service compensates for the food. I ordered this with the thought that "nobody can mess up a chicken parm"; I was proven otherwise. Tread wisely when visiting. chicken parm: 5/10 read more

Pirate's Cove - POPCORN chicken parm - American Near Me - New Bern, North Carolina

We walked out! Zero stars if possible. Waited 10 minutes to order a beer, another 10 to get it and 40 minutes for raw oysters that we were told were coming any minute. Wasn't even busy. Can't imagine how long it would take for food to arrive. Not waitresses fault. Kitchen is a travesty. Put money on the table to cover the beer and a tip. With all the restaurant choices and the bad reviews this has, I don't know how they are in business. And they don't even respond to the reviews. Tells everyone they don't care about customers. We went by default. Had a dog and other places were swamped. Don't go. I question if they are for real. read more

Other reviews seem to be fake. Slow service, mostly ignores you till delivering the check. Chicken Parm shouldn't be a black brick on noodles. Maybe sauce and cheese should be there. Beer should be cold. read more

We went here because the original restaurant we wanted to try was closed. Had decent reviews on Google so we decided to try. Worst decision. We ordered sweet tea for our daughter, she got unsweetened. We ordered the $75 Captain's Feast which comes with oysters, asked for them raw on the side and added an additional half dozen oysters. After 20 minutes 5 oysters are brought to the table and we are told that they are out of oysters. We understand and ask to have the other half dozen removed from the check. The first one we tried tasted absolutely foul. We sent them back and had them removed from the check. 30 minutes later the seafood boil came out on a tiny plate and was no way 4 lbs of seafood as advertised and before they brought the food to the table they threw raw oysters out of the shell into the bag with the steamed food, they were still cold when we started eating, just random oysters floating around in watery soup, absolutely disgusting. We begin eating and realize there is no corn potatoes or sausage included. It took another 20 minutes for our server to return to inform her that items were missing. In her defense she did say it was her first day, but that this was the second time today that the kitchen staff has sent her food out without all of the included items. We were nearly done eating at this point so we asked to have the corn potatoes and sausage put in a Togo box to take home. Included the photo of what was brought to our table for 3 people to share with a 75$ meal. Three potatoes, one corn, and cold sausage. I saw 3 or 4 different servers doing laps around the restaurant but our drinks were only filled once because I asked, extra plates were not brought and no one came to apologize about the oysters or forgetting half of our meal except for our server who was waiting the entire pirate's cove side alone. At the end of the meal I got up to wash my hands in the restroom and walked by a table with an identical order to ours served on a large metal platter, corn sausage and potatoes included and much more food than what we received (also it wasn't swimming in water). I can understand being a new employee and I am not a super picky eater but it was just extremely disappointing to spend basically an entire day's paycheck on what was supposed to be a family dinner and not be able to enjoy it. At the end we didn't even want to complain anymore, everything brought to the table was wrong in some way. I hope that this review saves someone else from having to experience the same thing as us. Save your money, go somewhere else. Seafood and especially oyster safety is super important, I really hope that we don't all get sick from eating here. Never again. read more

Pretty cool place with a lot of seating. They have a bar counter made completely into a long fish aquarium! Service was friendly though very slow for a Saturday afternoon. They were completely out of lobster and oysters unfortunately. We did opt for the seafood nachos (which were pretty good with the fried pita corners) and the mozzarella cheeseburger with mozzarella cheese sticks AND then even more mozzarella! For some average all- American bar/diner food, this is pretty good. read more

Pirate's Cove - American Near Me - New Bern, North Carolina

See all

We stopped in here for the first time. We wanted to check it out. I didn't realize it was a sports bar and it was crowded and very noisy with all of the TVs showing a game. We both chose the seafood combo of fried shrimp and scallops. My wife Kathey chose the red potatoes and a salad for her sides while I went with the fries and some coleslaw. The food was ok as was the service considering how busy it was. Not sure if we will return but for sure it won't be on a Sunday game day. read more

See all

Absolutely terrible customer service. Shift manager was rude and didn't accommodate to our problems we had. I wouldn't recommend this place to anyone. read more

I come here often. I mostly get their alligator bites and beer. But I have had their steak and raw oysters. I don't ever have a problem with service here. The ladies are attractive and nice. The place always smells clean. The only complaint is the extreme prices of their steaks. I will continue coming here though! read more

