Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Papa Johns Pizza

    2.6 (47 reviews)
    Open 10:00 am - 12:00 AM (Next day)

    Order Papa Johns Pizza Takeout or Delivery

    Papa Johns Pizza Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Papa Johns Pizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Mushroom disaster
    Chelsee H.

    Holy Mushrooms! I can't even describe the amount of mushrooms I had to pick off their "fiesta chicken", where's the chicken?, I like mushrooms but not that much, we had to re organize our whole pizza....

    "Extra Cheese"
    Amanda W.

    Ordered a pizza with extra cheese. There was almost no cheese at all. It was also burnt and cold. They took it off our bill, but that didn't change the fact that we didn't have anything to eat. I wasn't expecting something life changing, but I don't even think what we received could even be called Pizza. Just order Dominos.

    Not sure what these are... but not chicken.

    See all

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    The hottest fastest pizza I've ever received and with my details

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    14 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Papa Johns Pizza

    Review Highlights - Papa Johns Pizza

    Things happen out of their control.

    Mentioned in 2 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 9,393 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Hops n Drops

    Hops n Drops

    3.7
    (403 reviews)
    0.3 mi
    $$

    We were out running errands in Maple Valley and decided to stop into Hops n Drops since we've had…read moregood experiences at other locations--and this one didn't disappoint. Right off the bat, the hostess stood out. She was genuinely engaging and welcoming (wish I had caught her name), and we were seated immediately in the bar area. It was a little past the lunch rush--around 2 PM--so it was nice and relaxed, which made for a comfortable, easygoing vibe. We went back and forth trying to beat the lunch cutoff or just lean into the happy hour menu, and ended up doing a bit of both. We split a Caesar salad, which was fresh and really well done. For the main, we had the bacon avocado chicken wrap with tots--great flavor, definitely a solid choice. The only knock was the tots were a little on the cooling-off side and didn't quite hit the mark... although I still managed to finish them. To drink, I went with a Sky Kraken Pale Ale, which was excellent (and yes, there's photo evidence). Hey I'm retired now, I can drink at lunch! Overall, really enjoyable stop--good food, great service, and a laid-back atmosphere. We'd absolutely come back again. Solid 4 stars.

    Wow'd. Had a lunch special burger, was wayyyy better than Red Robin! Especially the hand formed…read morepatties. At first I was wondering if 4 oz was enough, afterward my bulging belly assured me that it was. Son ordered a Spiked Root Beer and it was gigantic. Servers checked us a number of times. Very pub like atmosphere.

    Photos
    Bar
    Bar
    Carne asada STREET TACOS
    Carne asada STREET TACOS
    BBQ Chicken Wrap with Fries

    See all

    BBQ Chicken Wrap with Fries
    Crockett’s Public House

    Crockett’s Public House

    3.4
    (419 reviews)
    0.4 mi
    $$

    Outstanding service, esp at the bar during the week. I've been a regular over the years (I've over…read more3000 points accumulated so far). 2 things: - The new menu leaves a lot to be desired. Time to step it up. Let's try a daily special or a Thursday/Friday special; hello Teriyaki Burger??? - I've regularly seen people leave when they learn the Mariners game isn't available. If it wasn't for the awesome service, I'd be frequenting some other local establishment. (The nearby steak house has an awesome double cheeseburger)

    I've never eaten here before or if I have I don't remember. I ordered breakfast and that's not the…read moreissue. The issue is what you use for your breakfast doesn't correlate what you charge I ordered chicken and waffles, eggs, scrambled, and two orders of grits The whole order came out to about almost $50 I understand that the price of goods have gone up, but if you're going to charge people more than use fresh products or better product products the fact that you're charging over 6 dollars for grits that are literally the packet grits not even instant grits which you can't even tell their instant but you guys are charging that for a packet of grits so I paid $12 for the Quaker oats packet grits, which is insane The waffle was undercooked, and the chicken was cooked well but as dry as all get out. I did eat the eggs so that's the only win! I get it. I totally do, but it is super insane and I am livid about the grits as a southerner to sell people packet grits for that much is basically robbery. One order pays for literally a box of them or two boxes. I'm so disappointed.

    Photos
    Crockett’s Public House
    Wings (buffalo)
    Wings (buffalo)
    Mahi Mahi - very well prepared dish

    See all

    Mahi Mahi - very well prepared dish
    Red Dog Saloon

    Red Dog Saloon

    4.3
    (35 reviews)
    5.4 mi
    $$

    The food was sub par, it's dive bar so I didn't expect to have GF options, but chicken wings are…read morenaked here, so that was a good option, but overcooked and dry. Hubby had fish and chips.... Very very Meh.... Only one person working on a weekend night, friendly but had to go to the rail to get drinks and food (off a sticky icky menu). Great band, limited seating. Pool table and darts.

