Peace Pie

Elizabeth helped us tonight find the best popsicles! They were so delicious! The location and…read moreambiance was so fun and whimsy!

The cashier, Caide was very kind. The popsicles were exquisite and refreshing with exuberant…read moreflavors, and the atmosphere was perfect.

Blackberry limeade

See all

Outside

Cousteau's Waffle & Milkshake Bar

4.3(651 reviews)

0.2 mi

Nice little shop with friendly staff. I got The Calypso which was fantastic! The graham cracker…read morecrumbs in it made it so good.

This is a kind of hard review because I have got waffles and milkshakes both and they are in two…read moredifferent classes . Waffles are pretty dense and just alright . The waffle toppings are way better than the waffle itself . Priced high for the quality , still worth a try . Milkshakes are excellent , coconut shake actually has coconut flake in it . Top notch milkshakes . Waffles 3stars Shakes 4.5 stars

Milkshake menu.

See all

Mayday Ice Cream

4.8(233 reviews)

0.2 mi

Had the strawberry matcha ice cream and it was AMAZING! So sad we don't live close by, I'd be there…read moreall the time. Staff was so nice and the shop is adorable.

After a Cuban sandwich lunch we were in the mood for something sweet - and just a few doors down…read morewas Mayday ice cream. There was a line, but it moved and our wait wasn't very long. The one complication of the line is that it made it hard to see all the flavor choices with your view blocked. We ended up choosing Triple Vanilla(My wife) and Espresso Chip for me. The few tables inside were taken so we enjoyed our choices outside in the sun. This ice cream was excellent, not your run-of-the-mill typical ice cream. It's advertised as small batch ice cream made with premium ingredients and that's exactly how it tastes. As a sweet tooth satisfier it definitely hit the spot!

Smores ice cream in a sugar cone

Pilot with Triple Vanilla and Parent Trap!

See all

Cone Heads Ice Cream

4.2(212 reviews)

4.0 mi

Our first time here.... Definitely go back!!…read more Hubby had the Chicago dog.... He is SO happy to find it authentic, tasty & fresh! I had S'mores Sundae. Such a delicious treat! Nice & clean shop Thank you

Came back again after 3-4 years. The plain waffle cones are still just a dollar extra. The ice…read morecream is still yummy; however, today i felt the scoops were a little on the small side.

See all

Cone Heads Ice Cream

Kilwins Ice Cream - Chocolate - Fudge

3.9(145 reviews)

0.1 mi

Stopped by Kilwins Ice Cream in Saint Augustine and went with the peach flavor. It was super…read moresmooth, creamy, and had a really fresh taste that stood out. Definitely one of those flavors that hits just right, especially on a warm day. The shop has a great vibe and smells incredible when you walk in. It does get pretty busy, so there was a bit of a wait, but it was worth it in the end.Would come back and try more flavors.

Nowhere did they tell me they were gonna charge me an 18% tip. All I did was bring up a bag of…read morepackaged candy and they rang it up so we gave them a cash tip. Then we look at our receipt later and it has an additional 18% added so it was $4.90 extra plus our cash tip in fees for the effort of ringing up two bags of candy. Uncool!

Cookies and cream on a delicious waffle cone

See all

Cookiebird Ice Cream Bar

4.7(75 reviews)

1.1 mi

The food is amazing. The best things about this place is the simplicity of the flavors and…read moretoppings. Back to basics. The atmosphere is cozy and very welcoming. The service is incredible. We hit it off immediately with the owner. The staff is patient with answering questions. They give some samples to try of the cones they make. Would definitely recommend to everyone who loves soft serve.

Service was fast a friendly. The soft serve is definitely "extra" as it's the creamiest and also…read moredensest (not a bad thing) soft serve I've probably ever had. It tasted like serious calories - again not a bad thing - LOL. I will say I don't think the extra cost for waffle cones was worth it.

Not* patiently waiting for his pup cup :)

See all

Cookie bird flight

Castillo Ice Cream

4.9(42 reviews)

0.3 mi

This little stop has some good ice-cream and flavors. We discovered this place a couple visits ago…read moreand try to stop when we come. Today was the day since we parked in the lot across the street. I typically get strawberry cheesecake and did again but with a scoop of cherry also and a sugar cone to top it off. They have some sherbet, waffle and came cones too. Worth the stop when you are in St Augustine.

