Worth the visit. I've been eating a cheese slice from all my local places. This place by far has my favorite cheese pie. Lady up front was helpful took the order. Pie made it home and was disintegrated within seconds. Will be back. Let's see what they have. The ambiance was a pizza spot looked like a pizza spot read more

Been going around and trying all the pizza spots around me to compare to who has the best that I can continue ordering from, from now on. This pizza spot is pretty good, does your pizza look appetizing? They are cheese pizza is actually very good. No oil dripping down your arm, just good cheese and a perfect amount of tomato sauce. And the service is great. read more

Best pizza in town. Great thin crust. Server was nice. Small place but seating outdoors is possible too. We chose inside which was good. The owner cares. Lot of carry out business. read more

My first time here I loooked at the pictures and was like yesssssss !! Super excited But the pictures look better than the actual food. It was not awful pizza but I won't go back EVER. My kids did not like it Wings tasted so old dry and stale ! Definitely reheated from the prior day or made super early and left all day Pizza was ok..::just ok Rolls soft but not garlicky Usually you can smell the garlic in the rolls smelled. Nothing but pizza As a New Yorker uh uh But good customer service read more

This is a little place. The menu looks great! We had a couple slices and a large salad. The salad was fresh and delicious. The pizza was very good. No flop, crispy and chewy crust and toppings were plentiful. The staff were friendly, service was good. Will absolutely go back. read more

I happened to come across them on uber eats and decided to try them out since the prices are good, ended up finding the best pizza i've had in the entire Orlando area! I don't think I'll ever order from another place. Perfect sauce to cheese ratio and not too salty which is an issue I see with a lot of NY style pizza. This place nailed it read more

This pizza is delicious. Just had a cheese pie and will have Bianco next time. Absolutely Delicious!!!

First time there.Will be my last time. Pizza undercooked, bland taste.Also ordered Greek salad, and was given ceasar dressing.Could not eat it. Unconcerning employee up front. Wish I can gibe no stars. read more

Halal pizza where have you been? Here and it's NY style. Soooooo good! Pizza was hot and ingredients were fresh.

Fast friendly local owner not a chain (Yet) couldn't be more pleased with food and service. You can even get a slice. For altamonte springs best kept jewel you must try! Best in the area I have found! read more

NY Best Pizza - Food Delivery Services Near Me - Altamonte Springs, Florida

This is the first "NY style pizza " I have in the area and I have no complaints at all ! I got the pepperoni pizza and wings with the sauces on the side , absolutely fresh and crispy ! The outdoor seating was super cute and staff very friendly! If ever in Altamonte area or by Cranes Roots, as I was ! You got to visit them !! #familyown read more

NY Best Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza - Food Delivery Services Near Me - Altamonte Springs, Florida

See all

Good Pizza and friendly service. Stopped here on a Friday night and got my fix of NY style pizza. A lot of times these pizza spots don't have good wings but the wings here were great I would eat here again. read more

See all

Loved every part of this place. The environment was great, we had wonderful service, and the pizza was 10/10, super easy to eat.

So we got there later than want to pick up time says because majority of the time things are not ready. Not from this area, so therefore wasn't aware that they had absolutely no orders and that they would be prepared on the exact time. My son walked in. And said a woman said it's been sitting here waiting for a while rudely. We got back to our hotel. To notice that our cheesy garlic bread is mainly just garlic bread with a pinch of cheese. While I asked for extra sauce and pepperoni on the garlic bread that was not done nor communicated in regards to allowing me to pay extra or just automatically doing it and telling me there was an up charge when I got there. I come up here often and by all means will never come back to this place. Hopefully this review will help them be able to be a little kinder to a teen. As well as make an order properly as requested. read more

NY Best Pizza - Apparently, this is their garlic bread with cheese. If you're planning on ordering this, I just wouldn't bother. - Food Delivery Services Near Me - Altamonte Springs, Florida

This cozy little pizza spot is the best! I love, love, love their pizza. Tucked in on Wesmore drive, away from chaotic traffic.

