I am 69-years-old, grew up in a New York suburb that was largely Italian, and have been searching for my entire adult life for pizza outside of New York that could measure up to the pizza of my youth. I have finally found it. Carlo's pizza not only measures up, it is up there with the best pizza I've ever had. A perfect blending of cheese, tomato sauce and oil, with a thin, firm, tasty crust. Very generous and high quality toppings, particularly the anchovies. Yes, it's expensive, but worth every penny. I only wish they were open more hours than they are at present. read more

The best pizza I've eaten in the area. Maybe the best pizza I've had in GA. I'm no pizza connoisseur but I think I know a good pizza when I have one. I had two slice, one plain cheese and one with the specialty meatball slices. The pizza was delicious. It was perfect. Idk if I was just really in the mood for pizza or what but my first bite was like the scene in rattouille when Remy was experiencing a euphoria from his food. Service was good. One of the best pizza slices I've ever had for sure, definitely try them out if you're looking for a good pizza. read more

See all

[[HIGHLIGHT]]While family is hungry after the high school game, & this is the ONLY place nearby that we could find that's still open and would be ok to bring the kids with us.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The guys here are so friendly. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The diner is bright & clean.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]I do love that they have the picnic tables outside and booth seating inside.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]The hubby & little one enjoyed killing time on the mini-arcade game while we waited.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] We already know the hot pizzas will be amazing, but we're trying the mozzarella sticks for the first time. I like their selection of Italian iced to go and desserts as well. Just not tonight. read more

Carlo's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Marietta, Georgia

A great New Jersey pizza. Large 18" pizza loaded with Italian sausage, pepperoni, and white onion. Pizza was greasy in a good sort of way from the pepperoni but not too greasy. The crust was thin and very crispy. Stayed crispy and did not get soggy. Service was very friendly and helpful. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Pretty busy for a weeknight.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Took around 25 minutes for our pizza. [[HIGHLIGHT]]A few tables and bar stools inside and out but better suited for take out.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Be mindful that the toppings are expensive. $5 to add sausage and $4.50 for pepperoni. Adding a 15% tip with it ending up with a $42 pizza. Was good but definitely on the pricey side for a pizza. read more

My brother, John, has been raving about Carlo's Pizza and we finally made it out here. Carlo's Pizza is family owned and serves up NY & NJ style pizza. They are located in a Publix shopping plaza. We did takeout. We got 4 slices and the artichoke appetizer. Loved the toppings. They give a generous amount of toppings and they were tasty. The pizza tasted great! The dough was really good too! The artichoke appetizers had a nice presentation and were made well. The dipping sauce that came with the artichoke dip was bomb! I had some of that dip with my pizza and it was the perfect combo. We also wanted to try their sub but they ran out of bread. Will definitely have to come back to try that and the other menu items. I will definitely be returning! It was worth the drive from Suwanee. read more

See all

This place never disappoints! The pizza is delicious - the marinara is tasty and you always get ample toppings. We went with the pepperoni and mushroom tonight....so good! Their salads are also terrific - we always go with the Greek and it's awesome! [[HIGHLIGHT]]If you wanted to eat before you left you could - there are a few tables but it's top notch takeout anytime![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The order is always ready very quick when you place it! read more

We ordered via doordash and it was hot and pretty good. The dough was a little soggy, but that could be because we asked for light bake. read more

We love Carlo's Pizza and it has become our go to in East Cobb. I highly recommend a pie with tomatoes, basil, and light cheese! It's delish!! read more

We're back First of all - the pizza is delicious!!! We usually get 1/2 and 1/2 with pepperoni being on one and being creative on the other side. I also like their artichoke (if you haven't tried it ... and you like artichokes ... try it Service is good. We usually call in and then go pick it up. Pleasant customer service every time. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The place is small...don't plan on eating here but they do have some tables outside.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]I love the arcade game they have to entertain my 6 year old when I arrive before my order is ready[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Five starts read more

I always get a pepperoni slice when I come here. price is reasonable for 1 slice. I like you can call-in your order or walk-in. I usually call-in. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Located in a shopping plaza as Publix. The store is small. Window table with bar stools enough for about 6 people. it's more of a pick-up and go establishment[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]]. They recently added cane sugar soda--both fountain and large bottles. I apparently keep forgetting to take food pictures. I seem to gobble it down (usually in my car in the parking lot. oh..1 time I tried the Italian sandwich(over 1.5 years ago). try it if you're a sandwich person. I personally want pizza from a pizza joint. late post is better than none....last visit 08/05/2024. read more

