Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Paranormal Pie

    4.0 (86 reviews)
    ModeratePizza, Salad, Sandwiches
    Open 11:00 am - 8:30 pm
    Updated over 3 months ago

    Order Paranormal Pie Takeout or Delivery

    Paranormal Pie Photos

    Business Info

    PARANORMAL PIE ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Quiet
    Casual
    Outdoor seating
    Good for groups

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Paranormal Pie

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Greek Gyro Pie
    Kimberly H.

    We have fallen in love with their Greek Gyro Pie! Their deep dish is yummy, but not authentic and very decadent and not for the lactose sensitive The saddest thing was our first trip I didn't know they sold baklava when my hubby went to pick up the order. We haven't made that mistake again - we always get it when it's available!!! Learn from us

    Medium Florence Pizza
    Levi P.

    Really nice people, and solid pizza for a neighborhood pie shop. It's mostly for takeout and delivery. Pulcinella down the street has better crust and sauce, but they also have smaller and more expensive pizza. I like supporting Paranormal.

    Half house pizza half pepperoni
    Iman A.

    Friendly staff, pizza was tasty and fresh. Best of all, full halal menu! Dough was thing and cooked perfectly. Toppings were fresh as well.

    Menu 2022
    Kirstin H.

    I have heard good things about Paranormal Pie for a while now and was finally in the area so I had to pop by. They did not disappoint! They offer a variety of classic pies as well as Greek/Lebanese inspired pizzas, calzones, sandwiches, appetizers, and desserts. I asked for recommendations and the owner suggested the House Pizza as well as their pesto based pizzas. I will have to return to try more items next time!

    Deep dish, pizza with veggie and meat
    Push D.

    This is my first time eating at this restaurant. I came in and asked the nice lady upfront what she would recommend. She said everything was delicious. Obviously I couldn't order everything , so, I ordered the deep dish pizza with meat and vegetable. I have lived in Seattle very long time and this is one of the BEST deep dish pizza I've had in a very long time.

    Hawaiian Pizza
    Ella W.

    In my opinion, this looked like a drug front run by mafia, with a side of illegal bird selling. No kidding there was a cage of exotic birds in the lobby. Neither of the employees we saw were wearing masks, which was concerning as they were very old and likely at risk of COVID. Very surprised to see an "Excellent" food safety rating in the window. Friend says it's better than dominoes though personally I must disagree. This pizza was subpar, very greasy, and a little pricy. Also it was cut by a knife which I'm very sure they would've used on me if I was not accompanied by my young sister and male friend. Especially because behind the register was a very large man intimidatingly staring me down with his arms crossed. My friend would like to compliment them on the sprite.

    See all

    7 years ago

    This place is awesome. The food was exactly what I wanted. Great service and amazing people. Totally recommend.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of M N.
    0
    8
    0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Mahroo K.
    235
    13
    0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 3 of 3

    Ask the Community - Paranormal Pie

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 33,345 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Jude's Old Town - Beignets

    Jude's Old Town

    4.5(196 reviews)
    0.1 miRainier Beach
    $$

    Really great southern food! I was by the airport and rarely ever come this direction but heard…read moreabout Jude's from a friend and decided to drop by. We walked in around 5pm on a Sunday night and was greeted by a very friendly waiter who offered us a few choices to sit. We ordered the gumbo, the grits plate w blackened catfish, and an eggplant dip appetizer. I'm from the south and didn't know seattle had southern food like this! The ambience was great and food absolutely delicious. Would definitely come again!

    Great Cajun food with serious New Orleans vibes…read more Jude's is a great little Cajun spot that really delivers on the food. My wife had the po' boy, and it compared surprisingly well to a true New Orleans-style sandwich--definitely one of the highlights of the meal. Everything we tried was flavorful and well prepared. The ambiance is very Seattle, in the best possible way: casual, eclectic, and perfectly suited to its Rainier Beach Old Town location. The neighborhood can feel a little sketchy, but honestly, that's part of the setting and fits the vibe of the place, so I wouldn't hold that against Jude's. Service was good overall, although it was a little slow considering how small the restaurant is. Still, the food and atmosphere more than made up for it. Definitely worth checking out if you're looking for some solid Cajun food with a distinctly Seattle personality.

    Photos
    Jude's Old Town - Outside, nice moon

    Outside, nice moon

    Jude's Old Town - Mushroom Étouffée with NOLA fritter upgrade (one missing cause sharing is caring)

    Mushroom Étouffée with NOLA fritter upgrade (one missing cause sharing is caring)

    Jude's Old Town - French 75, yum

    See all

    French 75, yum

    Bang Bang Kitchen

    Bang Bang Kitchen

    4.2(183 reviews)
    1.4 miBrighton
    $$

    Came here on a Saturday afternoon for lunch and happy hour and had a pleasant time. Parking is easy…read moresince you're able to validate it in the restaurant using a QR code or something similar (I forget) on the table which was super convenient. We got seated right away. Food came out quickly. Our server was very friendly as well. Checked up on us often and was very warm. We ordered a couple drinks. They were solid and got me a bit tipsy lol. We ordered queso fries as our appetizer. It was my favorite thing we ate there. Fries were warm, crunchy, and soft in the inside. The sauce and meat tasted great too. We also ordered corn dogs off the happy hour menu - the cornbread around the dog itself was thinner than I'm used to in a normal corn dog, which I liked! It was a good bread to meat ratio and the sauce was excellent. For our main, we got the bang bang burrito and the birria tacos. The burrito was delicious. Super flavorful and the side salad was good too. Loved the dressing. The birria tacos were not the best I've ever had. The tacos themselves were good, and the side of beans was solid. Just the consommé was very oily. Very enjoyable experience overall. Definitely would return.

