Came in for a pizza, and the service was spot on. Nice and crispy was the crust, good and thin and still piping hot when we grabbed it to go. We were out in the area and I wanted to stop by since Portnoy gave them a good score. We were about 25 minutes out and the food was basically ready when we got there to pick up. Came home and had the pizza and I will tell you if we're ever in that area again, Sal you have our business! Nice job on the pie. Thanks again! read more

Amazing pizza & meatballs! Called in an order for pick up and it was ready when promised. Small little pick-up only place was busy on a Saturday night but the crew worked like a well-oiled machine. I don't live in the Chicago-land area anymore and crave this kind of thin crust pizza with Italian sausage and Sal's killed it! Also tried some spaghetti & meatballs and a cheesy meatball sub, meatballs were flavorful & moist, definitely recommend! This place is my dad's go-to and I'll definitely be getting it again next time I'm in town. read more

Sal's Pizza Company - Cheesy Meatball - Pizza Near Me - Algonquin, Illinois

See all

As far as local thin crust pizza goes, Sal's is top notch. There's a clear sense of pride in the craft. From the execution to the quality of the ingredients. It's evident they pour themselves into what they do, and it shows in every slice read more

Fries not cooked mozzarella sticks not cooked and the pizza a big disappointment I think I'm done with sals in Algonquin maybe it's time to teach your staff how to make pizza and yes I grew up making pizza in the city so I know what I'm talking about read more

Sal's Pizza Company - Pizza Near Me - Algonquin, Illinois

See all

Horrible order. Food was 30 minutes late for a pickup. They added onions to one of my pizzas and it was supposed to be sausage only. I hate onions. Pizza was supposed to be no cut and it was clearly written with red marker on the receipt. They cut it into TINY squares. We threw it in the garbage. Other pizza had almost no sauce and the little sauce on it tasted like water. Our order of cream cheese poppers were cheddar cheese, which we don't like. They were cold and the cheese was hard like they were sitting out for an hour. They didn't include any ranch for the poppers. They just lost a long time customer for good. $82 down the drain. I have always said that Sal's is the only decent Pizza place in the area, especially when people new to the area ask. Now I will be telling them stay away from Sals. I don't think they care anyway. read more

Hands down the best thin crust pizza in Algonquin . Been ordering pizza from here for years!! They are very consistent and never let me down!! read more

I ordered a sausage pizza and chicken parmesan. The pizza had sausage pieces in casings that looked like leftover italian sausages from sandwiches. The pizza dough had a weird taste similar to being in a smelly fridge too long or freezer burn - we know, your dough is made fresh daily. I paid extra for the meat sauce for the chicken parm and got barely any sauce. The pasta was dry and the whole thing was flavorless. I thought I had never been to sal's before but my son reminded me that we tried them 2 years ago. I will not forget again. read more

I really love this place. Good pizza great qualities pizza and better ingredients Nothing can beat sals pizza. And in algonquin rd on hanson rd and their food is so good. Me and my family had a good pizza tonight and I recommend this place. Even if you have and deal free coupon for pop mentioned it with 36 inch pizza any size and good sauce too! And black olives, pepperoni sausage, bacon, bell peppers, which is red peppers, onions, tomatoes, cheese read more

Sal's Pizza Company - Pizza Near Me - Algonquin, Illinois

It's a tiny little hole in the wall place, around the corner from a seven eleven. However, we've been coming here over 25 years I think their deep dish pan is one of the best pizzas I've ever had. We like other items on the menu too.Especially the inferno wings. read more

Delicious thin crust pizza, Sausage has amazing flavor, would definitely order again

Great tasting pizza. I find it a little on the pricey side, other places are more reasonable. But the taste and crispness brings me back offen. read more

We enjoyed the deep dish and thin crust pizzas. The pizzas were very generous and flavorful. The service was excellent, friendly and pleasant. There was music playing which we enjoyed and were able to have a conversation easily. We loved the location with the holiday decorations on the town square across from the restaurant. Fun time! read more

Very good pizza usual ready when the predict. I also had the shrimp this past weekend and it was surprising good

A short and sweet review. I ordered from Sal's for my daughters 1st birthday. Everybody loved it! I'd definitely order again!

