Sadly not what I remember. We started with spinach artichoke dip, it was ok, but lacked the main ingredient; spinach and artichoke. It was just a cheese dip. I ordered the chicken Milanese salad and it was absolutely disgusting. The picture speaks for itself. It was described as "House made crispy breaded chicken with rosemary". If that's homemade I don't want to know how. It was cut like a fan and appeared to be premade, rubbery and burnt breadcrumbs. Whenever I took a bite I couldn't take the DRIED rosemary taste. Who uses dried rosemary on anything?? I suggest to have the chef taste this, I refuse to believe anyone would intentionally have this on their menu. I'm a positive note that drinks were excellent, pricey but good. read more

See all

Very good bar with great service. Drinks are top notch. Food is excellent. High energy atmosphere.

I ended up getting takeout at my recent visit here.. and I got to say when you're here they treat you like your family and half the times I've been putting my phone down and and enjoying the experience. But everything that I have tried out of this restaurant is just 110% amazing.. . Even had car shows next door but then came over to pies and pub to get chicken wings ;) read more

Excellent menu, while there are some imaginative pizzas, other items are often original and interesting. Prepared as well as possible. Service was excellent read more

Stopped in midday w a friend. Place is clean and feels like classic pizza joint . Staff was friendly and informative We got a salad and pasta fagiole. Both were abundant and fresh. I very much appreciated the pasta being added into the fagiole fresh, instead of the pasta sitting in it getting overcooked a f mushy . This pasta was perfectly Aldenti ! read more

This is a regular local stop for me. First draw for me has always been the fine craft beer selection but the food is good to excellent depending on what you have from their fairly wide ranging menu. My favorites are the chef salad choices, pizza and pasta fagioli. But there are many other ways to go. It's a casual tavern atmosphere with tv viewing available throughout out. They also have a good sized deck for the warmer weather. Draft & cans/bottled beer selection is possibly the best in the greater Waterbury (along with The Corner Tavern in Naugatuck). Plenty of parking, very appropriate for family dining, open all week long for lunch & dinner. Clean facilities and a fun atmosphere always. Service is typically prompt and pleasant. read more

See all

Stopped as I was passing through to grab some food to go. Ordered Two meatball grinders and a Cobb salad, one with raw onions, one with green peppers. Had a drink while I waited for the food to be prepared. There were a few tables with people eating and the bar was almost empty. 37 minutes later my grinders and salad came out. I live 8 minutes away. My wife had everything ready for us to eat. The Cold, dry grinders and one with no peppers were disappointing. Salad looked fancy so I'm assuming grinders were out in 10 minutes and it took someone 20 minutes to cut an avocado and chop up the rest of the veggies. Very lackluster and disappointing. Bartender was nice and my drink was good while I waited. Think it's a hard pass for to-go orders. Maybe we will stick to eating in. My wife opted to just eat the meatballs as seen in the pics. read more

See all

Sat outside with some friends. We ordered our food before the rest of our party came. We got it after our later people ordered. And it was appetizers! Ordered the pot-chos and was unimpressed with them. Needed salt and pepper on the potatoes. Goat cheese flat bread was tasty and the goat cheese pizza needs some color on it mayve some arugula? My friend had the fish and chips dinner and didn't get her side salad. The waitress asked her if she wanted it to go, and my friend said no. No option to just get it. Strange. read more

I have eaten at pies and pub three times in the the last three months. I have no complaints and we leave after every visit full and happy. Their specials are seasonal and unique, and there are plenty of old standbys to choose from as well. Our favorites are the "pot-chos", spinach and artichoke dip, pepperoni pizza and the cobb salad (it is huge). We are regulars. read more

See all

We go to pies often really like sitting at the bar great vibes and of course we love to see Brynne she is so sweet and makes the best drinks

We ordered the prosciutto de parma pie and added some spicy honey from home so it wasn't as dry, regardless it was delicious! The service was quick and easy and always a fun atmosphere for afternoon/late night locals. read more

This restaurant has a good atmosphere, I think the food and service is top-tier. Great employees !!!!!

