Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Paper Mill Island

    4.5 (4 reviews)
    InexpensiveMusic Venues

    Paper Mill Island Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Paper Mill Island

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    15 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Rachel L.
    202
    46
    18

    14 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    14 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Pizza Man

    Pizza Man

    3.9(38 reviews)
    0.2 mi
    $

    Placed an order for takeout at 4:00 on a Monday. Was asked to hold for a couple minutes which was…read moreno big deal. I was told my order would be ready in about 25 minutes. I arrived about 5 minutes early and was greeted by the friendly staff member on the small takeout side of the restaurant. I paid, 39 dollars and change for a large specialty pizza and an order of wings, which I think is fair. I waited for my food to be ready and then waited till I arrived home to eat. The pizza was a large chicken wing pizza which was interesting, though not in a bad way. The pizza came in 12 very unevenly cut (triangle) slices. This doesn't bother me at all and in some respects could be a benefit for portion control. The pizza was cooked well and was perfectly taken out right before it would've been crispier than I like. There was a nice chew to the dough as well. Not quite thin crust. The chicken was well portioned and the Buffalo was just a standard mild sauce- I would've perferred hot but to each their own. The interesting inclusion was chopped celery atop the pizza. I've never seen this before but I admit it was a nice inclusion even though I was skeptical. It adds a nice texture to each bite. The sauce on the wings was hot bbq. Which again, wasn't as spicy as I would've liked but good nonetheless. The wings came in an order of 10 (booooooooo). I would've liked more sauce on the wings but I'm sure I could've asked for that. The ride home ensured the wings would not be very crispy- which I was fine with because I don't like super crispy wings. You may want to account for this if you are someone who loves super crispy wings. All in all, there's some things I'd do different if I order from Pizza Man again, but I was pleased with the meal.

    tried this place for the first time tonight, got there and my husband was told that the delivery…read moredriver took his wings and that he would have to wait for him to come back!! really?? so I said i was not waiting and she handed me a receipt and no $ back, I said, I want my money back for the wings, in which then I got an attitude from the person and the Manager. so I got my money and left. To get home and find out they did not give me the blue cheese either. so another 2.00 I am out. Will not be returning

    Photos
    Pizza Man
    Pizza Man - Steak sub

    Steak sub

    Pizza Man

    See all

    Persimmon’s Restaurant - Chicken Milanese

    Persimmon’s Restaurant

    4.1(84 reviews)
    3.4 mi

    So glad they are back open. Service Speed: Last weekend…read morewas so busy and definitely a getting back on their feet night. People seem to forget that the servers, bartenders and cooks are human. My favorite part of Persimmons is that the service isn't super fast. It so nice to just sit and enjoy conversation and not feel like you are being rushed. One time at brunch our server told us to just flip our table topper upright when we were ready to order so that we didn't feel rushed. Food: I love the menu! My husband loved the catfish. Truffle fries are amazing. Brussel sprouts are delicious. I have not tried the calamari yet but have seen several people order and rave about it. It looks amazing. Super odd but I'm obsessed with the grilled chicken on the salad. It's literally cooked to perfection every time! The house salad dressing is amazing. Ooo and the wings. The Georgia bbq has just the slightest peach flavor. It's so good. Compliments to the new chef! I'm really excited to see what else he brings to the menu. Drinks: probably the highlight for me. The bartenders are amazing!! Charlie, Sienna, and Azalea are amazing! Overall: how about that manager!!! I just love him! He works so hard to make sure every guest feels special and taken care of. So thankful to have such a nice welcoming place to spend a Friday evening at.

    Nice place. Food was so so. And the 2 things we wanted most on the menu were not available.read more

    Photos
    Persimmon’s Restaurant - Interior

    Interior

    Persimmon’s Restaurant - Parmesan truffle fries

    Parmesan truffle fries

    Persimmon’s Restaurant

    See all

    Duskee's Sports Bar & Grill - Soup Flight

    Duskee's Sports Bar & Grill

    4.2(31 reviews)
    5.3 mi
    $$

    I haven't been here in a while, so I was glad we decided to have lunch here. There has always been…read morejust one lady here.... holding down the entire bar and all the tables at lunch time (when we've stopped in for lunch before). It was nice to see two very friendly and super attentive servers for what turned out to be a pretty busy lunch. We were seated and then drinks delivered, order taken, food brought over, water refilled, and being checked on regularly. My hamburger was excellent and my friend's steak salad was declared delicious as always...the steak being perfectly med rare. My only complaint was that I asked for no mustard and it came with mustard.....I had no allergies so I did my best to wipe it off. I am glad to say Duskees is as good as ever.

    If you want wonderful food, service and a great sports vibe, Duskee's in Phoenix, NY is the place…read moreto go!!! Nick and Chanel have created a sports Mecca with great beer selections, incredible food and a crowd that loves the Syracuse Orange! Emma and Kelsey were incredible servers, checking in with us constantly and refilling our beers. The food was hot and delicious! Ordering extra crispy medium wings was a great call! They were great with French fries with gravy to dip in. Paired with our favorite beers, it was an SU game meal to remember! Great job, Duskee's! We normally hit Chubbys up for wings but these were on par and on point for a couple of hungry guys on a cold Saturday afternoon!

