The management team is perfectly on point. Both my wife and I were at work, and she had no cash. I knew she wanted a drink, but had no way to get one. I wasn't able to leave work to take one to her, but I thought maybe I could explain our situation and if they had an order going there, perhaps they wouldn't mind. I knew it was way below the minimum required delivery point, but when I asked the manager, he said, "It would be up to the driver." I was so impressed he would defer to the driver for the final approval. It showed me how much the drivers opinion meant to him, and the value he placed on him. Even if the answer was no, I was totally won over. The driver agreed, and the boss even waived the minimum delivery fee (since it was more than my order!). Yes, I tipped well, but I wanted everyone to know how much I appreciated the crew at Papa John's Lebanon. You made me a loyal customer today. read more

Sorry, to charge me almost $45 for 2 medium pizzas, supposed buy 1 get one, not a good value when the quality received was just not good. Asked for banana peppers, got 1 in one box which was about 1inch long and 1 in the other that was normal size. 1 each that definitely not worth 1.50 add on. Horrible. Sorry, but you need to do much better that that read more

Papa Johns Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lebanon, Ohio

See all

Fair, comparative review of the new sandwiches. All bread, no substance. All I could taste was hard, toasted hoagie roll. I choose the Philly. Lacking meat and veg. I do not recommend. read more

My best experience is always when they're not slammed. Because I know they want to get your food to you fast but sometimes the pizza is rushed and undercooked. I am always fine with waiting a few more minutes than normal to get that perfect crust and oh so yummy cheese read more

Attempted to place order on line. Web site would not allow us to check out. Called direct, sounded like a call center. Asked for address then for our zip code. Could NOT understand what the person was saying. Asked him to repeat 3 times. Finally hung up. If I call the local store why do I need to give my zip code? Are they not in the same zip code???? Will no longer order from this location (or any other). They will be the next pizza place gone from town. Frustrating!!!! read more

So irritated! I ordered a Papadilla Sandwich and a Diet Pepsi last night. It came with a not so hot Dry sandwich and a Hot Diet Coke! Now mind you I've called and complained about the Papa Johns on Columbus Ave in Lebanon's in the past but was never rude and I complained about things like the Driver dropping My food onto the porch scooping the food back into the box and saying It's Ok it didn't touch the floor!! Well I called and told the manager Same Mean Rude Woman Erin that always answers and is hateful toward me!! She said she was refunding my money and to Never Order From them Again! I couldn't even begin to say how much business they've Ungratefully gotten from us because of the Shelter in place and what has followed...times when mom wasn't her best (Who by the way just died and I had to depend on delivery food to get us through at times.) or I was worn out or we wanted a break and something different. I did not deserve to be treated like this because I called and reported an issue. I also was calm and informative. I was not asking for anything or demanding anything. I said all because I informed you of a problem?! I told her I will be calling the corporate office!! I mean really with restaurants failing in record numbers? I know they are great because of delivery but can they afford to run off business? Especially to a loyal customer who doesn't call screaming or demanding? I merely was informing them. I didn't even ask for a discount. read more

Love this Papa John's! The workers are so friendly, and my food is always ready on time. I've ordered from this location a ton and I've never had a wrong order handed to me! Very impressed and great deals! read more

You people shouldnt be allowed to sell anything let alone food. You guys are so Incompetent I live in Lebanon just north of Cincinnati clearly a 513 area code and the pizza guy calls me from a 614 area code. (Columbus Ohio--- 2 plus hours away) of course I ignore that since there are so many scammers now so I waited two hours for my pizza and come to find that 614 number was my pizza guy. I call this sad excuse of a restaurant and I don't even get a "sorry" just excuses and reasons why I'm wrong. I guess how dare I not accept random calls from literally half way across my state. What was I thinking? I was clearly wrong though. Wrong to ever contact papa johns. You (papa John) should be condemned just because youre business practice specifically the Lebanon Ohio location btw. absolutely the worst pizza Delivery I've ever seen. You should all be fired and I'd give negative stars for the rating if it was possible. 1-5 stars??? Papa johns in lebanon Ohio gets -10000000000. I made an account on this site just to leave a bad review if that gives other consumers any idea. read more

Stopped in and ordered the two, two topping pizzas for $20. The place was clean and the staff was friendly and knowledgeable. We'll be back read more

Stopped in to try them out. I ordered a small garden fresh pizza that's was the worst I've ever had. Dough uncooked, cheese unmelted it was terrible. On top of the nasty food I had a pizza box that was used to kill bugs with cause there was several dead bugs ok my box. NEVER AGAIN!!!!!!! read more

I love the fast and friendly service! The food is always fresh, the drivers are always happy to see us, the staff all see to be great. The best wings, the best pizza.. I love these guys! Try the honey chipotle wings! Those are a favorite of ours. read more

Why do I pay so much and get so little? I was looking at my 5 item pizza when a papa johns commercial was on TV.. Why does the 2 item pizza have so many ingredients when the 5 item has nothing and is burnt.. Talk about false adverting..I was looking forward to the good pizza I use to get a great pizza.. I was totally screwed over and you will be too. read more