I ordered the fettuccine Alfredo so creamy so good, the garlic knots were amazing, the canoli was ok not that great. The cream melted by the time I had it. The restaurant is located at the Montgomery shopping center next to cvs & l.a fitness. Service was friendly and quick. Is a family oriented establishment which is very nice. Can't wait to try their pizza next time. Prices r decent for the amount of food they give you. read more

See all

Pizza pie prices are reasonably sized for their price and ambiance was cool pizza place. The toppings can add up though so don't get ahead of yourself. Not sure it warrants me for a return but great spot nonetheless if you're in the area. We sat outside because it was just nice evening for it. I wish I would have ordered the pizzas crispy though but I acknowledge that's to my liking. Service was also quick and breezy too.. read more

Papa Joe's - Pizza Near Me - Altamonte Springs, Florida

Staying with a friend down the street, so I went here a couple of times. Slice of Cheese Pizza: not a favorite. Friends felt it was good New York Pizza. Meatballs Sub: Meatballs were great, sauce good and plenty of cheese! Bread, however, was over toasted and hard. Side of fries were ok...added salt. Chicken Parmesan: The chicken was actually very good. Side of pasta was ok. Garlic bread was more grilled bread with a little cheese sprinkled on top. Salad was very basic. Service was good. Prices varied. Don't want to pay $20 for pasta unless I know it's going to be great! read more

It feels very much like a classic family owned restaurant. I've only had pizza from here. Every time I've been there to pick up pizza, the locals and staff know each other. read more

Staff were fighting in the kitchen tonight. Lots of customers in the dining room and lined up to pick up orders that could see and hear them fighting. Delivery service drivers also got yelled at and told to wait away from the pick up area. Doesn't seem like the best work culture or managed well. Great pizza though. read more

My husband and I love Papa Joe's!! The food is great! The service is excellent! It's a lovely family, mom and pop restaurant. Papa Joe's does not disappoint!! read more

Best pizza, hands down! Fold over and hold in your hand pizza. Chewy crust that's crispy in all the right spots. The owner is quite a character, too. They've had many of the same employees for decades! That's how you know a place is worth frequenting. Before you know it, you will know all their names and they'll be yelling "Hey Joe!" as you walk in the door. Great iced tea too. read more

Don't get me wrong, it wasn't bad, it just wasn't good enough. The salad was just average, the spaghetti was watery and average, and my Calzone was good, just not great. Service was good. Atmosphere was OK, price was average to lower than some. Didn't try the pizza, but NY style is generally poor, so. . . . Doubt if we will return? There are better Italian restaurants around! But in a pinch, maybe ? ? ? read more

If I could give this place a negative rating, I would. The manager was extremely aggressive and obnoxious toward me--it was genuinely scary, and I had no idea what his intentions were. For my own safety, I had to walk out of the restaurant because I felt completely unsafe. His behavior was despicable, unprofessional, and totally unacceptable. read more

Papa Joes has become our favorite local pizzeria. Just a fantastic NY style pie! But it's not just the pizza that's amazing, everything we have ordered has been great! Our favorites are the baked gnocchi (just wow!) the meatball sub and/or the chicken parm sub (the best chicken parm sub in CFL and it's made on a sesame seed roll which is next level!) If you live in the area and your family needs a go-to Italian restaurant, choose Papa Joes. read more

Papa Joe's - Homemade Baked Gnocchi - Pizza Near Me - Altamonte Springs, Florida

See all

Hands down, my favorite lasagna around!! Always delicious, cheesy and saucy. It reminds me of home.

We have never had a bad meal here. We have eaten the pizza, gluten free white pizza, lasagna, cake and many other items on the menu. They have all been delicious. Tonight was really spectacular. I had the Sicilian Salmon without the butter sauce for my gluten allergy. It was so fresh. Just the right amount of seasoning, the broccoli was tender but not too much and the lighter sauce was so good and lemony, I loved it. My friend and hubby had sausage ravioli which they both enjoyed and her husband had lobster ravioli which was in a pink sauce and stuffed nicely. The service was impeccable and we almost always get a hello from the owner-tonight it was a Merry Christmas wish and wonderful conversation. Don't miss this little gem plus they have two more in Lake Mary. read more

See all

In my heart of hearts, I want to give this place a high ranking. But, it's getting 3 stars, which is a C grade. First off, the ambience is fun and a bit campy. It's decent enough. A mix of Italian-inspired decor, with tons of Brooklyn Dodgers memorabilia (which is cool) and then old food service posters - you know those posters about cheese, tomatoes, deli meats, etc. So, it's all a mish-mash. But you get the point that the owner is an old-school, real Brooklyn-Italian. And he is. And he's really, really nice. And cares about food and restaurants. That's why I want so badly to give this place a 5, but because of the food, it's a 3. So what was good? Well, Joe's Antipasta Salad is actually very good. Large portions of meat and cheese on lettuce and a really good Italian dressing make this salad, not only a good value, but something you could devour after a workout, and still feel good about, while getting in some serious protein. So yes it was good, although it did have that food-service kitchen quality to it, rather than genuine restaurant quality. Let's get to the disappointing part. The garlic knots. They were dry, hard and stale almost. Covered in oil and basic, raw minced garlic. If you've been to a great Italian joint, or other places in Orlando (I'm talking about you Pizza Bruno) you know how good a garlic knot can be. Here, they were just bad. Not a pleasure to eat. Tough on the stomach. And almost thrown together. Then the pizza, which I ordered super thin and crispy. It came out not that way. It was chewy and still doughy. The cheese and sauce were good, but nothing remarkable. But again, it just doesn't come close to other places with smashingly good pizza. It's just really average. Which is the fitting term for this place in general. Really, really average. Hence 3 stars. Yes, it's a heart-warming local joint, with all of the best intentions. But somewhere that doesn't translate onto the plate. I wouldn't say don't go, but I wouldn't make it a special trip. And stay away from those knots. read more

