Only tried a couple of slices but they were very good. Sicilian was nice and airy. Traditional was very good Nicks is next to Grattin Dog off of 436 in Altamonte. There is no inside seating. You drive into the gas station and order there Not bad. I understand on Mondays you can get a large cheese for $10 so I'll be going back read more

See all

Had a great experience ordering pizzas for a party from Nick's Pizzeria! If you're looking to feed a crowd, they've got a great special on two large 1-topping pizzas plus garlic knots for $30.99. The quality, especially for the price, was excellent. The highlight of the order was definitely the garlic knots, no one could get enough of them! I found their online ordering system to be incredibly user friendly, and had a positive experience picking up my order. Freshness and timeliness can be hit or miss with pickup orders, but my food was hot and fresh exactly on time, and the employee working was such a pleasure to interact with. Couldn't recommend this spot more! read more

I was very excited to try this pizza joint and got both the Bianca and the pepperoni. The sauce was good, the toppings tasted fresh, and the ingredients seemed high quality. Unfortunately, the crust was so hard that my jaw was aching after just two slices, which really took away from the experience. There were definitely some positives, but the crust was a dealbreaker for me. read more

Omg so good. I'm so happy I stumbled across this actual hidden treasure in altamonte. Very fast and kind. Thank you!! read more

Nick's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Altamonte Springs, Florida

Authentic NY style pizza! Don't let the window next to a gas station fool you, the quality is amazing! Also they have specials on Monday for $10 large cheese pizza! read more

The meal I got from there today was so good, I have to absolutely say something about it. I haven't even made a marinara sauce as good as this, oh my goodness gracious, all kidding aside, this is amazing. Before I go back home, I am going to buy some of that marinara sauce. And some other things for the friends and family, as a matter of fact, as I think about it, I'm going to take a lot of stuff home to pop in the freezer. Oh my gosh, I'm gaining pounds just talking about it read more

Saw this place had a vegan cheese pizza option and tried it on a whim. I'm really glad I did cus it HIT. I love a nice thick doughy crust and that's exactly what Nick served me up. I never order just a plain cheese but this was so perfectly seasoned and full of flavor that it didn't need anything else. Texture was also excellent. Nick's nails it! This is my new favorite pizza place. Thanks for the vegan option! read more

Nick's Pizzeria - Vegan Cheese Pizza. Very flavorful with perfect thick doughy texture. - Pizza Near Me - Altamonte Springs, Florida

See all

Came for a pizza review and got slices. It was next to a gas station and other small restaurant. We got a bianca, chicken bacon, grandma and bacon tomato. Because we came as they were closing down, they gave us the three slices for $5 and the original two were $9. We liked that they did this! It was better than some others especially in this area but still mediocre. The Bianca was a bit dry with not enough ricotta. The bacon slices were not very good and lacked flavor. Grandma needs to be thicker and MORE TOMATO ! Chicken bacon ranch (we added ranch) was only saving grace here but season the chicken! In a pinch, would come here if did not find better in the area. TikTok Reviewer: acaicaitlin read more

See all

I'd say they get a solid 5! I personally think they have the most reasonably priced pizza in the area. I paid $40 for an extra large meat lovers, a large specialty salad, garlic knots, and 2 beef patty's. Anywhere else, I'd be at least $50 for less items. They also had some really killer looking appetizers you won't find at other pizzerias. They had potato balls and beef patty's. The patty's were great, similar to what you'd find at a Caribbean restaurant. The salad was good too, super fresh and crisp with an awesome House Italian dressing that was to die for. And the pizza, it was huge and absolutely loaded with toppings. I always appreciate when a Meat Lovers pizza is in fact made for the meat lovers. It was loaded with ham, bacon, sausage, pepperoni, meatballs and mozzarella. Great pizza, great options, and an incredible price. We'll be back ;). read more

See all

We've ordered Nick's a couple times and it's our absolute favorite place now! The pizza is artful! So much flavor and such a great crust! Service is great and we always get our food quickly and correctly. Our favorites have been the pizza Bianca, Giovanni's pizza, and the Rustic Veggie. We were so excited to eat, I forgot to take pictures! The pizzas were beautiful and so so so delicious! The veggies, garlic, and sauce are infused with so much goodness. I can't recommend this place enough! read more

Food is good but only for pickup. If you order for delivery the food is overpriced and often arrives cold.

