch of appetizers... Mozzarella, sweet potato, waffle, fries, calamari... With like three different dipping sauces. Each of those was fantastic. Folks ordered burgers, chicken, cheesesteaks, traditional fair, like cottage pie, etc. Quantities were massive. Food was tasty. Many to go boxes were provided. The desserts were a surprise... I got my bread pudding to go. And then a few people got the lava cake and shared it. Great beer selection. Great cocktail selection. Great music on the speakers... At least I thought so, the Young'ns weren't as impressed with the sing-along Classics. Our server was beyond helpful, responsive, kind, accommodating,; probably one of the best I've ever had... Is that possible? Big party, I didn't check the details on the check... and the large party tip was included already. So I gave her too much cash for the tip, she stopped me on the way out and wanted to make sure I didn't screw up... Which I did. So she returned a couple bucks. But she earned every every bit for a tip yesterday.

Friendly service and delicious food! We are new to town and…read morethis was a great first stop. The cheese steak was fresh and perfectly seasoned. The fries were crisp and tender. My son enjoyed the burger and my husband says the fish and chips were fantastic. We'll be back!

There are good bartenders, and then there are those rare few who genuinely elevate the entire…read moreexperience -- today, she was that rare kind. Her warmth, attentiveness, and effortless hospitality turned an ordinary visit into something memorable. It's clear she doesn't just serve drinks -- she creates connection. I truly wish she were here more often; her presence brings something special that you can't teach There are good bartenders, and then there are those rare few who genuinely elevate the entire experience -- today, she was that rare kind. Her warmth, attentiveness, and effortless hospitality turned an ordinary visit into something memorable. It's clear she doesn't just serve drinks -- she creates connection. I truly wish she were here more often; her presence brings something special that you can't teach

This place is the salt of the earth. Nice people just having fun. Sienna, bar manager was so…read morenice and very helpful about the area. The beer is good priced and cold. The company is friendly and again Sienna was so nice and welcoming.

We had such a great meal! Carlisle has a lot of history and I love that this quaint restaurant…read morecaptures those vibes. If you enjoy whiskey then this is a great place to visit. If you don't enjoy whiskey this is still a great place to visit. I do recommend their old fashion and their midnight manhattan. We started with warm bread and butter. Best bread ever!! Then we tried the crab fries - fresh cut and cooked perfectly. Plenty of fresh crabmeat on top. We enjoyed the beef stroganoff- we added mushrooms - the beef was very tender. My husband doesn't like beef stroganoff but loved this. Finally, our server, Jayden, made our evening. She was so sweet and attentive. She really knew the menu and gave us some great recommendations. I hope her Dad gets to read these compliments because he really raised a wonderful human! We can't wait to visit the 1794 again and try some different menu items!

Came here for the first time for dinner with hubby. We orders the whiskey rings appetizer (I.e.,…read moreonion rings), trout, Wagyu steak, and a couple of beers. Total came out to approximately $99 (not including tip). What's hot - Menu. Fairly short and straightforward menu. There appears to be something for everyone, even possibly vegans (I.e., mostly salads). - Quality. The whiskey rings appetizer was delicious- lightly breaded, crispy, nicely seasoned, and a good dipping sauce. My trout was served hot and nicely seasoned, as well. Tender and moist. I would've liked the skin to be crispy. The main disappointment was the steak, which I address below. - Location. Fairly easy to find in town. They have a nice indoor seating area and seating on their front porch. Their outdoor seating area is very pleasant when the weather is nice. - Price. With the exception of the quality of the steak, which I address below, their food is good value for money. What's not - Quality. The Wagyu steak was a disappointment. They cooked it appropriately (my husband ordered it done medium), but the meat was not tender at all. Rather, it was tough despite it being cooked medium. Would not order it again and it makes me doubt the quality of the rest of their meats. - Service. My husband's main issue with their service is that the second round of drinks we ordered were full price, rather than the happy hour discount. He insisted with the wait staff that we ordered the second round right at the end of happy hour, but they did not accommodate his request. - Parking. There is street parking, but it's timed and metered. There are a couple parking lots nearby within a block's distance, but they're more expensive- approximately $5-$6/hr. If you're willing to walk a few blocks, there is free parking. - Reservations. It's probably dependent on the day and time you go, but it appears reservations may be better. We went for Friday dinner. The hostesses asked us if we had reservations, which we didn't. As such, they asked us if we prefer to be seated outdoors or at the bar. My point is to be prepared. Final answer Willing to return, but not a first choice.