We ordered pizza Friday night. Hubs got the deluxe and I got a cheese. I enjoyed mine, but the crust was a bit tougher than I expect from NY style. I liked the cheese but I did need a bit more oomph as it was missing something so I added some garlic salt. His pizza smelled delicious and he said it was good. The chocolate cake was soooo good. I would def get that again and maybe try one of the lunch specials I read about here on Yelp. read more

See all

Didn't come correct, pizza has no flavor. NY style for sure but no cheese even and that's all they put on it.

Ordered lunch from here with some co workers. We each got a baked ziti for only $8. Portion was a solid size so no complaints there! Taste was average, nothing special, not terrible. If we ordered here again I would probably try the pizza! read more

NY Best Pizza - Lunch portion- Baked Ziti - Food Delivery Services Near Me - Altamonte Springs, Florida

We just moved to the neighborhood and kept our fingers crossed for a good pizza. This was our first attempt and no need to look further. This is the best pizza we've had in a very ling time. Did I mention that my wife is from Queens? read more

Tried a lot of pizza places in search of a great pizza . It's a lil spot in a plaza and is family owned and run. The pizza was tasty and the crust flaky lol overall great place to get a slice read more

Love their pizza! The pepperoni (which if beef not pork) is delicious. I also get the Greek salad frequently with the oil and vinegar for my dressing. The portion size and freshness of ingredients has always been top notch! The service is always fast and friendly. Our office orders here frequently for lunch. The lunch special is filling and very affordable. Ambiance is chill. Limited seating but I've always been able just to grab a table during lunch service as most other diners are getting take out. read more

Doesn't look like much, but we were on our way home and just wanted to grab a quick take out pizza. We just got a small plain cheese and to be honest, it was better than my expectations! We will be ordering again! read more

The food was excellent. I had the pink sauce with spaghetti, which came with two garlic knots. Both were amazing.

what a great place to eat at. The owner is always smiling and excited to see customers come in. Ive tried just about everything and it's worth the money. read more

This is the best pizza in the area. Delivery I divers are great and they are always quick. This is like true New York style pizza.

Hands down this pizza was bomb dot com. It was cooked to perfection! The reason I'm giving this establishment 3 stars instead of 4 is because the wings. The wings looked delicious however, they lacked the desired flavor. For the wings to be garlic Parmesan, it tasted like just fried chicken. I would recommend some sort of Garlic seasoning for flavor. I would recommend the pizza and would definitely try this place again and skip the wings. read more

NY Best Pizza - Garlic Parmesan wings ( no flavor ) looks good but lacks the desired taste! - Food Delivery Services Near Me - Altamonte Springs, Florida

See all

Support this company. Great people and pizza is delicious!!!!! I found this on yelp and loved the food

At the risk of sounding a little over the top, here it is. THIS IS HANDS DOWN THE BEST PIZZA IN THE AREA!! On top of which their chicken wings are flat out spectacular!! Salads are ridiculously fresh and loaded with goodies!! Subs and sides are off the hook to boot!! If you are getting pizza, wings, salads and sandwiches from somewhere else you are making a big mistake!! Just saying, this is THE BEST! Don't waste your time and hard earned cash elsewhere! I am not related, nor paid. I just no good food when I taste it!! read more

Customer service is very important. No matter the quality of the food. I'm on vacation with my niece,staying next to the restaurant & when we walked in,the owner was on her phone,sitting down and didn't even look up to acknowledge or greet us. We ordered with the young kid at the register,who was the best,nicest kid. I only asked for a request because I am a vegetarian and if they couldn't complete the request,I was more than understanding. We just placed the order,and sat down to wait. They had forgotten our fries and when I asked for them they told me I never ordered any,which I did..so I just reordered some and the owner lets out a"they're a pain in the a**" ..for asking for our food,once..we're pain in the a**es? Who even speaks like that to their customers? The young kid at the register noticed that we heard her and repeatedly apologized. We had just gotten our food a minute prior & we asked for to go containers because that was just so unnecessary and uncalled for. What a shame,do better lady. They're lucky I contained the Bostonian in me. read more

I have had the cheese pizza, Brooklyn pizza, cannoli, zeppole, and French fries. Delicious and piping hot. read more

