I don't remember how I found this place, but I'm so glad I did. Literally THE best meatball sandwich--so fresh and the bread is amazing. I've been coming here a couple years now, and it's literally my go-to for when I just need a *really* good meatball sandwich. The cocktails are nice too :) would post a pic but I inhale the food too quickly to catch it; it's that good read more

can only speak to the sandwiches, but Panineria definitely delivers when it comes to Italian flavors. Even though I came in close to closing, the staff were welcoming and provided great service. I'm always drawn to spicy Italian meats, so I went with the Diamante--loaded with spicy salame, provolone, and olive oil--and it absolutely hit the spot. Really flavorful and satisfying. Overall, I'm glad I stumbled across this place and would definitely recommend it for sandwiches. Looking forward to coming back and trying more of the menu. read more

See all

I contacted Panineria to cater a lunch meeting in the office after it was recommended to me by one of my colleagues. The order was placed late last week for today. Placing the order via their website was very simple, and I received a confirmation via email right away. They communicated to me on the day of the meeting with an update that their A/C wasn't working and they were going to close early. However, that didn't prevent them from delivering the food order in time for the meeting. The food was delicious. There weren't any leftovers. A special shout-out to Francisco for his great communication. Highly recommended. read more

The food itself was good -- nothing mind blowing but tasty. However, we asked for our food to go and after paying our while and waiting a bit, we never received our to go food (which was like almost 2 whole sandwiches). I forgot about it because we lingered for a while and I'm not sure why it would take so long to pack up a sandwich. Partially on me for forgetting, but also disappointed in the slow service. I shouldn't have to remind someone to pack up my food and give it to me. read more

Panineria - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Decided to get food from this location and when I arrived I parked on the street nearby! I walked into the cutest little restaurant. I was greeted and sat and served by Katerina and a really nice server! I ordered: Bolognese Pasta Affogato Amaretto Chanti wine The food and wine were good! The Affogato was a great dessert! All in all, I had a really good experience! read more

See all

Chill vibe, very lowkey. Focaccia was legit. The service was alright. Food came out fasttttt. Quick spot to eat some bread before you go out haha. Lots of carry out orders pulling through. read more

Panineria - Focaccia - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Narrow sandwich spot with some viability as a hidden sit-down restaurant that serves alcohol. Very fast service and fresh sandwiches. I don't have a particularly strong opinion on how it stacks up against the rapidly-spreading All'Antico Vinaio or the other gourmet sandwich shops all over the Village. It tasted good, although the focaccia was a bit soggy by the end, and the POS tip percentage was on top of tax, making the sandwich + lemonade a bit pricey ($35+) for what should be a go-to lunch stop. read more

Plenty of options available at this elegant pasta and panini spot. Sure, the gourmet sandwiches are pricey, but they're big, and the quality of the ingredients is top. I split a Fresh Truffle on an onion focaccia that was to-die for. Their sangria is also very good, and so was their complementary pistachio cream shot... mmh. The tiramisu was very little for its price tag. The staff is super nice, too. They have another location in the UES (mostly take out) and a much bigger one (100 seats) coming up in Morningside in the fall (can't wait for this one). Recommended. read more

See all

I had the focaccia with potato which was the star of my sandwich. So soft, buttery, and a slight crunch from the potatoes. The perfect bite. I felt the prosciutto to be a little salty and the sandwich I had modified to have no cheese but still came out $20. I'm not sure how it came out being an extra 50% more expensive but the cashier assured me she'd customize my sandwich accordingly. read more

Panineria - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I ordered a sandwhich through DoorDash from here. Specifically the Vegetarian burrata Sandwhich which I added a chicken cutlet and pesto sauce to for an upcharge. When my sandwich came all it had was a chicken cutlet, tomatoes and some pesto sauce. No arugula or burrata cheese,which is what they advertise to come on the sandwich already read more

Panineria - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

A gem! Great service, reasonably priced, and the food was amazing. I got the Peppe panini, and it is my new favorite. Highly recommend. I will absolutely be a regular at Panineria. read more

