Yes, Yes, Yes! We…read moreordered a large cheese pizza and they did not miss!!! Just the right sauce, thin crust and cheese! Amazingly good!

Seriously the best pizza around. This is the closest pizza you'll get to NY style. 10/10 food and…read moreservice!!

After being a regular at another pizza restaurant for years, we now have switched this restaurant…read more The pizza here is always cooked perfectly. The crust is just the right level of crispness and the bottom of the pizza is never "doughy". The sauce is not too sweet and the amount of cheese is just right. I judge this place in the perspective of being raised in New York City. There aren't many places in the area that make a pizza that reminds me of home and tastes this good. Another home run here are the cannoli. YUM!! They are made when you order them. You can tell this by the crunchy shells and delicious filling. Many places the shells are soft and soggy because they are filled hours before which leads to a yucky cannoli. NOT here! These are Great. Give this location a try. As there are several with the same name, be sure to check the addresses

This was terrible food - will never order from them again. Pizza was terrible and the chicken…read moreMarsala was awful - so bad. Not sure who cooked this (summer interns?) but this was not good.

We dined in. I will not crave this pizza EVER, and that's…read moresad. The dough is not delicious, it's rubbery, and dry. The toppings were not hot or cooked enough, the pizza was semi cooked. The toppings are not of high quality and the actual bake was lacking skill. Considering they have a great oven my expectations were to have a nicely cooked, bubbly pizza with a little crispness and char... If I'm eating pizza it needs to be delicious, if I'm coming back, it's because I crave it! This place is okay, not the worst place, but not a go to place.

We love this family owned gem! Gluten and dairy free pizza…read moreis impossible to find especially that tastes this good and is made safely! The staff is always mostly sweet even on a crowded night! The place is clean and run well. The line moves great and everything always comes out hot, fresh and delicious! Great family restaurant we love frequenting.

I called in an order for pick up and the lady on the phone was super helpful since this was our…read morefirst time. My husband said the place was packed with to go orders and it seemed very clean and organized. We ordered the bye bye American pie without pineapple and the artichoke cheesy bread. Um...yummmm!!! And that sauce that came with the sticks was nice and spicy- super delicious! I was a little bummed about that bottled ranch though- nothing worse than that stuff. One slice on a large pizza was enough! Those babies are huge and loaded with toppings. The price was very very affordable as well. We will definitely be coming here again!

I ordered Margherita Pizza. The tomato sauce tasted quite sweet. The other pizza I had ordered…read morewhich had only basil olive oil and garlic on it, was better. Although I love Margherita pizza the most. I remember one time I had ordered Margherita pizza it was quite greasy. Too oily. I love this restaurant because it is quite close. However I wish they change the recipe for the tomato sauce. It was quite sugary or I should say sweet. The servers were very nice! They were all smiling and eager to help and serve customers! I love the restaurant. In the future I might try their wings or Margherita calzones. I hope this restaurant flourishes!

one of if not my favorite pizza spot in atl as a nj native! comfortable atmosphere, friendly…read moreservice, cold beers and you have to try the spinach and artichoke dip!

I've had Carlisle's saved on my bookmarks for a while and finally decided to give it a go a few…read moreweeks ago for date night. Hubby and I are early birds, so no surprise that we were the only ones there upon arrival around 4ish. We sat down and started to look over the menu. There was only one guy working and whether intentionally or not, he definitely gave off a vibe that felt like he was annoyed we had come in, which wasn't a great first impression. He never gave us napkins or utensils, so hubby got up and got some for us after the garlic bread we ordered as a starter arrived. The garlic bread was literally just toast with some garlic spread slathered on. It wasn't great, and we would not order it again. Aside from that, I ordered a classic pepperoni pizza and hubby got his weird Hawaiian concoction that I will never understand the appeal of. My pepperoni pizza was amazing. Perfect amount of sauce, cheese and pepperoni distribution were spot on, and the best part is that the bottom was perfectly crispy but not burned. Hubby's was good too, though he is less appreciative of the crisp factor than I am, though to be fair, he is not really much of a pizza fan to begin with and was just humoring my date night pick. After our pizza was brought to the table, other employees had started to arrive. Salty dude disappeared and a much nicer lady took over for him by bringing us drink refills and later closing out our tab. We will not be returning for date night, but the pizza was definitely good enough for a repeat visit. I will most likely just order as carryout during lunchtime instead, though. I wasn't really a fan of the vibe for dining in, particularly due to the salty guy who we seemed to annoy at the beginning, but I think the pizza was definitely worth coming back for.