P&P has been our "local" since they first opened. We recommend it to all our friends and family. The food and beer menus are quality and are regularly updated. We go there for the staff as much as the food and drink. Just yesterday, Brynn took great care of us and we liked her playlist, too. read more

The food is great especially the chicken avocado wrap, that is my personal favorite. The service is amazing, and the vibe of the resturant overall is great. Very comfortable and fun environment and whenever I am there I always have a great time! read more

I absolutely love pies and pubs, formerly pies and pints in middlebury. The pizza if delicious, the salads are huge and the chicken portions are great. I don't think I've had a bad meal from them yet, highly recommend read more

The food here is consistently good; it is our go-to place from Southbury. It's a pub but clean and friendly. The staff is courteous, friendly, knowledgeable, and attentive. read more

Stopped here because it was on way to Mohegan Sun. Great place! Good beer selection we had delicious IPAs. Hot pretzel was great. Then had Cob Salad also good. Our server Georgia was fantastic. Very sweet, always w a smile and very good at her job. Will return to try the deserts next time they looked legit. read more

Holy crazy parking lot. It's straight down a giant hill and there's not much room. Thankfully, I came when it wasn't busy. I had a gift card. $25 is $25. My expectations based upon Yelp reading was super low. It wasn't really as bad as I expected. We made it in time for happy hour. So we indulged in the $5 nachos. Hard to argue the price. A lot of olives, jalapeños onions and tomatoes in there. The cheese underneath wasn't fully melted. I would say it was acceptable. I read some horror stories about the sauce. So I veered towards a white pizza. Manage your expectations. So I got a buffalo chicken pizza. It was actually quite good. No complaints there. I had two German styled microbrews. One was made in Waterbury and one was from Poughkeepsie. Not bad beers per se. Drinkable but not particularly representative of the styles and certainly not on par with an import from Germany. Waitress was nice and helpful. One qualm about the service though. I checked in one Yelp and it said $1 off lunch. So it was like 5:30 and the $1 was good for 3 hours. So I showed the waitress and said I have a discount for $1 for checking in. She was like well it's really not lunch anymore. The discount expired in three hours and it's really not going to be lunch for about another 20 hours was what I was thinking. It's a buck. Nothing not worth tipping 20% over. Also worth mentioning on here though. read more

Pies & Pub - Chicken Buffalo Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Middlebury, Connecticut

We will never buy again! Mozzarella sticks so hugely overdone they went directly in garbage We asked for extra thin, thin crust with a well done crust.....nope.... Medium thick and doughy. Sorry but this establishment doesn't listen to what the customer wants and sends inferior food. read more

We decided to go for brunch, it was lovely. Amazing Bloody Mary and nice food options. I had the cannoli French toast with homemade cream. It was to die for and the portion was huge! My husband had the Monti Cristo which was also exceptional, he added eggs and they were heavenly. I can't wait to go back next week to try something else. read more

Pies & Pub - a dessert with strawberries and ice cream - Pizza Near Me - Middlebury, Connecticut

I really come here for the pretzel expect that they changed the cheese sauce and is not great. I normally take out from this place; wings and pizza. I ate there and the staff was very nice but the place needs a little freshen up. read more

This place used to be pretty good but the pizza we had was terrible yesterday. We hadn't been in a while because the last time we were there it wasn't great but we figured we would give them another shot. The cheese was way too heavy and filled with oil. The service was also really bad. The place was almost empty and our waitress didn't even check on us or refill our drinks. The other issue was our appetizer came out and a few minutes later our pizza came out. Then when we were done we waited 15 minutes for our leftovers to be cleared and our check to arrive. We won't give these guys another shot. read more

Wow I should have read the reviews. Painful service and the boss didn't seem to care. Every beer order was wrong except fo the Guinness, go figure right... In the end my wife was sick after dinner. To bad I had heard so many good things but something has changed. I hope read more

