Pita Amore

As anyone with a gluten allergy knows, eating out can be stressful. The staff here are genuinely…read moreeducated on gluten-free safety and cross-contamination.A huge warning for anyone visiting the island: many places claim their tortillas are "just corn," but they are often mixed with masa or flour blends that contain gluten is my understanding so I didn't feel comfortable trying any chips or taco stands. Lola's actually brought out their tortillas, let me look at them, and explained how they were made. One meal, I had the gluten-free pancakes, and they were hands-down the best pancakes I have ever had in my entire life!

Such great service and food!!highly recommend trying the appetizers and drinks! Don't be shy to try…read moredessert and enjoy the ambiance

Cute decor

Octopus

See all

Lights out. But fun.

Rosa Sirena's

4.6(78 reviews)

3.0 km•Isla Mujeres

Traveling to Isla Mujeres in early February 2026, we wanted to try Rosa Sirena's for dinner based…read moreon the many good reviews we had read. A reservation was easy to obtain via email and we were all set for a sunset, evening meal. We were warmly welcomed and promptly seated. The service was impeccable, the atmosphere pleasant with an acoustic duo playing mellow tunes in the background. Honestly, we were a little disappointed with the view that most reviews rave about. Our sever was knowledgeable and made several suggestions. We selected the Pepita Crusted Tuna for a starter, my companion had the fresh catch which was grouper, blackened with a side of the peanut sauce. I chose the Surf and Turf. For dessert, we shared the Key Lime Pie. Everything was beautifully presented, and quite artistic. The tuna appetizer was very good, but the main courses were frankly a disappointment. The creativity of the plate did not make up for the lackluster food. The steak was tough and poorly seasoned, the lobster was just passable but also chewy and not tender. The fish was not as well cooked as other restaurants downtown and again the seasoning was lackluster. The sides, lentils and mashed potatoes were just ok. The homemade Key Lime Pie was enjoyable but again seemed to lack a depth of flavor. If the food could match the service, presentation, and atmosphere then perhaps this could be one of Isla's better dining establishments, until then "the juice was not worth the squeeze."

Went to Isla Mujeres and enjoyed this place so much for dinner and drinks. The ambiance is friendly…read moreand romantic. We absolutely loved the food and ate here multiple times on our trip. Highly recommend the vegetable salad, arrachera, and lobster bites. Will definitely be back!

Irish sign made us feel at home!

See all

Exterior

Xantolo

4.7(131 reviews)

0.2 km•Isla Mujeres

Don't be fooled by Xantolo's location and Touristy perception. A local recommended it to us and he…read morewas spot on. Best dinner for us in Mexico on our entire trip. Service was a little slower and prices were a little higher but we did not mind. As it turned out, we were in for quite the night. Every dish was flavorful and better than the next. Their Mezcal Ceviche is not to be missed and their Carne Asada was the best we've had by far. The corn bread is also one of the most unique deserts we have ever had and the bonus on top, was the free live music we were serenaded with. We ended up staying over 2 hours to eat, drink, and listen to great music, people watch, and soak in a true vacation.

This review is on the drinks and the vibes. Every time I visited this location I was full. LOL. The…read morebartenders were great and I requested a Coconut Mojito (Coconut rum vs regular) Which is my favorite. And WE ALL KNOW Isla Mujeres LOVES their mojitos... But it was amazing :)! They also had a professional flute player as live entertainment and that was beautiful. The bar has swings and is very nice to sit at and people watch as all the foot traffic passes. I would add this place to th list.

Swings at the bar

Surf & Turf dinner

See all

Grapefruit and rosemary margarita. But honestly, it smelled like sage.

Los Tacos de Humo

4.7(230 reviews)

0.1 km•Isla Mujeres

Ran into this place by accident. So glad we came in because the food was delicious and very…read morefilling. They give you a lot of meat in a taco so it is very filling. The waiter was attentive and so nice. Small restaurant that was clean with AC. Would definitely recommend you to stop by and get the dessert at the end too.

Really expected a lot with all the excellent reviews. We got the three arrachera tacos. Yes they…read morewere huge but the quality of the meet was mid. It was tender but it tasted like steamed meat. Not very flavorful. Paid almost $20 for 3 tacos!!!! That's an insane price for tacos. The customer service was good. They had AC but not worth the hype. I don't get it.

The inside

Guacamole

See all

Yummy monster size Carnitas tacos!

