Kelsey G was wonderful! So personable and helpful. The food was delicious too. We had Chicken Piccata with cavatelli pasta with the piccata sauce rather than marinara, Caesar salad, Chicken Gnocchi soup and Shrimp Maria. We enjoyed everything and we will be back. read more

We've been going here for years now. Best arrabiatta I've ever had, and their house salad and dressing is wonderful. Also bread is to die for. read more

Our waitress was amazing and the food was authentic Italian - almost better than your Italian grandma's food! The chairs could be more comfy but then I probably would've stayed even longer. Bravissimo! read more

Dawn & Shannon made my visit here exceptional. They both went above & beyond standard service. I would come back here simply for them. Dawn was enjoyable to talk with. This is a cute little restaurant. It's a little on the more dressy side, but I didn't feel too out of place in joggers & a hoodie. The bread & oil is the perfect start to the rest of the meal. I ordered the Eggplant Piccolo for starters. It was cooked perfectly, crispy on the outside. The cheese on top made the center a little soggy but it was still delicious. It was a great balance between the marinara, eggplant & cheese. I would recommend this as a starter. For main course, I ordered the Chicken Parmesan. It's worth noting that the portions here are large & worth the price. Had I known how large the portions were, I probably would not have ordered the appetizer. *Chef's kiss for the Chicken parm. It was breaded & dried perfectly without becoming dry. It was perfectly topped with sauce & string mozzarella. The spaghetti was cooked perfectly. Highly recommend this dish. I did end up ordering a slice of Tiramisu to go because I heard it was phenomenal here. I'll follow up with the Tiramisu review later. :) Thanks Dawn & Shannon* read more

See all

Chicken marsala, Sicilian chicken, fresh salads. Nice atmosphere. Carley is such a kind attentive server, I'll request her every time. read more

See all

called for reservations for 2 people @5:00pm and requested a high top table, I was assured my request was confirmed by the male person I talked to @2:33pm. My wife and I arrived at 4:55pm. The host said she could not seat us at a high top table (even though I requested one and it was confirmed) I had requested one for physical disability reasons. After this disappointment we were seated at a regular highth table. I ordered their Fettuccine Alfredo w/grilled chicken. The chicken was not "Grilled" (no seer marks) and the entire dish was too salty and not edible. I mentioned this to our server, she apologized and asked if I would like to order something else, I declined. I was not charged for my entre but tipped our server very generously for the two meals as ordered. We have patronized this restaurant many, many times in the 22 years we have lived in Mayfield Hts. and also have used their catering services. Thank You to our wonderful server. The reservation problem was not handled to my satisfaction and in my opinion their "Greeting Host" needs more training. As for the excessive salty Fettuccine Alfredo, an entre they are famous for, if the chef made a mistake in preparation so be it. However if it was done vindictively by the staff for my disapproval of the way they handled my "Confirmed Reservation" the restaurant owner or general manager should look into this matter. I could have overlooked the problem of the high top table if it wasn't for my physical disability read more

I truly enjoyed every dish; the food was incredible. This was my first visit, and I had such a wonderful experience. Thank you for making it special! read more

See all

Our server Kelly was absolutely amazing. She went above and beyond our expectations. Food was delicious. I will be returning.

Karlie has been amazing every time our family comes in for dinner. She is very attentive to our small children. The staff has always been pleasant and we always leave very full and happy. read more

