Well I waited a bit and 3rd time a charm. The pizza was perfect . Forget the others and order here . Need to get BarStool here to take the 1 bite challenge . Think Mr. Portnoy would love it ( Dave ) time to give it a try . read more

Husband ordered a pizza tonight after a long time and this was his pizza very disappointed they used to be so good very very bad unless you're super hungry this is OK probably will not be ordering from there used to be again unfortunately cause this be awesome read more

Pinemoor Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Crystal Lake, Illinois

Great pizza. We come home from Florida and that the first stop. We have been going for over 20 years. Not a better place.

Best pizza spot around. No frills, just quality traditional pizza. We have this atleast once a month. read more

Pinemoor Pizza - Extra well done large garbage pie - the only way to order Pinemoor - Pizza Near Me - Crystal Lake, Illinois

FANTASTIC pizza!!! When I lived in the area I tipped well and after a few orders the pizza would come so fast it needed to cool a little before it could be eaten. The cheese was so hot I'd swear they cooked it in my driveway. Prior to this it was fresh and hot but, after some nice typing, they really upped the game. Ever so highly recommended. read more

I am a resident at Crystal pines rehabilitation Crystal lake Illinois. I'm just writing to thank you for opening early so we could enjoy your wonderful pizza at our Halloween party. God bless! read more

Best Chicago tavern thin crust style pizza in the area by far! Growing up on Father N Son on Milwaukee Ave this is on par. Always hits the spot! read more

Pizza was good price is good, the only problem is pizza is only on the menu and the biggest pizza is a 14" so if you want more then pizza this is not your place but if your looking to grab pizza not a bad pizza at all read more

Crust was Under cooked. Worst pizza in 2023. Not sure how this gets the good reviews.

Ordered tonight & got the most GOOEY slop you could call cheese *gag* there was no pulling one "piece" apart cause the "cheese" wouldn't part or the crust was STUCK TO THE BOX ‍ MY friends have gone here before & the pizza was amazing.....guess tonight wasn't their night. I have been VERY sick for days & we made due with what we were given. As I had no plans to make dinner feeling only a third human....but I'll be ordering elsewhere from now on. read more

There was a mishap with our pizza and they took care of us. I can tell this is a business that has great character. Delivery was super fast because we had a tight window. And the pizza was fantastic ! read more

I was recommended to try them seeing that they are 2 minutes from my house. When I got the pizza all the cheese had slid to one side. I was a little upset but hungry, we got a 14in sausage, spinach. It ended up tasting really good with a lot of cheese although the toppings could of been a little more. I will definitely be trying them again and asking for my crust more well done as well. That would definitely be a 5 star. Also the price is right compared to most pizza places. read more

we have been long tone customers of 25 years however after tonite no more 1 hour 15 minute delivery time when we were told its on its way is not good customer service . I called after an hour and told the women that answered I was displeased and no longer wanted it after 1 hour 15 minutes her response was just tell the driver and hung up WTF read more

Husband loves pizza he could eat it every day. Me not so much . That was until we moved to Crystal Lake and discovered Pinemoor. While I still won't eat pizza every day I will order from here a couple of times a month. read more

no real flavor, needs more sauce and tastier ingredents. some cheap. frozen pizzas are better

Actually one of the best pizza places in ChicagoLand. Plenty of parking. We visit them everytime we are in town. They can do a thin crust well, not burnt, sauce is delish, no heartburn. Plenty of cheese, but good quality so it is still good for breakfast the next day (the true test of a good pizza). Reasonable prices too! read more

Only a small step above chuck e cheese.. cheese is not ooey gooey. It is that harder snappy kind. Ingredients probably canned.

We have been waiting to try pinemore since march. But they are always so busy, a few times we called and couldn't get through. We were worried that they might have shut down from Covid. However, my husband birthday was last weekend and he was DETERMINED to get pizza from here! IT WAD WORTH THE WAIT, YALL! Crisply crust, fresh ingredients, inexpensive, and the pizza was delivered so hot that the boxes were steaming! We will never order from another place again! read more

Pizza was not great. Taste worse than dominoes. Will not go again. Don't waste your money.