Exhausted after moving into the area I decided to try Sal's for an easy dinner. Absolutely outstanding. Starting from the ultra friendly person that took the order to the fast delivery I was already impressed. Then I bit into the thin crust pizza and wow, just so good! Crisp bottom and thin but not TOO thin and not TOO crunchy, to me just perfect tavern style pizza. My parents had come by to help unpack and they keep telling me they'll come visit just so we can order (or go to!) Sal's! read more

Best pizza in town!! Great service and great deals. My family drives over 30 minutes to get Sals, they are our family's favorite for over 3 years. Their pizza is fresh and tastes like no other. Even if they mess up (only occurred once), they make up for it and treat us like valued customers. The workers also appear to enjoy their job and want to be there. I always appreciate their customer service and quality assurance. 10/10 read more

Ordered an Italian beef for the first time with this location compared to Huntley, They literally put 50% less beef in the sandwich at this location for the same price, I called to complain about it, and the guy who answered, says that Huntley isn't abiding by their new "standards" And claimed they were in the wrong, but I believe this Algonquin location is in the wrong because Huntley has been perfect for over two decades. They didn't offer to rectify or help the situation in any way shape or form, Just placing blame on some logistics system. Don't recommend this location read more

What is wrong with me, I've haven't talked about Sal's? There are many things wrong with me, and that 4000 page book is for another time. The little pizza places are what I always look for. Sal's is a staple. Don't be fooled by it's location and exterior appearance, this workhorse is around the corner of a 7-eleven building. The appearance is small but internally, thanks to the hard workers doing their thing, they produce some great pizza. Their tavern style is classic, thin (but not cracker thin) crust has generous, tangy sauce, and hearty, fresh toppings. I like that the sausage isn't too salty like other places. Don't sleep on their wings, they are meaty and done right. Sal's is 100% pickup or delivery. They have other options for pizza, appetizers, hot sandwiches, pasta, ribs, salad, etc. Dave Portnoy recently put them on an extended map..beyond word of mouth from locals. I never expected him to show up near my neck of the woods, but if he was in search of a "real deal" or "go-to" tavern-style pizza, he made the right decision. Even without One Bite, Sal's was already award-winning. Be sure to use their coupons as they gladly accept them. read more

See all

Awesome pizza quality ingredients and all we order this pizza all the time Friendly staff Still giving it five stars but hope they are more careful with our orders going forward not sure if I received someone else's order but we had two large pizza and both wrong customization and toppings read more

Great pizza very consistent I think prices are very high compared to local other options! read more

Great pie, always a fresh hot tasty pizza. Great service always ready when picking up, I also like their Royal Crown sugar free soda. Order by phone and it's ready when you arrive. 5 stars in my book ! read more

In my opinion, Sal's thin pizza is probably the best tasting and quality used ingredients pizzeria in McHenry County. read more

Sal's Pizza Company - Leftover Sal's pizza tastes great even the next day - Pizza Near Me - Algonquin, Illinois

Decided to try Sal's Pizza because I saw Dave Portnoy go there. The pizza is fantastic - good amount of toppings + not overloaded with cheese. We did delivery and they were quick and sufficient. read more

Sal's Pizza Company - black olive and pepperoni sausage and onion veggie pizza - Pizza Near Me - Algonquin, Illinois

See all

It's been a while since we ordered and glad we went back to our favorite. The medium deep dish cheese , sausage and green onion was utterly over the top.. There was enough sausage pieces on this pizza to make two sausage sandwiches . No skipping here. The best deep dish pizza in the area My wife and I each ate two pieces and and enough for left overs ( Like half the pizza) I It was that filling. . Hands down. And I can Eat a store pizza folding it in half all By myself. Sals pizza hands down the best ! read more