See all

Well my mistake in trying this horrible place again. Service was terrible. Server Chris is rude and shouldn't be in any sort of customer service job. All you can eat? No, I reordered immediately after receiving my food. Over an hour later I still had not received food. I will not be back and wouldn't recommend this place to anyone. read more

Nope, just nope. As New Bern résidents we hadn't tried PC. First the good-- good beer selection. And none of this was our waitress's fault. The food was awful. My shrimp po boy was frozen battered shrimp dropped in the fryer. Which makes me wonder why it took 10+ minutes to come out AFTER my husband was served his cold fries and lousy burger. His burger was supposed to be a marvelous creation with cheese mixed in with the meat. Uh--nope. He bit into it and got a mouthful of salt and pepper. The meat wasn't even mixed. Never again! There is no chef but a cook that doesn't know anything about running a kitchen. $45 and wasted time. First, last and only time mateys! Go to Morgan's or MJs always good and reliable. read more

Everything needs improvement especially the service. If you can't handle all you can eat customers DO NOT ADVERTISE IT

I loved the dress up (both staff and decorations) for the season. Our waitress was attentive and cordial. Our food was kinda meh. The best dish was the seafood nachos. The crab and seafood chowder was kinda bland but passable. Crab cake sandwich was fun with the legs sticking out making for an authentic experience, but the rest of it was just a leaf of lettuce, a sliced tomato, and white bread thrown in a toaster. Cajun linguine was terrible. Not Cajun at all, just a garlic sauce and a little black pepper. Way overpriced ($24). Seafood Nachos - 4 / 5 Chowder - 3.5 / 5 Crab Cake Sandwich - 3.25 / 5 "Cajun" Linguine with shrimp - 1.75 / 5 Decorations and service - 4 / 5 Tap Selection - 3.75 / 5 Overall - 3.25 / 5 read more

Pirate's Cove - Crab Cake Sandwich - American Near Me - New Bern, North Carolina

See all

The hubs and I came for a drink and a couple of appetizers. The drinks were great.we had the fried green beans which were fresh and not greasy. The clam chowder we ordered tasted okay but the texture was a bit mushy ( like the potatoes broke down inside the chowder due to overcooking) . Finally, we ordered the crab cakes and while they did have a pleasant taste, they were incredibly overcooked. The corn that was served as a side was also delicious but a bit overcooked. We will be back and try some more of their food. *end note The bar, which doubles as a fishtank is fun and the crabby salt shakers are a fun addition. read more

See all

My daughter wanted to come here. She lives in New Bern and has yet to come. We went in and she wanted to sot at the bar. The bar is so cool, its a huge fish-tank. I tried a few of their local beers who's names i forget but they were house beers and very good. For dinner, we started with the alligator bites which were fried perfectly amd served with a nice dipping sauce. We then split the Whydah Galley steampot which was oysters, shrimp, clams, mussels, snow crab and king crab for $60 plus they charge you $5 to share a plate. Everything was outstanding Except, the shrimp weren't clean there are so many that you are cleaning shrimp poop for some time. Other than that, this was a great time read more

See all

Sandra is the best! Very friendly and professional! They have live music Friday & Saturday nights. read more

Pirate's Cove - American Near Me - New Bern, North Carolina

See all

We ordered beers and steamed oysters to start. She brought our beers. We ordered Heineken. She came back no Heineken. We ordered a substitute and had to ask for glasses. Our dinner came before the oysters. The oysters arrived halfway through our meal. They were good. I ordered Maryland lump crab. They are NOT Maryland lump crab. Baked potatoes were cold and undercooked. Corn was soggy and cold and tasted like it was soaking in oil. We won't go back. Our meal with 3 bets was almost $100. This was NOT a $100. Meal. The windows were open and flies were everywhere. read more

Food portions are equivalent to a child's menu, and the shrimp were just frozen battered shrimp. Oysters were nickel sized and chewy. Worst meal I've ever spent $23 on per person. Service was terrible also, we got no silverware, my dad ended up having to get up and go get it himself after asking multiple times. We were not offered any refills on drinks either. I saw multiple plates being returned to the kitchen for various problems. Honestly just pick a different place for dinner and don't waste your money here. read more

Food was ok, service was very slow our poor server seemed alone in a 3/4 full restaurant. Overall the place needed a good cleaning.

