Everything mentioned before my review, is TRUE. I asked for the pizza to be square cut. Ok, it came out pie cut. But it's not even "cut", at that. I had to tug at a piece from someone else's piece to separate them. There wasn't even enough sauce on the pizza to cover the pizza. How do you get a so-called large pizza, where the outer crust is literally 2 inches from the pizza sauce ? Stingy with the toppings too. I seriously need to understand, who was the mammal that made my pizzas ? I could've been better off with frozen pizzas. Shame on ME, that I saw the "2 rating on Yelp and thought, hopefully, I don't have any issues like the customers before me". Thank You - for not disappointing = Your poor reputation lives on PS. I wanted to take pictures, but I felt pity......If I showed the readers/audience, the funny looking pizzas you made me = I guarantee, your business would reduce by 60% (shame on me for not taking pics) read more

What a dumpster fire full of lies.... I arrive about 5 mins after notification that my pizzas are ready. Mind you it's early 11:35 am so shouldn't be busy and walk in and was told by the OLD woman working in there that oh yeah they will be right out... Watch 3 people come and go then notice her make a pizza exactly like mine and throw it in the oven.... Wait wait wait.... 20 mins later she boxes up my pizzas. I asked the OLD Lady did I see you making my pizzas after you told me that it would be right out? She said I don't remember and I told her as I walked out I am just looking for a little Honesty here. What a joke.... The stars and reviews on here speak for this low down pizza joint. read more

Worst customer service, cussing out a customer should never be allowed nor be rude. Guy on register was yelling and being extremely rude and someone from the kitchen randomly cussed at me, nowhere near professional. read more

Ordered a few pizzas on the app for delivery at 6:30. App says the pizzas were done at 7:30. 8:30 rolls around and the pizzas still haven't left. I call ask what's going on. Mike the manager tells me "What do you want me to do? You should have ordered for pickup" like I'm supposed to know when I ordered on the app. Then he hangs up on me. I get a message that the delivery will be done by Uber eats and will be delivered at 9:30. I call Mike back at 8:45 and ask if I'm going to be discontinued since the pizza would have been sitting around for 2 hrs Mike tells me "well I just canceled your order." At this point I get a call from the uber driver saying he's been waiting 20 minutes to pick up my food. I had to tell the guy that the manager canceled my order. The manager Mike over there is incompetent and shouldn't be working there if he can't deal with people and operate a business properly. I'll never be ordering from there again. read more

i ordered a side of spicy garlic and this is how it came. what is this? i also had to re-cut the whole pizza myself because whoever prepped it wasn't trained on the pizza cutter apparently. i carried out this order and seeing how messy it looked on the inside, i questioned if i should even be eating food that was made in this establishment. you're better off going across the street to Mariano's and getting a frozen pizza. read more

Papa Johns Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Shorewood, Illinois

Never liked papa John's pizza and never will. It is way too greasy and will avoid it at all costs.

I mean, it's not bad pizza. It's definitely not as good as a local Mom & Pop, but...it definitely does the trick in a pinch. I will say, I do appreciate the fast delivery. And, honestly, it's good pizza. read more

The drivers are so disrespectful expectfully the old guy with the red car. Everytime they always have attitudes and you think I'm going to tip you get real. So I stop ordering from them read more

Today I put in an order to have pizza delivered at 630pm. The order was placed very well in advance and was to celebrate the end of the school year with my kids. At 650 the order wasn't here, I called and the automated system told me it was out for delivery and would be here by 651. 705 still not here.. called and was told it was out for delivery and would be here within 6 minutes. 720 still not here... I called again and was told they couldn't get ahold of their driver. At this point I asked for a refund. they didn't even try to get me my pizza- why wouldn't they have sent it with another driver or continued to follow up with the driver they supposedly couldn't get ahold of? Not to mention I was never notified it was going to be late in the first place My kids waited and were so excited for their pizza celebration only for it to not even show up. 730 is almost their bedtime.. then we had to figure out other plans. read more

ordered a large garlic stuffed crust pizza; no garlic on the crust - tasted like regular crust, and it was burnt, two pieces were edible. staff talked for 2 minutes before they took my pizza, that was burnt, out of the oven. read more

Constantly screws up your order. Pizza is cold and majority of the time not correct. Managers are rude and refuse to help you.

