Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Pantry Pizzeria

    3.7 (3 reviews)
    Open 11:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Updated 2 months ago

    Pantry Pizzeria Photos

    PANTRY PIZZERIA ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Pantry Pizzeria

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    1 month ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Jeff L.
    115
    280
    1430

    2 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    2 months ago

    Horrible service and very bland pizza. Not worth the money. The owner is very rude. Not for sure what else to say

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 1,028 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    BuffaLouie's - Medium Traditional Wings with Celery & Carrots with a Soft Drink

    BuffaLouie's

    3.9(456 reviews)
    4.1 mi
    $$

    Onion Rings: 10/10 -- i would come back just for these!!! the crisp was immaculate and the batter…read morewas so good the onion stayed in tact with each bite. the house sauce was a creamy aoili-like mix which was super yummy too. Buffalo Chicken: 6/10 -- my sister got this and rated it a 6 (because there are no 7s on my scale). for $15+ and no side of fries this was kind of a scam sandwich lol #recessionindicator Sweet Lou's: 6/10 -- heavy on the sweet i was a fool i looooove bbq but their special "q sauce" was a bit like molasses rather than classic bbq. the patty, onion ring, and bacon were perfect but i literally could not taste them without scraping off the sticky sauce. again, $15+ and no side i feel like the flavor wasn't enough for me to recommend this to anyone. Tender & Fries: 6/10 -- what in the walmart brand frozen curly fries without salt nonsense on a plate was this... they got us LOOOOL... great value??? YEAH hard pass!!!! I was visiting my sister and she recommended this place because she had heard about it from fellow IU students. My thoughts: come for the IU memorabilia, and ambience, eat an order of onion rings (maybe sip a beer) while you watch a game and leave! The food was mediocre at best and wayyy overpriced.

    Bloomington institution that, if you have parents, they'll wanna go to with you…read more If you dont have parents its still an okay place to go. Counter service, cold beer, pretty good wings. Right by the sample gates. Cool inside too, lots of different levels of seating.

    Photos
    BuffaLouie's
    BuffaLouie's - Buffalo Chicken Salad

    Buffalo Chicken Salad

    BuffaLouie's - All-American Burger with Curly Fries

    See all

    All-American Burger with Curly Fries

    WingsXtreme U - Same thing I ordered Mozzarella Sticks I didn't ask for fried air

    WingsXtreme U

    2.7(98 reviews)
    4.7 mi
    $

    holy cow the wings here are crazyyy. i got a deal, 10 wings for $9 and thought they were gonna be…read moreskimpy for that low, but oh my god these are so crazy. i could imagine seeing god if i ate these drunk. sauce is amazing, and they DUNK these mfs in it. literally 10/10 the mozzarella sticks are mid. big tho and service was quick and easy. nice.

    WORST experience for food and customer service I have ever encountered. GM hung up on me instead…read moreof discussing their errors and never even apologized. They took a delivery order when had no delivery method and never contacted to let us know. When I called to check on my order I was told. The food had been sitting for 30 min already. They "found" a way to get a doordash driver and said they would remake my food as requested since it had been sitting. When it arrived everything was hard as a rock and dried up as it had obviously been thrown back in the fryer a second time. The wings were black! And literally hard as rocks! Completely inedible. The GM wouldnt even discuss it and told me he didnt have time to deal with it and would tell the owner and hung up on me when I asked for a refund. I called back and was hung up on again after he called me HONEY! I called back the next day to ask about my $100 refund for food that ALL had to be thrown out and was told the owner said he wouldnt authorize a refund! What!? This is horrible customer service! I have pictures of this awful food! Fries were whitened they were so dried out! $100 for no food we could eat and not even an apology or attempt at making it right! Horrible place! Don't waste your money! ZERO STARS!

    Photos
    WingsXtreme U - Store menu board

    Store menu board

    WingsXtreme U - Order Mozzarella Sticks with no cheese? I think not I am mad

    Order Mozzarella Sticks with no cheese? I think not I am mad

    WingsXtreme U - Menu

    See all

    Menu

    Twisted Wings  - Lemon pepper wings

    Twisted Wings

    4.6(23 reviews)
    53.8 mi

    Yum! Twisted Wings is a contender for best wings in town. They have over 30 different sauces and…read morethey are excellent. They'll let you try samples of sauces. I recommend doing that because their standard buffalo sauce (which was alright) was the worst of the sauces that I sampled. I ordered hot honey wings and loaded fries. The hot honey wings were dynamite. The loaded fries were good too - the fries and seasoning were great and the nacho cheese was okay. The staff was nice and patient with me since I was a newbie. The restaurant consists of a take-out counter so you have to place your order to go, which takes about 10 minutes. They have a couple of picnic tables outside. Chilly Water Brewing is across the street if you get bored waiting for your order. There isn't a parking lot so you have to park on the street. They're open until midnight, but I would feel weird going here after dark because it's not in the greatest part of town.

    Noticed this place when visiting an establishment across the street and made a mental note. The…read morewings were good, similar to most other wing spots but a little too heavy on the bbq sauce for me. I was greeted promptly when I walked in. I did a pickup order that was ready when I arrived and my fries were still hot and fresh. Parking can get a little tricky with it being in a residential area and other nearby businesses.

    Photos
    Twisted Wings  - Menu

    Menu

    Twisted Wings  - Stinging honey garlic and pineapple jalapeño boneless wings with a regular loaded fries!

    Stinging honey garlic and pineapple jalapeño boneless wings with a regular loaded fries!

    Twisted Wings  - 20PC TRADITIONAL

    See all

    20PC TRADITIONAL

    Pantry Pizzeria - pizza - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...