La Lomita

4.5(127 reviews)

0.3 km•Isla Mujeres

La Lomita is just OK. We keep coming back for the suiza…read moreenchiladas, but it has been a busy the last Two times. Chicken needs seasoning and the chicken is dry, like super dry. The owner is very nice and will greet you. It is nice that it is off the beaten path as well.

Walked up here from the south side on a day electricity was out all day. Glad to find a restaurant…read morewith power. We sat outside, ordered waters/sodas/beer. Good variety on the menu. I ordered the ceviche de pulpo -- absolutely fabulous. Husband and son enjoyed their chile rellenos. There was a vegetarian option for my daughter. Prices were reasonable. We ordered the chicken skewers to go for my youngest who wasn't with us. They kindly included extras of rice, beans, salsa, tortillas and cutlery. Only negative was the food came out at way different times.

Beautiful wall paintings.

See all

Loved the ceramic glasses!

Polo's Café Mango

4.8(442 reviews)

2.9 km•Isla Mujeres

Just as we remembered Mango from 2014, it is the best breakfast place in all of Isla, possibly…read moreMexico. It's a small nicely decorated restaurant. Everything on their menu is cooked fresh to order and incredibly tasty. The only drawback back is how busy it has gotten over the years, but their service and quality have not suffered.

Came here and was seated immediately. Got the famous coconut French toast and also the Mayan…read morescramble with a side of steak arrachera to share - they didn't disappoint! Solid breakfast I would return for.

Inside the restaurant

Stuffed poblano

See all

Stuffed Poblano Pepper

Green Verde

4.6(145 reviews)

2.5 km•Isla Mujeres

I loved my breakfast here. It's along a busy street so it has a buzz; but tucked inside of the cute…read morepatio oasis in the shade, but with dappled sunlight, you can hear the birds singing and the local music is a vibe. I got the French toast for breakfast and it was muy bueno. Soft bread soaked in egg and milk and sugar was like a breakfast custard. The fruit was fresh and sweet paired with hot, salty crispy, bacon And my coconut latte was pure delight. I'll be back!

Nice people and good service but I didn't care for the food. Chicken burritos were meh, not much…read moreflavor and no salsa. Husband thought the burritos were okay. Came back a second time and ordered the tri mole enchiladas with Mexican rice??? and they weren't not good. Rice was really bad!! I was hungry so I put some of their hot salsa on the enchiladas and put the rice in the mole sauce to try to make it somewhat palatable. Still not good. On the plus side the restaurant is beautiful. LOTS of beautiful living plants all over.

Cactus

Dessert was the best dish

See all

Cute turtles

Fuego De Mar

4.9(80 reviews)

3.8 km•Isla Mujeres

Very nice night!! We were accepted super last minute the night before Christmas for 8. Only 6…read moreshowed & we accepted the terrace. Only complaint was the loud metal plate out front. Clanking all evening But not their fault. The food made it worth it! We truly enjoyed all the food, ever we had was absolutely amazing!! The bread was a treat and nice & light. The best night for a holiday dinner. Thank you!!!

Fuego was indeed fuego (sorry). I was craving a roasted whole fish and the version that they do…read morehere was flavorful and a substantial portion, stuffed with spinach and some sort of foam drizzled over veggies, with perfect crispy skin. I would've liked the actual meat of the fish to be more tender (it bordered on overcooked) but still I walked away plenty satisfied. It does have lots of tiny bones. Bread basket came with the most delicious roasted eggplant in oil, I could've eaten just that with the bread and been a happy camper. The roasted octopus was not bad but a touch too heavy on the sauces for me, I would've wanted more of the flavor of the octopus on its own. The potatoes under the octopus, however, were perhaps my favorite part of the whole meal. Everyone else seemed happy with their food - the catch of the day (with the fluffiest mashed potatoes) was a very popular choice. If you're sick of seafood, they have steak and braised brisket on their menu. Really cozy and romantic ambiance as well for if you want to dress up slightly. This place gets very popular for good reason; I liked the little bar counter they set up out front so you can watch the grilling in action.

The two on the left were the mixologists, and the sweetie on the right was our server.

Grilled octopus on potatoes

See all

Dirty Martini. Mmm.