Also stuffed crust pizza perfectly made easy to order online many options for payment method delivery was very quick an i live Plainfield an the business is in shorewood. When delivery arrived it was still hot like out the oven fresh delivery driver was very friendly so of course he got a good tip great service all around will be doing business often read more

Fast and pleasant service. Order and then pull up to the door. You do not have to get out of the car.

This papa johns has gone way down hill. You might want to eat elsewhere. But still ok in a pinch, but only in a pinch. read more

Papa Johns Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Shorewood, Illinois

From the continuous specials and reward points, I've eaten for so cheap and sometimes free. I know everyone has a different perception on the perfect pizza but Papa John's always hits the spot for me. I like soft fluffy crust and veggies that are still crunchy and flavorful and fresh (I don't like when pizzerias overcook the veggies to limp noodles). Some pizzerias serve really oily pizza that gives me acne just touching it with a fork but I've never had an oily problem with Papa John's! I may be ordering at slow times, but all 6 or 7 times the delivery person beat the estimated wait time. Wow! And they're always so nice. It all got even cooler because instead of watching the tracker on my phone, I punch in my phone number and I'll get a text alert when my pizza is coming. The building a pizza/order tool online is also really efficient and simple. I like how fast and easy it is to order from Papa John's. Happy to see also that they've committed to sourcing their chicken from better welfare farms! Two requests- get dairy free cheese please! And remember to not ring the doorbell if my delivery request says so- can't let my kid know I'm getting late night pizza. read more

I wish I could give this 0 stars. I had such horrible experience here. There was zero accountability for their mess up and when we asked for a manager, manager "Zay" hung up twice and called back asking if we wanted a job. This is unprofessional and an actual manager needs to correct the employees that work there. I am very upset with this place and will NOT be giving business to them at all. read more

Don't know why we bothered... thought we would give this place a try after a disappointing experience a few years ago. Nothing had changed. Tonight's take out pizza with 3 toppings was awful: Luke warm, bland, not enough of the toppings (about six pieces were really skimpy) and not enough cheese. Do not waste your time and $... I would not serve this to jr high kids. That bad. read more

Don't order from here! They delivered my pizza to the wrong address and didn't even care. Terrible customer service!

We ordered pizza for delivery for the first time from this location. We ordered the BBQ chicken pizza, it was good. The crust perfectly cooked and the toppings adequate. (I say adequate because you can never have enough pizza toppings, especially the cheese!) We also ordered garlic knots and dessert. The food was good. Delivery time was reasonable. The website was having technical issues, so we had to place the order over the phone. The "order taker" would not give us the "SUPERBOWL50" deal over the phone, but offered a discount. When the food arrived we noticed the pricing was not what we were told and we were missing the additional dipping sauces we ordered. I called the manager to let him know the issue. I am super impressed by how well the manager handled the situation, he apologized, explained the proper protocol, stated how he would handle the situation internally and train the employees AND comped our meal. Wow! That's customer service at its best and as a result I gave the extra star and will go back! read more

Ordered a pizza online and the only thing good was it was delivered on time. I also submitted a complaint through their corporate website ( incident number PJIA-A5E3PJ ) and as of this date haven't heard from anyone! Worse pizza I have ever had! read more

Always great pizza and sides. Never a complaint from me or those I know that eat here!

Pizza took 90 minutes after promising 45. Pizza was burnt and yet arrived cold. Horrible! The customer service was non existence. They used to be better than Domino's for cheap pizza but no longer. Will never order from here again! read more

Impressed. First time ordering from this location. Placed online delivery order for 2 lg pizzas and 2 5$ sides. Delivery came in 30 minutes and it's a Friday night. Wow! I hear the doorbell ring right when I was just going to call to make sure the online order was received. I've had terrible luck with other places online ordering, so it's just standard for me to do it now. No need with this place. Driver was courteous and food was delicious. Awesome service. read more