Carlo's Pizza - Cane sugar sodas 08/05/2024 - Pizza Near Me - Marietta, Georgia

Ordered the frozen pizza delivered to my door during the pandemic. Loved it. Had to stop in driving from Florida back to home in northern Ky. Placed the order online and it was ready when I arrived. Friendly staff and most importantly great tasting pizza. read more

Carlo's Pizza - Road Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Marietta, Georgia

Being from the North East I could be biased but my bougie taste for good food tells me otherwise... the pizza at Carlo's is DELICIOUS! The perfect amount of cheese & sauce with the perfect, let me say it again, PERFECT crust. Ive also tried the salads , their vinaigrette dressing is sweet and delicious. Let's talk about the FRIES!!!! Every Philly or South Jersey native knows it's all about a lil' spice and some good cheese sauce to make the perfect French Fries and thank goodness this place does that recipe justice. I've been there 2x in a week and the people behind the counter have been friendly and helpful. It's a cute little place, about 10 counter top seats outside , 2 picnic tables as well. I think about 6 seats inside the shop. I'm so happy to have found this place. read more

Just try it. You will come back for more! I'm not a big pizza eater but this place will stay at the top of my list.

Carlo's never disappoints. Large plain pie and a birthday personal with spicy Italian sausage was fantastic! Everyone happy. Transplanted NYer and self proclaimed pizza snob rates with very high marks! We'll be back. Soon. read more

If you moved down to GA and have been looking for a place, this is the one to be at. This hidden gem offers more than just pizza, but their slices are so good, I just go with my regular large pie. Their crust is phenomenal, their slices fold to perfection, and everything stays on the slice after one bite. Pizzas always come out on time and they have continued to impress both my dad and I on both a food quality and customer service perspective. read more

Carlo's Pizza - Sausage and pepperoni! Left overs are even better if you put the extra slices in the oven. - Pizza Near Me - Marietta, Georgia

Carlos pizza is nice addition to the East Cobb neighborhood. If you're not familiar, they were originally near the Sweet Auburn district in Atlanta but have since relocated to Johnson ferry. The pizza is traditional Jersey style with a lot of quality imported Italian ingredients they've been in business for 20+ years and have quite a legacy of pizza making that started with the patriarch in the family whom the restaurant is named after...Carlo. This is an all in the family, Irish-Italian clan and the kind of business where the brothers and sisters work tirelessly together to keep up the family legacy and pass down tradition. If you are intent on supporting local small biz, you may want to start with Carlos pizza. I haven't yet been inside the new restaurant but I have ordered delivery and I can tell you that they have specials as well and the pizza is excellent. Everything from the sauce to the dough and the cheese. Surprisingly I also ordered one of the salads and the dressing was delicious and the salad itself was very fresh so I would highly recommend. I will be coming back to try the tiramisu, but I have high hopes for that as well. I'll make sure to snap a few pics of it next time but local gem and if you're looking for an alternative to chain pizza you'll find your match with Carlos pizza. read more

Really Really Good Pizza ! They have always been accurate on pick up times. They use very fresh ingredients. My favorite take out pizza !!! read more

The pizza is authentic and always fresh and the staff are very helpful and I'm always kindly greeted when I walk in. Everything on the menu is thoughtfully prepared. Typically, salads a pizza restaurants are pretty bare and boring but Carlo's makes very nice salads with house made dressings. They also sell Boylan craft sodas and an awesome selection of real water ice/Italian ice. [[HIGHLIGHT]]It has the look of a real old school pizza place without trying to hard and it gives the perfect ambiance to enjoy a meal or even just a water ice.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] My family and I just moved close to Carlo's and I'm so glad we found this place! Please give them a try! read more

Absolutely fantastic. We had the giant cheese pizza and boardwalk fries. Both were the best I've had in Georgia. Absolute perfection, can't wait for my next visit. read more

The best NY/NJ style pizza in the south by far!!!! Extra thin and crispy and great sauce with just the right amount of cheese read more

Carlo's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Marietta, Georgia

Still the best pizza in GA and some of the best outside of the NY/NJ area. Family owned business that uses the best ingredients. Not the cheapest, but with food costs the way they are, I'm not holding it against them. read more

Carlo's Pizza - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Marietta, Georgia

Review for slices- Carlo's has $4 cheese slices all day and they are worth the drive. New York style. Slightly greasy which I like. All drinks (aside from the birch beer) are just a buck! Not too bad for a San Pellegrino! My dad got the pepperoni and sausage and they looked great with generous toppings. Next time I am gonna try a full pie! read more

Carlo's Pizza - Slice of pepperoni! Yum! - Pizza Near Me - Marietta, Georgia

The pizza is amazing, and the staff is very friendly. had to wait a little bit, but it is worth the wait. I enjoyed the pizza and the service from the staff very much. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The ambiance was what I expected.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Spectacular pizza. Definitely my first choice for pizza in East Cobb. The crust, the cheese, the sauce, toppings, are sooooo good!