I have never been to Piccolo's before this experience which I am surprised about since I love family-owned, local Italian restaurants but I guess the buzz didn't reach my ears before reading about them in the Pizza Week flyer. I really enjoyed seeing how busy they were on a regular 'ol Monday evening. The place was packed and there was a line. I am unsure if they take reservations though but it might be a good idea to make some if they do. I ordered a 10-inch Tutto Carne pizza to-go as part of the $9 Cleveland Pizza Week specials. Initially, I was surprised at how small the pizza was but the size did make it a manageable personal pizza for a solo diner. As for the taste, I was impressed by the meat quality, particularly of the meatballs. I wish there was even more. The pizza was not over or underbaked and the crust was quite tasty. I would have liked more sauce on it as well as some seasoning of some kind to make the pizza stand apart. Overall, I am quite happy with my $9 pizza. However, I do not believe it is worth it at its full price. It is normally a 12 inch pizza, so it is larger typically, but the OG price is $18.50! An extra 2 inches do not equate to twice the price. However, I'm looking forward to joining the large amount of locals who choose to dine-in and try some authentic pasta dishes! read more

Piccolo Restaurant - Tutti Carne, 10 inch - Wine Bars Near Me - Mayfield Heights, Ohio

Used to be so good here. The happy hour food is now half the size it used to be. Not fresh. Service was terrible.

Almost always eat at the bar. The staff if very friendly and efficient especially when having dinner at the bar. Have not had a bad meal there. I usually order the rigatoni bolognese and my wife the chicken piccata, both excellent and always consistent. Don't forget the Martinis, lol. Our go to place. read more

Food is great... $19 for a Manhattan is stupid! I did not realize it until I saw receipt weeks later. I've been eating there for years. Won't be drinking there anymore.. I will eat dinner though.. read more

**** **A Surprising Gem With Great Vibes (and Zero Judgement)** My partner and I stumbled into this place on a whim and left totally impressed. It's got that casual, laid-back neighborhood feel--think cozy booths, friendly staff, and a menu that nails comfort food without being boring. Now, let's just say my partner's outfit was turning *heads*--a little bold, a little risqué (in the best way). We've been places where that sort of thing gets you side-eyes or attitude. But here? Not even a hint of judgment. The staff welcomed us with nothing but warmth, and the overall vibe was chill and accepting. Honestly, it made the whole experience even better. The food? **Delicious.** We're talking crispy fries, rich sauces, and a cocktail list that does not play around. Bonus points for the playlist--whoever's in charge of the music knows what they're doing. Whether you're dressed to impress or just rolling in from errands, you'll be treated like you belong. We'll definitely be back--and next time, the outfit might be even spicier. read more

Neighborhood feel, warm welcome. Great food and attentive service. Quality ingredients and decent drinks menu. Would recommend!

Love the Happy Hour Sunday - Sunday! The food is so good all the time. 1/2 pizza & wine on Mondays is the best!! Thank You to all the staff at Puccolo's, keep up the good work!! read more

A friend and I were in the area on business. I scoped the restaurant out two days before we got there and decided that's where will dine after we were done working. We arrived around 1pm. The door was open we entered, there were no customers. A gentleman greeted us and said they were closed and there were no servers or bartenders take out only. We said how disappointed we were because of the distance we traveled and were looking forward to dining at Piccolo's. He said if we don't mind sitting at the bar he would wait on us. WELL what a great meal we had, great wine and a great dining experience. Highly recommended. Tom. read more

My partner and I (K) came back here the other night for work dinner. We both got the bolognese. It was delish. Hands down the best bolognese we've ever had. We were so full we couldn't even share a dessert like we typically do. read more

Good food, good service. I had the bolognese rigatoni and it was great. Someone else had the lasagna and it looked really good and was huge. read more

Hostess was confused about seating and the restaurant was small so we ended up squeezed into a two top table. We both got veal, which was a little chewy. The meals came with a side of spaghetti which had a nice marinara sauce. The calamari was a little spicy but the portions were just right. Our Server, Olivia, was Excellent! Would like to go back and try other dishes. read more

I went here on a busy Saturday evening, nearly every seat was taken & the wait was not long at all. All associates were very effective & efficient in what they were doing like a well oiled machine. The real star of the night was Kelsey (our server) she was quick to introduce herself, waited the perfect amount of time of time between asking for our drink, app, & entree orders. She was constantly working & moving. My interaction with her was amazing but seeing how she treated other guests just made it all that better. She was very personable, gave a genuine recommendation on what she thinks is good. Food was great, wine was great. Service was great. This was my first time at Piccolo's & going to a restaurant for the first time can be slightly intimidating. Kelsey made it 100x better. read more