good tunes and the restauras is cute. Great time and good food. tasty beer, my sister took…read moreGarrett's pen sorry Garrett

Came here for for the first time for lunch on a Sunday. We were a group of five and ordered their…read morepretzel sticks with beer cheese (appetizer), hummus wrap, fish sandwich, chicken fingers, two burgers, and a couple of beers. Total came out to approximately $99 (not including tip). What's hot - Quality. Fairly good. My hummus wrap was yummy and had a good amount of veggies wrapped with the hummus. Their fries are the best part and well-seasoned. Depending on the person, it could be considered overly-salty. Their beer cheese is pretty flavorful, as well. Their burgers are tender, juicy, and a good flavor. - Menu. Decent and short. - Location. Fairly easy to find downtown and there are other businesses and restaurants close by. Street parking is available, which is metered during the weekdays. - Price. With the exception of the sides, which I explain below, it's fairly good value for money, given the quality and decent size portions. What's not - Quality. Their soft pretzel sticks were not as soft as I expected. They were actually harder than I hoped. - Dishes come with potato chips. Their sandwiches come with potato chips. Fries, coleslaw, or salad cost extra. My hummus pita wrap and my friend's fish sandwich automatically come with potato chips, so ordering the fries cost extra. Not cool. This is a matter of personal preference. This is a pub, not a deli, so potato chips should not be an automatic side. - Not many vegetarian or vegan options. There is hummus, a salad option, and a fish option. Very limited, which is a detractor. - Service. One of our family members ordered their burger with no pickles and no mustard, but the wait staff made an error when they entered our order. I understand mistakes happen, but simple things like this take additional time to fix. The wait staff had to put in the correct order and we had to wait longer. Additionally, we had difficulty flagging down staff when we needed things. Their staff are nice, but they don't appear well-staffed. It was not full the Sunday afternoon we were there, so I'm uncertain what a busy time actually looks like. - Layout. For parties larger than 4, it appears they need to put tables together, so be prepared. Final answer Would be willing to return, but not a first choice.

The staff was pleasant and enjoyable to be around. The food was cooked perfectly. Honestly, the…read moreprices are too low. We thought they ran our bill wrong. We were driving through and in a hurry. The food came out so fast. It was like magic. I can't say enough positive things about our experience.

We were in visiting relatives in PA and had a Monday night dinner at Rustic Tavern. Service was…read moreprompt, friendly and efficient. We had the broiled Crab cakes and they were excellent. Maybe a 4.5! The Pork chop was amazing, wonderfully grilled and juicy and favorable! It was a decent value and pints of the local beer were only $3 a pint! Highly recommended if you are looking for a casual dinner in the Carlisle area!

Wings were good. Beer was good and cold (and there were options). The staff was kind and helpful…read more Only downside is the glaring, blinking, "Skills Games" machines that entrance kids.

Unbelievable ... A friend has been talking about this place for more than a year. I thought I knew…read morewhere it was and this is the place. I've ridden by it so many times and assumed it was the kind of place that reeked of pee and cigarette smoke. Nope, it was warm, clean, and had two of the nicest people serving delicious food and drinks. Most of us had fish sandwiches which were amazing. Fries come out in a gigantic basket and were also delicious. There were 10 of us and the dining room is slightly small so I'm not sure how many people could fit. We had a great time and a great meal.

I was not expecting to have a wonderful of a time as I did. Thought I'd stay for a few hours, ended…read moreup staying the whole day. Absolutely wonderful experience! After you've seen the house, take the time to walk around the grounds; the recreated farmland, the forest trail, and the gardens are all breathtaking. Loved the museum inside main building. The gift shop is more tasteful than is usual with historical locations (looking at you, Gettysburg). The food court didn't have much to offer by way of, well, anything that wasn't typical lame fast food, so that was a little disappointing, but they do offer outdoor seating so that was nice. This place is a national treasure. Bring the whole family!

The best in Pizza for the surrounding area!! Yummo stop in for a variety on the full menu!read more

Great food cold beer nice staff will return the next time we end up in town for the racesread more