I would like to write a a review, but being I never got a return phone…read more call to place an order, I can't. Must be understaffed that there is no one to properly handle phone calls to place take out orders. Or if by some reason they were closed this particular Sunday, there should have been a new recording stating they were closed instead of a customer waiting patiently for one. A sure way to lose customers! I bet Pagley's would love the competition.

Food is delicious. Crowded but can be expected when only open on Sunday. Reservations a must!read more

Best Italian restaurant in New Castle! Food here is the best! Servants and management take care of…read morethere customers!

I thought the food was very good I had the fish it was excellent and the service was great also I…read morewill continue to eat there and I am from Pittsburgh very good food

Good Bar food, great beer and great bartender atmosphere…read more French fry's with gravy, a must.

They have really good food here! I've been here more than once. I like getting the Pittsburger, but…read moreheads up because they load the fries on it so if you get the side of fries also, you'll have a lot. Typically we will grab a small cup of cheese also for the fries. But they have a lot of good options. Service has always been pretty good. It's nice inside but can get busy and you might not find a seat at the bar. Since they have come to New Castle this has been a nice place although it can be a bit pricey at times. The food portions do accommodate for the prices though.

Joseph's Marketplace, an Italian market. just off of Mercer rd., right where it changes from…read moreHighland rd to Mercer rd. Joseph's is convenient for me, it's just into Neshannock TWP and easy access off Mercer rd. into the plaza. Coming from Mahoning County, it's a nice surprise in this area. They have a nice sized Market. Like supermarket sized in 1968, I'd imagine () and the aisles have food racks that you can see over. It's connected to a coffee shop, baked goods (mainly pies and cakes and Italian cookie variety's. Like clothes pins, Buckeyes, it rotates and is fresh daily and unless you live next to Jimmies in Liberty you will do just fine here with the desserts you will find here. I've had a little of everything here over a year and it's all typically excellent. This side also has some breakfast muffin type things, a nice area with nice round tables and chairs, and a front window that lets in light. You got a parking lot to look at, but it's actually nice to look out here. They serve hot food daily, the menu is updated by 11am daily on Facebook. But, it's popular, so if they have pot roast or something, it goes fast. Saturdays when warm they do racks of ribs for carry out. You have to be checking Facebook on fridays for this it's preorder. Nice feature is the Coffee shop side is walled off from the grocery, open just at the very front to go to grocery. The grocery side looks like a small market. And walking through the place the outside wall from the left is. Veg, meat, deli, and down far wall, dairy and freezer. Also inside is bread (can find Mancini and Breadworks here. Whole loaves, sliced, rolls and buns. So, THIS is where you go for genuine rolls for cookouts) Everything else is standard Italian market. When in season they'll have greens and vegetables, but it's more about the Olives and canned goods here. And nice selection of Italian baked biscuits and cookies here. The freezer is great. Lots of homemade pastas and filled pastas. And Wholey's brand seafood. Calamari, breaded, and frozen whole. The service is always friendly. There will be just one register going, but I've never had to stand in a line. It's usually people picking up genuine products for sauce or a recipe. No people with the cart filled up, so it's fast and easy to get in and out. I go here like I'd go to a Dollar General. Milk, bread, and then I look around for anything else I might need. And always wander over to the Coffee Shop first to see if you want a desert or cookies. Nice spot to impulse buy a couple cannoli. Overall this is a great spot to shop, let alone an area standard. One of those places that have been here in New Castle for a hundred years, and is still run as a local friendly place that draws in anyone looking for Nona's Italian market for Holidays, Sundays, or just day to day grocery shopping. And, Mancini and Breadworks are both available here fresh.

