I finally made it to The Pie Bar in Phinney Ridge, and it absolutely lived up to all I had to issues for in a desert destination. Everything was made with love, with the kind of quality you can tell comes from someone who cares about what they're serving. The peanut butter jelly pie completely stole the show. It was smooth, creamy, and full of rich peanut butter flavor without being overly sweet. The rich jam and peanut butter combination was perfectly balanced, and every bite was delicious. The berry crumble pie was just as impressive. The filling tasted fresh with the perfect mix of sweet and tart berries, and the buttery crust held everything together beautifully. We had a lemon drop drink, and a apple pie mule drink. Both beverages from the bar were amazing. Everything about the pie bar was perfect. We will definitely return and when highly recommend each table to get 2 to 3 different types of pie varieties to try. read more

Pie Bar - Phinney - Bumble berry crumble pie - Desserts Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

The bumbleberry crumble pie was not too sweet and had the right amount of tartness. The vanilla ice cream balanced out the fruitiness. The crumble was a little soggy and the portion of pie was somewhat small for the price. Service was quick and friendly. We were the only ones in the restaurant on a Sunday, early evening. It's a small area with a shared door to the Cornuto Pizza deck. We thought they were connected at first but realized they are two separate businesses. read more

Pie Bar - Phinney - Bumble berry crumble - Desserts Near Me - Seattle, Washington

Depressing ambience. bland, overpriced pie! Grab a six pack and a fro pie from QFC. The vibes will be better. read more

We stopped by for pie on a Sunday night. The entrance is located in the back and through the first door. I like that their fruit pies come come ala mode, which we ask to have on the side. The Bumble Berry Crumble Pie arrived warmed and was a nice mixture of apples and blueberries. The Snickers pie was a chocolate cream pie with chocolate and caramel sauce drizzled on top and topped with peanuts. The fruit pie was delicious and demolished at the end. The Snickers pie was not chocolatey enough for my liking. Service was friendly and welcoming. Depending on when you go, parking can be a challenge in the Phinney/Greenwood neighborhood. read more

Pie Bar - Phinney - Snickers & Bumble Berry Crumble Pie - Desserts Near Me - Seattle, Washington

Pros of this restaurant are the friendly service and bright inviting atmosphere. What I did not particularly enjoy was the pie itself. Tried both a mixed berry crumble and an apple crumble. First the mixed berry crumble tasted both burnt and undercooked. The edges of the crumble tasted burnt and then the middle of the crumble lacked any sort of structure and felt doughy and raw. The filling itself lacked the elements that make a berry desert enjoyable. It lacked any sort of tartness or brightness to balance out sweet. The fresh berry taste also felt lost in the sweetness and it felt like the floral notes of fresh summer berries was gone. The apple crumble was minimally better. The crumble still felt undercooked and the apple had a good texture. I appreciated the warmth of this pie. Finally it's pretty expensive for a piece of pie. Including tip and tax I paid $14 read more

Pie Bar - Phinney - Brumbleberry pie - Desserts Near Me - Seattle, Washington

Pie bar is a corner spot right on the street. The trick though is to get into the restaurant you have to go around back. They have a walk up window facing the street but if you want to sit inside than head around back. The guy behind the bar was definitely over worked. Friendly and talkative but he was the only person on staff on a Saturday night. I had the key lime pietini, which was ok. It had a bitterness to it that was not very pleasant. We also had the apple pie with ice cream. It was an ok pie. Not a bad place for a late night drink/treat. read more

Wanted some dessert after dinner nearby and they had a spot for us here so we got a slice of pie to share. When we got there it was so so crowded but I just think it was because of one large group because after they left it was a lot roomier, it is a small spot so if there's even a couple of groups can feel cramped. Is a good spot tho! Pie and service was good! read more

Pie Bar - Phinney - Banana cream Monkey Nuts - Desserts Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

Got to Pie Bar at 5pm in the pouring rain looking to just take out, but they weren't open yet and waited till 5:10. Came back at 5:30pm only to see a sign that they weren't going to open until 6pm. I ended waiting anyways and order a slice of Chicken pot pie and Oreo. Both were ok but the chicken was lacking both flavor and sauce and really dry. read more

Pie Bar - Phinney - Desserts Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

It's too bad that to-go slices of pie are no longer available without going down a back alley. Used to enjoy going here