Los Abuelos

4.7(170 reviews)

0.4 km•Isla Mujeres

What a fantastic find! This tiny little restaurant is literally in a family's home. Upstairs is the…read moresmall seating area and you truly feel like you are being fed at family or friend's house. They have a nice menu and everything we had was fresh and cooked to order.

Prefect service, great food. We love the upstairs ambiance and really enjoyed our night.read more

Grilled Octopus, delish but a bit overcooked. Ask them to not overcook it if you order it.

See all

Mango Margarita

Basto's Grill

4.6(64 reviews)

4.4 km•Isla Mujeres

Service was amazing! Such a hidden gem! We got the platter for 2 and the steak and chicken was…read morephenomenal. We will definitely make this a regular stop when visiting

Off the beaten path and 100% worth it! My husband and I could not decide what to eat so we got the…read moreBasto's plate for two and added a side of rice. Fantastico! This might be my favorite meal on the island.

Bastos sign

Menu

See all

Menu

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

1 review that is not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Salim M.

0

9

0

8 years ago

Food is alright although it's always empty but the regular chicken with some white sauce was good

Pita Amore - mediterranean - Updated September 2026

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Pita Amore also viewed

North Garden

4.6

(195 reviews)

North Garden breakfast never disappoints. Deliciously fresh food, beautiful presentation, and…read moreamazing service. The atmosphere is very chill, it almost feels like you're in a tropical tree house. All of their dishes are well seasoned and generously portioned at fair prices. I highly recommend them!

Food was delicious and the staff were super friendly, they hung out chatting with us while our food…read morewas prepared. Recommend stopping here first if you're headed to the beach where the eateries aren't as good. Docked a star because the ladies restroom needed major attention

La Lomita

4.5

(127 reviews)

La Lomita is just OK. We keep coming back for the suiza…read moreenchiladas, but it has been a busy the last Two times. Chicken needs seasoning and the chicken is dry, like super dry. The owner is very nice and will greet you. It is nice that it is off the beaten path as well.

Walked up here from the south side on a day electricity was out all day. Glad to find a restaurant…read morewith power. We sat outside, ordered waters/sodas/beer. Good variety on the menu. I ordered the ceviche de pulpo -- absolutely fabulous. Husband and son enjoyed their chile rellenos. There was a vegetarian option for my daughter. Prices were reasonable. We ordered the chicken skewers to go for my youngest who wasn't with us. They kindly included extras of rice, beans, salsa, tortillas and cutlery. Only negative was the food came out at way different times.

Coco Jaguar

4.7

(27 reviews)

CAN WE TALK ABOUT HOW THIS IS THE BEST KEPT SECRET ON THE ISLAND!…read more I have been here almost a week and have not found one single spot that I love as much as this one. Family ran, excellent atmosphere and the FOOD I CANNOT SAY ENOUGH ABOUT THE DELICIOUS FOOD. this is everything an island restaurant/bar should be. Go right now and give these folks your money. You owe it to yourself!

So delicious! We sat on the top deck and had an amazing breeze. The portion sizes are generous…read more The fish Tacos were lightly fried (Not breaded). The Ceviche had a slight sweetness and was delicious. The Ice tea was unlike anything I have tasted but it was also delicious. Enjoy!

La Cazuela M & J

4.6

(18 reviews)

This was the first time to the island and had no idea what was good so restaurant picking was a…read morechallenge. We looked through yelp and found this restaurant. The place is on the outskirts of the main road and had absolutely no one in the restaurant but we walked in anyway and was greeted happily we sat and was given a cute little fruit basket and bread which was yummy. I ordered their house special which was a huge plate of cheese, egg and sauce GREATNESS it's truly enough for 2 people so luckily my husband ate the rest I couldn't He ordered a traditional egg breakfast which he said was ok but loved mine. When in the island please try this place it's great

I am in love with the cazuela dish! It's bubbling hot melty Gouda and eggs (everyone knows Isla has…read moreamazing eggs) and filled with other toppings. I went with ham, tomato, and mushroom. Tortillas on the side. I will dream about this glorious gooey Gouda cheese delight forever. Adorable little covered patio spot right on the corner. It's quiet and the service is super friendly. Highly recommended!!

Polo's Café Mango

4.8

(442 reviews)

Just as we remembered Mango from 2014, it is the best breakfast place in all of Isla, possibly…read moreMexico. It's a small nicely decorated restaurant. Everything on their menu is cooked fresh to order and incredibly tasty. The only drawback back is how busy it has gotten over the years, but their service and quality have not suffered.