Sal's is great! Always liked the pizza here and for a takeout spot run by mostly high school students...always super nice and friendly. Not available to eat in, if you want that go to their location in Huntley. Want some good pie for a family pizza night? Try this local joint out! read more

Sal's Pizza Company of Algonquin and Huntley is the best pizza you will find in the suburbs of Chicago. Not just the pizza, but everything else on the menu is perfect! I want to try more things on the menu but the thin crust pizza is just too good. It is the BEST thin crust pizza that you will find! The staff and the service is excellent! Now you can dine in at the Huntley location. They always treated me with respect, and they are very kind. This is a family business that was owned by a good childhood friend of mine! His family is very nice and would always host us and sponsor sporting events. They really make a big impact in the community and it's very cool to see it! Every time I return home, it's one of my first places to stop to eat! The pizza, the wings, Italian beef, French fries. Everything on their menu is so good! I love Sal's Pizza company they are the best! read more

Garbage pizza and wings on Friday. Go to Sal's enjoy a great pizza and beer. Always friendly. Quick delivery and never screw up your order. Food is delivered hot. read more

Our new go-to place for pizza. Never a bad bite, lots of cheese, lots of toppings and specials you'd actually order.

The pizza is thin crust and very cheesy, good sausage and envelope though the are often very busy. The always have ready in the time quoted

Always amazing food and exceptional service. Best thin crust anywhere and the rest of the menu is excellent, too.

Sal's has been located in Algonquin for decades and offers delicious pizza for a fair price. The pizza is so good that I haven't eaten their sandwiches but the selection is vast. We have had their wings; yum! Note that Algonquin is not a sit-down restaurant....but we were thrilled when they expanded to add a Huntley location with a dine in option! They'll be serving up delicious eats for decades more. read more

Fantastic pizza. Reminds me of how pizza should be made. On time and hot. This is a place I drive an hour to go to

Love Sals! A hidden gem and has been a part of Algonquin/Lake in the Hills for so long sometimes you forget. They keep busy though! Pizza always good. I like my crust extra crispy and it is good. The food accommodates a wide variety of people's tastes. Thank you and keep it up. read more

Pretty good pizza. I was in the area yesterday while en route to Tom's Orchard in Huntley for some apple cider donuts and had a taste for pizza so upon perusing yelp, I landed on this spot based on the glowing reviews. Well, the reviews didn't lie. This place is pretty good. Maybe not the best for the entire Chicagoland area (I've been to a lot of pizza places throughout the city) but definitely a top contender for this area. We got a medium thin crust with sausage, spinach and hot giardinera. Great amount of and nicely flavorful sauce, good amount of fresh ingredients and perfect amount of cheese, all on top of nicely cooked crust. Made for a tasty dinner. A hidden gem! read more

Sal's Pizza Company - Medium thin crust with sausage, spinach and giardinera. My wife stole a corner before I could snap a pic - Pizza Near Me - Algonquin, Illinois

Great classic tavern-style pizza. Everything we had was fresh and cooked to perfection. It was well-priced and all the employees were friendly. Look forward to many more visits! read more

THE BEST PIZZA IN THE AREA!!! Moved here from the city and was having a hard time finding a pizza I liked until Sals! 10/10 every time!

Catered from Sals for my wedding yesterday and everything was outstanding and very good! All the guests raved about the chicken and everything else!! The BEST MUST HAVE!! Thanks Sal and your team for a great evening!! read more

Great pizza and chicken Parmesan. Easy pick-up or delivery. Friendly. Reliable. Always good!

Sal's is my favorite pizza place in the Algonquin area. The pizza is always fantastic! I'm up in the area a couple times a year to visit the kids and grandkids. I always buy pizza from Sal's. Everyone loves it. read more

Great pizza and great beefs. Nice staff and the food is always hot! What more can I say about a great pizza joint!