See all

Not the same Poppa Joe's as the years go by and time passes. Probably more of a 3.5 these days but still a good joint to stop by for a couple of cuts and a coke. Still wish they sold the bianca by the slice like they do in most pizza joints. read more

See all

Great service and good food . I have been going there for years .... I never got a dish I didn't like.

We have been here a few times for lunch and it was not the same. There seems to be new staff and lots of politic talk coming from the kitchen into the dining space. read more

This is the best pizza place in town! I love the cheese pizza, chicken wings, baked ziti, and garlic bread. Very friendly staff and excellent location. Fast take out. Highly recommend. Long time customer! The Steeler Lady. read more

The pizza is wet garbage. At nearly 20 bucks for a personal pizza I shouldn't have to bake it at home just to be able to eat it. Soupy and gross. I expected better. What a let down. read more

Incredible! A large group of us came here for an early dinner and the service was outstanding. Honestly, it was the best service I've ever had at a pizza joint. And their food, wow! We had several pizzas and wings. We ordered the hot wings and the garlic extra crispy and they did not disappoint. They were crispy, sauces, and loaded with garlic. We also had the Bianca and added sausage. It was the best Bianca I've ever had. I literally had to stop myself from eating the entire pizza. If you're in the area, you have to try this place. read more

See all

Pizza was delicious! The staff was so friendly and the food was ready quickly. The whole restraint was like a big Italian family with fun and laughter everywhere. It will be joining our families dining rotation. read more

We eat at Papa Joes probably once a month for the last 3 years. We were seated before 6 PM and the service was sub par for sure! Took over 10 minutes for someone to bring us a menu. The server that seated us and wasn't our was rude and sad they were busy. Others that were seated after us already had drinks. Finally we got a menu and ordered drinks and a pizza. The pizza was brought out and it was barely warm. My wine glass was empty and no one asked if I'd like a refill. I only ate 1 slice because of the luke warm temperature. The server finally came over after my husband had eaten 2 slices and asked what was wrong. She was also non apologetic. You could tell she was not properly trained. No manager came to the table. The pizza was good when I went home and reheated it. Its a shame a great neighborhood place has slipped this low. It will be a while before we go back if we do. read more

Surprised by the reviews. This a very tasty NYC style pizza. The crust I usually get rid of, too dense, but this was actually chewy and crushable. Thin crust, well cooked. I did come by because they posted on Facebook that they have a NY style Sicilian slice. I went in for that and they didn't do it by the slice. Maybe next time. read more

Ah, Papa Joe! You've won my heart with your amazing food, atmosphere, sarcastic (humorously!) cooks, and attentive servers (shout out to Renee and Mike). Not a single bad meal in the dozen and a half times I've visited in the last 3 months. From the chicken parm sub and gnocchi to the calzones, pizza slices, garlic knots, and fettuccini Alfredos it is all pure heaven. One day, I wish upon a wish I'll get to meet the legendary you I've heard so much about and thank you for an amazing establishment. But for now, I'll be content feasting on everything on the menu. Until we meet... mangiare felice! read more

This meal was $17 , I think that's a bit much . The pizza was ok & I did not like the taste of the shrimp. Bathroom was clean tho ! read more

Papa Joe's - Slice and Bang Bang Shrimp - Pizza Near Me - Altamonte Springs, Florida

Pizza was ok only warm would be much better if hot when delivered. Tasted decent. What I was surprised was the charge for drinks at $3.50 each were so small and did not taste good at all. Ice tea was unsweetened but not advised and the lemonade was hardly any taste to it. This was very disappointing. Sorry but won't be back. read more

Five starts for slices to go! You can't beat the experience of coming in and getting a slice or two to go. The pizza cheese gets a little crispy from reheating, the guy in the kitchen is friendly and has a great NY accent. I look at the deli section they have and it reminds me of being back in Queens. I love it and it's my favorite place to drop in to. Dining in I had a different experience. The waitress usually smells strongly like cigarettes although she is nice enough. The pizza is very wet and hard to separate as the cheese slides off. Some people like it like that but I do not. Again the guy in the kitchen is warm and welcoming. The prices for fountain soda was high enough to make me think I should've order water for everyone. Great place and I will return. read more

