I am from Brooklyn and let me tell you if you miss the pizza got to go to Peter's pizza. It will take you back home . Love it a must go !

I had a chicken salad wrap for 11.00. The wrap was on the smaller side but so was the price. At 11.00, they must own the building otherwise the price would be more if they had to pay rent. I was full so it was big enough. It is a few blocks up from the center of the shopping area. They only have street parking but no meters. It is your basic pizza shop so you know what to expect. I would have to try again before I would pass judgement but I see no reason why I would not return. read more

See all

Classic spot in Wellesley that has been open forever. Reasonable prices and quick service, everything I've gotten on the menu is solid, chicken fingers are a favorite for sure. Included photos of the recent menu for reference. read more

Peter's Pizza - a menu for a pizza restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Wellesley, Massachusetts

See all

I've got a bone to pick with Peter's Pizza. We had a family get together this evening and figured we would order Peter's as we have done so many times in the past. Peter's has been some of the best pizza in the immediate radius. We used to love Peter's Pizza but the quality has dipped a bit recently...ok maybe because of COVID.....so let's still support the local brand and not fracture the whole relationship. That stops now. Our steak and cheese subs were filled with bone chips tonight. Yes, bone chips! (See below) This certainly spurred a call to the manager asking for new subs (something different of course) and the manager was adamant that I save the subs and find the bone chips to send back. He was specific in stating that he wanted the bone chips back because the company he buys his provisions from would owe him a credit of meat. I thought ok (a little weird), but I don't want this to compound any further. So as I'm trying to eat with my family and I was also separating bone from steak and cheese for the manager. I found a lot more bone chips on top of the ones we already threw away. I called back saying they really should do something for the inconvenience. The manager said I will only give you a sub (BTW we had two steak and cheese subs). I told him I didn't think that this was humerus!!! The delivery driver showed up and I politely declined the sub and showed him the "bone bag" I had. He was horrified as well! He said the manager really should have made it right. Just a bad experience and I'm moving on. Please be careful! read more

Peter's Pizza - Bone from Peter's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wellesley, Massachusetts

See all

If you like your pizza delivered about 1-2 hours after you ordered it, colder than a witches' tit in a brass bra, Peter's Pizza is your kind of place. It sucks! Go anywhere else! read more

This is a true jewel of a pizza and sandwich shop. I personally love the chicken cutlet sandwich. The pizzas are crispy, chewy, and flavorful. The store is tiny so there's really no place to dine in, so call ahead and you're in/out in the blink of an eye. read more

The service went above and beyond. Gave me a free slice plus & a chicken tender and some fries. Like come on got me fallin in love with a pizza place. Not to mention the very friendly staff, very well done Peter's pizza read more

Gees: Seen some Negative reviews but I did not find anything wrong. The only thing is being a Vegan & Not being able to Eat that Sicilian Square-pan Pizza that Looked so Yummy OMG I was getting Second thoughts but I stuck with being a Vegetarian _Vegan What brought me there was my Company ordered 5 different kinds of Pizza and I didn't hear 1 complaint from the workers : All Liked the Pizza and Free wings too read more

Best breakfast sandwiches and subs and pizza in all of mass! 10/10 would recommend! Super friendly service and great food! If you are looking for something local to eat, this is your place. read more

I hadn't been to Peter's pizza in over 12 years and decided to stop in to grab a slice for lunch. I asked if they served slices he named what kind and I said two cheese He looked at them and said "I give you two for one because a little burnt" then walked to the oven. A woman walked in after me (African American) she also order two cheese pizzas and a drink. And paid. A new man asked me if I paid I said no he charges me $6 the man from the oven comes up and says only one slice for her so he charges me $4 Two slices come up in a bag I'm assuming for me since I was first but he said no and the other woman got them. She walked out he said "I didn't want her to see you got two" Sooo I'm confused as to why I paid for one and she paid for two and we got the EXACT same thing?!? ALSO they have photos all over the walls of someone who hunts for show showing all the animals (zebra moose cheetah) clearly not hunting to eat just hunting for fun which is DISGUSTING. why would anybody want to look at innocent animals before they eat?! This is a complete disgrace. I will not be returning. Also my pizza was indeed burnt and nothing special. I feel bad giving one star because the man was nice but this kind of behavior is unacceptable read more

we always ordered from Pete's pizza. When the kids have bdays or we have get together. We ordered a large cheese today for pickup and either they shrunk or he gave us a small. When I asked him about it he insisted it was a large and the next size up was family style. Umm, since when? I have my kid with me and don't want to make a big fuss because he isn't backing down. I always want to support my local places but this was a small. read more

Peter's Pizza - Is this a large slice? - Pizza Near Me - Wellesley, Massachusetts

