What went well? EVERYTHING! First time groom appt. here and my 2-1/2 yr. old pup came out looking like a Queen. Carla the groomer asked me if I wanted her to be groomed a certain way and she did exactly as I requested. I added nail filing when I made the appt. and her nails were done perfectly. I highly recommend this store for grooming and highly recommend Carla. Add in that Carla is super sweet and personable. I had recent surgery and was there with a walker and everyone there including Carla, helped with getting my pup to the back to Carla to get my purchases to the car which neither I nor my mother could carry. This place is A-+ read more

See all

I have shopped from Pet Supplies Plus in Oceanside for many years. Their prices almost always be Petco and Chewy, which is why I can just stop in and grab something without really thinking about it. I placed an online order yesterday and it came way earlier than predicted. One of the items was missing, and I called the store, they immediately connected me with the manager. She was so understanding and is sending the out right now. I can't say enough good things about going into the store with my dog or stopping in just to see the hamsters. Everyone is super nice and it's a business that I love to give my money to. read more

Staff is very nice and helpful every time I come in. I go monthly for my cats and dog so it's an easy stop to grab what I need since everything is always in stock. read more

Received a coupon that was good on dog food, order in the am, Received it at my door by the afternoon. You cannot ask for more.

Consistently outstanding experience from a trained and helpful staff. It's alway easy to find assistance if you need it.

My 'Sis' brought her fur baby here to be groomed on 9/27. When she arrived to pick her fur baby, she was met with an awful job and horrific ulcers in both eyes! A $95 job quickly turned into over $600 in vet bills! Look at the pics. Where you see green, those are ulcers. Think long and hard before deciding on taking your pet here. read more

See all

Friendly staff, great selection, and amazing team for grooming our Rosie! Thank you all! read more

Pet Supplies Plus Oceanside - Rosie after grooming appointment - Pet Stores Near Me - Oceanside, New York

See all

Items stocked on the shelves behind sales signs that weren't on sale and a much higher price . We spoke with a sales rep about the item before choosing it. When we decided to purchase the item we took it to the register and it rang up $20+ more told cashier the sales price (which was reason we choose it in case it didn't work for us) and she went to shelves and said oh wrong spot and pointed to price ticket which was high up and hard to read. Many more items behind the wrong price ticket and she didn't bother moving items or putting correct price in from of the items. Seems like a scam to get you to register with the more expensive item not a sales item. Was annoyed when we told her to take it off sale we weren't buying it. Bait and switch. Sad the store used to be very good. read more

Five star groomer Tanya she is amazing and loves the animals. I take my dogs there and they love her she does an amazing job highly recommend her read more

I was looking for some new healthy raw food for my little guys. I have an overweight teacup Yorkie who weights in at 7lbs at the moment and should be in the 4-5lbs weight range. I was able to find a variety of different brands of raw food here. They have a very large selection of dog food, cat food, bird food and many other animal foods. While I was here I picked out some new toys and a new bed for my little guys. The nice girl at the checkout signed me up for their store savings card and holy moly did I really save on the dog bed and toys. I also noticed a sign and something to the effect of if you continue buying food from them you get an addition savings after so many bags. I've been back a few times and the staff are always super friendly and helpful. Definitely my go-to pet supply store. read more

See all

The assistant manager Phil I think his name is and the girl at the register are extremely rude. They have a 20% off sale going on right now they have items mispriced and they don't want to honor the prices. They were very dismissive and rude. read more

I called and asked if they had a particular dog food in stock. I was then placed on hold for 52 minutes then someone picked up the phone and I said hello and with no answer the phone was then hung up. No respect for the customers time. I would not recommend this location. read more

Brought my dog on September 27th to be groomed and this is how my pup was returned to me... a $95 appointment turning into $605 worth of medical bills. Contacted the store and spoke to manager Karen and groomer Taylor and received no resolution or accountability. I the response I received from Karen was "I feel like you're taking it negatively." Those green circles in each eye are ulcers caused by their grooming which they attempted to hide by leaving the hair over his eyes. read more

Pet Supplies Plus Oceanside - The morning of grooming - Pet Stores Near Me - Oceanside, New York

See all

Pet supplies plus in oceanside has a fantastik grooming Dept. They love dogs and always do a great job. Reasonable cost

