This used to be the gold standard--when you ordered a "supreme," you got a loaded pizza. Every…read moreslice had a solid mix, generous portions, and it actually felt worth the price. Lately, though, the last few pizzas have been noticeably lacking. Toppings are sparse, unevenly distributed, and some slices feel like they barely qualify as anything beyond cheese and crust. The flavor is still there, and the crust is consistently good--but that's not really the point when you're paying for a premium, fully-loaded pizza. It just doesn't hit the same when you're hunting for toppings that used to be a given.

Ordered Guinevere's Garden pizza and it came with rotten ingredients. Looked to be the tomato had…read morespoiled, I didn't pick apart the entire pizza to see if that was the only culprit (it smelled so damn bad I could barely stomach the small exploration I did), but was able to see one chunk covered in mold and was decomposing. The pizza notably smelled rancid when we opened the box so I'm struggling to understand how this was missed (seems more likely that they just didn't care). We've never had a good experience at this location and we won't be back to try a third time. Store is dirty, food is always disappointing, but this is totally unacceptable and disgusting. I'd recommend making the drive to the GH location where we've never had a bad time or meal. Shame on this location.

Our family really enjoys the chance to mix it up and each order own unique personal pizzas. And,…read moreyou can't forget the no name cakes! Great food. Always great, friendly service!

I am so happy they have broccoli back in the menu. That is what makes their pizza my favorite. I…read moreespecially love the fig glaze on top too. The service was quick getting my pizza and it was delicious. The ambiance was loud ish it's not a quiet place.

Couple less minutes in oven may have made this better. First time going here and sadly even though…read moreI char some of my foods, this was perhaps more burned than charred. We liked the thin crust part. Chewy....but burnt flavor was pretty strong.

I have lived in this area for the vast majority of my life and somehow never eaten from this place…read more I pass it a minimum of 2-3 times per week and it just never occurred to me to get food from there for some reason. Well I'm happy to say that it was great! My husband and I shared a Brooklyn Supreme pizza and we were both pleasantly surprised. There were plenty of toppings, the pizza and slices were big, and everything tasted great. It wasn't cheap but nothing is now and good pizza is hard to find. They told us it would take about 20 min to cook (we just walked in rather than calling ahead) and it was done in about 10 min. The outside seating area leaves something to be desired.. it could be a great spot during the sunny months. Overall I think we will eat there again.

This place has declined over the years. With them being a staple in the community for a decades…read moreit's sad to see this. We went for a birthday celebration and our server was absolutely amazing! They seated a large party without hesitation. The pizza of course is outstanding and I will always get that. Every entrée that was ordered lacked flavor and the love that used to be there. No one finished their food nor took it home. I was disappointed in the cannoli. I got the regular flavor and the filling was gritty. I only ate half. My husband ordered the mousse and it was pretty think. He ate half as well. Is it worth the drive?...no

My kids enjoyed their meals. They all said theirs was flavorful. I tasted a little of each and I…read moreagree. This place is WELLL worth the price. 3% SERVICE CHARGE ON ALL BILLS IS ADDED FOR THE KITCHEN STAFF TO GET TIPPED. THIS IS NOT OPTIONAL. THIS DOES NOT GO TO THE WAIT STAFF. THEIR TIP IS EXTRA AND OPTIONAL. The parking is tight but they do have back parking which I showed in the picture. They staff is really friendly. They were really slow with service but they did have a HUGE 10-12 person party come in. Still, the food is worth the horrible parking, worth the 3% non optional service charge and worth the slow service. This is a place to sit, chill and relax. Not a place to go and be rushed.

Let me start by saying if I could rate a 4.5 stars I probably would as I was on the fence here. I…read morereally liked the pizza. We had a cheese pizza with ranch sauce and the ranch sauce was excellent as was the sour dough crust. From a balance perspective there was a lot of crust around the edge so I would definitely suggest adding some ranch to dip it in. Of course, that will cost you extra. We also purchased a dessert brownie and it was good. I feel like their pricing on their menu board could be more clear as we had to ask on some items. They also were out of drinks as they said their vendor did not come to fill them. While they can't be blamed for this, it did cause us to have to drive to the gas station and get drinks to bring back for when our pizza was ready. Seating is non-existent inside and very limited outside with little to no shade in the evening. At the point of this review the restaurant also does not accept American Express. Just a heads up for those business travelers or American Express customers so that you are aware that you will need a different form of payment here but in another swerve they also DO NOT accept cash.

I swung by here more out of convenience than anything else. It wasn't on my bookmark list but since…read moreI was right by it going to Bainbridge Island Brewing I figured it would save me time in scrounging around for food later. What drew me in was their sign that they did pizza by the slice. I always like these kinds of pizza restaurants because I don't necessarily want a whole pizza. I got a slice of cheese pizza and a slice of pepperoni pizza. The pizza was pretty good, I've had better but it wasn't bad and it got the job done for me with getting a meal out of the way. I liked the outdoor seating and the Autumn weather felt cooperative in having a nice dining experience outside near the restaurant.

Tried the new chicken strips way overcooked and almost burnt and way too salty. So disappointedread more

My focus at this food court is purely for the pizza and that $10. You can't beat a large pizza…read morethat's not only looks good but taste great as well. I dare say this place is the best deal in town. The workers there aren't all that friendly but I think it's due not having enough time to small talk.The atmosphere is at times chaotic and other times slow but you shouldn't miss out on this $10 pizza.

We had a great experience here. I ordered the Apollo pizza, and the flavors really worked well…read moretogether -- creamy pesto, sun-dried tomatoes, artichokes, and chicken were balanced and flavorful. I also loved that the pizzas are made in a wood-fired oven. Our waitress asked if we wanted parmesan and ranch, which I appreciated -- especially since the parmesan was freshly grated and the ranch tasted house-made. Their happy hour prices are amazing, and they even have my boyfriend's favorite beer, Ridgetop Red. Plus, there was plenty of parking, which is always a bonus. Definitely a spot we'd come back to.

Great little find. Their Wedge salad is worth the trip by itself. Very good pizza, great music, and…read morestellar service made this a really good first impression. Comfy booths too, and a great drink selection make this another go to spot.

It's been over 4 years since I've been to Olive Garden. The last time was just before my parents…read morepassed away. Dropped in on Wednesday with my daughter and son-in-law after picking them up at the airport. In the past I have wandered through the menu and tried different things. But lately I've always gravitated to their Eggplant Parm. It's always such a generous portion, but I was totally surprised to see a SMALLER version on the menu! I ordered that and it was STILL a good sized portion. And, as good as I remembered. Nice crispy discs of eggplant, a huge raft of melty cheese, marinara and a side of spaghetti! I had missed it so much I was very tempted to eat it all, but after salad and a breadstick, I was happily satisfied so took my leftovers home for lunch the next day. Service was super pleasant and, given the crappy drive I had to/from the airport in a soaking rain and blustery wind, I really needed that glass of wine. Of all the chain 'family restaurants' I think the OG is my fave. Comfortable, unpretentious and at reasonable prices. Thanks for scratching my eggplant itch!

We were in the mood for soup and salad. Fagiol soup, bread sticks with plain butter (not garlic),…read moresalad with onions and tomato on the side. Just like we wanted. Great service,Nina! Got a quiet booth, also what we asked for. Good job OG!