Peter's Pizza is the best pizza I've had in Mass. The crust has a very nice crunch to it and has a little thickness to it, unlike most MA pizza. The sauce is sweet and the pepperoni is very flavorful. I'm looking forward to trying their sausage pizza next. Unfortunately, I'll never be able to review their other food because I'll always get pizza. I'm rarely ever in Wellesley, unfortunately. read more

**BUT*** I'm sad to say I won't be returning to Peter's again after being a regular customer over the past year. The pizza is great (tho the large is really a medium). The Greek salad is good (also way too small though). The reason that I'm not returning is that I was in there recently and suddenly noticed a wall I'd never seen. It was a wall covered in photos of presumably the owner showcasing all of his many kills as a hunter. There are so many reasons why this is in poor taste not the least of which is upsetting little kids. My kid would be devastated to see him standing proudly over the ZEBRA he killed with his rifle in hand. Just not a good decision. Given how faded they are, I'm sure the photo has been there for years. It's pretty inappropriate in my opinion. Will be sorry to not have Peter's Pizza again. read more

Peter's Pizza - a wall full of framed photos - Pizza Near Me - Wellesley, Massachusetts

Decided to write a review because this place isn't getting the credit it deserves: If you're looking for a delicious breakfast, lunch, or dinner - stop in. Best breakfast sandwiches and the pizza is amazing. Quality is consistent and prices are fair. The owner is a local who grew up in the area and his restaurant has been a staple in Wellesley for years. For everyone writing negative reviews, can only imagine the snobby BS they put the staff through. It's a pizza shop, calm down. read more

Decent breakfast burrito - I had the eggs Swiss cheese and turkey - prepared quickly tasted good but not spectacular and not cheap $8 or so. Place is dingy w Fox News on the tele and pics of the owner and family w their dead animal trophies. Really I don't care about the politics and killing of animals - I'm a total carnivore - just calling that out. Issue w place is the dinginess and lack of even the most basic friendliness of the owner. The guy has what appears to be contempt for his customers (at least he did for me) - looked thru me, didn't so much as say thank you or show that he gave a sh*t about my biz. Anyway - no genius in the kitchen - the burrito was decent - coupled with the above negatives no reason to go back. read more

The food is fine however I can't get over the photos of the owners pleasure hunts in Africa that were on the walls until the dentist. zebra Gazelles lions moose bears ....ohh my I lost my appetite!!! He must realize the error of his ways the photos have been removed however the stains on the wall remain read more

Peter's Pizza - This is a wall in Peter's that showcases the owner and his dozens of African big game hunts, is he the next Dentist you decide - Pizza Near Me - Wellesley, Massachusetts

See all

I suspect this place is under new ownership, it used to have rather good, not great, but good pizzas. I haven't had a take-out pizza in two years and was in the area and decided I wanted one. I called and asked for a basic Margherita pizza with bacon and artichokes. The person said she had no Margherita pizza, I asked if she was sure because that is a pizza staple. She called a man. I asked the same of him. He said they had no artichoke (a surprise at an Italian pizzeria, but they could have been out of stock), okay, I said, could I have asparagus? Yes, he said, they had that. Encouraged I asked for mushroom too. He then said, do you want tomato on your pizza? That was when I gave up. A tomato base is found on every pizza. read more

This place rocks! I just ordered a meatball sub/grinder and their Italian sub/grinder....AND WOW! Just like home! I am a transplant from Brooklyn and are up on Italian heroes (sub/grinder in Brooklyn-ese) and Peter's Pizza is the real thing!!!!! The only thing better would be my mom's sub shop in Bensonhurst... WOW! Thanks for reminding me of Mom's! read more

I travel a lot because of work. This week we're in Boston with one of my favorite coworker. Love the pizza read more

Peter's Pizza - Amazing pizza. Cheese Pepperoni and extra cheese on top,... - Pizza Near Me - Wellesley, Massachusetts

For some reason the crew closes the grille at 7p when they claim to be open until 10p. Don't bother calling past sunset because they can't be bothered. read more

So incredibly rude. Got hung up on twice and then proceeded to bark questions over the phone. Sorry to inconvenience you to give you my money? It's unfortunate because Peter's came highly recommended. I will be talking about my experience to everyone in my office! read more

I walk in look up with the menu as soon as my head looks up the guy said what do you want... I asked him to give me a minute my coworker ordered two slices they were 2.50 each and extremely tiny my coworker grabbed his slice of cheese pizza I went to Cook's window Pizza on Washington Street I grabbed two slices and a drink for 6:19 my coworkers are mine and went and got another slice cuz it was almost four times the size my co-workers exact words cleaner better and real Pizza read more