OMG THE BEST pizza and wings. I get food to go all the time Highly recommend - just the right amount of sauces and seasonings read more

Best pizza and service in all of Atlanta! I'm from NY originally and have lived in Atlanta 10 years now and Carlo's by far has the best NY style pizza in the city. I eat here once a week and it's great every time! The staff is super nice and friendly! read more

I don't even know where to begin here - but let's just say this pizza is so damn good I could cry. Literal tears of joy almost ran down my face as I ate this. My family is from the north east and I grew up in south Florida. There is some damn good pizza coming out of NY & NJ and for whatever reason you just can't get it down here - well, so I thought. Hubs found Carlo's Pizza on YouTube from a pizza reviewer and mentioned it to me. I looked at pics briefly and said it looked good, but figured we'd probably still be disappointed. I was VERY wrong. This is the best NY style pizza I have had anywhere in FL and GA combined. I do not say that lightly, I truly do not. The crust is expertly done; crisp, chewy, and just plain delicious. We always order well done when we get pizza and it is done perfectly here. The sauce and cheese go together like a beautiful symphony and the toppings are great. I may be crazy but I taste garlic on the mushrooms which is a welcomed addition if my taste buds aren't deceiving me. We have ordered twice in one week! The first was online via the website. The pizza took longer than we were quoted but after having tasted it I would happily wait over and over again. This evening we ordered through door dash and while it was more expensive (to be expected) it was still as scrumptious. You HAVE to try it. Don't walk. Run! All the way there. And thank me later. It is worth the wait I promise. read more

Carlo's Pizza - Large Pepperoni & Mushroom - well done ($36 on DoorDash) - Pizza Near Me - Marietta, Georgia

The best pizza in East Cobb, we love Carlos! Our favorite is the pepperoni and Italian sausage. Love the NJ style crust. Their salads are also delicious with always fresh veggies. Friendly service, too. Highly recommend. read more

Had lunch here for the first time and it was delicious with a professional and caring staff. I highly recommend this locally owned and operated restaurant and I will be back and thanks! read more

FANTASTIC New York style pies in a no-nonsense storefront. A little slow on the pick-up side (on a late Friday afternoon so I'll give them a pass on that) but worth the wait. Definitely our new pizza purveyor. read more

The foods fine but not for waiting another extra 45 minutes after my scheduled pick up time. Maybe next time we should hurry when you see 10 customers starving waiting for the food that takes way to long. Do better.... read more

My absolute favorite pizza in Marietta! I And the wings are stellar too! Everything I had had from Carlos has been awesome!

Outstanding pizza! The team was so helpful when our car broke down to ensure we had a fresh pizza. Really appreciated their willingness to ensure we had a great experience. Definitely will return!! read more

This pizza is made by a family of second generation pizza artisans and it is excellent! The pizza crust, the sauces, and the toppings are all top notch and made with family recipes. We also love all the other dishes, salads, pastas, sandwiches, and appetizers. Get to know the four brothers who cook with their mom to honor their father's legacy begun on the New Jersey boardwalk. Yum! read more

Best pizza in Georgia! Authentic New Jersey style pizza. Delicious sauce, dough is cooked to perfection. Love it!

AMAZING food with incredible value and homemade taste!! the meatballs are absolutely divine, and the mozzarella sticks were so good and very obviously made my hand! 100% cannot wait to come back read more

Best pizza in Atlanta. Thin crust as it should be made with fresh ingredients. Have only had their pizza but the other items look phenomenal as well! read more

the pie is fantastic. I love the sauce, tangy, salty and perfect with the cheese and awesome crust. Real NY pizza. also the frozen pie is perfect if you work from home. it's perfect for one and GREAT pie even though it's frozen! read more

Best pizza in Atlanta! If you're looking for NJ/NY style, this is your place. Always delicious and served with a smile.

I've had Carlos pizza a couple times and the consistency is key as its very good and gives the true NY/Northeast style of pizza authenticity. Pretty perfect folding slices are key! I'd give it a 4.5/5 rating This last time I tried the garlic cheese bread and though it wasn't bad, it didn't hit like the pizza did so I would rate it 3.5/5 read more

Carlo's Pizza - Garlic cheese bread - Pizza Near Me - Marietta, Georgia

See all