Easily the best pizza in Marshall County. Great thin crust tavern style pizza with toppings almost…read moreto the edge. I intentionally try to plan trips to Bremen around their operating hours so I can order pizza to take back home to Winona Lake. Restaurant is so popular that the wait times quickly escalate, so I always call the night before to insure I get the pick up time I want.

Food was lava hot comes out fresh Prices are responsible…read more Family friendly and clean They don't really have a wait staff to take orders or refills so you have to get up and go back and forth a lot to the order counter they will bing the food out but that's about it. The beer is ice cold The sides of garlic cheese bread and Broccoli bits are small but taste good The pizza is good but average nothing special Better than like Casey's or Pizza Hut haven't tried the sandwich but they looked good 6 or 7 out of 10 but 3.5out of 5

Wow was the pizza here good, and the delivery was fast and reliable. We had two sizes of thin crust…read morepizzas, the cheese pizza seemed extra thin and really, really tasty. The sausage pizza we had was amazing and if we had gotten a smaller one, we probably would've been fighting over who got the last piece. The cheesy garlic bread was good and we were getting delivery from not that far away so maybe that's why but the fried mushrooms and french fries that we had in our delivery order were still really really tasty even though those kinds of things can cool off en route. I will definitely try this place the next time I'm back near here.

Best pizza in the area! Good selection of toppings and the crust is terrific. We order from here…read moreevery week. My boyfriend likes the sausage and pepperoni and the little nieces and nephews like plain cheese. The 20" leaves enough for seconds and leftovers for the next day. Reasonably priced as well. Highly recommended!

I have previously left a great review a couple of years ago. Hadn't ordered from them for a while…read moredue to the very long wait times. Today, I decided that I wanted something different and had a drive until I was back in town, so it would be fine to have a longer wait time for pick up. I don't see why it takes 45 minutes to make a regular crust pizza with one topping, but at least they let you know ahead of time. My issue today was that I also ordered a sandwich. I picked up my food as the pizza was coming out of the oven, in which I had to wait on.. and the whole time my sandwich was setting there boxed up. It had been boxed up for quite some time. The sandwich was cold, and the pizza was bland and didn't have the extra sauce that I paid for. It's just very bland pizza. The crust is flavorless, and it seems like the cheese is too. The sandwich would have been good if it was hot and the oil hadn't soaked into the bread by the time my pizza was ready. Let me also add, that it's a pretty pricey pizza. So... high cost, long wait times, and meh flavor.

We have never been here before but when visiting Plymouth we stopped in to try the pizza…read more First the good, it was quick and the pie had plenty of cheese. The toppings were covered with cheese so I couldn't see the quality or quantity. The pie crust was too thick and chewy for our taste. The price for a 14 inch, 2 topping pizza was twenty dollars. Not exactly a bargain. We were expecting more.

I want to thank the team at Bourbon Street Pizza for helping me deliver a special Friday treat for…read moremy student and her dormmates at Culver Girls Academy! Ordering in advance was SUPER easy, prices were reasonable, the pizza was delivered right on time, and the students loved it!! You made it SO easy for me to do something special for my student and her friends from hundreds of miles away!

A great value pizza backed by consistently great staff. The pizza is ready on time every time…read more Made to your specifications without fail. Fresh ingredients. Good crust. Terrific online ordering.

Ordered to go. I was actually surprised in a good way with the pizzas we ordered. The hand tossed…read morecrust is the way to go. Quality sauce and plenty of toppings. Friend my staff on pick up.

Very solid pizza. They will do large deliveries, pretty consistent with not messing up orders. I…read morewish their cinnamon sticks were better, and their pizza isn't top-notch. Their breadsticks and cookies are very good though. They have a wide variety of pizza types and options to add any toppings you want and are quick with their deliveries. Eating at the restaurant is nice, too. They have free refills on their drinks, a TV which usually has sports on, and serve you at your table. If you're in Nappanee, this is the pizza place to go to.

Service is always good!! Pizza was absolutely delicious! Lots of toppings and plenty of cheese!!…read morePizza Bills never disappoints!!

The food has been consistent since the 90s, which isn't a bad thing at all! Sadly since Covid the…read moredining room has stayed closed. Honestly I'd probably give them 5 starts if they'd just open that back up.

The pizza was very good. I ordered online so I asked for a specific time which was Super Bowl…read moreSunday the only complaint was my Pizza stuff to the bottom of the cardboard.

Their pizzas are good size, but very pricey. This is my…read moresecond pizza I got from Panther Pizza, and the crust on both pizzas wasn't done. I ordered a large pepperoni with 4 different toppings. There was only 3 pepperoni on the pizza. They put way to much sauce on it, couldn't even taste the cheese. I'm a pizza lover, and couldn't tolerate this pizza!! I believe their oven isn't working properly. I wouldn't recommend this pizza place, unless you like undone crust and way to much sauce on your pizza.

Leftover food served as fresh (heard directly from the owner this is how every night begins), dirty…read moreestablishment (unclean floors, cobwebs on the ceiling), hot and humid in the dining area and flies so bad you have to be careful you don't mistakenly eat one! Not sure what keeps the doors open, but our family and friends will not be back!! Side note: I'm also convinced we had a light case of food poisoning after eating their greasy pork ribs. not a pleasant experience.

If you're going to bring back a business, do it right. They never answer the phone, hours are…read moreinconsistent. I saw someone get carry out on a friday at 11:30, then called Saturday and the voicemail said only open 4-8. Make it make sense.