Holy cow--we ordered the pizza 2 hours ago, they said it was going to take 30-45 minutes to get here and we are STILL waiting. Every time we call they say "sorry but we're backed up." That's it. Ok, it just arrived... The delivery guy was nice and actually seemed to care, but food is not hot and our night in is kind of ruined (this was movie night with our 5 year old). What a bummer-- beware of ordering from them if you want to eat within a timely manner. read more

When Peter's was across town on Linden Street, my office mates and I used to order their pizza most Fridays. I thought it had gone out of business but while driving on Washington street in Lower Falls, I was surprised to see that it is still in business, although in a much smaller storefront; no eat-in tables, a much reduced menu and no daily specials. I ordered a large pepperoni and bacon. My first surprise was the size of the large, which had shrunk to 13.5 inches. The next surprise was that the pizza was noticably dry, having very little sauce and, if possible, even less cheese. The final, and worst surprise was that the taste had been lost in the transition. I asked the counterman if they had to come in early in the morning to make the dough. He said, no they don't have the time to do that any more but, luckily, they can buy good pre-shaped crusts. I suspect the average buyer might argue with the "good" rating of the crust, which to me, was flavorless. In reading the reviews online, I noticed that 10 percent of reviews were 5-stars! My wife read them and said they obviously were written by "My mother, Mary" or other paid review writers. A sad state of affairs. read more

This place moved from the Linden Street location. Recently, my club got delivery from Pete's Pizza for a spring kick-off meeting. Delivery was right on time. The pizza is delicious, and the sauce is especially great. We all enjoyed the large greek salads with yummy dressing. Everything was crisp and fresh. I would definitely recommend this over any other Wellesley pizza establishments! read more

Excellent pizza with crunchy crust. I recommend extra sauce, because it's yummy! Also do hamburgers, subs, wings, and even breakfast sandwiches! All great! Price is good an service is friendly. Best pizza in Wellesley hills/lower falls. read more

I'm almost thirty years old and I've been eating Peter's Pizza ever since I can remember. They're always consistent and taste the same as they did 20 years ago, they're always pleasant on the phone and know exactly where to deliver, and most of all I ALWAYS look forward to coming back home to Boston to devour a fresh hot pizza all to myself. It might look like a small forgettable joint on the outside but Peter's is actually the hidden gem of Wellesley. read more

the food here is great everything tastes good.. but the customer service is terrible.. they hang up on you before you can finish your order, they have bad attitudes and just overall miserable people.. if you can get by that then its fine.. read more

Having been eating here my entire life. Always consistent quality and good prices. Friendly staff too. Best pizza in town!

This is the worst pay value I've ever seen. 35 dollars for a big big pizza do get your hair I'm sick of it.

Pizza is good - people not always in the best mood. Service factor low - value for money reasonable. Best choice is the large size pizza with three toppings. read more

I'm also writing a review for Peter's Pizza as their pizzas were delicious and everyone raved. We needed about a dozen pizzas for an event. Peter took the order; the pizzas were ready when we'd needed to pick them up. All of the people who had pizza that night were delighted with the quality and taste. This is a pizza place worth a visit, and for me a revisit. It's not a big place, but they make great pizza! read more

Local pizza joint. Family run. Descent pies, good for local take-out.

Never again, 14.95 for a large pepperoni pizza and the pizza was small. $2 for a can of soda, $20 for a large(small) pizza and 2 cans of soda. It not worth it change the prices or lose business read more

Very disgusted and disappointed. I regularly order from peters pizza even though they are never pleasant on the phone. However, today will be my LAST. They forgot one of our salads and when we called to inform them we got series ATTITUDE. The man on the phone kept asking if we knew who delivered our food because he had no idea about his employee whom deliver the food. Didn't have their numbers or anything. Then after he said he would send another salad....it showed up a half hour later, cold and they charged us more for the salad. Terrible customer service. read more

The owner is a prick! So rude. No Hello nor thank you when taking an order. Uncooked eggs on the omelet. I work and live in Wellesley and we just given this place too many chances. If you dont want to get food POISON dont order from here! read more

Peters Pizza is excellent. I have order several large orders before they actually open and they always go out of their way to open up for me and give me a discount. read more

My co workers and I had ordered lunch quite a few times from this restaurant, hoping from the next time the service and quality of food would be better, but again we were disappointed!!!!!!!!! Delivery always takes over an hour, and when it does show up, the food is cold and hard and they do not even offer a discount or a refund. When ordering from the menu on hand, they charge a different price than on the menu. I would not recommend this place unless you want to get ripped off with cold, hard food!!! read more

Peters pizza is the best pizza place in Wellesley. I have been going there my whole life getting breakfast, lunch, and dinner. I love their breakfast sandwiches the most since it's so fresh and great price. Also everyone there has been so kind to me and always treats me extremely well. I highly recommend peters pizza read more

Great pizza. Love the buffalo wings. fast delivery. Steve is great to talk to...plus they are open on sundays!!!!