We had friends in town and were excited to try Pie Bar. We stopped at the Ballard location but it was takeout only so we drove to the Phinney location. Only had takeout there, too! And no bar service. Ugh. We tried the pie and were underwhelmed. read more

This place is really odd. We went here and it almost seemed not fully operational. They didn't have many pie flavors and when we asked about the savory pies, the lady working there told us she wasn't sure which one was beef, chicken or veggie as they're not labeled and it would be a surprise. We were wondering what someone would do if they were vegetarian or didn't eat beef? It was super strange. Also, this place charges a ridiculous amount for a slice of pie, it was $12 for one slice! AND the crust was stale as heck and chewy. Pie crust should be fresh and flakey. This place is 0 stars. read more

They closed 45 min early. We are visiting the area from Oregon and found it disappointing to go here and find they closed early.

I'm not much of a dessert person but had the opportunity to join friends here recently after dinner and drinks across the way. We had an awkward time trying to get into the restaurant as you have to go around the building and enter from the back. Not sure if you need to do the same for outdoor dining which is along Greenwood. Interior is classy and intimate with a row of tables along the south wall. I didn't order my own pie but happily stole bites of everyone else's (yeah, I'm that person). The berry crumble was so tasty, and the lemon cream was light and yummy. I didn't try the peanut butter cream pie but heard it was rich and delightful. Each came with a generous scoop of vanilla ice-cream. If I'd known about their gorgeous cocktails I would have paced myself earlier in the evening. Now I have something to come back for. read more

Always really good pie. Seems like less options then the Ballard location. We tried the banana cream and the pb &j. The crusts were both a little stale but the pies were really good. The banana cream tastes just like banana pudding. The pb&j is definitely peanut butter heavy but with some jam. Great service but I would go to Ballard for more of a selection. read more

Pie Bar - Phinney - Banana cream pie - Desserts Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

Didn't realize they closed Pie A la mode on Phinney. After finding out, I found the Pie Bar on Greenwood. Ordered the Apple pie alamode. Wasn't very good. Had some kind of weird spice that turned me off. read more

We came here for some drinks on a Friday night and they were delicious. You could not taste the alcohol which is scary. The drunken Munk was refreshing and I had two. My cousin had one with pineapple and she enjoyed it as well. The pies are awesome. We came on another night for that and we enjoyed every bite. We got the cookies and creme pie, as well as the apple. It was a great night cap and it included a scoop of ice cream. Thank you for delicious night time beverages and dessert. read more

Great pies from fruit to gourmand flavors. While I enjoy a fruity slice the portion is generous with a flaky crust like the bougie chefs that mimic your grandma's recipe claim as a must have. I love the ambiance when eating in and being able to take out a slice for car pie (pie you eat in the car.) Both places are cozy and warm in my opinion. Good for a first date or whenever date. Go with friends or by yourself. Just go, pie makes it all better. read more

Finally tried the pie bar now that they have a location in Phinney! It opened this past summer during the coronavirus and is designed to be for walk up takeout. It's a quick, easy, and convenient way to get savory and sweet pies. I tried the chicken pot pie for lunch - the crust was flaky and the fillings were well seasoned, but there were too many potatoes inside and no where near enough chicken and veggies. The savory pies also come with an arugula salad - I wish there were other leaf base options. I was also little dismayed that they just heated up the pie in a microwave rather than an oven, thus the crust lost a bit of its crisp. read more

Pie Bar - Phinney - Pumpkin pie - Desserts Near Me - Seattle, Washington

First time here and it was amazing. Chicken pot pie was delightful and the bumble berry crumble was very tasty. Services was great, very friendly and sweet, we got to meet everyone working there as well as the Pie Mascot, Lulu. Great spot to hangout especially for a nice late night spot. Will definitely return soon. read more

Amazing food and fantastic hospitality from the owners! 10/10 experience would definitely recommend :)

Horrible service on Saturday night. Even besides the lack of customer service skills, this was just a mean person who had no desire to be even the slightest bit understanding. Hate to give another 1 star review after the two previous to mine, but the management team needs a major wake up call if they think having someone like this on their staff is acceptable. We have absolutely no regrets giving this woman the lecture they deserved. On a plus side, the bar located right next door had wonderful ambiance and cleaned up the mess that Pie Bar made on our night! read more

Take out only and yet the service was so awful. Horrible service that left a horrible taste in our mouth with the pies.

Horrible customer service. Incredibly disrespectful and vile. Rang up pies before checking stock , despite KNOWING she didn't know how to refund. read more

All you have to do is be open when you say you're going to be open, rather than closing 4 hours early just "because"

We tried the peanut butter pie and the monkey nuts pie - both were delicious! The pies are light and fluffy so you don't feel quite as guilty about eating all of it! Also they come with a scoop of vanilla ice cream - I'd never had ice cream with pie except for fruit pie so this was interesting and I loved it! A bit of a splurge when it comes to the price for dessert after tax and tip, so not something we'd do often but it was delicious! read more

How to do business with this place? Today is the third time I have shown up to make a purchase and they are not open during posted hours. I give up. read more

Friendly and good service, cute place. The banana cream pie is maybe 2 stars. It's a whip cream pie w no bananas and bland but does have a good crust. Oh well. The apple pie was very good It's worth checking this place out, IMO read more

They serve amazing pies there but you can not bring in children under 18 because of the bar and then they make you wait around 20 minutes for just a slice and they say it takes around a day's wait for a whole pie if you want one. Overall 4.5/5. read more

"Wait...I can have a dee-lish-shush piece of pie, and a beautifully-well-crafted-cocktail outside on a summer night? I AM HERE FOR IT!" I've been to Pie Bar on Greenwood several times, and never been disappointed. The service is five stars, the cocktails are five stars, and the pie...I can't write enough about 'em. Even if you're not into pie (I've heard that those people exist. You do you, Baby.) It's a sweet spot (see what I did there?) to enjoy a cocktail. Stop reading, and go now. read more

This place is delicious and hit the spot. I got a tattoo next door and it was everything I ever wanted and more. Technically they forgot my salad dressing and I could've knocked them down the star for that but I had ranch at home and it still worked. I got chicken pot pie with a side salad and banana cream pie. I ate a banana cream pie so fast I forgot to take a photo of it. It's a little on the pricey side but totally worth it. For everything I got I paid about $30. I love that it's a little walk up bar and they have outdoor seating but it was raining really hard so I took it back home. read more

See all

Taste like there was too much (one tablespoon ) too much cinnamon in the apple crumble pie.