I stopped in here after seeing good reviews on Yelp. I wanted a hot chocolate to walk around with…read moreso I could admire the Christmas lights. The hot chocolate was rich and delicious and topped with whipped cream. 10/10. The wait was a little on the longer side. I would love to return to try their ice cream or milkshakes. They had so many flavors!

10 minutes ago, the place was full and the guy working knocked the line out fabulously!

Hot chocolate

See all

The St. Augustine Scoop

4.8(76 reviews)

0.8 mi

If you're reading this review- just go!…read more Sooo delicious with a variety of flavors. The ice cream is sweet and creamy without being so decadent that you can't finish a 2 scoop serving. The shop is adorably set up. We walked in on a father and son playing a game of connect four on their wall, and walked out to a small family sitting on the outside bench just chatting. So homey and sweet. But right alongside the great ice cream- major shoutout to the patient and amazing staff. We sampled over 6 flavors with no judgment haha...ended on two orders. Mine: Banana Pudding & Coffeehouse (10/10) Partners: Graham Central Station & Coffeehouse (he finished before I did )

What fun spot to stop for ice cream located it is in uptown St. Augustine. Our server was so…read morefriendly and patient with us. And the prices were very reasonable. I had two scoops, Key Lime and Coconut Chocolate Almond, absolutely delicious with great flavor and add ins. And well priced for $5.25. My daughter and her boyfriend both had ice cream sandwiches which were served on warmed cookies with a scoop of ice cream in between. Inside the shop is decorated with Polaroid photos and a Connect 4 board is hanging on the wall which my kids played a few games. Best ice cream shop we visited during our vacation in St. Augustine.

See all

Moose tracks mint ice cream

Grilled Cheese Gallery

4.4(515 reviews)

0.1 mi

Man.. 10/10. Go support these guys! they have so many options of different grilled cheeses! I had…read morethe tomato and bacon grilled cheese! 3rd on the menu. WOW!! Go try!!

We were rather surprised to find a restaurant in Saint Augustine that specializes in ... grilled…read morecheese sandwiches! One would think there's not much you can do with a grilled cheese sandwich, but the Grilled Cheese Gallery proves that assumption wrong. There are 13 amazing and creative choices of grilled cheese here. Don't like grilled cheese? They also serve salads, poutine, mac & cheese grilled sandwiches, ice cream and other desserts. This is Comfort Food headquarters! There were actually so many choices it was hard to choose. I chose A Night in Amsterdam: Gouda, Gruyere, Swiss, Cheddar, on Artisan White. My wife had The Queen Brie: House cured bacon, French Brie, Raspberry Puree, Balsamic on Sourdough. My Amsterdam was quite a creation: three slices balanced on a pedestal with cheese trailing down more than a foot. It was delicious! My wife lauded her Queen Brie as well. We wish we had more time in Saint Augustine as this place is definitely worth a second visit.

The Queen Brie

See all

Queen Brie on gf bread

Cold Cow

4.4(108 reviews)

5.3 mi

Just wow, the ice cream here is great. A very long list of homemade ice creams. 3 of us enjoyes the…read morerich, creamy goodness along with a line of people. I had the Coffee Crunch, whose coffee ice cream tasted like coffee for a change (not some lame watered down flavor). Others had chocolate flavors which really impressed them. I got the toddler size which would.have been a small anywhere else. Place was cute with tables and chairs, and Adirondack rockers too.

Cold Cow is an absolute must-stop on the way home from any trip to St. Augustine! We've been coming…read morehere for years, and it never disappoints. They have more flavors than I can even remember--truly something for everyone, including sugar-free and dairy-free options. The "single scoop" here is absolutely massive; at most other places, it would be considered a large. It is incredibly well-priced (under $6!), so you really get your money's worth. I got the Dairy-Free Coffee Almond Fudge, and it was fantastic! While I wish they had a few more dairy-free flavors to match their massive traditional menu, I love that they don't upcharge for the dairy-free options. That is a huge win in my book. The vibe is exactly what you'd want from a local mom-and-pop shop: kitschy, eclectic, and covered in cows. They even have rocking chairs on the front porch to relax in. The crew is always friendly and helpful, too. Pro-tip: This place is popular for a reason! If you're visiting on a weekend, be prepared to wait a bit. Trust me, though--it is so very worth it.