Four of us ordered lunch. One of us ordered gluten free pasta. The waitress took the order and they started preparing the meal. After a while the waitress came back and told us that the gluten free pasta had not been cooked and that we would either have to wait for it or we would have to order something else. We were told that the pizza would be quick so that is what we decided to select. It was not quick and 1 person ended up eating alone since the rest of us were pretty much done eating. No offer to reduce the check. A very disappointing experience. I reached out to the restaurant and they responded and offered to fix the problem. Kudos to Piccolos for fixing the problem!! read more

Great dining experience sitting at the bar. Food and service were both top notch and we'll definitely be back again.

Really enjoy their fried zucchini and happy hour. I've been many times to this location and I'm a real big fan of the $12 fried zucchini appetizer with A cream mayo. I also like their pasta of the day Happy hour for $12 and my friend enjoyed mussels for $10 is a happy art option and she was full from all of that. Definitely enjoy this restaurant. read more

See all

Great Alfredo!! Food was great service friendly and attentive. Will stop again!!!! Decor is casual and comfortable read more

So I've written reviews for Piccolo and I have purchased family meals from here several times. I even bought gift cards during pandemic to use later.i probably won't be returning which in the scheme of things isn't a big deal. I took a friend there last week for dinner, she loves eggplant parm and I love their polpette (meatballs and ricotta). We get the same thing every time we go. When our food came after a 40 minute wait there was about 2 oz of ricotta on my plate, usually there are 2 good size 3 oz dollops of ricotta. My friends eggplant had very little marinara and hardly any Parmesan. Not like usual. We asked the waitress to remedy it she came back telling us the owner and chef said that I ordered off the happy hour menu and that's all I get same response for the eggplant. First off hers was an appetizer not happy hour secondly I get the same thing every time I go there. I would have been fine paying extra but that wasn't even an offer. Apparently happy hour patrons get less for their money. It's to bad their food is pretty good. Chef and owner not the nicest. read more

Atmosphere was great. Full bar. Great food. My bride enjoyed her meal and l enjoyed my shrimp n noodles!!

This veal piccata is delicious! I haven't had it in over a year and I will say it tastes a little different than previous but still amazing! Lightly breaded veal sauteed with artichokes and capers in a lemon white wine butter sauce served with a side of pasta and marinara OR you can have it prepared old school {pictured} so the veal is mixed into the pasta. Served with a house salad {their house dressing is perfect} and I like to add blue cheese crumbles...because duhhh they rock! read more

Piccolo Restaurant - Lightly breaded veal with artichokes and capers in a lemon white wine butter sauce prepared old school - Wine Bars Near Me - Mayfield Heights, Ohio

See all

Walked in at right at opening at 4pm and was excited to check out the restaurant after reading the reviews. We checked online and there were reservations openings at 4:15 PM just prior to our arrival. As we walked in, we were the first two people to arrive. However as we arrived, the hostess indicated that there was a large party coming in at 5:15 PM and asked if we were going to be gone by then. We informed her, that's not going to be a problem. However I did think that was strange given the number of openings that they had a listed on their website reservation app. The bread was cooked nicely, but the herb dip mixed in with olive oil lacked flavor. The side salad was fresh and I appreciated the chickpeas on top, but there was very little dressing. We ordered the calamari as an appetizer, but the calamari was not crispy and instead of placing the sauce on the side, the sauce was poured on top further taking away the crunch of the calamari. It also lacked seasoning. I ordered the chicken piccata with a side of pasta for my main course. Portion size was appropriate. However I was not a fan of the entree. The artichokes were very chewy and not properly prepared. The chicken was breaded nicely, but there was no flavor. It lacked the lemon wine sauce that truly makes the dish what it is. Although this is kind of petty, I hated that this Italian restaurant did not have fresh Parmesan cheese or cracked black pepper to accent the dishes. I did like the ambience of the restaurant. It was nicely decorated and felt intimate. Our waitress was prompt and was familiar with the menu and specials. In short, it was a cute location, but given the expensive price tag for two people, I had higher expectations and left disappointed. Also came in the hostess rush to get us out, we left close to 5:30 PM and there was still plenty of openings within the restaurant. I most likely will not return. read more