Wanted to try a different restaurant but for the second time they were packed at 515 so I went down.the street to here. Again the service was pleasant and the martini was good. The oysters (were blah but one was off. I had high hopes for the red snapper plain but hopefully cooked well but it was like eating chalk. Mac and cheese was good kinda like Panera the collards were ok too. Two things 1) the app and dinner came at the same time 2) something probably an oyster made me run to my hotel to use the loo. read more

Pirate's Cove - Oysters Rockefeller - American Near Me - New Bern, North Carolina

See all

Just, keep walking. Tried to be adventurous and try Pirates Cove after walking past it many times. Big mistake. Beer was flat and sour yet still was charged for taking a sip. A single sip. Ordered a side of broccoli with our burger. When I say ice cold, I mean it was still frozen and hadn't thawed out yet. Waited a good 30min for a chicken sandwich with only 4 other tables. Like I said, just keep walking. read more

Fish Tacos were incredible!! Next time I'm in New Bern, I'll definitely return. Wait staff was courteous and helpful also.

Stopped in for lunch. Marielle greeted me with a smile before I could get through the door. I wasn't sure what I wanted to drink, she recommended the coconut lime margarita wings were equally yum! Plus they have fish swimming in the bar! How cool read more

Pirate's Cove - American Near Me - New Bern, North Carolina

See all

I used to love the crab dip, but they changed the pita chips and they are terrible. Definitely won't order again.

Went to The Pirates Cove for lunch in January while on vacation and had a great experience. Dated, but cool decor. We got the crab dip with pita chips, which was delicious, and po-boys. They were also delicious. However, our choices were a bit narrowed as it was the 2nd and the New Year had wiped them out. Not a big deal and totally understandable. We went back a couple of days later for dinner & were pretty much able to have whatever we wanted as they were able to restock quickly. We got the "Buried Treasure" steam pot. It was absolutely huge, and another order of King Crab legs. Wonderful. We're back for another week & went this evening because, after a long day, sometimes you want to go where you don't have to guess. Both my husband & I were extremely disappointed. There were, yet again, things on the menu that were not available. Not even the fresh stuff. Simple things like coconut shrimp and even alfredo sauce. How do you run out of alfredo sauce? Because it's not fresh. Anyone can go to the to the store & get alfredo sauce. A restaurant should be making it fresh. It's quite simple to make. We started with the little necks. They were teeny tiny, and had no flavor. And the butter tasted as if it had been sitting in the refrigerator with leftovers. My husband stuck with the po-boy, which he said was good, but the collard greens had no taste. I asked for Shrimp Scampi. What I got was overcooked angel hair pasta that was swimming in melted butter. No garlic, no parmesan, no wine, no flavor. And no bread. I asked and was offered crackers even though they clearly had bread. Unless they used the last bit for my husband's sandwich. The beer was good, and waitresses were helpful and on time, both times. Maybe they could apply to that show, Restaurant Makeover (not trying to be mean. The place could be really cool). Until then, the bad outweighs the good, and we will not be back. read more

I gave this two stars cause the bartender was very sweet and chill. Unfortunately for the food it was atrocious. I ordered the Grilled Oysters and there was so much sand in the oyster I could grind my teeth in it. The oysters were awful. Do not order. Cool environment but not worth the money to spend on food. read more

Pirate's Cove - Grilled Oysters - American Near Me - New Bern, North Carolina

I ordered delivery via DoorDash and my meal was actually pretty good. I had an oyster po boy with a Side salad. The oysters were great and the sandwich has a really good Cole slaw on it. The salad dressing was a Golden Italian but it was still a nice salad to compliment. The pricing for the sandwich and salad was around $11.00. So, I was impressed with that. I would order from here again. read more

Pirate's Cove - Oyster po boy - American Near Me - New Bern, North Carolina

Living in New Bern, we finally got around to trying Pirates Cove yesterday. We sat at the bar which is a flat fish tank and adds a dimension of entertainment to the meal. We almost always try a new-to-us place with lunch first and based on our meals, we will definitely return to Pirate's Cove for dinner. My wife had the fish tacos with snapper and rated them 4.5 out of 5. Also, the fries were perfectly cooked and seasoned with rosemary. I tried their peel and eat shrimp in order to compare them to those of a nearby favorite eatery. I rate them a perfect 5. The service was very good and our server, Marielle, was friendly and knowledgeable and made us feel welcome and added to the positive experience. read more

We had a wonderful time the atmosphere was fun and the food was great!!! It's a must when in New Bern. read more

See all

Pirate's Cove has a great atmosphere and excellent service. The food is consistent and delicious.