Spending more & more time in the city these days. Saw a post about Panineria somewhere with a positive review and decided to have a sanddd-A-beeech. Drove to St Marks Pl. Walked in, it's a small place in a 'residential' neighborhood off of 5th Ave. This was mid afternoon. There were people walking in & picking up orders. It does have a few tables for 'dinning in'. It looked clean & had a nice aroma of... herbs & food. The staff was extremely friendly. After perusing the menu for a few minutes, decided on the Fresh Truffle sanddd-A-beeech (prosciutto de parma, organic mozzarella, truffle cream, organic arugula & truffle oil). I had a choice of three breads - baguette, ciabatta or potato focaccia. I chose the potato focaccia based on two recommendation from the staff, ordered it warm. Finally it came out, back to grandma's. Woe, that is huge, Jurassic Park size. Probably feed a family of four from elsewhere in the world. I was somewhat disappointed with the flavor of the potato focaccia - lacked something...seasoning...onion, like a French potato/onion tart... Will be back soon read more

Panineria - Fresh Truffle sanddd-A-beeech, trust me it's big & delicious - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Incredible sandwiches. The bread is amazing and the fresh cut meats and cheeses are delicious. Such nice staff and easy take out ordering system. Will be back! read more

This place made me wish i had 3 stomachs Everything. And i mean everything on the menu is Certified 5 star general deliciously amazing. Small place with small staff but every bit of my experience in this restaurant was pleasant. I had a macaroni n burrata salad.mind blowing flavor.that alone was 5 stars. I also had some sandwich there with arugula,mortadela,mozz, sun dried tomatoes! Fire as well. Honestly this place so good id do my daughters quinceañera here..definitely bookmark worthy spot. Cant wait to come back n kill the rest of the menu read more

Panineria - Pasta Burrata Salad I like how the burrata dictates the flavor and the macaroni the texture. Smart delicious combo - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Came here twice on a 4 day trip. The sandwiches are made with a lot of organic and super high quality ingredients and SO GOOD. The service is very nice and attentive for such a spot. Panineria is unique I think because it kind of skirts the line between an italian sandwich shop and a nicer italian restaurant. The spot in the village is quite small, but cozy feeling instead of cramped. The sandwiches are great, with great bread (I had a potato foccaccia sandwich which was a first for me). There's not a lot of places like this in that area. I will definitely sing Panineria's praises read more

Writing an update because I cam back today and it was so good. Got my usual, the Peppe panino and this time the baguette was warm and crunchy. Unreal. They redid the inside and changed ther furniture both inside and outdoors. Great experience. read more

Panineria - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

The food and service were incredible at Panineria! I definitely recommend to anyone in the area. Very cozy inside and lovely ambiance. read more

Panineria - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Came here for an event. It's a cozy Panini shop that also has pasta. I like the lemon trees wrapped around the pipes above the counter, and they have fun Halloween decorations up. Tried a few different sandwiches. Service was friendly. Bread was great, as was the mozzarella and salami. Going to have to come back and try a couple others. read more

See all

The food was amazing, but surprisingly that wasn't the best thing about this restaurant. The service was 10/10 and the waiters were so attentive and so friendly! Shout out to Marco for being an amazing waiter read more

Amazing little authentic Italian restaurant close to the main NYU campus. We stopped there for lunch and had a lovely meal. We tried the pasta and several different sandwiches. We highly recommend the meatball sub and pesto pasta. If you get a sandwich make sure you get it on a baguette. read more

Panineria - Meatball Sub on a baguette. - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Good quality sandwiches with fresh ingredients. I tried the special which had ham, goat cheese, arugula, hot honey, and evoo. It was pretty filling and you can choose ciabatta or baguette. There are only 6 seats so it's more of a take out spot read more

Ordered for pick up - order was correct, on time, communicated about via text and best of all - delicious! The sandwiches and pasta were excellent and the price was fair. We actually ordered from the new UWS location read more

Marcos damn charming! Amazing truffle panini too! Super good music and atmosphere was so cute! Service was fast and again we are quite charmed. I would jump off a bridge if he asked me too! read more

Marco was so fantastic. I had the most incredible experience, and the food was super tasty.