Things to do in St. Augustine

Mint Chip with FUDGE !!

See all

Large selection of flavors

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

1 review that is not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Maryrose L.

83

3

16

7 years ago

Always new flavors, always delicious ice cream, we love what we do and the people we do it with! Experience an ice cream sandwich like none you've had before! Two locations, 8 Aviles Street, st augustine ; 691 A1A beach, st augustine beach we ship, we deliver, we cater! read more

Peace Pie - desserts - Updated August 2026

Best of St. Augustine

People found Peace Pie by searching for…

People who viewed Peace Pie also viewed

The Sweet Spot

3.4

(90 reviews)

Everyone here is very nice and the best customer service, always try to hurry to get the costumers…read moretheir order

We wandered in here on a whim, and we're pleasantly surprised by lots of fun, candy, ice cream, and…read moretreats. They even have the viral mango and viral peach ice cream.

The St. Augustine Scoop

4.8

(76 reviews)

If you're reading this review- just go!…read more Sooo delicious with a variety of flavors. The ice cream is sweet and creamy without being so decadent that you can't finish a 2 scoop serving. The shop is adorably set up. We walked in on a father and son playing a game of connect four on their wall, and walked out to a small family sitting on the outside bench just chatting. So homey and sweet. But right alongside the great ice cream- major shoutout to the patient and amazing staff. We sampled over 6 flavors with no judgment haha...ended on two orders. Mine: Banana Pudding & Coffeehouse (10/10) Partners: Graham Central Station & Coffeehouse (he finished before I did )

What fun spot to stop for ice cream located it is in uptown St. Augustine. Our server was so…read morefriendly and patient with us. And the prices were very reasonable. I had two scoops, Key Lime and Coconut Chocolate Almond, absolutely delicious with great flavor and add ins. And well priced for $5.25. My daughter and her boyfriend both had ice cream sandwiches which were served on warmed cookies with a scoop of ice cream in between. Inside the shop is decorated with Polaroid photos and a Connect 4 board is hanging on the wall which my kids played a few games. Best ice cream shop we visited during our vacation in St. Augustine.

Tedi's Olde Tyme Ice Cream

4.0

(65 reviews)

A short and... Sweet (because it's I've cream get it?... I'll just write the review now) review…read moreabout this place. It's a very small location right on St. George Street. Whenever I'm here there tends to be a line but it's quick moving and I've never waited long. The staff is friendly and the prices are good enough. The ice cream is real nice and on a hot day, something that is amazing! I had the blueberry cheesecake when I was here last time and it was very flavourful, the price is decent but you are basically paying a little more here because of the location. There are only a few tables in here due to the size but people eat their ice cream rather quick so I've never waited around, there's also benched everyone if you don't mind sitting outside. Friendly staff and good ice cream will have me stopping here again next time I want something sweet on St. George Street!

On a Saturday night if you looking for a sweet cold treats in st. Augustine, this spot is it …read more Love the sampling, I felt like I didn't have to order after the tasting lol. The Ice-cream was smooth and each flavored was is unique. If you want something fruity you got it ! Or nutty they have the selection, good variety. The workers were great, nice and polite. You can either stay in or leave with your items. Good sweet spot.

Castillo Ice Cream

4.9

(42 reviews)

This little stop has some good ice-cream and flavors. We discovered this place a couple visits ago…read moreand try to stop when we come. Today was the day since we parked in the lot across the street. I typically get strawberry cheesecake and did again but with a scoop of cherry also and a sugar cone to top it off. They have some sherbet, waffle and came cones too. Worth the stop when you are in St Augustine.

I stopped in here after seeing good reviews on Yelp. I wanted a hot chocolate to walk around with…read moreso I could admire the Christmas lights. The hot chocolate was rich and delicious and topped with whipped cream. 10/10. The wait was a little on the longer side. I would love to return to try their ice cream or milkshakes. They had so many flavors!