Came here and was seated immediately. Got the famous coconut French toast and also the Mayan…read morescramble with a side of steak arrachera to share - they didn't disappoint! Solid breakfast I would return for.

Madera Food & Art

5.0

(47 reviews)

Yes! Yes! & Yes, again! We have now found our favorite place to eat on the island. What an…read moreincredible discovery! From the service, ambiance, food, drinks and amazing humans here. You can taste the pride in the flavors. We could've eaten here everyday and I'm looking forward to our next visit just to eat here again. And of course the beautiful island. ;) The burger is to die for! It's juicy, flavorful and decedent. The shrimp bowl was insane with perfectly grilled shrimp, vegetables, and rice. We also got the chefs special with asparagus- YUM! We want to try the shrimp burger next time. Our drinks were delicious! You can tell they really take the time to pour love into their food and cocktails. The service was beyond outstanding! They're all so kind and attentive. Huge shoutout to Guillermo who came out of the kitchen to explain the dishes to us. He's so passionate and talented, it really shines through him. It's amazing to see his talent showcased in the meals he presents! Thank you for an amazing experience. We can't wait for our next visit

Away from the bustling North and South ends of the island, Madera Food & Art is a total hidden gem…read moreright on the main street overlooking the crystal clear ocean water. It's a gorgeous and quaint spot with entirely covered outdoor seating with views of the water. Food options include rice bowls and burgers, and they have alcoholic drink options. I got their veggie bowl and thought it was delicious! After days of meat eating, the vegetable bowl was perfect. They have a few spots for parking across the street. Service was attentive, friendly, and efficient. They have COIVD protocols in place like hand sanitizer and temperature checks.

Lola Valentina

4.6

(483 reviews)

As anyone with a gluten allergy knows, eating out can be stressful. The staff here are genuinely…read moreeducated on gluten-free safety and cross-contamination.A huge warning for anyone visiting the island: many places claim their tortillas are "just corn," but they are often mixed with masa or flour blends that contain gluten is my understanding so I didn't feel comfortable trying any chips or taco stands. Lola's actually brought out their tortillas, let me look at them, and explained how they were made. One meal, I had the gluten-free pancakes, and they were hands-down the best pancakes I have ever had in my entire life!

Such great service and food!!highly recommend trying the appetizers and drinks! Don't be shy to try…read moredessert and enjoy the ambiance

Limon

4.4

(51 reviews)

One of the better restaurants on Isla Mujeres. They are cash only (MXN or USD accepted)…read more Reservations recommended in peak seasons. They have both indoor/outdoor seating. They do have a 2nd level outdoor seating area. However, the stairs are steep so if you need easier access, I would definitely recommend reservations. The food is good. Meat is cooked on a grill and the smell permeates the air. Good flavor. I requested medium rare on mine and it was slightly cooked closer to medium+. Although it was overdone for my preference, the flavor was still good so I didn't send it back. My wife ordered Coconut Shrimp. They are cooked & served head attached. She really liked the flavor. I'm not a fan of coconut anything but thought they were decent. We started with a Caprese salad, which was definitely big enough to share. We left very full so be careful not to over order. Bottom line - Really good food. Reservations recommended. Bon appétit, y'all. Check out my entire Isla Mujeres collection here https://www.yelp.com/collection/YZgGKQUTLXZ0K1-H5UtK5A?utm_content=Collections&utm_source=ishare

We stopped in here for dinner because it was referred to us. I had the pork chop and my husband had…read morethe ribs. Food and service were good but not great. I would have rather stayed in town and explored more of the restaurants on Hidalgo.

Q'Bravo

5.0

(33 reviews)

This place is just all local & oh so lovely. Open air seating with fans. The coffee was hot &…read morestrong like I like my men. The staff friendly & welcome like my friends. The 3 eggs were bright yellow looking fresh from a chicken that is living they best life. The bacon was crispy & plenty of it. Don't be intimidated. Menu is in English, too. The ladies speak English & are so sweet & helpful. Felt alike I was at my aunts place. The whole plate was very balanced. Once again, that coffee!! Yum. Plus so so great priced. $7 breakfast for the win.

Great place to grab breakfast or lunch while in isla mujeres. Had a great menu, seating area with…read moreviews of the street ambiance. Service was fast and friendly.

Los Abuelos

4.7

(170 reviews)