We've eaten here many times in the past few years and enjoyed our meals. The quality at Pies and Pub has changed for the worse in the past year. We're not customers that complain often but the last three times we've eaten here the food was awful. Tonight my wife had shrimp tacos which she has enjoyed here before. The waitress said there was a special price tonight. Is that good news? No, that's bad news.. where's the shrimp? Just a few small pieces here and there. I always have enjoyed their pizza but there's no quality control in the kitchen. The server brought my pizza to our table and said - oh, that's really burned so I'll get you another. Twenty minutes later the next pizza was way under cooked and looked like tomato soup poured over bread. Big problem at Pies and Pub. read more

This place use to be good years ago but continues to go down hill. First place they can't take a order right. Don't know if they changed cooks but definitely not as good as it used to be. Gave up on trying to get a good pizza here won't return. read more

I really wish the pizza was good or at least improve. Crust/sauce (not enough...barely)/cheese are tasteless. Menu needs a serious do over. read more

Generally the pizza is excellent. The last one we got was burnt on the bottom on one size-line the oven was unevenly heated

My family choose this spot to try on a Tuesday. Came in for 8:30. Good beer selection. However, food not good. Mack a Cheese came out cold. Ive ordered pizza that was hotter when I picked it and brought it home. It was taco Tuesday and there was only 1 other couple in the restaurant. I asked if they could possible give me 2 chicken and 1 shrimp taco just to try. It was an automatic "nope"answer. They have to all be the same flavor. I asked the waitress if she could ask the cook to make an exception Since it was extremely slow and my first time trying their food. We were only 1 of 2 patrons In the whole establishment. The smallest courtesy of granting a reasonable request would have went a long way. " If we do it for 1, we gotta do it for all". Ok. I can see if it was busy. The chicken tacos were not warm and they were dry. At the end the waitress asked why I didn't ask for the food to be warmer. And honestly, I shouldn't ask for hot food at a restaurant. I knew I wasn't going to return so I was just ready to pay and leave. We obviously won't be returning. Back to 66 church for taco Tuesday! read more

I love this place! It is my go-to place to eat out for dinner, a little outdated but the owners are very nice and it is great seeing them work so hard every time I go out to eat there. There is many teenagers working that can be a little rude but overall, 4 stars. read more

This review is based on an experience I had at the ice cream window 6/14. Having visited this business' page now, I'm not at all surprised to hear about the awful service here. I would love for this place to disappear so that someone who can contribute something of value to society could take its place. I went for a run. I seem to go on these annually without any hitches (yes, you read that right, annually), but this one was just a series of unfortunate events that culminated in the misfortune of stopping here. I have never needed to stop at some random place and ask for water, but somehow I ended up feeling like a salted eggplant on a 90 degree day. Slowing to a crawl paced walk, I noticed that the ice cream window here had just opened. There wasn't a single person in sight. I ambled over, legs shaking, about to give way to the dehydrated being they were supporting, I asked if it was possible to get a glass of water. 'No, we don't have any carry out glasses.' Assuming that they may have had legitimate glassware, I asked if it was possible to drink some water and return the glass.' 'No, all of our plastic glasses have our logos on them and cost $1.00 so...' Incredulous with the fact that this is the first time in my life someone has denied me a cup of water, and understanding that this wasn't going to go anywhere. I walked the last half mile to my car and promptly stopped at the first place I saw to get some precious gold; ice cold water. Yes, I bought this one. Sorry I don't routinely run 6 miles with my wallet shoved into my sports bra or something. I would never have wrote them a review for their food, but while I'm here I might as well tell you it's garbage. My family ordered once to support a local-ish business since we always order from Middlebury pizza. Somehow, they managed to create a barely edible looking round thing that was as greasy and abhorrent as their service. What is this supposed to be, New York, Detroit, New Haven style? It's like a two year old that loves oil cheese used these ingredients unsupervised on a piece of cardboard and stuck it in the oven. If you live in the area and want convenient delivery, shoutout to Middlebury Pizza! Obviously, it's where I should have stopped and succumbed to my thirst to begin with. Don't waste your time on this feckless rubbish. I can't think of a single redeeming quality that could salvage this place. Don't believe me? Look at all of their recent reviews. read more