Tried a slice yesterday and it was delicious. Ny style and on Monday you can get a large pie for 9.95

Just perfect if I could give this place more stars I would the owner is so nice and as my husband being an Italian man he 100 percent approves will be back!! read more

Was definitely the best substitution for NY Pie while I was in Florida. 5 stars! Always ordered off door dash too so it was great. Such a good quality pie and knots especially for the price! Great value. Def try Nick's!! read more

Nick's Pizzeria - Brooklyn Express Combination - Pizza Near Me - Altamonte Springs, Florida

This place never disappoints me, great food and great service. Love their white cheese pizza (Bianca) read more

Nick's Pizzeria - Half Cheese and Half Bianca. - Pizza Near Me - Altamonte Springs, Florida

This was a pleasantly surprised stop for us. Pizza was great. The staff is friendly. Don't let the location deter you from stopping.

Nick's was everything we dreamed it might be. We were visiting Orlando from out of town and landed here - so glad we did. The pizza was delicious, garlic knots were sublime, and the zeppolis for desert were heavenly. We got to meet Nick and had the best service from Him. The atmosphere was simple and sincere - outdoor seating. Would HIGHLY recommend for all locals and tourists! read more

The pizza was so pretty!!! All the toppings were cut a nice size & spread evenly! The crust was nice & crispy. The lady working the window was super sweet & smiley everything was 10/10 read more

This place knows how to make a great pizza. I have never had a bad experience. Pizza is always on point. Highly recommend!

We are originally from NY and this pizza was authentic. Amazing pizza and the family time special is a great value!

The pepperoni pizza is very NYC. That was my favorite. Also love that they have alcapurria and beef patties. This will be our new pizza spot. read more

Very good pizza. Quick service and friendly staff. Modestly price. Definitely recommend this place.

This is the best pizza I've ever had and workers treat us like family I will tell anyone to try this place out

Maybe it was the pizza I got, but it was horrible. Tasted like pizza you get at Chuck E. Cheese and the bottom was so chewy. It didn't break through on the bites , you had chew it like gum. I got half pepperoni , half bruschetta. The bruschetta side was so gross. The reason why I gave two stars is because my bf liked it. But he eats anything so that's not saying much. read more

Nick's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Altamonte Springs, Florida

You do not get better than Nicks! The pizza is always fresh and tastes amazing. The grandmas pie is my go to! They might not always have it, but I never mind waiting for a fresh one. read more

We have been ordering regularly from Nick's through Uber eats. I don't know who is Nick but I do know that everything we have always ordered is delicious, fresh and prompt. I'm from the northeast and this definitely reminds me of New York pizza. From the pizza, to the wings, garlic knots, calzone, coco bread, beef patties and the amazing zeppoles. All great. Needless to say I recommend you give Nick's a try. read more

Went by to pick up a Monday special - 16 inch Cheese Pie for $7.99. The service was awesome from Nelly and Noel (pie man). The pie was really good as always. I ask for it a bit crispy. I was just in Tallahassee and had a mediocre pie there. Had to come to Nick's right away to cleanse the palate. Take-out only. There are a few tables outside. read more

OMG. The best pizza I have tasted in many years. The sauce was perfectly seasoned, the toppings were fresh and the crust was perfectly baked. I also got garlic parmesan chicken wings that were moist(not dried out). They were awesome as well. This is the place for the best New York pizza in Central Florida. read more

We ordered from Nick's pizza yesterday. Something I've noticed in Florida is that some take outs are attached to gas stations which is odd. There's no sit down seating except one little outdoor table pictured here. There is no indoors for guests either, you order at the window pictured. We ordered a pepperoni pie, chicken Caesar salad, meatball sub and 1 slice of bacon ranch pizza. The pizza was phenomenal! Originally from the northeast, born and raised in Philadelphia and most recently lived in North Jersey before moving to Orlando, this pizza reminded me of back home. The meatball sub was not good though. The meatball lacked flavor. I took two bites and couldn't eat it. It was ground meat shaped into meatballs topped with mozzarella cheese but with zero seasonings. If you order from Nick's, stick with the pizza though. The pizza was legit. read more

See all

I found Nicks Pizzeria a few months ago and what a find. I know a lot of places claim they have 'New York style pizza" but he is from NY and the pizza is right on target. I tried their meatball parm sub today and it was delish. I highly recommend this place. read more

Monday's special $7.95 large NY style cheese pizza can't be beat in town (that we are aware). Located in a small location with a few outdoor tables for dining and outside the gas station across from the Sunrail train station in Altamonte Springs. Good cheese pizza with a tasty sauce and at the Monday special $7.95 large cheese pizza price definitely worth giving them a try. The Monday special $7.95 large cheese pizza got us to try them out and now we'll be back to try more menu items and more pies and report back. read more