We visited Panineria and tried 2 sandwiches from their special menu that just came out! They are both amazing and wonderful. First we tried the 4 Cheese Lover Sandwich on their baguette. The baguette is just the right amount of crispiness and not hard! The sandwich is really cheesy and flavorful, with every bite blending the flavors of four different cheeses. Next is the Chicken Cordon Blue Sandwich on their ciabatta. It had a juicy chicken cutlet, Italian ham, and fresh mozzarella. The sandwich came out so hot that it was still steamy when I got halfway through! It was simple, flavorful, and so satisfying. For dessert, we had a lemon sorbet with peach purée. It is perfect for summer. We also had the rich chocolate cake with vanilla ice cream. Definitely will visit again! read more

Yum yum yum delish Caesar salad + Americano sandwich changed my perspective on Italian food read more

3rd time i went here and this time it will be my last one. Ti expensive for a sandwich lacking everything. Basically all you get is the smell of the chese and the ham. They also git my order wrong. I m not sure how they can stay in buisness read more

great food and drinks!! the service is amazing - Felipe helped me with my order and recommended the peppe sandwhich. SO GOOD!

Buono. Fresh ingredients, good bread, fair prices. Great service. It was worth the trip to check it out. To compare with other similar places, I felt the ingredients and bread are fresher/more tasty than the chain Antico Vinnaio. I can't speak for the OG location on Sullivan where I had some of the best sandwich memories of my life but have not been back for many years and only visit their franchise locations which are subpar compared to panineria. I hope that as panineria expands that it will maintain that same quality I experienced today. One nitpick is that the restaurant was a bit dark for lunch and was lighted as if for dinner service. I love the lunchtime vibe a Da Capo and wish it was a similar vibe here but I guess they have a more extensive menu and want to give a more formal restaurant feel. Overall no complaints, and hope to be back soon! The waiter was great! read more

Panineriq has some very tasty sandwiches in addition to some Italian dishes. Service is quick and my server very friendly. These sandwiches are not small so you will not leave hungry. The atmosphere is that of a cozy cafe. My prosciutto sandwich had the right amount of meat and d not too much bread. read more

See all

I from Florida and saw a reel about this place so naturally we had to check it out. The food was delicious and our server was amazing and super friendly. The restaurant is so cute with the lemons on the ceiling was totally worth checking out. read more

See all

We had a delicious focaccia sandwich and split it because it was big and also had a glass of their wine with the 5 dollar wine deal. Truffle sandwich on focaccia is a must. And Shakira was super helpful, very attentive, great service! read more

Panineria - Burrata Sandwich - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

We loved this place, super nice servers, food was great and affordable! Our party of 3 had three different sandwiches and all were fantastic! read more

I have been wanting to try this spot for a long time, as I heard they had excellent sandwiches. Let me tell you it did not disappoint. I added the spicy sauce to a burrata sandwich with spicy salami. So delicious. Highly recommend! read more

Cozy restaurant in fabulous location by Washington Square with outstanding food, all home made. Service by Lyza was fabulous and overall atmosphere was wonderful. read more

A bit pricey but very good sandwiches. I ordered a burrata sandwich on a baguette. The staff was very friendly and the place looked very nice for a lunch date. read more

Panineria - Burrata Sandwich - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Woo! This place is worth the hype. I loved it so much, I came back twice in two weeks. Haha I had been looking for a really good sandwich place in NYC, and this place came up. I had their most popular sandwich - the Peppe Sandwich. That thing is huge and delicious. Definitely worth the price. The staff is very sweet too - very accommodating. The ambiance is nice but it's kind of small on the inside. Definitely sit outside. Dining with a little view is always nice. Highly recommend this place! read more

Panineria - Peppe SANDWICH - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Service was wonderful, prices were extremely fair, and the food was sooo delicious!! Liza was our server--she was really friendly, personable, and made it a 10/10 experience! Will definitely recommend to my friends/family! read more

Yum! Ordered a sandwich for delivery for lunch the other day and it was great! All of the ingredients were very fresh especially the mozz and bread. I would definitely get again. I got the sorrento with arugula read more

Panineria - Sorrento Sandwich - Vegetarian - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Stoped by here on a beautiful and sunny Saturday to eat outside with friends. Although we were immediately seated, it did take a while for someone to come and take our order but the food was so good that I'm not even gonna takeoff a star for that because it just made our experience that much more relaxed and fun. We all got sandwiches and everyone enjoyed what they had. The burrata sandwich on a baguette, which is what I got, was definitely a stand out. I saw that in some reviews people said that they didn't give enough meat in the sandwich but personally, I think that when you overload a Parma or any sort of prosciutto sandwich with too much meat, you don't get the proper mixture of flavors in each bite, and I thought that the portion sizes here were absolutely perfect and reasonable for the price. Definitely will return here one day, hopefully soon!!! read more

Panineria - Burrata Sandwich - Italian Near Me - New York, New York