Hole in the wall place that I didn't even know existed.. Good pizza. Crispy crust, gooey cheese, generous toppings. Reasonable price. Able to pick up in 30 minutes. FYI for those concerned about Covid, none of the staff were wearing masks. read more

Best crust in suburbs, fave pizza is canadian bacon, pinepple, pepperoncini - don't knock it until you try it!!! Sauce is great, people great, ordering simple and quality consistent! What more do you need. Order one now read more

Meh... pizza was okay. Nothing else on menu. Not much to write about. Won't be reordering.

Finally tried Pinemoor this evening. We ordered two 12". One mushroom and onion and the other mushroom and black olive. I wanted to love their pizza after reading good reviews. Taste is subjective but slimy canned mushrooms, chewy cheese and sauce that was ice cold at the edges is why I could only give two stars. We called in the pizza and left to pick it up 5 min after we called so the pizza should have been hot. Also, the menu posted online on Google search had priced out 2 pizzas with our toppings at $28 and they charged us $30. read more

I just finished WOLFING a HALF of a LARGE pizza from here. And I want more. The reviews are right--there's something addictive about it. My husband, who went in to pick up the pizza, thinks he *may* have seen a pinch of sugar (???) sprinkled on top of the pizza before it was baked. I don't know if it caramelizes the cheese and toppings or what, but it works! I was a first timer to the pepperoncini rings as a pizza topping and I totally dug it. The place has been around since 1952. I'd say they're onto something. For us, it became an instant classic. Helpful hint--They have "Facebook Specials" (specials posted on facebook). Check them out and save a couple bucks. Our large, well-dressed pizza was $14 total. read more

This is being dictated by my husband, a Crystal Lake native: "Every visit to Crystal Lake starts with ordering Pinemoor on our way from the airport. About 20 minutes from town we place our call, typically ordering 3 or 4 large garbage pizzas. When we give our name, the invariable reply is "Will that be pie-cut?" This is because one time, and one time only, they mistakenly made the pie square cut, to the abject horror of my 6' 3" 250 lb. brother in law. The pie was given to him free as a new one baked. He struggled disgustedly with the abysmally cut square parts and ate while he waited. So, it was all good. The friendly people at Pinemoor always make sure of that. My husband, sons, brother-in-laws and nephews each gobble down at least half a large pie each, often more. Once, my nephew ate a pie and a half. They rave and rave and can't get enough, for over FORTY FIVE years now. THAT'S how good it is. Note: Do not ask if they have salad unless you want to be mocked like the rube you are. read more

Out of the pizza places I have tried in Crystal Lake, Pinemoor has the best pizza. The crust is thin and crispy, the sausage pieces are large and are like little flavor explosions. I had to deduct a star because they used canned mushrooms. How disappointing. I wish people realized how quickly the flavors of the other ingredients can be degraded because they were paired with the salty-brine flavor of canned mushrooms. Always use fresh ingredients, people! Mushrooms last a week in the fridge! No excuses! Oh....side note #1: The value was pretty good. We were surprised at how inexpensive our delivered pizza was. side note #2: FYI, this is a delivery and carry-out only pizza place. read more

Get the sausage! I'm normally a pepperoni guy, but the sausage here is awesome. Great local business, been around forever and for good reason. So much better than any of the commercial pizza places around town. read more

My whole family has been obsessed with Pinemoor since I was a little girl. My family lives in Crystal Lake and we live in Indiana, so every visit while we grew up and STILL to this day, when we get in town it isn't "what's for dinner?" .......it's "what time are the pizzas ready?" I love every kind of pizza they have too. It's different than normal pizza. It's a thinner crust (but don't be turned off by that statement if you aren't a thin crust type of person....it's delicious.) And their focus isn't a thick layer of sauce and then some cheese. It's a nice thin layer of a light but delicious sauce, and covered by a thick layer of cheese from heaven. Some toppings like pepperoni I think come under the cheese which I used to hate as a kid because I would just want plain cheese and I couldn't tell which one it was. But as an adult I love it because the stupid toppings don't fall off. Their crust is crispy and the pizza dough is chewy but soft. Also the staff is awesome. When been regulars a long time and when my grandpa died 8 years ago they delivered us pizzas and didn't want any money. I thought that was so sweet and I will never forget about that. read more