    Photos
    Duskee's Sports Bar & Grill
    Duskee's Sports Bar & Grill - Bourbon glazed wings

    Bourbon glazed wings

    Duskee's Sports Bar & Grill - Duskees what the hell

    See all

    Duskees what the hell

    The Reef

    The Reef

    4.0(43 reviews)
    6.0 mi

    It had been many years if not decades since we had last visited the previous Jack's reef at their…read moreold location. We decided to take a road trip to check out the new Reef restaurant. The dining room was spacious and clean and bright as were the servers and the bartenders who expertly served us. They have a happy hour from 5 to 7 that varies each day so on this Thursday was half price on selected appetizers as well as $2.50 domestic select drafts. We got there about 10 after five and the bar quickly filled up, which seemed to be regulars, which was a good sign. We decided to linger a little bit over our first drinks and ordered deep fried cheese curds with a delicious margarita type tomato sauce. I had never had fried cheese curds and they were plentiful and came out steaming hot topped with a sprinkle of Parmesan cheese, unfortunately I did not take a picture as we were hungry and dove right in. When it was time for our second drink, I pondered over their wine list, but decided that with my Reuben and mac & cheese dinner a cold draft would suffice. My husband ordered the Philly cheesecake sandwich and onion rings. The mac & cheese and the onion rings were up charges of $2.50 and they were worth it. The cheesesteak sandwich was not shaved beef, but wonderfully thick pieces of beef on a perfectly toasted bun type with cheese and peppers. The onion rings were generous as well as crisp and not overly breaded. My Reuben was perfectly toasted on a delicious rye bread with just the right amount of sauce to not make it soggy. The star was their mac & cheese served in a steaming hot crock! It was creamy, not too cheesy, but cheesy enough to know that you were digging into a delicious bite of mac & cheese.. well done kitchen! All in all the meal was so large we could only eat half of it and brought it home for another day. We would certainly return as we enjoyed every bit of our evening. The patio looked invited and will be opening soon. They also have live entertainment to enjoy.

    We had an unexpected, last minute invite for dinner. We were greeted by the hostess and seated…read morepromptly. It was just a few minutes before our server came and got our drink orders. She came back pretty quickly and took our orders . The calamari was not a huge portion, but was beautifully crispy and seasoned nicely. The warm tomato sauce went nicely with the seasoning. Our wedge salads were huge, and there were a nice amount of toppings. My husband said his Reuben was very good and so were his his chips which tasted homemade. Our server was excellent and checked in periodically to make sure everything was good. It was starting to get busy but she was efficiently keeping up with all the tables.

    Photos
    The Reef
    The Reef - NY Strip Sirloin with seared scallops added on.

    NY Strip Sirloin with seared scallops added on.

    The Reef

    See all

    Jammers Sports Bar & Restaurant - Chicken wings

    Jammers Sports Bar & Restaurant

    2.7(107 reviews)
    4.7 mi

    Fun Friday night celebrating a friend's birthday who follows the Arcade band! My understanding is…read morethis is a recent $500,000 renovation updating this amazing concert venue! High end technology creates amazing sound and lighting! My phone warned me repeatedly off loud noise. Lol. Lots of seating available to get a drink and bite to eat. Lighting and sound We got our first drinks at the main bar in the restaurant, though they were busy Julia provided friendly, efficient service, and offered some cocktail options as well. Raspberry Martini and a High noon $17. Not bad! $10 admission for Arcade. Great Concession stand offering quick bite options, or go early and dine in the restaurant or spacious bar. We ordered Pretzel Logs with Beer Cheese four for $8, another good deal! They were soft and warm with beer cheese that was delish! Our group likes to be right in front of the stage so it's challenging navigating a crowded venue, but this is such a great space with outdoor tables and seating as well. They have a huge lot and parking attendants and security assisting traffic flow.

    We went to Jammers to watch a band, and have dinner. The band sounded good (after an overhaul of…read moretheir room acoustics). The service was SO sub-par, it was awful! It took forever to get our food, and when it finally arrived, the waitress proceeded to drop one of our meals on the floor! After roughly 15 minutes of not receiving any replacement food, we flagged down THREE different employees to check on the status on our food. They ALL were aware of the situation, but NONE of them seemed too concerned. ANOTHER half hour later, the food finally showed up....no apologies from the waitress that delivered it, and we never saw the girl that dropped the food the rest of the evening. Way too few wait staff for the amount of customers that go there. Not to mention that you have to order your food from a "Digital Dine-In" QR code on your table. Piss poor set up, and even worse attention to the customers by the wait staff. Might attend another concert here, but will NEVER order food here again.

    Photos
    Jammers Sports Bar & Restaurant
    Jammers Sports Bar & Restaurant - Wings Jammers style

    Wings Jammers style

    Jammers Sports Bar & Restaurant

    See all

    Paper Mill Island - musicvenues - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...