As a Brazilian, I am very picky with my pizzas, this place has been one out of two pizza places in the U.S. where I truly enjoyed their pizza. Well done read more

I love Detroit style pizza, the cheese melted on the crust, all of it. Pandora's has a special on Wednesday and it is Detroit style deep dish!! Man, it is fantastic, don't worry about not being full. One pizza filled up 4 grown men, so you won't go hungry!! read more

Pandora's Pies - Pizza Near Me - Elon, North Carolina

See all

I've had Pandora's previously, but this was my first time dining in. It's a somewhat small restaurant and we had a little over 20+ minute wait on a weekend night. While there was a wait to be seated, the server wasted no time to take care of us. We were in and out within 30 minutes once we actually were seated at a table. My husband and I shared a small thing of garlic knots (4) and the bee sting pizza. We each got our own small pesto Caesar salad too. The garlic knots were good, but I wish there was more actual garlic than the garlic butter it was sitting on top of. The bread reminded me of a pretzel you'd get at a sports game. The pesto Caesar salad tasted like a regular Caesar salad with a hint of pesto. The bee sting pizza is a combo of pepperoni and hot-honey drizzled on top. I love the combination of pepperoni and honey, but be warned...it was SPICY. Service was great and quick. While I do love takeout at Pandora's, the crust of the pizza just tasted better dining in. This is a super casual, family friendly restaurant. There's a small parking lot nearby or you can find street parking. read more

See all

We did take out while moving our daughter back to Elon. The spinach, chicken salad was nice and fresh with apple slices, cranberries, candied walnuts and flavorful chicken and I really enjoyed the vinaigrette. The pizza is better than chain delivery pizza. I like the buffalo chicken pizza better than the pepperoni. They had it ready on time when we arrived. The inside looks spacious if you decide to eat in and they have a few TVs to watch while you eat. Noticed many people were eating wings which I would try if dining in. read more

See all

I was at Pandora's Pies to celebrate a coworkers birthday. The restaurant had a couple of large parties due to Elon's graduation that day. However, we were greeted immediately. I'm not a huge pizza fan so I didn't want to order pizza. I asked if the wings were something people get often. The wings were a customer fave according to the server. So I decided to get the wings with spicy heat sauce and the potato skins. The wings were really good and flavorful and had a nice kick of heat to them. And the texture was spot on because I prefer my wings breaded/crispy . I didn't like the green onions that were placed on them as a garnish. I asked about this prior and was told it wasn't going to be on there but it was so I just picked them off. The potato skins come with the same garnish but they were left off like I requested. I was not a fan of the potato wedges. I couldn't quite figure out what was wrong with them. It could've been because it was more skin than potato but it wasn't crispy like I would expect it to be. Overall, the experience was okay. The service and the ambiance made up for what it lacked in food on this day. I may try again when it's not graduation day. read more

Pandora's Pies - Wings - Pizza Near Me - Elon, North Carolina

See all

The food was very good but the overall demeanor of the wait time was disturbing we got our starters fast but the food was highly delayed. Overall the ambiance of the restaurant is amazing and highly recommend for everyone and get the potato skins because they are exquisitely delicious. There was an error with my food but could have been a misunderstanding because I ordered half cheese and got cheese with barbecue. read more

Pandora's Pies - Pizza Near Me - Elon, North Carolina

Great great atmosphere, as a typical for a pizzeria next to a college. The service was fast and professional. The pies themselves were middle of the road. My wife went back there and tried it again and again the pizza or the pies were not bad they're about average for a bar. read more

We experienced Great customer service , attentive , responsive and pizza was fresh and tasty ! I tried a different type of pizza than what I usually get. read more

We've been going to Pandora's for 10+ years and have always loved it. The pizza is high quality and tasty, but the garlic knots are a real treat. They have GF pizza options and a full ice cream section. Service is friendly and they have a rotating beer selection which usually includes multiple local options. read more

The best time ever! the food is soooo good, i recommend getting the bruschetta to start. I also recommend getting the pomegranate cider, it's sweet and tasty. The staff is incredibly kind and bubbly. They make pandoras always a fun experience whatever the occasion! read more

Pandora's Pies - The amazing staff - Pizza Near Me - Elon, North Carolina

Cool local pizza place in downtown Elon offering pizzas, calzones, salads, and sandwiches. The food is excellent, made with fresh ingredients. I had a personal Wharf Rat pie (the pie is so much better than the name!). They have unique pies or design your own. Their salads are outstanding as well. The dressings are made in house. Our servers were very friendly and had great recommendations. To address the pandemic, the restaurant has outside seating and has limited the inside seating. Staff wear masks, hand sanitizer is on every table, and the tables are sanitized after every turn. They are doing everything possible to make dining safe. read more

Pandora's Pies - Wharf Rat Pie - Pizza Near Me - Elon, North Carolina

Their deep dish pizza (they call Detroit Style) is AMAZING!!! My server Paris was friendly and did a great job! What a fun place to eat.