I signed up for autoship for this dog food and they shipped it twice to me, two days apart, due to a glitch in their system. The local store in Oceanside did not care to help me rectify this issue and they refused to pick up the second bag of food due to an error in THEIR system. I even spoke with the manager, Fara, and she was very dismissive and disinterested in the issue. They told me I had to bring the bag of dog food back to them for a refund. Now I have to carry this huge heavy bag back to them to correct THEIR mistake. I immediately cancelled my auto ship membership and after this bag of food, I'm changing dog foods because I will never shop at Pet Supplies Plus ever again. Their store employees are rude and have no interest in their customers and the corporate office doesn't answer....you have to leave a message and they never call back! From now on I'm going to PETCO because they actually care about their customers! read more

Teach your employees better customer service and have your return policies printed out. I had a large bag of dog food set for auto-ship and it arrived on time, however I didn't need it at the moment. I went to return it at this location and the manager was a total JERK... first I bring in the bag and have my emailed copy of the receipt ready. She first says that they can't return online orders which I called BS right away and asked her to see it in writing which she refused. She finally checks my receipt, then she gets reluctant and says that the sku numbers didn't match.. I showed her the numbers were EXACTLY the same and then says, "I can't get you a cash return just store credit. All I wanted was for her to return it to MY card. The irony of this whole thing is that not only os she the manager but her name was Karen. Go figure. I was very upset and she WAS being prejudice. I've been ordering dogfood from this company for years and for me to have a HASSLE to do a return on DOG FOOD I don't need and that I paid for with MY hard earned money is NOT fair!! Will NEVER be going there again. So sad and pathetic !! read more

This store is disgusting and they do not take care of there animals. 15 baby birds showed in 1 cage with no food and no water. How is that ok?? A ferret that was living with poop all over, and was standing in its own urin. This store has NO business selling animals. read more

Pet Supplies Plus Oceanside - Animal living in its own dirty poop - Pet Stores Near Me - Oceanside, New York

See all

I love this store always help me with everything I need for my puppy . Thank you so much . The store is great always so much stuff to pick from toys and food treats read more

See all

Brought my golden retriever to get groomed there as I've done so many times. Used to go to Dylan and Melissa who were great. Also used Tania the past few times with no complaints. I showed up and asked for what I normally ask for, bath brush and deshed package. Except, when I picked up my dog he was completely cut short as if he was a yellow lab. I asked Tania about it and she told me that was the deshed, as she was talking on the phone with someone else. Since I already had to pay ahead of time and was in a bit of surprise I walked out. On my ride home I noticed he was cut completely uneven so I called to speak to the manager and offered to come back with him. Karen was nice and said she would call me back after speaking with the groomer. I never heard back so called 2 hours later, I spoke with Phil. I asked to refund the 133 dollar cut because I was so disappointed in how my dog looks and will have have to get him fixed to grow back right. Phil was extremely rude on the phone not at all apologetic. Wouldn't even consider a refund and said there's nothing he can do but give me a 25% off my next cut. I attached pictures of my dog before and after for reference. I won't be going back. read more

See all

I love this pet store! The staff always greets me with a smile, and always asks me if they can help me find something. The store is always clean, well stocked and well organized and I can always find what I need. They do a lot to help support local animal charities as well. My favorite place to shop for pet supplies! read more

No rating. Do not take your dog here. Woman lied. Dogs nails were cut but also the skin, made the dog bleed. I had to look at my dogs paws to see the blood. Never again. Hope she gets fired!!!! read more

Not only will you find what you're looking for, but the store provides a fun environment in which to do it in. The staff leave me feeling good about my purchase & have fun raffles on occasion for everyone. The discount coupons I received though email is a plus too! read more

Pet Supplies Plus Oceanside - Baby, my Green Cheek Conure - Pet Stores Near Me - Oceanside, New York

See all

A tad less expensive than Petco. Some refrigerated items not seen in the typical pet store. Helpful staff and a place to get hard to find items read more

Pet Supplies Plus Oceanside - Pet Stores Near Me - Oceanside, New York

Walked in looking for a life vest for my dog the cashier asked me to put my phone number to check for discounts and sure enough I got a great deal read more