How I heard of this place: On a whim, a friend and I decide to check this place out - she had been to a different location. Type of cuisine: Once inside the cozy, tiny establishment, we decided that dinner AND a dessert pie could not be resisted! A selection of sweet and savory pies (cobblers) are available with a side of green salad (savory) and ice cream (sweet). Ambiance: Dark and mood-y, a bar with an easy-going vibe perfect for pairs to enjoy a treat, a meal or a drink - or all three! The bar definitely takes up the majority of the space, with only a handful of stools at the bar, a small bar-height table with four stools and one table in the street facing front window with seating for about six guests. What I ordered: We started with chicken pot pie - amazingly flavorful, full of chicken and veggies and not at all goopy, then finished our meal with the rhubarb crumble and vanilla ice cream. What I loved: Both of the pies were perfect! Buttery, flaky crust, excellent, rich fillings and generous portions. Why I loved it: Friendliest staff, serving, preparing, checking in. They were gracious hosts and made us feel welcome and taken care of. With small bites of "samples" as we awaited our meals. The food was good to boot! Cost: High ($17 per savory pie) read more

Pie Bar - Phinney - Bumble berry crumble and ice cream! - Desserts Near Me - Seattle, Washington

I only knew about the pie window, and have been missing out on the inside experience! Solid lateish night food spot (food till 1030, closes at 11, but don't be a and show up at close) This and the Ballard location are both the OG pie bar in terms of recipes and whatnot. Pies are so fkn classic and perfect. The prices seem off putting at first, but slices are large and come with a thicc side salad, pies come with ice cream. We weren't drinking, but great cocktail options and ppl in there clearly just there for the cocktails so that's promising. 21+, enter through the back in the winter while the garage door is closed. Can't believe I've lived in the neighborhood almost 4 years and never knew how pleasant the inside is. Warm vibes and personable service. Will be back for sure ‍ read more

See all

What a cute little spot. It is CROWDED!!! And it is neighboring to two other restaurants. We went to the one to the left of it first. Waited 40 min for a table to be seated and realize it was not pie bar. So we left and stood in the long line outside of pie bar. Just to realize the line we were in was just to go. To go into the sit down area, you have to walk around back. We were lucky to get 2 seats at the bar but it was hard for a few other people to get seats. There was 1 bartender and 2 at the to go pie window. It took awhile for us to order as the bartender was tending to drinks, taking orders, and checking people out, cleaning the tables, and bussing tables. Honestly, needed more people for the night we went (pi day). The food was really good though. I was not a fan of the arugula salad. But we got Chicken Pot Pie, Oreo Cream Pie, and the Apple Crumble (TO DIE FOR). I would go back all the time for that apple crumble. read more

See all

I will say that the pink sign out front is super cute. The service to-go is a slow and it shouldn't take 16 mins to box 2 pieces of a cold banana cream pie. Sad because I really wanted to enjoy the pie. But what passes as banana cream pie can only be described as cold goo that is banana adjacent with the essence of sadness and despair. So the pros: cute pie spot and open late Cons: bland pie, over-priced, over-hyped, and better off going to another spot. read more

Pie Bar - Phinney - "Banana Cream" pie - Desserts Near Me - Seattle, Washington

A very unique establishment offering drinks and pie. The pie was delicious and the service was friendly and quick. It was a cozy little spot and I can't wait to come back and have the cookies and cream pie again. read more

The atmosphere was wonderful and the pie was delicious. Our server was funny and soso kind for letting us stay so late. Would definitely visit again! read more

Walked in and discovered the only coffee served was Keurig coffee for $3, and when I commented that was pretty steep, the employee said "welcome to Seattle"... had Fox News on the TV, and we decided to leave. read more

Some friends and I decided to start our weekend out with an evening walk and a trip to Pie Bar. We arrived around 7:30pm Friday night, there were several groups inside and a larger group on the patio. We sat at one of the remaining tables outside. With outdoor seating you still have to order at the window, so be aware that you don't get the same table service as inside. The three of us each ordered a slice of pie and shared: we got the Peanut Butter Cream Pie, Berries & Chocolate Pie, and their Seasonal lemon custard pie. Each slice was served with a vegan vanilla ice cream. We weren't a big fan of the ice cream, but to be fair we were there for pie! The Peanut Butter Cream pie was the clear winner, rich and indulgent piled high with thick peanut butter infused cream and topped with whipped cream and chocolate syrup. The other two were good, but didn't stand out in the same way, especially for about $15 a slice. I will definitely be returning just for the Peanut Butter Cream Pie! read more

Really delicious pie but hecka expensive. Slice sizes aren't as generous as they should be for that price IMO. We tried three different ones and they were all delicious (banana cream was our favorite.) So this will be an every-once-in-a-while treat for us. Staff were really nice and service was good. There is a walk up window on the main drag with a dine-in entrance to the back. read more