3 stars only because the apple pie was pretty good but the low rating is because we paid 119 dollars for two pies BEFORE tip. My person was in a hurry, paid and left. He gave them a 20 percent tip as well. I was certain that there was a mistake and so over the course of three days I tried to call - no response. I also emailed - no response. Idk why these pies were so expensive but o do not recommend. Sorry our bar - fail read more

It's pie. Service was super nice. The pie had kind of a hard crust, it was the mushroom one so maybe it's the lack of butter? I also tried the Cubano pie and it was overly salty. The fruity pie might be where it's at, so maybe I should try that next time. My favorite was the side of salad. It was pretty tasty! read more

This place is still on my mind from when we there years ago. Will never forget the pie bar.

Both the savory and sweet pies are delicious! Comes with a side of ice cream for the sweet pie and salad with the savory. Outdoor seating available. Can't recommend enough. read more

Pie bar (all locations) had been 1 of my favorite pie companies for many years. I have placed numerous pie orders with them throughout the years and for various occasions. This thanksgiving, however, they really dropped the ball. I pre-ordered a pumpkin pie for thanksgiving well in advance for pickup a few days prior to the actual holiday (my credit card was immediately charged $40+). I ended up getting called in to work the day that I was suppose to pick up my pie and tried numerous times to get ahold of the store to let them know. I even tried calling the other locations to see if they could get the message to the Phinney location crew, only to be told that they "weren't associated with other locations" and were unable to help. I tried repeatedly calling for 3 days with no answer. I decided to just drive to Pie Bar on thanksgiving eve (a few days after my scheduled pickup) to pick up my pie since I was never able to reach anyone at all, and assuming that the pie I ordered (and was charged for!) was still there. I live 35+ min away, so it wasn't a quick commute. Upon arrival I was told that my pie had been returned to main shop because I didn't pick it up on the day originally indicated. After explaining my exhausting attempt to contact them well in advance and reschedule the pickup date, the woman very flatly said "oh, well we don't have a phone" ...... then why on God's green earth have a phone number listed on the website?! Additionally, I HAVE called the company in the past and actually spoken with someone. Although I was fuming at this point I calmly asked her how anyone was expected to get ahold of them if need be, to which she over-excitedly said "email, of course!". Like, seriously??? A hipster company like Pie Bar expects that people will email vs call? Seems ridiculous imo. Long story short, I wasted well over an hour of my time just trying to pick up my thanksgiving pie that I paid a lot of money for, only to leave empty handed. It's quite sad, really, because I never minded paying a premium to support this company, but I will definitely not be a returning customer. read more

So... the service is fantastic no matter what day you come. Everyone is friendly and kind. The drinks are so well made and creative. The pie is delish and changes a bit seasonally. Absolutely recommend. read more

I can feel the love in these pies. I had to try more than we could eat. The vegan, the chicken pot pie and the mashed potato one. So good and finished with a berry pie and a side of ice cream. YAsss!! read more

The worst and most disturbing behavior at Pie Bar. Phinney pie bar location should be avoided. My husband and I went out for dinner and were hoping to stop for drinks and dessert this evening but that ended quickly due to a very unpleasant and unexpected experience. We live close by to this location and have loved having it in the neighborhood and in the past have had good experiences but tonight I left baffled. I went to the counter and placed an order, then waited. I waited for about 10 mins and saw multiple people come and go with their orders before I went back to the counter asking what was up. At that point a very rude young man by the name of Jorgan (I think) said he forgot about us and instead of being apologetic he was so condescending, he even rubbed his eyes like a cry baby while yelling at us if we still wanted the slices of pie. We have all had rude experiences at places but this was beyond. If you want rude teens and hair in your pie this is the place for you. read more

Great cocktails and really savory pies!! The cookies and cream dessert pie was also amazing!

My partner and I had been to this establishment a few months ago and loved everything about it. The drinks, the pie, atmosphere and our bartender who was great! So we decided to come back this past week and went at around 11:00p. We were served drinks and pie and at around 11:20 a couple walked in asking for the same. The girl working sighed with her co workers and said "she was about to do last call" which would make it 40 minutes before closing time? They seemed so irritated that service was needed?!? She got them their drinks and then came over to say it was last call for drinks. The bar closes at 12:00a so I'd expect to be served drinks until at least 11:45p if anything? It just made us feel like we needed to rush and that we were quite frankly not wanted. I love everything else!! The pb&j pie is my favorite but if it states the bar closes at 12- customers should feel welcome till then. And that is why my rating isn't a 5. read more

We tried the chicken pot pie, the banana cream pie and the cookies and cream pie. The banana cream pie was very good but everything else wasn't! The salad was wilted and yellowed, the chicken pot pie was meh but the worst was the cookies and cream pie. It was lumpy with blobs of what I think was unmixed cream cheese. I was hoping to love it but sadly we're crossing it off our list. read more

the crust was stale and a bit like cardboard. the fruit filling was a strange fragrance. the price was $11.00 for one small piece of berry pie. way overpriced. read more