Damn good pizza ! Cbr is fantastic. I hate that my reviews have to be 85 characters....

Great food! On the door there was a poster advertising any large pizza with four ice creams for $40 for 4 people. The ice creams are two kiddie sizes and two small sizes of the ice cream, which, I believe, was not said on the poster. The pizza we ordered was the Day Tripper, which had a garlic oil base, prosciutto, caramelized onions, roasted red peppers, goat cheese, and arugula. It was a great choice- not too heavy, but also decently filling. The crust was super crispy/almost flakey, but not hard at all- delicious. Everything worked together well, so overall, a really good pizza! I left a separate review for Smitty's ice cream, but tldr; good ice cream, but not anything amazing. They do give out samples! read more

See all

This place is more "meh" than anything. The garlic knots were swimming in butter, the stromboli was under-stuffed and under-baked, and we were brought out an incorrect order, and didn't get the correct one until we were leaving. I'm pretty sure they forgot about it. It could have been a bad day for the kitchen, but it's not a spot that I would look forward to returning to again. read more

See all

We were in the area visiting our son and opted for a late afternoon lunch at Pandora's Pies. There were 4 of us and for the most part, we had the place to ourselves. We had a wonderful waiter who was very helpful and patient as we were all taking a little long to catch up before we ordered! We ended up ordering 4 salads: the Pesto Caesar Salad, the Chicken Spinach Salad, the Greek Salad and the Pandora's Salad. All were very fresh and were delicious. We are looking forward to coming back in a few weeks and trying some of their pizzas and wings as well. read more

Was in the area and heard this place was worth checking out, so I did. The inside dining room was closed at this time so there was a stand outside to place your order. Ordered the garlic knots, gluten free pizza, and the regular Margherita pizza. THE GARLIC KNOTS WERE TO DIE FOR! Seriously, dead. If you like garlic knots even a little, you must order these! They were fresh, warm, larger than your average knot, and beyond delicious! It came with a large cup of red sauce to dip it in. I want more just thinking of them now... The gluten free pizza was excellent, thin crust, fresh, and tasty. They dumped on plenty of toppings from edge to edge. The Margherita pizza had red sauce and the tomato slices on top. The place is located in downtown Elon, across from the University. There is parking on the both sides of the street. Since the dining room was closed, there was a tent next to the restaurant (not sure it was there for Pandora's or something for the University). There are a few outside tables and park benches around if you want to eat when you enjoy the college vibe and the atmosphere of a sweet small town USA. All and all, a pleasant Saturday afternoon experience. read more

See all

After trying different pizzas on different occasions I conclude this is THE most overrated pizza in North Carolina. Also service sucks. Sat with an empty drink for over 10 minutes multiple times. One bite everyone knows the rules. read more

We got three personal Bourbon BBQ Chicken pizzas. They were absolutely delicious (not the best pizza I've ever had but really good enough). The BBQ sauce was perfectly sweet and it hit the spot. Only thing there wasn't much chicken on the pizza so it wasn't as filling as I'd like. Crust is not too thick which I enjoyed. Great service as well. Waited about 20m for the food. I asked for some basil which was an additional cost. I usually get this with pizzas for free. Not a big cost but still. Although we didn't try other things on the menu, other tables seemed to be enjoying the garlic knots. I'd give that a shot my next time there. read more

Pandora's Pies - bourbon BBQ Chicken Pie - Pizza Near Me - Elon, North Carolina

Fun atmosphere. Excellent food. Good ice cream on the way out. So much of the staff has remained the same for years. Love Tuesdays for the make your own slices. Calzone's and Stromboli's are great. Wanna go light? Enjoy a salad read more

Stopped in for dinner tonight. We decided to get two personal sized pizzas so that we could try two different flavor combos. We ordered a Bee Sting and a Sinatra. Both were terrific. The service was amazing and to be as busy as they were, the wait for our pizzas was really short. We will most definitely be back!! This is a true gem for Elon!! read more

One of my favorite pizza and wing spots in Alamance County! A little hidden gym and Elon with some of the largest wings I've ever seen in my life lol I swear they come from a T-Rex. Not to mention they have some of the most creative pizzas I've also ever ate in my life. I always get the porkys little Diddy, shredded barbecue with barbecue sauce and a jalapeño relish is amazing! Definitely must try! They also put all of their draft for one dollar at the end of the month. Get there soon! read more

Great pizzas with fresh ingredients. Sandwiches good too. Highly recommend. Located across from Elon University. Good location. Good food.