4 stars because it took a while for our food to come out. Other than that, service was great and food was amazing. I love the olive oil and seasoning mix they create for the bread. Salads were fresh and filling. Pastas were amazing!!! And a plentiful helping! Tiramisu may have been the best I've ever had. *All pictures were taken from videos so may look a little blurry read more

See all

They start you with a basket of excellent focaccia bread with plate of oil and breadcrumbs. The pasta marinara was cooked just right and the sauce excellent. Service is excellent. The dining room is clean and comfortable. Reasonable pricing on all menu items. read more

What a great find!! Piccolo's makes your feel like you're in a small town and everyone knows each other. I have gone several times and it has always been a full restaurant, granted I have only been on the weekends. I recommend making a reservation or else you may need to wait to be seated. The food is high-quality and the bread is AMAZING! AllThey always have specials so be prepared to possibly change your order after looking at the menu online. read more

My sister and her family chose Piccolo for my beautiful Nieces baptism luncheon today. It was the perfect spot!! We started with the bread and oil, which was fabulous! We followed that up with the house salad with balsamic. The dressing was just perfect! We chose from eggplant parm, cavatelli, and chicken piccata. I had a little of each and they were packed with flavor! The eggplant parm and chicken were lightly fried and it was so tasty! I absolutely loved all of the food and the atmosphere was so family friendly! The staff was absolutely fantastic! They were proactive and extremely helpful! Thanks Piccolo! read more

I did an order for 50 people from their catering menu. The catering manager, Anna was extremely friendly and helpful. There was more than enough food, and everything was delicious. The delivery was right on time. Price was reasonable, service was excellent. We are a large Italian family. The food did not disappoint.! I have eaten dinner in the restaurant. Also very good. I highly recommend Piccolos for any event you want catered, or a nice dinner out. read more

Love this place! Food is fantastic and the wait staff is wonderful! It's cozy and clean too!

Decent restaurant. Nice atmosphere. Sat at the bar and enjoyed happy hour specials of calamari and wine. Calamari... they add the sauce in the middle of the nice crispy fried calamari, making it a soggy mess where the sauce touched. Next time, I will request the sauce on the side if possible. Bar tender was quick to respond and attentive to all her customers. If I am in the area again, I would go back. read more

Best Italian I've had in Cleveland! I stumbled upon this one day and now it's my favorite secret treasure! Great atmosphere, great staff that is always accommodating, and the most delicious desserts! read more

This neighborhood Italian restaurant was recommended to me by a hotel staff. Small pace in a shopping plaza with a nice atmosphere. The menu looks good and the specials are good too. I had their wedding soup which was tasty, ceasar salad was good and I ordered the veal saltimbocca. The veal had a nice crunch, the sauce was creamy but not overpowering. The side of spaghetti with Sunday gravy was tasty, a little sweeter than I like but I am bias to my wife's sauce. Overall a pleasant surprise. Caution they cater to an older crowd so there is a lot of complaining from the patrons by nature... read more

See all

Food was very good. Service was excellent. Ambiance was very comfortable. Will go back.

Best Italian food I've ever had!! The eggplant parmesan was amazing and the wine paired perfectly!! I was in town for work and sat at the bar to eat as I was alone. The bartender was my server and she was spot on!! This place is a must have!! read more

See all