The pizza was very good. I ordered online so I asked for a specific time which was Super Bowl Sunday the only complaint was my Pizza stuff to the bottom of the cardboard. read more

Their pizzas are good size, but very pricey. This is my second pizza I got from Panther Pizza, and the crust on both pizzas wasn't done. I ordered a large pepperoni with 4 different toppings. There was only 3 pepperoni on the pizza. They put way to much sauce on it, couldn't even taste the cheese. I'm a pizza lover, and couldn't tolerate this pizza!! I believe their oven isn't working properly. I wouldn't recommend this pizza place, unless you like undone crust and way to much sauce on your pizza. read more

Walked in at 7:30 and they would not serve us even though their hours are listed until 8:00 pm. Any good business owner knows you serve customers until the hours posted. They did is a huge favor though, went down the street to Bourbon St Pizza and had a great pie with super friendly staff. read more

The pizza is delicious and huge! Probably our favorite pizza in Nappanee. It takes a long time to get it though so be sure to plan ahead.

The best pizza in town. First time we ordered they Have Great Service and Food. Panther Pizza is definitely a place to go and get there food. Highly Recommend tiring and going back for more. Great Job read more

Panthers has the best pizza! Our first time we ordered an extra large, lol if you've never ordered their extra large, be ready for pizza for days! I like that they employee a lot of teenagers, and that the kids do a great job. It's our go-to for pizza night! read more

Pizza was O.K. We ordered a Margarita Pizza and a Pepperoni for the kids. Our Puzza was fresh and tasted great. The kids was just O.K. Edges were black and crust was too tough for my kid to enjoy. The price seems high but I will say you get a lot for the money. The people working were pleasant and attentive, and the store was clean. read more

This place was pretty good. The ingredients seemed really fresh and good quality, the service was fast and good, and the price was reasonable. Hubby and I got the chicken broccoli pizza and bruschetta. The bruschetta just seemed like they used Italian dressing so it was super greasy, but again the ingredients were really good so you didn't totally mind. Pizza was good (good ingredients, nice shape, very fresh) but the crust was really bland, and a little undercooked in the middle. We will try it again. read more

We live in Louisville but whenever we are in town this place is a must!!! I haven't found a better pizza, it's the best! read more

Panthers Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Nappanee, Indiana

absolutely worst service ever! came in at a lunchtime to order food and sit down and wanted to eat the gentleman running The register was extremely rude to myself as well to my husband. food took about 45 minutes to make went up and asked gentleman how long the wait would be, and he said oh I could've told you it was a 20 minute wait but.. we had been there over a half an hour waiting on our food. We won't be back again so sad because of all of the reviews that I've seen and also how good the food is and this was very disappointing to live in a small town and have a such a talked about company treat its customers the way that they were treated and then for him to also bash the local police department and EMT service because they came in and ordered pre-sliced pizza and made it as if it was a burden to him that they came in on lunch and brought pre-sliced pizza, and made it clear to other customers basically bought it all just such a sad thing that to say that they will never be getting my service again or my money. read more

When I first started going their it was really good pizza. But it's starting to get worse. Staff is still really friendly. Prices are really high. Would recommend if you are willing to pay an arm and a leg. Pasta is pretty good. read more