The less than room temp iq bartenders ripped the absolute f*** out of me. i was on a first date and got 2 drinks, a white russian and a beer which apparently costed 16 for the white russian and 6 for the beer, which are "normal prices" but he rang me up for 43 dollars and added pies to my order. obviousl, he knew it was a first date so he could swindle me into not wanting to make a scene by complaining about the recipet. i went back and they were extremely rude about trying to figure out the pay read more

I got a slice of their Sweet, Sugar, Candyman Pie (monthly special from October) to go. It also came with a side of ice cream. They offered vegan options as well. The staff were very friendly and helpful. The service was pretty quick, there was only one other group ahead of me. Definitely want to come back and try other pies. read more

Pie Bar - Phinney - Side of Ice Cream which came with a slice of Pie. - Desserts Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

I've never had a savory pie as good as from Pie Bar. This was the Turkey jambalaya and it had a lot of flavor! It was nice that it came with greens too. I actually came to pie bar and took this photo on pi day, and considering the line was long and it was very busy, the service was still great. I ate outside in their outdoor dining area. Will have to come back next pi day. read more

Pie Bar - Phinney - Turkey Jambalaya Pie - Desserts Near Me - Seattle, Washington

I'm obsessed with their peanut butter pie. It gives me life. And, their owner, Natalie, is amazing!

I used to come here often and their cookies and cream pie was always my favorite! I went back for the first time in about a year on Thursday with a friend and what we were given was terrible. Stale, soggy crust and the cookies and cream part was just white whipped cream cheese. No Oreos blended in whatsoever (only barely sprinkled on top) and the portion size for the price was atrocious. Took two bites and tossed the whole piece. Friend ordered the peanut butter and jelly pie slice and said it was terrible compared to the previous times she used to go there also. Customer service was very slow and it took 15 mins to box up two slices of pie to go. Was very disappointed and we won't be going back. read more

Came here on a warm afternoon weekday, so we sat in the pleasant outdoor seating area by the sidewalk. Ordered a couple pies and cocktails. Root beer float pie: Whoa, how unique! I just had to try this. Unfortunately, it was hard to taste the root beer in this pie. It was more like a chocolate pie but uh... that is something that would please my palate anyway so I can't say this was bad at all. It came with some nicely salted caramel sauce and a scoop of vanilla ice cream (very plain, nothing special but I understand you don't want it to compete with the pie). The pies were surprisingly light and fluffy so I didn't feel overly full afterwards. Peanut butter cream pie: This was for my partner, who loves peanut butter anything. He was quite happy with this! I tasted it and it almost seemed like it had a bit of cheesecake flavor, which I enjoy. Too many peanuts on top though, for me. This also came with the same vanilla ice cream as the other pie. My partner got the Jungle Bird cocktail which was tasty and on the sweeter side. I got the Almond of my Eye, which was so nicely balanced with sweetness, and a slight bitter but delicious cardamom tang. I loved it. The server was informative and very friendly. Prices are kinda steep. That, and the lack of root beer flavor in my pie are the only reasons I'm taking off one star. I'd still like to come back, perhaps on a special occasion. read more

See all

I really enjoyed this spot. I had the chicken pot pie and the monkey nuts for dessert. My group also ordered the mushroom savory pie, apple pie, and the turkey/rice/broccoli savory pie. Everyone was content with what they ordered. The savory pies came with a generous side salad including feta cheese. This time it was for to-go only, but we enjoyed using their patio. There was only one employee on a Saturday night. She did a great job keeping up with walk ups and to-gos. It seemed quite odd that she had to work alone during a busy time, but she gets total credit for how well she did. If I lived in Seattle I would be back. read more

Snohomish pies are so much better. Less expensive. We got two pieces to go. Our pieces looked like, what was left in the pie plate. Or that they dropped the to go container several times. Very disappointing especially for $23-$25 for Two pieces. read more

Best staff EVER!! Great little place with cool ambiance and yummy pie and drinks !! Carly is wonderful and very nice to talk to as well

Everything was awesome! Love this place! Great atmosphere, great people, great menu, great pie! read more

Got three slices at the take out window. Took a crazy amount of time just to cut and box them between a couple young dudes who didn't seem to know where a lot of things were. Got home and tasted the weirdest and worst banana cream pie I've ever had. It tasted like straight whipped sweetened butter with a little banana flavor. No bananas, just this strange inedible filling and a stale crust. Other pies were a berry and an apple. Both had completely raw dough underneath the crumble topping abd on top of the fruit. I checked to make sure it wasn't cream or something else. It was raw dough. Put them in the oven to finish cooking and they tasted just ok. read more