Jospeh's is my go to everyday store for meats, bakery items or quick dinners. I'm in there non stop…read moreeven 2x a day sometimes. I placed a bakery cake order for my child's birthday, was super specific on the theme and what I wanted of course. I called to add something on to the order and gave details and to confirm they could do it, they said yes. I get my order and it's not even in the same zip code as what I ordered, I called that night to confirm my additional order was correct because I was disappointed with what I got and felt screwed, I was so disappointed I ran to GE to get new cupcakes. When I called and spoke to the owner he was very dismissive and didn't show any empathy towards the mess up, instead I was met with "it's a busy time of year and my ladies in the bakery are making thousands of items and i'm surprised they are still standing" while I have compassion towards that and can understand I still paid for a service $60 to be exact to get something I didn't ask for, If you're that swamped I suppose you shouldn't of taken my order to begin with. I will no longer come back since my order wasn't an importance to your business.

Service at the bar was good. Laura was quick and professional. We had a sausage and pepperoni pizza…read morewhich came out quick and was good. Relaxing and not overly crowded tonight.

I really liked this place. IDK why it's call four Irl but II tomato on here, but I don't care. The…read moremood was amazing, everything looked great, I loved the pizza. In summary I loved this place.

Edwards is the place to go on the north side to meet up with family & friends. Interior is some…read morewhat average but service & food are great. Always make it here when I'm back in town to get my lamb on the rod fix, delivered perfect mid-rare with hand cut fries & pepper sauce. Met up with 2 cousins one had a salad & the other pasta - both said were good.

Stopped here for lunch with a group of coworkers while working nearby. This is a nice casual spot…read morefor classic American fare done well. I opted for the half pound burger with their fresh cut fries. The food was cooked perfectly and brought out fresh. Everything tasted great. We sat in a booth that had a TV playing sports which I appreciated. The restaurant has tons of TV's all over the place, so definitely a good place to eat if you don't want to miss a big game. Our server was friendly and attentive, food was brought out quickly even though they were surprisingly busy for a weekday lunch. Everyone in our group loved their food and we may be back again if we're in the area.

Food and service was very good I will continue to order from there I just moved here from…read morePittsburgh one of the best sandwiches

We decided to try something different. So we ordered Philly Cheesesteak. We also got loaded fries…read morewith garlic Parmesan. We we very pleased with the quality and quantity of the food we got. Once again Pizza Man's was well worth the stop!!

New Castle Italian in a casual atmosphere with Rock Star service. There were about 20 of us…read morearriving at 4:30p for dinner (many old people were amongst us, lol). The staff was amazing with taking orders, refilling drinks, clearing plates and drinking the food. Great job team! Thanks for hosting the family minus one! The bread was one of the best dang breads I've seen in a restaurant. It was crusty and soft and HOT AF at first which was awesome. No problem with the butter on that stuff. The Wedding Soup wasn't my favorite as there were no Pepe's in it. I don't know about you, but I prefer my Wedding Soup with Pepe Noods instead of just meatballs and greens. The broth was good, but put dat Pepe in there! The Deluxe Antipasta Salad was ok. The lettuce was a rough chop of iceberg and the meats just seemed like they were hormel out of a bag. Some of the other dinners I saw others order looked pretty good. I was just trying to have a light snack and my "snack" items were pretty filling.

Recently had an Birthday Party here with 18 family members, service was great, decor is nice. Food…read moreis average for Italian, had the chicken parmigiana smallish pattie, a bit dry n massive amount of pasta, ratio definitely off.

Excellent pizza! We ordered an extra large with pepperoni and a large poor man's pizza (plain…read morewhite). Amazing crust & sauce. Absolutely delicious! Kind, attentive service. Good price! Well worth a visit for pick-up or call for delivery!

The pizza is AMAZING! We drive 25 minutes to get it. The crust to sauce ratio is delicious! Call…read moreahead and ask what the special is! You won't be disappointed!!!

Always fantastic and helpful service. Great selection of very fresh and quality cuts of meats with…read morevery fair prices, and also unbeatable sales! This is definitely my go-to place for the best! Convenient location, with extremely easy parking. It's great for a quick stop, especially if you've already called in an order.

We stopped by the Meat Guyz while visiting New Castle. We bought a prime rib for NYE, stuffed hot…read morepeppers and hot dog chili. Everything was terrific! The staff was very helpful and friendly. Will visit again when I'm in town.