We lucked out finding Panoony's Pizza & Wings! Apparently they've been around for 13 years, and…read morethis was our first time eating there. It doesn't look like much from the outside, but don't let that stop you from giving this place a try -- it was amazing. I'm not a big pizza eater and can be hard to please when it comes to dining out. Pizza definitely isn't at the top of my list, though my spouse loves it and has his favorites (which have always been just "meh" for me). Today was different. We will absolutely be back. We ordered at the counter, and the food was delivered to our table. We decided on the Fultzstix and a sausage and mushroom pizza. The ingredients tasted fresh, the crust was moist yet crispy, and there was just the right amount of spice. Everything came out hot and delicious. The young man who delivered our food was very personable and hospitable, which made the experience even better. If you're craving pizza -- and they offer many other items on the menu as well -- this place is a must-try!

Thin crust was like paper. Very little tomato sauce. Extra cheese was not evident at all…read more Scattering of banana peppers and Italian sausage was minimal. Overall very disappointed by this pizza, and it was not worth the $30 I paid for it.

We decided to try this for lunch and we were pleasantly pleased. The restaurant was limited on…read moreseating and we were glad that we got there early for lunch because it quickly filled up. There are two rooms to dine in. But not a lot of tables so avoid busy times. They have a salad bar with lots of selections and a pizza bar as well. Plus they had soups and breadstick. You can't go wrong with all this food and it was only $13 per person. We had quick service and the waitress was hopping taking care of the lunch crowd

Rockstar Pizza was a fun and memorable experience. I went specifically to take on their massive…read morepizza challenge, and although I didn't win, the pizza itself was pretty good. The flavor was solid, the crust had a great crunch, and the sauces were honestly delicious, the pizza sauce and garlic sauce both stood out in a really good way. The only downside was that the pizza was a bit on the greasy side, but that's somewhat expected with a pizza of that size. The wait was a little long, but considering I ordered a huge challenge pizza, it made sense. The staff was friendly and welcoming, and I appreciated that they even took before-and-after pictures for me. It adds to the fun and makes the whole experience feel more exciting. The inside of the restaurant is really cool, decorated with photos and artwork of famous rockstars all over the walls, giving the place its own unique vibe. It's definitely a spot with personality. Even though it's a bit out of the way for me, I'd definitely visit again. Overall, good pizza, great sauces, friendly staff, and a fun atmosphere, I'd recommend giving Rockstar Pizza a try!

I am from out of town and decided to give them a try. Their supreme pizza was amazing, full of…read moreflavor and exactly what I ordered. I had it delivered and it was hot when delivered. I also ordered their bread sticks, they are huge and so good. The canola I ordered was to die for. Would definitely order from them again.

Heard about this place via yelp and Facebook. Decided to check it out vs some of the other local…read morepizza places. Value wise, good. Freshness good. Workers, pleasant. Ordered the two cheese, meat lovers and garlic breadsticks. Crust had a nice flop to it and the end was not chewy like another place nearby. Could use a little more flavor but overall good. Cant wait to try some other custom pizzas from them. We will be back.

Papa's is a small spot in a strip mall off Green St. It is currently carry out or delivery only…read more The ordering process online is very easy and they bring food out to your car. They have a larger menu than I'd expected including pizzas, calzones, and specialty pasta dishes. We went with the traditional spaghetti & meatballs which had a good flavor and we enjoyed the meatballs. There were 2 of good size. You can order more online. We also had the tutti mare which was ok. Nice shrimp, mini scallops and mussels. It was actually better the 2nd day. Pasta dishes come with garlic bread which was pretty basic. We did enjoy the tiramisu which was large enough to share. Overall we would try it again. Maybe the pizzas next.

Been several times and every pasta dish I've tried I loved. Haven't tried the pizza yet but…read moredefinitely will.

The BEST pizza..thin crust. We order for pick up. Also fantastic food for dining in..mushrooms!…read moreYum! Grouper! Yum!

Heard great things about this place so we went. I had the breaded tenderloin sandwich and it was…read moreoutstanding along with their fries. My husband had the steak and asparagus. The steak was very small, looked old and it was tougher than leather. He ordered it medium rare and it was well done. Stick with the bar food selections and stay away from the steak..

Pizza has been very good this past year. Crisp crust…read more Used to visit another location, but they have good promotions as well.

Overall, you will get better pizza from Casey's Gas Station down the road, and personally, I will…read morenot return here ever again. If I could give zero stars I would. The breadsticks were rock hard as soon as they got to the table. No one ever asked about the food or if we needed one single thing, unsure if that's part of the 'order and pay at the front desk' charm.. but don't forget to tip! The pizza sauce was coming through the thin layer of cheese, and unlike the breadsticks, very doughy. Majority of TVs off in the dining room, or with 'Channel Signal Lost' on instead of anything to watch. Left quickly, unsatisfied at best.

Great authentic Italian food. Service is always great, and the prices are fair and moderate. The…read moreentire restaurant has been completely remodeled. Some of my favorite items are the garlic knots, chicken parmagiana, and the spaghetti with meatballs. The oven baked pizzas also make this place a one of a kind that make you come back for more.

Sal's has always been one of my favorite places to enjoy some delicious Italian food, and they…read morehave made it even better with their new renovations! It simply elegance only adds to their incredible food! We were pleasantly surprised by their Valentines Special Menu - it had it all! The Lemon Picante is usually my go to, but the pizza was calling my name this time! It did NOT disappoint! You definitely need to try the Tiramisu! It is absolutely delicious! The service was friendly and the price was right!

Amici's is a good "go to" pizza for us. Everyone in the family likes it, and they never disappoint…read morewith service or food quality. I also like how involved they are in the community, as that goes a long way with me.

The family and I decided to try this pizza place out in Plainfield and it was pretty good. The…read morebreadsticks were soooooo good!! The pizza was also really good. Buffalo chicken pizza wasn't very spicy. Overall we enjoyed it.

Love this place, I recommend a reservation if going during peak hours. Service is always fast and…read morefriendly. I love the house salad with homemade peppercorn ranch dressing and the White Pizza is the bomb. One of my favorite pizza. The decor fits the pizza place vibe.

Amazing! We sat at the bar where Madison had us covered! She was the best! She gave us…read morerecommendations on food and drink. Everything came out so fast. This place played the best music! And the food was very reasonably priced.

Magoo's is our household's go-to pizza spot for when we want a hot, delicious pizza for takeout or…read moredelivery on the west side of Indy. They have their original location on 38th street that I think the dad still runs, but the Avon location that the son runs is a tad bit closer to us (and also the one that we can do delivery from), so we almost always order from the Avon location. The owner is almost always working when we go in and is so friendly. Always remembers your name/order and makes you feel welcomed. We have been going here for years and I always rave about them to my co-workers and friends. We discovered early on that you can do half red, half garlic sauce on the pizza, so we always order a supreme that way with 2 cups of ranch. The ranch is house-made and worth the extra $1 per cup. And that is coming from a girl whose family was a blue cheese household growing up.

Spicy Hawaiian pizza & Chicken Tikka Magzone with ranch. Fast service, great food, fun vibes inside.read more