Great spot for both sweet and savory pies! The Phinney location has nice seating and decor inside. Definitely recommend dining in as the pie is served with ice cream. Service was prompt and friendly! read more

Pie Bar - Phinney - Cookies & Cream - Desserts Near Me - Seattle, Washington

Always out of Pie. They open at 5 pm, it's 652 and they're out of 3 of the 5 or 6 pies they offer. This is now the 3rd time I've attempted to get pie and they're either out of it entirely or they're out of something. Last time they were out of the compote and plastic bags .... Now what Reddit is saying about the construction having nothing to do with why they had to shut their doors makes total sense. How do you run a pie business and are out of the pies 2 hours after opening?!?! Make it make sense. read more

We bought 3 pieces of pie, the bill was over $40.00. Pie was good but we'll never patronize again.

Y'all, we stumbled in here after a pretty stressful day and it was just glorious. The people who work here are such sweet individuals . What they didn't know is my friend from my childhood has been diagnosed with cancer and we were across the street cutting her hair off, we came in. We ordered sweet pies and ice cream and just really had a lovely time because they were so nice. I will definitely come back. read more

Pie Bar - Phinney - Apple crumble with vegan coconut ice cream - Desserts Near Me - Seattle, Washington

I ordered a couple of pies to go. I got home and the pies were a complete mess. It was terrible to see. I am disappointed and hoping they do a better job preparing the pies to go. I had to throw away one of the pies. It didn't look pleasing to eat. Not sure if I will come back. read more

I really like the pie . It is very delicious but the service is very poor and I have left half the time unable to get any. I think it is more of an organizational issue but it is still of putting to go out to an open business and half the time the staff is annoyed or discourages you from going inside. They really try to push the to go option. We have tried to use that but the service even when the line is not long is very very slow. They often run out I guess or just are too busy to serve pie. I am not sure why this happens since pie is pre-made and can be just served in a to-go box but it happens to the point where we just have given up on going here. read more

This place warrants 2 ratings, one for savory and one for sweet pies. The savory menu gets a low 3. The flavor is pretty good but because they are premade and reheated, the fillings have dried out and the crusts are not crispy or flaky. The textures have congealed together and I imagine these tasted way better fresh when the crusts were crisp and the insides juicy. The portions are also awkward. 13.50 is a fair price for a meal but I'd rather pay 15-16 dollars and get 20-25% more pie. They're at an awkward size where you definitely don't want two of them but one isn't quite a filling meal. If you were planning to just come here for dessert however, the sweet pies here are excellent and don't suffer from the same textural decomposition as the savory pot pies. I tried almost every flavor with a large party and the bumbleberry and key lime stand out. read more

I need to know if a pint of beer here is always $10 a pint or what. Pretty unacceptable in my opinion, especially when there's no tap list or price menu. Hopefully, someone just fat fingered the price of the beer in their POS system and it gets fixed. I do consider the standard $7 pint to be a pricey beer, but that just seems to be the market rate for whatever reason. In no way shape or form is a Stoup Pale Ale that isn't icy cold worth anywhere near $10. Just a heads up for all those on a date night not expecting to cough up all their pretty penny's. Food is 5 star, service is solid, people are great. Lovely ambiance. I will go back, and drink their water. read more

Bomb. Perfect combo of boozy & sweetness! Got the cold weather in GoT the peach rum toddy adding extra sweetness. And paired it with Ballard bumble berry and ice cream. Soo warm and soo yummy! Would come again and bring people. The waiter/bartender was really nice too read more

See all

Some of the worst customer service I've ever experienced from a business in the hospitality industry. We ordered two slices of a pie for which there was only one remaining. It was literally fine--we would've been happy with just the one slice. We asked for a refund for the second one, but were very rudely and unapologetically informed that the manager wasn't on site and a refund could not be issued. We asked what options were available. The lady rolled her eyes and hostilely said to choose another pie flavor. (They were out of most of them.) This woman could not care less if we live or die. No effort was made to rectify the situation. No apology. No attempt to feign an apology. Bad attitude. Bad vibes. Bad hiring decisions. Clearly indicative of incompetent management. And to-go only on a Saturday night on a holiday weekend? This place is an embarrassment. read more

Yummy pie. Great drinks. Nice atmosphere. read more

Pie Bar - Phinney - Desserts Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all