I'm not quite sure why this place has seen so many haters! I thought it was fantastic!! I had the calamari appy, and I have to say, I'm a calamari enthusiast! This was one of the best I've ever had! Very unique, with Gorgonzola and jalapeños added. SOOO yummy! Had the P.O.B. Pizza (Potato, Onion, Bacon) and it was stellar! Caramelized onions, potato slices thin and crumbly bacon...yum! Had the P&P Bulldozer IPA, and I was very happy with the brew!! I think people come here thinking it's something it's not. I didn't have that problem, obviously! No preconceived notions due to past owners or whatnot! Give this place an honest try and my guess is it'll win you over! read more

Pies & Pub - My KILLER calamari !! - Pizza Near Me - Middlebury, Connecticut

Ok... I've been back twice recently. The second time was good and the place was crowded. Today at lunch the Mac & Cheese was bland and they put bacon on the chicken avocado sandwich. Why does every place have to put bacon on everything without asking. Make it an option. read more

Great time! Stopped in to grab some delicious take away and was greeted by Jess at the bar. She gave me an excellent recommendation with the Cider Boys Peach pint. Stop in to see her and enjoy the perfect local bar experience. Great food, cold drinks, and stellar atmosphere. read more

Pies & Pub - Pizza Near Me - Middlebury, Connecticut

I'm usually not a person who is sensitive to texture. But I ordered a chicken wrap with avocado in it and it was about three different textures involved with it. Crunchy, soggy, mushy, with no taste to it at all. The avocado had no flavor at all. I would not recommend the wrap to anyone. Maybe the pizza is better, or maybe it would taste better if it was eaten in the restaurant and not by take out. This was not a great meal for a date night with ones spouse. read more

I just moved into town, and the two times I have ordered a pizza from here, both times they completely screwed up the pizza. The first time they did not offer me any kind of discount or anything, and asked if I wouldn mind sitting there for 20 minutes for them to correct the pizza. The second time they messed up the pizza, I did not have time to wait, instead they charge me $15 instead of $20. Basically they gave me 25% off a pizza that I didn't want or didn't order, but I had no choice since pizza was our dinner for the night. Beyond frustrating. I will never go to this location again. Extremely disappointed since I just moved to town. read more

No, no, no. Staff seemed to not care at all when we spoke to them. The food was thrown together with no care. When you order nachos, all the cheese should be melted, burned outside, cold inside with unmelted shaved cheese. Main dish was just the same. Not worth $60 for three people with an appetizer and no alcohol. read more

Pies & Pub - Pizza Near Me - Middlebury, Connecticut

I have had takeout more than once and have been disappointed both times. I give two stars because the steak and cheese rolls were good.

We go here a few times a month and never get sick of it. We've probably tried everything on the menu and it's always amazing. Staff always makes us feel like family, can't recommend enough! read more

Pies & Pints of Middletbury makes a reasonable pizza and has a decent tap list. if you are passing by it is worth stopping in to see what is on tap and enjoy a few pints. the pizza - i don't know where i would say it falls on the pizza map - it's not new haven or new york, not really italian or greek - maybe something like a thin crust greek pie? i don't know if that's a thing. overall it was OK and i really have no complaints but I wouldn't call this place a pizza destination, but it is a beer destination - so if you are looking for brew, head to Pies & Pints. (also it is conveniently located along side a nice hiking trail that we hike on when it is warmer) Also worth noting, the large pie is very large. read more

Pies & Pub - Pizza Near Me - Middlebury, Connecticut

See all

I'm a little torn about this place. For the "pies" side, I would have to give them about a 2 start review. The pizza that we had (just a normal pepperoni pizza) tasted almost like a frozen pizza. In fact, the Newman's Own pizzas that I have had were a little better than the pizza here. The wings had pretty good flavor, but they were small and too well done for my taste. Now for the "Pints" side: they actually have a very good variety of beers; I think I counted between 20 and 30 different kinds/brands of beers, so that would be around a 4+ review. SO take the 2 for the food and the 4 for the beer and you get a 3 star review. read more