Great Food. Justin is the fastest food runner in the south!!! Go see Justin you will not regret it. Service is fast! Atmosphere is great! read more

Try the chipotle chicken sandwich it's so gas five stars for that alone Ight I'm just typing to get to 85

My first visit was today....Reason for only 3 stars is totally based on how long it took to get our food - server was great, the food once it finally arrived at our table was excellent - meals came out in stages, we weren't able to actually eat "together"....pizza and salads are awesome. It took 45 mins or so to get our food and that's just not acceptable....if it's due to staffing, then be proactive and only seat folks in a manner that the kitchen can keep up with. And if the kitchen is running behind, keep the guests aware of timing...try to prevent them from becoming frustrated. I'm willing to give this place another chance...maybe it was a fluke, but who knows read more

WE LOVE PANDORAS PIES! Every time we order the food is always on point. I love that they offer vegan cheese on the pizza and the gluten free option is also nice. Great food. The atmosphere is cool but very college aged. Wishing there was an in-house delivery option as door dash is wayyy to expensive. read more

Justin is a great server and runner great restaurant for family and friends to eat. recommend this restaurant to everyone

I ordered 2 Pie's and the bottom of the pizza was burnt, really threw off the flavor. The wings and garlic knots are phenomenal. Really disappointed with the pizza... read more

We eat here occasionally and it's always good. Called in an order for three pizzas one of which was a supreme. When we got home with the pizzas the supreme looked like they were out of toppings at the end of the night. From some of the pictures you see on here you would think I ordered this pizza at closing time not two in the afternoon on a Saturday. Highly disappointed with this pizza. Half effort gets the customer a half pizza. read more

Pandora's Pies - Pizza Near Me - Elon, North Carolina

First time here. Ordered the personal size pepperoni. Crust is more like a cracker, a little chewy and very little sauce & cheese. The server was attentive and very friendly. There are too many good pizza parlors to return to this mediocre restaurant. It's very popular because it's surrounded by Elon University students. I'll not return to eat here read more

DoorDash 3 items yesterday. - Granny Smith Chicken Salad Sandwich - gets a 2 of 10 for poor bread. Focaccia is usually soft, fresh - not so - 6/12 was hard, not fresh :-( Ruins the sandwich - New York State of Mind regular pizza - gets a 2 0f 10 for meager amount red sauce, thinly spread over only 70% of the crust. Barely cheesy, finely ground (I think) sausage. It's just not appetizing. Try harder. - Salad - just average It's disappointing. Maybe college kids like it this way, but I like REAL, FRESH ingredients. Ice cream=BEST, Food=NO read more

LOVE LOVE LOVE PANDORA PIES! Me and my classmates enjoying coming here. Highly recommend getting the sweet heat wings, you won't regret it! Also the staff here is really nice. read more

See all

Has vegan (dairy free) cheese option that tastes good!!! Has good options and sizes. I am from NY but this is my go-to pizza while in NC :) read more

Great pizza even if you're not a student at Elon. Everything is so good. And, the servers are all so pleasant. I've only been here a handful of times. But, the food is consistently delicious. Even the vegan pizza. So many great toppings. read more

Okay. Had the calzone which was okay-nothing special. My main computer was the paper the calzone came out with. Why would you place paper under an item that has to be cut and eaten with a fork? I did my best to pull the paper out from under the calzone once I realized the paper was disintegrating and becoming part of the crust. If I go back and have anything that requires a knife and fork, I will ask for no paper. read more

Family of 4 ate for 48.00 before tip and was stuffed! Fresh ingredients, they said farm to table type freshness. Place was clean, well lit and good college staff service. Better than Mello. Also, clean and fresh bathrooms! read more

Pandora's Pies - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Elon, North Carolina

See all

So worth the drive from Greensboro. We had Strombolis which were delicious. The Green goddess was delicious and I created my own. Definitely will be back to visit!!! read more

This place had great pizza for a small local bar on the college campus of Elon. The beer selection was great. They had lots of many local beers to pick from. The service was slow, and the food did take a long time to get to our table. The restaurant was empty for the most part and it took about 45mins. The one thing I would suggest this restaurant get is a changing table for the bathroom. I had to change my baby on my lap. read more

I am an Elon Alumni and even though I don't live too far away, I don't get back to campus often enough. The way the campus has changed is pretty awesome and kinda depressing at the same time. Back in my Elon days, there weren't too many options for food outside of the campus cafeteria but now there are more options and one of those options is Pandora's Pies. I was in Elon to check out what was new with the campus since the last time I visited (lots) and I found Pandora's Pies which is right across the street from the main campus. Pandora's is laid back kind of a place with a menu consisting of pizzas, sandwiches, and salads. I wanted to get a personal pizza, but I also wanted the Caprese salad, and then I saw the Italian sandwich and I wanted that. Decisions decisions! I couldn't get everything I wanted so the Italian sandwich one out this time. The sandwich was a little different than what I am most used to with Italian sandwiches. Mainly referring to the bread which was Foccacia. Everything else tasted familiar as far as what you would expect, and the ingredients were fresh. I enjoyed the sandwich and would order again (but not before I tried the pizza and salads). Pandora's Pies is a somewhat hidden gem in sleepy Elon, NC and worth a visit if you are in the area! read more