    Bang bang kitchen is a very vegetarian friendly restaurant located in the Beacon Hill area of…read moreSeattle. I love their decor and lots of seating options. However parking was pain. All street parking was full for blocks so we parked a few blocks away and walked. Only when we entered did we notice they validate parking for restaurant guests at the nearby parking garage. We were there in time for evening happy hour and they had a lot of choices for food and drink but to be honest, I thought the prices for happy hour were not that cheap and compared to other restaurants. Our server did a great job answering our questions and bringing out our food and drinks. We ordered zucchini fries and nachos. The zucchini fries were delicious and perfectly crunchy with the batter on top. We really enjoyed those. The nachos were flavorful too but the cheese wasn't what we were expecting. It was a green chili queso but it seemed very runny vs a thicker cheese. It was still delicious but just something different than we expected.

    Photos
    Bang Bang Kitchen - Entrance

    Entrance

    Bang Bang Kitchen
    Bang Bang Kitchen - Nice fireplace

    See all

    Nice fireplace

    Sam Choy's Poke To The Max - Seattle - Poke Bowl

    Sam Choy's Poke To The Max - Seattle

    3.9(400 reviews)
    2.5 miColumbia City
    $$

    Seattle has a lot of great options for poke, and Sam Choy's has been on my radar for quite some…read moretime now! While rotating through one of the nearby hospitals, my team and I decided to grab Sam Choy's for some good takeout! Unfortunately I can't speak too much on the actual establishment or service since we door dashed, but I can definitely talk about the food! I was feeling a bit unorthodox (most likely the sleep deprivation) and opted for the salmon poke nachos for my first time here. Priced at nearly $19, I was honestly pleasantly surprised with the amount of food I got! Normally with nachos, you're always gonna end up with a layer of chips at the bottom without any sauce or toppings -- I can't say I had this experience with the poke nachos here! There was ample fish, sauce, and other toppings. I never felt like I had a dry bite. The salmon was great quality as well, the pieces felt fresh and buttery, and there was a pretty good quantity for what you ordered. I'll definitely be back to try some of their other dishes in the future!

    My apologies, Sam Choy. I was not familiar with your game, or the fact that you are the "godfather…read moreof poke". I got a clam chowder, and my boyfriend got the garlic chicken. The chicken was satisfyingly sweet, savory, and crispy. The rice was a tad mushy, and the mac salad was valid. The clam chowder came loaded with clams and bacon, it was really yummy and had a seafood-esque flavor to the chowder. I was craving clam chowder this entire Seattle trip, and I was so excited that this was my final pit stop and that it did not disappoint. Next time I'll have to try this place and see if they really do poke to the max!

    Photos
    Sam Choy's Poke To The Max - Seattle
    Sam Choy's Poke To The Max - Seattle - Hurricane poke liddat

    Hurricane poke liddat

    Sam Choy's Poke To The Max - Seattle - Menu

    See all

    Menu

    La Herradura - Tacos (4)

    La Herradura

    3.4(16 reviews)
    1.2 miBrighton

    Drove by here for years and today we stopped in. The food was really good with super reasonable…read moreprices. The staff were kind and the food came out in a good time. Had the chicken fajitas and the steak and chicken tacos. Everyone enjoyed their meal.

    I went in yesterday with my boyfriend and we waited about 20 ish minutes for the food which was…read morereasonable I guess I ordered 2 asada tostadas and he had a side of beef broth with 2 asada tacos and 2 tostadas de ceviche. Off the first bite I had of my food the immediate taste of flavorless hit me and the meat just didn't taste right overall I literally took it all off my tostada and after my boyfriend ate his first taco he literally told me he felt sick and decided ro try the ceviche which was literally cocktail de Camarón NOT ceviche (look up the difference) he was not happy and wanted to walk out immediately but I told him we should be nice and at least pay for half but mind you that was us being NICE and fast forward on the way home he cannot hold in his disgust thank god I had a bag in my car he literally threw up SO much and I even had to pull over to the side of the freeway so he can finish throwing up. We had to stop by the store to get some stomach medicine because it was truly so gross we will NEVER EVER COME BACK the bathroom also stank so bad and smelled like piss, the booth I sat on literally broke im only 120 lbs like im not that big im built like a middle schooler it was just red flag after red flag and i ignored it all. Please just save your time and money and actually go somewhere GOOD I never write negative reviews I just sincerely wouldn't want anyone else to get sick.

    Photos
    La Herradura - Front dining area

    Front dining area

    La Herradura - Chicken Fajitas

    Chicken Fajitas

    La Herradura - Mexican Restaurant

    See all

    Mexican Restaurant

    Paranormal Pie - pizza - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...