    The Red Dog Saloon isn't just a restaurant--it's a temple of hospitality where the staff moves with…read morethe precision of a NASCAR pit crew and the warmth of your grandma who just won the lottery. The bartender doesn't just remember your drink order--they can recite your entire ancestral lineage while mixing it. And one server, I kid you not, once arm-wrestled a grizzly bear just to protect a customer's last french fry. But the real revolution happened when a veteran waitress (who definitely used to be in witness protection) casually mentioned her souped-up Toro TimeMaster to a regular. Like a match dropped in a pool of premium unleaded, the lawnmower customization scene EXPLODED. Now the back parking lot looks like Fast & Furious meets Home Depot. You've got flame-painted John Deeres doing wheelies between tables, and chrome-plated Husqvarnas sporting underglow LEDs that would make Xzibit weep tears of joy. Every Thursday night, the sound of modified 6.5 HP engines drowns out the jukebox as the "Mow Money, Mow Problems" crew shows off their latest grass-cutting masterpieces. Last week, someone installed a turbocharger on a push mower--sure, it only cuts three blades of grass before launching into low orbit, but that's the kind of innovation that makes America great. The Red Dog Saloon didn't just create a restaurant; they birthed a movement. Now you can't scroll through TikTok without seeing some influencer's "Lawn & Order: Special Mowing Unit" build going viral. And it all started because the staff here believes in encouraging their customers' most questionable hobbies with unbridled enthusiasm. Five stars. Would let them transform my riding mower into a grass-destroying dragon again.

    Photos
    Karaoke stage
    Karaoke stage
    Karaoke with Nikie on Saturdays
    Karaoke with Nikie on Saturdays
    It's like wow to the Blues!

    See all

    It's like wow to the Blues!
    Big Block Brewing

    Big Block Brewing

    4.6
    (14 reviews)
    2.4 mi

    Amazing food and excellent service!! We took the advice of…read moreanother reviewer on here and ordered the chips and queso!! Easily 4 adults could have shared that. The queso was so good that my fat self dipped my fries in it. The portions are really big here, do not let the pictures deceive you. And the food is quite good! Definitely elevated bar food. My order of 6 chicken strips were perfectly cooked and seasoned. I really like the breading and side of honey mustard. My husband ordered chicken wings and they were the big bulky wings not the piddilly little wings you get at a gas station. The spicy Korean sauce and garlic Parmesan were top notch sauces!! Really really great! We absolutely loved our waitress, she was very friendly and always anticipating our needs.

    Staff upfront- 5/5 Food wait times- 0/5…read moreFood itself- 2/5 Went there today after seeing the amazing reviews. Tried their kolsch and it was great. Ordered queso and chips and got it after 50 minutes. One of the two bartender ladies was nice and let me know they only had one cook and they weren't expecting the big groups. That's ok, I'm hanging I told her. I ordered the southern chicken sandwich and she recommends I get it extra spicy if I like spice. I ordered it as such. 45 minutes later my sandwich comes. Mind you, when I ordered it I was told they now had two cooks so it should not take long. The chicken itself was so rubbery and did not taste good. The sandwich was a big 0/5. The queso was really good. Overall the place is huge and has comfy vibes. However, not sure I'd return given the food took forever. The nice lady upfront told me last Saturday was not busy at all so it was staffed today as a reflection of that. However, it's sunny and a high of 66. You know we are all out of the house. Plan accordingly. I don't think I'll be returning here just because of the chicken sandwich being terrible as well as the food wait times. Oh also, if you order soda they open a can, give you what fills up the glass and save the remainder for whoever orders the same soda next. I ordered a Diet Coke and they poured an open can in first then opened a new can to fill the rest of the glass. Why not give the whole can?

    Photos
    Chocolate  Porter. Delicious!
    Chocolate Porter. Delicious!
    Wings
    Wings
    Chips and queso

    See all

    Chips and queso
    Black Diamond Grill

    Black Diamond Grill

    4.6
    (144 reviews)
    3.6 mi

    We came here on a Saturday night to celebrate my sister's birthday and were very impressed overall…read more The warm bread with oil was a great start, and the loaded potato skins ($13) were delicious even without the ranch. Drinks were solid and fairly priced: a spruce tip golden ale ($6.75), Modelo ($6), margarita ($15), and two glasses of German Riesling ($23). Entrees included chicken Florentine (subbed with shrimp for +$3), chicken fettuccine Alfredo, and fettuccine primavera (with shrimp for +$7). Everything came out hot, seasoned well, and very tasty, though my Florentine was light on spinach. Desserts were a highlight--raspberry cheesecake that was fluffy and creamy with a good crust, and a rich crème brûlée that disappeared quickly. The restaurant itself is small and cozy, set in what feels like an old home. Inside has around 15 tables and can get loud; the staff accommodated our request to move outside to the porch, which turned out to be perfect. Service was friendly, though our server forgot small requests like bread and to-go boxes until later. Prices felt fair, portions were generous, and the menu is well-balanced. My only real nitpicks: no Pinot Noir on the wine list (surprising for the PNW), and the Florentine could use more spinach. Parking is limited to a few street spots or a dirt lot across the way that seemed fine. Bottom line: excellent food, cozy atmosphere, and a great value. Definitely worth a stop if you're in the area--and even worth a little road trip.