On Aug 12, 2024, I ordered a pepperoni pizza from Papa Joe in Lake Mar, Fl. Got there and had to wait another 20 minutes when I got ther. While I was waiting, one of the employees took 2 slices of pizza that had a bunch of toppings on it. The employee was picking and smudging his fingers through and picking toppings off the pizza to satisfy a customer that wanted 2 toppings and recooking it with extra cheese, so they wouldn't know. How disgusting, can't believe they are in business. Anyway I finally got my pepperoni pizza. Got home to find it not only had pepperonI, but it had onions on it. After a few hours i was in the bathroom for a few. The pizza sucks. Threw the rest of the pizza away. Never going back. Buyer beware read more

After the week I've had, this beauty was a sight for sore eyes. Toasty, cheesy, tomatoey, comforting deliciousness ... Thanks Papa Joes! read more

Papa Joe's - Margarita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Altamonte Springs, Florida

See all

This is the first time I have been here. Someone told me about the pizza and I had to try it. The dinners are made to order and fresh. I will be coming back for dinner!!The place was full and the 2 servers were extremely busy and yet so friendly! i ordered a personal cheese pizza to try it and it was one of the best I have ever had! I will be back for dinner! My server was KIM... I hope you are fortunate enough to have her. It is rare these days to have such a great experience like this read more

Papa Joe's - And this is the personal pizza - Pizza Near Me - Altamonte Springs, Florida

See all

Best food in the Keys. I had the ribeye and it was phenomenal. Saedric was a great server. He guided us to have the best meal. Incredible views and food was amazing. I will definitely go back for another incredible meal. Thank you!! read more

They will tell you to NOT call ahead for a slice of cheese & then proceed to take 30 minutes to reheat a slice of mediocre pizza. I'll go to Jerry's down the street from now on. read more

I paid $60 to have a home delivery , my pizza was burnt there were three olives in a large Greek salad and the garlic knots you couldn't get a fork in them they were hard , I called the pizza place and the very very very rude employee argued with me , he told me he was going to send somebody over with the five other olives for the salad because it should've been eight, smartass , He would not let me speak and told me he'd have a manager call me , my family will never order from there again read more

Papa Joe's - I paid $60 for burnt pizza - Pizza Near Me - Altamonte Springs, Florida

See all

Love the food! I love the Papa Joes special pizza and the Stromboli best. Definitely better than chain store pizza. I like to order online and then pick up to bring home. read more

This is what a pepperoni sausage and mushroom looks like and no I didn't ask for toppings on half the pizza. read more

Papa Joe's - This is what pepperoni sausage and mushroom looks. And no I didn't ask for toppings on half the pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Altamonte Springs, Florida

I go to the gym next door and my husband and I decided to try them out. We ordered calamari as an appetizer and (4) slices of pizza (2 cheese, 2 pepperoni) and (2) coke. The calamari was okay, but the marinara sauce were terrible. I just asked our waiter for lemon to give it flavor. The soda was flat (assuming it was tap). The pizza: dough was rough like over cooked, the tomato sauce and cheese needs to be double/triple the amount they put in. It's like they're trying to save money on ingredients but still charged you the same. Overall, we will come back if we're not in the mood for Domino's. read more

Had Lasagna and it was not fresh or was cooked to much. Had the(you know whats) the next morning,

The pasta was so bad :-( worse than mall pasta. It looked really good too! The fettuccine Alfredo had no flavor at all and the penne ala vodka was bland also. The garlic bread it came with was also not good. On a positive note, their house salad dressing is delicious. I will not order from here again. read more

Having to update my review from a 5 star to a 1. I will preface this with, I DO like their food, however, I made an order online and it said the delivery was an hour to an hour fifteen. I called three minutes before the time frame was up just to confirm our delivery was going to be sent out. I called and told them I made an online order over an hour ago and I just wanted to make sure it was coming. The gentleman on the phone stated: "what's the last name, ok, ya your order is about to go out...why?! " I said " I just wanted to make sure everything was ok." He stated: " Ya well it's raining so everyone is getting delivery." That's fine, I wasn't upset or impatient, I waited over an hour and just wanted to make sure we weren't forgotten... No need to be rude, regardless how good the food is, you lose customers with an attitude like that. Now we are over the estimated time and my son, to which the pizza and cheese cake was for his birthday has now fallen asleep waiting for his birthday dinner. ‍ I could/ should have ordered from a big box chain or Broadway... My loyalty to this establishment ends today. Who waits over an hour and a half for a large pizza and a piece of cheese cake on a Monday? read more

The food is always great here. I haven't tried the pizza.. - I prefer more classic items. So I had fettucine Alfredo and my daughter had the tortellini Alfredo. Both came with a nice fresh salad and warm and crusty garlic bread. It was a cold night, and our dinners arrived at our table promptly and steaming hot. The meal was excellent, with just the right amount of seasoning in the Alfredo sauce. we were "early birds" and had the luxury of having two servers ready to bring us anything we wanted. Thank you, Renee and Mike for being so friendly and attentive! This restaurant is becoming our favorite place to go, and I would give it six stars if I could. read more

Awesome local spot! Wings are always tasty and I cannot recommend the cheesy fries enough!! Soo good!!