Don't waste your time or money on this place. Well below average food and even worse service

We've been here pretty regularly since moving here last year and always enjoyed the food and our favorite Bartender, Shelby. However, over the last few months, we haven't seen Shelby, and the current team in there is less friendly, less concerned about customer service and last night my Cajun linguine was like paste. Yuck. Also had to wait way to long for beverage refills, our food order and to get served in the first place. And as usual, this side of the establishment was not busy. Four servers standing at the end of the bar talking. VERY disappointed last night! Not sure we'll be going in again, even through it was always a good place to just pop in. read more

Great sevice from my server Haley today!! Highly recommend stopping by and checking this place out. I suppose I'm now a local but still a newbie. I'm usually a tourist to pop in someplace alone but felt so comfortable and welcome! Check it out. Thanks Haley and staff. read more

I went to Pirate's Cove tonight for the first time. I had been wanting to try their oysters rockefeller. We got there a little after 9:00 and it was Friday night. When i went to order the waitress informed us we could only get fried food since it was after 9. mind you, they don't even have any fried on their menu besides the captain's platter. The said we could order from Blackbeard's menu so we got some wings and fries. The food came up and sat on the counter for a good 6 minutes before anyone brought it out to us. Nevermind there were FIVE WAITRESSES standing right their just shooting the breeze. It wasn't even hot anymore! When we looked at the bill we saw that they charge a 3% fee for not paying cash. All I know is it was a total disappointment and I won't be going back. I'll take the waitrese recommendation and go to Captain Ratty's for the oyster. read more

Traditional Turkey Dinner served throughout the day. Nothing special about the meal I was served. Seemed like I was served the leftovers from an earlier seating. read more

Had dinner with the wife here over the weekend. Took a little while to get served, but once we did, everything was great. We had the steamed medley of clams, shrimp, oysters, and crab legs - it was great. Drinks were good and we'd come back again. read more

Walked in and was never greeted. I found a server who was busing a table on the other side (Blackbeard's) and asked her if we sat ourselves or should wait. We sat ourselves, as instructed. There were only two other tables and 3-4 ppl sitting at the bar. We sat there for 10-15 and never saw a server and was never greeted. The bartender appeared as if she hated life and never made an effort to even say hello. We eventually got up and left, the bartender didn't acknowledge us then either, even though we made eye contact several times. read more

What an underwhelming experience! If you're just going here for a beer/drink you'll be safe. The bar is eclectic with the a very cool bar /aquarium. If you're going here for a meal...Don't! So disappointing! They just miss the mark in so many ways. The food is lukewarm at best and the flavor smacks of frozen and unprofessionally prepared. There's a reason why you can get in here on the weekend and can't get in to any of the other restaurants downtown. Save yourself the disappointment. Come back for a beer and maybe the music. Leave the food to the professionals elsewhere around town! read more

New Place in my lovely little town. New in the sense it is a new business but is owned by the same people that own Black Beards and Tripple Play. I will say the menus are vastly different and the food we had today was very good minus one small dingy. My partner in crime shared a 2 option Captains Platter that was more than enough to share. We got the coconut shrimp and fried shrimp. Fried shrimp had great flavor and the cocktail sauce provided had a nice kick. The coconut shrimp is where the ding comes in. May have been slightly undercooked. However, it still had good flavor and good size. We opted for the red potatoes and collards. My wife being a collard connoisseur compared them to the pig on Simmons. those in the know, know what that means, very good. Potatoes were steamed and basted in what tasted like butter and rosemary, again, very good. Staff was attentive and friendly. Atmosphere was pretty cool for the theme. I will be back to try more and is worth visiting in my humble opinion. Thanks read more

See all

I've been going here off and on since it opened. It shares a kitchen with Blackbeards next door. I have no real problem with food or service. Last time I was there I started with their chowder. It was standard but the portion was tiny in a small bowl. The crackers were stale. A glass of house wine is 8 bucks and is half of a small glass full. The day I went they were out of many items due to the previous day's weather from Idalia. I ended up with fish and chips. The fish was way over cooked but plentiful. Lots of fries if that's your thing. My small cup of soup, the wine and fish came to $28. Imagine! I'll go back because their raw oysters are usually good. I know the cost of doing business has gone up however this place overcharges for the quality and quantity aspects. It's a so so joint with competent servers usually but none last long. On some nights the music from next door is too loud for my taste. I like to eat in peace and quiet. read more

Amazing bacon wrapped scallops. Amazing crab cakes and collards!! Very cozy atmosphere. We will be going back soon! read more

Pirate's Cove - Crab cakes with collards and red potatoes - American Near Me - New Bern, North Carolina