Mayday Ice Cream

4.8

(233 reviews)

Had the strawberry matcha ice cream and it was AMAZING! So sad we don't live close by, I'd be there…read moreall the time. Staff was so nice and the shop is adorable.

After a Cuban sandwich lunch we were in the mood for something sweet - and just a few doors down…read morewas Mayday ice cream. There was a line, but it moved and our wait wasn't very long. The one complication of the line is that it made it hard to see all the flavor choices with your view blocked. We ended up choosing Triple Vanilla(My wife) and Espresso Chip for me. The few tables inside were taken so we enjoyed our choices outside in the sun. This ice cream was excellent, not your run-of-the-mill typical ice cream. It's advertised as small batch ice cream made with premium ingredients and that's exactly how it tastes. As a sweet tooth satisfier it definitely hit the spot!

Mayday Ice Cream

4.7

(36 reviews)

You pick any two cookies and get 1 scoop of ice cream-$11.95.... but the cookies are massive and…read morehave a soft center. The sugar cookie is to die for!!! The key lime ice cream sandwiches-YUM!!! Hubby got the sorbet strawberry dragon fruit flavor. It is the best tasting sorbet of your life with real chunks of strawberry.

Shoutout to our local community heroes like Chase and staff!! We are so grateful for the dedication…read moreand commitment to provide a friendly atmosphere full of ice cream dreams and sweet treats. The team is welcoming and enthusiastic about finding the perfect flavor for the day. Trying samples ice cream and cookies is so fun!! Cookies, drinks, and flavor combinations are all amazing! The atmosphere is full of happy patrons as sweetness wafts through the air as soon as you open the front door. Reward cards and even merch is a bonus experience. Yummmm! I scream, you scream, we all scream for ice cream!! Triple vanilla to bourbon pecan to mint to blueberries... Yes, please!! (*´`*)

Rita’s Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

4.0

(74 reviews)

Absolutely Amazing! This girl with red hair i belive her name is Daisy was so nice she was smiling…read moreso lovely and i love her service and patience with me she helped me with what i should get! and the food was awesome! and i loved the space! please tell daisy thank you for me!

Still, Rita's is my favorite soft serve custard. The girl at the counter was incredibly nice and…read morequick. The parking lot was clean. My only issue... come on Rita's $6.10 for a small custard??? Insane.

Cafe del Hidalgo

3.6

(253 reviews)

Another day roaming around Saint Augustine - another excuse for a tasty treat! Cafe del Hidalgo…read more advertised artisinal homemade gelato on their outside sign - they had us at gelato! Lots of choices - over 20 different gelato flavors - it was hard to make up our minds! I eventually settled on the Toasted Almond gelato and my wife the Chocolate Hazelnut. This place knows their gelato - it was fantastic. My toasted almond reminded me of my Chicago childhood and favorite toasted almond bars from the Good Humor truck. My wife's chocolate hazelnut was perfect for a chocolate lover. Great spot for a gelato break.

Having just come back from my beloved Italy, to find "authentic" Gelato in St. Augustine was a…read moredream come true. You know its authentic as the color represented exactly what the ingredients were. Pistachio (pronounced Pis-tac-kio) was a creamy tan which it should be. Then a sample before ordering sent me back to Italy as the flavor was perfection. Best surprise was the taste of their Ricotta, Lemon and Basil. OMG!!! I would stand in line to get another cup.

Likit Dole Whip

4.3

(79 reviews)

On a very hot summer day strolling the streets of St Augustine this Dole Whip hit the spot! It was…read morelight, refreshing and tasted so fabulous!

Wonderful fun employee's on every occasion . One hundred percent % consistent every single time …read more Absolutely the best dole whip in the state of Florida and if you like your dole whip spiked , guess what they do that to . A little on the high price because historic St Augustine is a tourist trap . Still worth stopping if you are on vacation , passing thru or a local . 4.5/5 * Just because the tourist area pricing . Still understandable I for one will always break my diet while in the area on this

Le Macaron French Pastries

3.2

(127 reviews)