I've been a loyal Pinemoor Pizza customer for as long as I can remember. Great thin crust, with slightly sweet sauce and plenty of toppings. They always remember me when I call for delivery, even if it's been a while since my last order. Even though I live within throwing distance of two other pizzerias, I always choose Pinemoor instead. read more

I changed my rating down to 1 star due to poor customer service. Those women need to be replaced! This place lost me as a customer.... that's what happens when you have a bad attitude! All the time! Go to the Pizza Place instead. They are always happy and friendly. read more

My daughter came by for dinner the other day bearing a Pinemoor pizza. We have lived in Crystal Lake for over 30 years and used to get their pizza often but for some reason got out of the habit of ordering from them... we will definitely get back in the habit of calling Pinemoor when we want a thin crust pie, they make the best thin crust I have had in years. The crust, sauce, cheese and toppings are almost perfect, and it really hit the spot. If you love thin crust, definitely try Pinemoor... you wont be disappointed! read more

I must say, I am very disappointed with this establishment. Compared to other pie joints in the area this place is last in competition. We ordered a thin crust with pepperoni and mushrooms for delivery. The delivery person was about 20 minutes late than the given time. The crust on the edges was burns and the middle gooey. Toppings: The pepperoni tasted like it was purchased from a low end deli or bad market. There was no flavor in the taste. The mushrooms tasted very similar to a canned product. The cheese was unfavorable without a hint of taste. Now, I am not a pizza snob but for 17 dollars the expectations should be higher considering the area. read more

Very happy we found the place right away after we moved to Crystal Lake, this place is an institution in the area and a cool place to pick up pizza. very old school to see the family making pizzas in a very small space out in the open. Now that we moved away we miss it. After leaving Chicago this was the best pizza outside of Maries Pizza in Chicago. read more

Really great thin crust pizza made in an old school oven. This is the perfect no frills kind of place to get really good pizza. They have a pretty wide delivery range, but it's a fairly easy place to get to for pickup as well. They are in a shopping center right off of Highway 14. Be prepared when you order though, because there are just two sizes offered, large and small. It's a two inch difference, I believe, and just a two dollar difference between the two sizes. So just get the large. read more

Our daughter's school volleyball team was mid-way through it's third game at Crystal Lake Central HS, which meant it'd be a late night dinner at home. A quick check of Yelp and quick call to Pinemoor pizza and just 20 minutes later the game was over and we picked up our Garbage Pizza and Cheese Pizza at Pinemoor. First timer at Pinemoor, and certainly not the last. Worthy of it's 5 star rating. read more

Nice crispy crust, fresh tasting & reasonably priced. Will definitely return!

This is authentic Italian pizza! We had the thin crust with cheese and sausage. It was so perfect and yummy. Brought me back to my childhood when my uncle bought my first pizza for me. Delicious!! read more

If you want old school Chicagoland thin crust but you live in the burbs... this is your place. You will not find yuppy/hipster/beardster "artisan" crap here...just real pizza. My girlfriend and I are new to the area so we decided to try a couple of places in an attempt to find our goto pizza place. She ordered a pizza from Georgio's and i ordered one from here. Her pizza looked cute...in the dog bowl where she threw it after tasting my pizza. The search is over. I found my goto place on the first try and it shares a parking lot with Julie Ann's Frozen Custard...you're welcome. read more

Just good pizza. Crunchy, thin crust. Delicious!!! A family favorite. Have never had a bad pizza.

Incredible pizza! I remember having it delivered in the 60s. Nothing fancy but it all works together for the most perfect thin bubbly crust pizza ever. read more