    I love this restaurant. Rudy and his team are excellent. The food is fresh and delicious. My…read morefavorite is the spaghetti. I also love the lasagna. The Italian chop salad is lovely. I highly recommend this is a great restaurant that does not disappoint.

    Photos
    Black Diamond Grill
    White chocolate raspberry cheesecake
    White chocolate raspberry cheesecake
    Menu

    See all

    Menu
    Frankie's Pizza

    Frankie's Pizza

    3.9
    (88 reviews)
    0.2 mi
    $$

    Family in Maple Valley order from this location and say they "like all the pizzas" offered here…read more Order by phone, app or online. Pick-up or delivery. I called in our pick-up order and the staff we intereacted with both on the phone and in person have all been lovely. They have a couple of dedicated spots in the shared parking area and a couple of benches i side if you need to wait for your order. Two liter bottled sodas are for sale in the cooler near the cashier. No eat-in space. Take away only. The crust is thin on the bottom with a nice crusty edge and a good 'chew'. Not too much. The pie is not exactly 'foldable' like a NY style, a little thicker than that. The sauce is a little sweet with a good amount of toppings. The veggies on my pizza were crisp. I ordered from them twice during our week visit to the area. Unfortunately I forgot to get photos of the pizza. Too busy eating it.

    I walk the trail behind the pizzeria almost daily, and on certain days I get a pleasing aroma…read morewafting my way of pizza dough and meats, and often wonder if the place is good or not. I decided to do a search around me for some pizza joints, and this one popped with some decent reviews. Figured why not. It's just down the road a few miles, so here I am. As soon as I entered, I kept hearing a vaguely familiar voice... but no way... can't be... couldn't be... and then a face emerges from the back room to the counter and I was right. It was NOT Donald Trump. But man o man it was a spot on impersonation and quite comical too. It was complete with Trump's view of Covid as a weight loss program- it was comedy gold. Ya gotta have fun and laughs, know when not to take things too seriously. Ah yes... back to the pizzas. I ordered two pies, one with a meat medley and the other like a Hawaiian style topped with pineapples (yes...pineapples taste great on pizza)! Both scrumptious with every bite. I got regular crust, where I normally ask for a thin crust at other places, but needed a true test. I also got an order of wings. Took them home and enjoyed them down to the last bite (over a couple/few days-sheesh peoples-I ain't that bad!). All in all, a great experience and a place I would definitely come back to. It's kinda like a little hidden gem in the Maple Valley area. As always, Enjoy & Happy Eating!

    Photos
    Frankie's Pizza
    Frankie's Pizza
    Frankie's Pizza

    See all

    Nikki's Restaurant & Lounge

    Nikki's Restaurant & Lounge

    3.2
    (354 reviews)
    4.2 mi
    $$

    I've been to Nikki's about five times now. Every experience has been good, but not excellent…read more The environment: It's a cheerful little restaurant! It's clean, happy, and bright. However, the tables are packed closely together. On one of the booth seats, I believe it's attached both ways; my side of the booth seat and then the neighbor's side of the booth seat. So... the person at the table behind me kept shifting around in their seat, causing the side of mine to lift up and down a little with each motion. This was incredibly annoying, though it was only these booth seats that had this annoying function. The food: The food was good, but came in pretty small portions. Just one waffle with fruit, eggs, and two strips of bacon were about $20. The food was good, but it did seem a little spendy to me. The service: My fruit waffle barely had any whipped cream - I didn't say anything about it - but the waitress noticed and immediately got more whipped cream for it. So shoutout to the awesome waitress, Monse! She was so kind, cheerful, and absolutely awesome! Also, my cousin ordered waffles without butter, but she got a waffle with a big slab of butter on it. So communication between staff for that wasn't ideal. Final thoughts: Food was good, but the portions were too small to justify the price. Service was amazing!

    Food was ok. Standard bar fare. They had the red Robin style French fries which was a plus. Drinks…read morewere ok. Something was definitely off about the service though. Some of the patrons were friendly, others definitely weren't and made it crystal clear that they do not embrace diversity or the BIPOC community. And it's for that reason I'll have to look for another option when in that area.

    Photos
    I ordered the #2.
    I ordered the #2.
    Nikki's Restaurant & Lounge
    Spanish omelette and French Toast with eggs and bacon.

    See all

    Spanish omelette and French Toast with eggs and bacon.

    Papa Johns Pizza - pizza - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...