2 yrs ago I opened a bag of Purina dog food purchased in the store & it contained maggots. I brought it back to store and manager at the time exchanged bag without comment. An hour ago I opened new Purina bag and it contained bugs. Bag purchased 12/22/23.Assistant manager Phil refused to exchange because purchase was 14 days past his 30 day limit. Terrible customer service. Will never shop in PSP again. read more

Amazing I can not recall the young ladys name that helped me I think it was Cristina had a lot of tattoos is all I can recall so so so amazing super nice and so knowledgeable read more

I used to shop here or at their store in West Hempstead but no more. Prices have skyrocketed way beyond what others charge. $5 for a can of Blue buffalo dog food while Stop n Shop and Walmart charge about half that price. Same thing goes for Stella and Chewy meal mixers, they charge over $80 for the big bag (it used to be $35 there) meanwhile Chewy.com sells the same for half their price. This has nothing to do with supply chain, its about greedy owners. The only people that should be shopping here are those without the intelligence to know they're being had. AVOID AT ALL COST !! read more

Have been taking my dog to Pet Supplies Plus in Oceanside for the last 2 years. Great dog grooming service. Melissa is fantastic, gentle, kind and understands exactly how to handle my dog. Melissa is a great asset. read more

This store has a good product selection for my pup Jack. I miss the treats they used to carry in the dispensers though. Those are his favorite! They also have good deals and sales frequently. We will be back soon! read more

Absolutely the friendliest and most helpful staff. The store is well maintained and if you can't find something the staff is always willing to help. I needed a seatbelt for my dog and they helped me find something perfect. The staff is so supportive of animal rescue and fair they try to help as many as they can. I wish this store was closer but I am happy to go out of my way to shop here. read more

I spoke to the manager of this store by the name Phill. Rude and extremely unprofessional. It's a franchise. Each store's culture depends on the owner. This one is really bad. I had issues with them a couple times, and will not buy anything from them in the future. read more

John was super helpful in helping me find a harness for my puppy today. He was kind and patient! Awesome store!

Experience: I came here with my dad to buy my mom a new beta. Hers had just passed away after having it for a long time. This was supposed to be a quick in and out trip. A store employee offered to help me while I was looking for thermometers and I said no thank you. Then, he approached my dad and they talked for 10-15 minutes. After I had chosen a beta for my mom, this same person comes over and takes the fish and tells me he's examining it to make sure its healthy and starts tapping on the tank. That really bothered me. And then he kept talking to us for a long time and I just wanted to take the fish, pay, and get out of there. There are a few jars of fish that have been dead for a while and were decaying on that shelf. Something just seems off to have a 'fish specialist' there, yet some of the fish are dead on the shelf and not being taken care of. There are sheets there too for how to take care of the beta fish and other types of pets as well. There's a policy where you can replace the fish if it dies within 14 days of you purchasing it if you have the receipt. Recommend it?: Prices are fair, but I can't say I had a great experience here. read more

amazing groomer Tanya she's been grooming my dogs for a year and They love her five star service amazing

After a few attempts to get through via email I called corporate during regular business hours. They stepped up and rectified the situation where the local store dropped the ball. I should not have had to jump through as many hoops and gone through the aggravation but the corporate office fixed everything. read more

You have a young man named James that works for your company he is such a nice boy I would love to deal with him all the time. He is very respectful and always polite and always helpful. read more

It was extremely easy to order online and they were quick to fill my order. A big plus they always have my dog food!

They have the most ridiculous coupon policy, where they require you to print out electronic coupons. If they can scan it from my phone there's no need to print it out. That's moronic. Why in this day & age make anyone waste the time & paper to print out an electronic coupon? It makes no sense, is a waste & terrible for the environment. read more

I usually order pet supplies or what little I need from an online retailer, but for a last minutes need situation they're a pretty decent choice. They have a very vast high quality dog food selection, there's a lot of cat items as well. Clean store with a decent amount staff to keep things moving. Overall pretty decent location with a large selection of food items. read more

Pet Supplies Plus Oceanside - Pet Stores Near Me - Oceanside, New York

See all

Have been shopping here for my pets for 12 years- they have a great array of high quality items from food to clothing to bathing supplies. Parking is abundant and they always greet you when you enter and offer their assistance if they see you shopping. They do a superb job grooming and have a plethora of advice and experience in just about every topic related to your pet. They always apprise you of any special offerings and cause you to feel welcomed and wanting to return and take their time with each customer. read more