We order from here about once every couple of months; this week I have ordered twice. Sunday's pizza was carryout and absolutely great. The pepperoni was definitely the double order I paid for, and it was on top of the cheese, deliciously crispy. Today's order: meh. The cheese was over the pepperoni this time and even though I paid for double, it isn't nearly as generous as the last one was. This time it was delivery. Bad idea. The pizza was warm but the cheese was absolutely set, nothing stuck when I pulled it apart. Also, I requested square cut and got the normal wedges. 3 stars instead of 4 because of the inconsistencies. Plus, time estimated was 30-40 minutes and it was over 50min before it arrived and no phone call. read more

This place had the audacity to have their delivery person call us a half hour later than our pizza was suppose to be delivered to ask where we were. Like where are they the pizza was suppose to be delivered their a half hour ago. When we called to get another pizza the manager didn't seem to care that our order still hadn't come. The manager then continued to put us on hold while he took ten minutes to find our order. Also not good pizza the only reason they get one star is because to write a review you have to give them one star. The good thing about their food is the cheesy sticks and that for all our troubles we got our order freeeeeeeeee! read more

Horrible. Looked deliberately tampered with and messed up since we used coupons. Cheese was missing on pieces of pizza of 2 pizzas and wasn't cut at all. Low quality read more

I have been using the on-line feature for a while now and I have yet to be disappointed. The pizza always arrives very quickly when I order it to show up when it can, or it arrives on time when I select a time to have the pizza delivered. I'm never disappointed with the quality, either. I once made an order with double mushrooms and it did not disappoint. There was definitely more mushrooms on it than normal. Their toppings are never skimpy, either. I know it's easy to give negative feedback, passion can fuel the fire, but it's nice to hear good things every now and then. read more

This is in regards to last night's horrible service. I use the online ordering system because I get Papa John's emails every day, and the specials are for ONLINE ONLY. I also get Papa Rewards which means every 25 points gets me a free pizza right? WRONG! This is misleading, because that "free pizza" can never be used with any other offer which is pretty much all the time. Why have this, when I can never use it? So last night I decided to place two separate orders so that I could at least use my "free pizza" before it expired. I placed the order around 4pm. Did a future order for 7:30pm. Not only were both pizzas extremely late (which I fail to understand why a future order needs to be late ever...), but I got two pizzas by two different drivers...both of them VERY late, and one of the younger drivers gave me a lot of attitude when I refused the order. So to re-cap. Two orders, two drivers, both late...bad attitude. The older driver was very polite...I wish he was running the place. He called his GM and offered to give us the pizza for free. Now why does the driver have to do the GM's work? The GM should have called me, but he never did. We refused. We are not trying to get deals or free food, we just want a no hassle service. I would pay $100 if we could just avoid the hassles. What he told us was that this GM is not "tech savy" and has problems with the online ordering service. Really? Wow! Too bad all the good deals are for ONLINE ONLY! This is the third issue I have had in the span of about 4 months, and frankly I am through. Every time, the issue is with the online ordering feature. I mean, if you can't get this right, why advertise it?! I am emailing this NOT TO GET ANY MORE COUPONS OR FREE FOOD. I just want you to know that you lost an entire family that used to spend about $20-$30 a week because this location cannot seem to get it together. PLEASE DO NOT CALL ME, DO NOT CONTACT ME, I AM DONE! AND I will be posting several articles on social media about this because this place ruined my dinner, THEY EARNED THAT. Just thought you should know. You have one service, one product, and you can't ever get it right. Also, this location is about 10 minutes away tops. Why is it always LATE?! 14 years of service ruined in 4 months. Sad. read more

30 min late and still waiting for a 2 pizzas ordered an hour in advance online. And the manager's explanation was "we are busy".

papa johns always has great deals goin on so i decided 2 get the 2 3-topping large pizzas 4 $19.99! isnt that a great deal!? had 2 meet with friends so why not share!? great tastin pizza 4 a low price! what more can u ask 4? read more

Have been going to this location for years and never had a problem until the other night. Their costumer service seems to have taken a big hit lately. Had online order to be ready at 5:45. I arrived at 5:45 and paid for the pizza then the girl at the counter looked at all the pizzas to see if it was done. She told me it would be another 5-10 minutes, which is horrible for being an online order. 10 minutes pass and she checks again and grabs a box that has been sitting there the whole time. 10 minutes of my time wasted because she can't read a label? All I got was a mumbled sorry that I could barely understand. I will probably not be visiting this location again. read more