See all

Alright guys.... I'm way too hype for this ! So I've known the owner and his family my entire life, since New York, so needless to say, that they have this pizza thing done RIGHT! First off, my heart will forever belong to their cheese pizza. Good God, I love it all the time every time! All their pizzas are amazing, don't get me wrong, however my heart is forever sold to the cheese pizza. Second, their Jamaican Beef Pattie with cheese... oh boy! I always crave for it! Add the cocoa bread, we are freakin solid! Bomb dot com! Finally, my sugar powder on top, the Zeppoles! Ugh! Made with just amazingness! Perfectly cooked and coated with sugar powder to just give you final touch to end your amazing meal! - FYI, yes all these were my first order! If you haven't found yourself at this location, I highly suggest you do. They are all amazing people and so kind. Plus, anyone wants amazing food, soooo, this is your spot! read more

See all

I wish I could truly explain the customer service! Way above and beyond. There was miscommunication with a 3rd party, but Nick went out of his way to make it right! Delicious and beautiful food, and amazing service. Definitely a great way to run a business! read more

See all

While on an extended stay in this North Orlando (Altamonte Springs) area for orientation with my new employer, I tried a few of the better-rated pizza places in the area. Nick's Pizza in Altamonte Springs was by far the best! Their pizza just blew me away, it was real NY Pizza, nice crisp on the pizza crust, fabulous sauce, & cheesed and cooked perfectly. You know you can't make a good pizza unless you start with a great crust (followed by great sauce), and Nick's just nails it. Nick's was only 2 miles from my hotel though I would go out of my way & travel miles to get this pizza, and have marked as a favorite on my mobile Map Apps. Don't be put off by the location (little shop next to a gas station), while other places are prettier & have indoor sit-down, this place has the best pizza, and that's what you're looking for in pizza, right? If you're a pizza snob like me, given the great pizza and the bonus of a very nice owner & staff & timely service, THIS is where you want to order your pizza from in the greater Altamonte Springs - North Orlando 'Burbs area. read more

Heard so much about Nicks so first timer here and so glad I tried it. Tasted like New York pizza and I'll be back to try other items as well. Had half with sausage and mushrooms-- yummy. Close tie to Carlo's in Fern Park. read more

Tried Nick's for the first time tonight, and got 2 slices, wings and Greek salad. Wings were really good pizzeria style wings. Cooked well, tasty sauce, reminded me of some of my favorite pizzeria wings from when I was younger. Not the wings I crave if I'm primarily in a wings-eating mood and looking for the best (and spiciest), but exactly what I want in a side of wings when getting pizza. Does that make sense? :) When I went to pick up, the pizza and wings were ready but they took a little while to get the salad together. Overall decent salad but wish they had more dressing options. They don't actually have Greek dressing for a Greek salad lol. Personally I love when there's thousand island but that's rare these days. But I would get it again! I also thought the folks working were really awesome. Slices were really good, but a tad cold by the time I got home. Also I realized that mushrooms weren't a great topping to have added to a slice since they get added after and heated up, and mushrooms are better cooked right in. But I could tell the pizza is great and really enjoyed, can't wait to get it again. I'd love to go back and get a large pie, or get fresh cheese slices and eat them there on a non-rainy day, since the only seating is outside. Love that it's a cute window stand, wish there were more places to sit outside though! I'll update this review when I can have their pie at its best read more

I was in the area and I stopped by based on the reviews. Unfortunately, my pie came very chewy. It was a little bland. It was a little hard to eat and I ended up throwing it away. It was too far for me to drive back. read more

Nick's Pizzeria - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Altamonte Springs, Florida

I moved here from NY & "NY Style Pizza" here in Florida is not it but Nickkkkkk did his thingggg . This pizza is bussin ! Definitely will be back read more

My hubby & I wanted to try a locally owned pizzeria. So happy we found this place on Yelp ! We ordered the from the menu on here but when I went to pick up the pizza, I found it's under new ownership. It's now Ciro's Pizza. I was also told they deliver! Anyways the pizza was amazing. The toppings were plentiful nd the dough was definitely made in house ! The bbq wings were juicy & crispy I asked for a side of hot & blue cheese & they gave a generous portion of both. Sooo good! My hubby's did say he'd want extra sauce on the pizza next time ! We will be back we had half a pizza left over . read more

See all

No frills pizza. Decent pie, better than the chains. Other than the convenience of being close by not sure I would recommend to anyone who has to to drive more than 2 miles. read more