NY Best Pizza - Brooklyn pizza (small) - Food Delivery Services Near Me - Altamonte Springs, Florida

I could eat this pizza every day. Really good. Of course, way better than all these chains out here and comparable prices! Great service as well. The first woman who took my order (possibly an owner?) was incredibly kind. Yum. I wish I could eat pizza every day. Can I eat pizza every day? Should I eat pizza everyda read more

See all

Omg the only word I can think of is AMAZING!! My husband and I are vacationing from North Carolina! And they have no places that can match the flavor and authentic nyc flavors of this pizza ! If you're ever in Altamonte Springs please check them Out!!! Also the service was quick and courteous. read more

NY Best Pizza - Ha this is 2 out of 8 wings lol! Very good - Food Delivery Services Near Me - Altamonte Springs, Florida

See all

Pizza is simply delicious. We just moved over to this side of town and decided to give it a try . And I'm glad we did. Will be ordering again for sure read more

We moved to Altamonte Springs from Brooklyn, NY and are very happy we found this pizza spot! I've ordered on uber eats a few times and it was great and finally walked in today to eat in after being away from the dine in experience for a few months and had a great experience. It gave me that home feeling when I walked in... looks just like a Brooklyn pizzeria!... It's been a few months now and I didn't realize I didn't post this review, Love this place and we have ordered almost weekly in the 4 months we have lived in Altamonte. read more

Real NY style pizza and good oven backed wings too...the garlic knots are delicious as well.. Do yourself a favor and just get the extra large pizza...2 pizzas and wind cam honestly feed 4-6 adults. Don't go cheap, this place deserves every dollar read more

Fast service!!..Definitely I will order again!!..I'm from New Jersey!!.flavor awesome!! read more

NY Best Pizza - Meat pie - Food Delivery Services Near Me - Altamonte Springs, Florida

Little pizza joint with very good food. All that needs to be said. Off the beaten path slightly so be sure to look for it if in the area.

I'm giving a 5. Not because it's the best I've ever had. But it's the best I've had in recent memory and the best "random walked in off the street" REAL pizza place I've had in Central Florida. PIZZA BY THE SLICE!!!! Friendly staff, fresh slices ready to heat and eat. I had a white slice and it was authentic NY style. So bravo for being real & priced right. If I lived near here I'd be a regular. *I took a. It's of this slice before the photo* read more

NY Best Pizza - White slice - Food Delivery Services Near Me - Altamonte Springs, Florida

So, I figure I would try out a pizza place near my home on Sunday. You know how it is. Got to get something good, so I take a look around Yelp, come across this place. It's right down the street, people are going on with their reviews about how this is the best pizza in Altamonte Springs, yada yada. They're not very busy, so I order their special. From all the reviews I've read, I'm expecting something good at least. Did I get good? Nah. Sadly, I got mediocre at best. I'm just telling it like it is. This pizza is slightly better than Costco. I ordered the pizza, a side of bread and sauce, and some wings. Failed on all three counts. The wings are like Wingstop wings. I hate Wingstop wings. They have absolutely no flavor outside of the sauce that they dip I'm in after they take them out of the oven without even putting any salt or pepper on them. In other words, they take the wings straight out of the bag, throw them in the oven, then drench them with sauce after they're cooked. Honestly people, in the future, just go to Winn-Dixie. They have better wings than both Wingstop and this place at half the price. Back to the pizza. Don't get me wrong. I'm not picky. But, like I said, this pizza is about Costco level in taste. But, a Costco pizza will cost you about $11. I got their special, which including the wings and the sides of dipping bread for about 31 bucks. Not even close to being worth it. I mean I wanted something other than Little Caesars, that I get a lot of the time. I was expecting something better than the Little Caesar pan crust or thin pizza. After tasting this pizza, I'll buy Little Caesars every time. I know I'm being harsh, but that's just a truth. Hard pass for this place in the future. read more

This spot was Proccolinos, then Modena and now NY Best and what a claim to make for a pizza joint!! You will not be let down, lunch specials are great. As a huge fan of a bianca slice, this is probably one of the best I have had. Lots of garlic, huge globs of fresh ricotta, good lord its a slice of heaven. Far and away one of the best slices around. read more