Lunch specials. Pizza salad and drink. What a slice. Huge. Good pizza too. Salad fresh ingredientsread more

Not a fan. I've been there twice for slices and it's mediocre at best. Yes it's a large slice, but…read morenot that great. Prefer Brooklyn Joe's.

My office orders from this location whenever we have people in from out of town. The pizza, wings,…read moreand meatballs are always good. While I knew I would be ordering a meatball appetizer, I wanted something lighter for my entree. The Tuscan Chicken Pasta seemed the perfect solution. First of all, I'm not sure what mystery meat was supposed to be chicken, but it most definitely not a grilled chicken breast. Instead it had the texture of a sketchy fast food chicken nugget. Real chicken doesn't have a green hue! Now, let's talk about the flavor of the dish. This dish was supposed to be spaghetti tossed in garlic and olive oil, with sautéed spinach and grape tomatoes. There were a few pieces of spinach and lots of grape tomatoes. If there was garlic in the dish, it was hiding somewhere. To be quite honest, I've had pretend meals from a small child with more flavor. There were literally zero redeeming qualities about this dish. Thankfully, it came with a salad and garlic bread, and I had ordered the meatballs. I pulled out the mystery meat chicken, and will take the pasta home, throw in some actual garlic, and some Italian spices so I don't totally waste my money. Going forward, I'll stick to what I know they do well - pizza, wings, and meatballs. Restaurant prices are far too high to come up empty on a flat dish.

I've been getting Johnny's New York style pizza since I was in Elemantary School. It had become a…read morestaple in my family's weekly pizza day. Today of all days. Pi Day was the first time I spat my pizza out. I normally always & I mean Always get the bruschetta. 3 times I have ordered this at this location & its been so soggy it falls apart before I can even put it in my mouth. This isn't the disappointing part. On day of all days, I knew I should have ordered Papa John's today. No offense, but we all learned our shapes and sizes in primary school. If the pizza does not fit into the box, then what makes whoever packed this think it was ok to fold it?? Do we not know how pizza works?Not only was it folded, and ruined 3 slices on a medium there was no flavor, and it was like eating a hockey puck. Why was it so dense and hard? I could probably get over the fact that they were dumb enough to fold the pizza, but for it to taste the way it did. unacceptable and disappointing. Normally I order to go from the Canton Rd location. They have been pretty consistent, they haven't made me spit out any food. I can't even help it, food delivery apps just assigns the location. I HATE writing 1 star reviews, Especially for small businesses, because I like to give places a chance. HOWEVER this is the 3RD time I ordered from the woodstock location and its 3rd strikes you're out. I ordered another Large pizza that wasn't folded, but it was also tough like a hockey puck. You would think for $60 for 2 pizzas and one bruschetta it would be amazing! I could spend half at papa johns and they would NEVER send me a folded hockey puck. In all honesty PLEASE DO BETTER! Its an embarrassment the Johnny's New York Pizza name. I've been to a lot of other locations, and I seriously have never spat pizza out. I mean it's not even a wonder why every time I pass the Woodstock location you guys are never busy. The location is pretty huge, but I see why barely anyone is there. Please also do teach who ever folded the pizza, that if it doesn't fit PUT IT IN A BIGGER BOX! It's rudimentary common sense!

Wish I could do 6 stars! Inside was super clean, staff was very friendly and helpful! By far the…read morebest pizza I've ever had! 10/10 recommend!

We loved this place. we ordered the bbq/lemon pepper wings and the bbq chicken pizza. everything…read morewas delicious!! the pizza crust was really good!! amazing service. highly recommended.