Was in the area and wanted to try a new pizza place. We stopped in and checked out the menu. We decided on the Brooklyn pie. We ordered it to have a couple slices there and to get the rest to go. Staff was very pleasant. Waited about 10 minutes for our order. The gentleman behind the counter brought out our pizza in a boxes as well as a couple of plates. He also brought out over all of the spices. We opened up the box and the pizza looked great. The crust is exactly how I like it. Light and fluffy yet crispy and chewy. The sauce could have been a little bit sweeter but once she added some grated Parmesan cheese to it it did add a little sweetness. The pizza was super hot when we got it. Once it cooled down a little bit you could kind of taste the flavors a little bit better. Overall, very good pie. Would definitely get again. read more

Pizza Barn - Brooklyn Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mount Holly, New Jersey

I got a cheesesteak and wings. It was cheesesteak hoagie the LTMO were fresh but just not the best quality. The cheesesteak no way I think should've bought steak ums. The roll I could do better off the shelf. The fries under cooked and soggy I didn't eat. I also got breaded wings. The mild sauce on side was fine what I expected no problem. The blue cheese dip I like more chunky but at least minimal chunks. The wings the breading was fine the wings average but the cook was good. Fries again couldn't eat. I did take out no ketchup so make sure u ask. But cheesesteaks and wings are everywhere prices were good but I'll order elsewhere even if I have to pay a few dollars more read more

We live close to the Pizza Barn, so we gave it a try. We were very pleasantly surprised at the quality and quantity of our portions. It was delicious and we had enough to have another dinner the next day. The menu is expansive and we will most certainly go back and try other selections. Would highly recommend. read more

Pizza Barn - a variety of food items on a kitchen counter - Pizza Near Me - Mount Holly, New Jersey

Worst $18.99 I ever spent on pizza. The crust was floppy, and the pizza sauce had no flavor. My dog wouldn't eat the crust, and she eats anything. Pick up a Red Baron Pizza at the store because, let's be honest, you work too hard for your money to waste it on terrible pizza. read more

Zero if I could. They delivered my food to the wrong house after waiting an hour then when I called they said they would send the guy to verify it wasn't the correct address which is fine but I said are you gonna send him with another pizza and they said no.... So you want me to wait another hour for you to go back and forth..so I went to the business and the manager or owner or whatever he was was extremely rude and arrogant like this was my fault and not once did he apologize for THEIR mistake I'll never be back. Bunch of scumbags read more

Barilla tacos are the best. Must try. I would eat them again and again. I cannot believe how good they were.

If you're a fan of food that doesn't show up for delivery this is the place for you. Ordered food - never came. Fantastic! I can't rate the quality or lack there of because the delivery man called me 45 Minutes after their "latest estimated delivery time" to tell me he was sent to the wrong address. Fantastic again. Hopefully I'll see my refund some day from this craptastic place. read more

I think we will stick to their pizza. My cheesesteak was all bread and very little meat. The Gnocchi looked like soup and was very over cooked. My salad looked like it was last weeks produce. We have had great pizza from this place and have nothing but a great experience. My final complaint is that we were told to be there in 30 minutes, but got there and waited almost an hour. I get people have off days, but I'll stick to their pizza. read more

Pizza Barn - a pan of melted cheese with a fork - Pizza Near Me - Mount Holly, New Jersey

There are definitely new owners here. Food is NOT the same for the last 4-5 months. We waited an hour and ten minutes last week for two cheesesteaks, calamari and fries! Where's Sammy...... he's not here. We will not be ordering again! Why can't any good eateries make their way to this Food Desert !! : ( read more

Wow. What a great find. I've driven past here numerous times. But have never eaten here. We got wings and a white pizza. The wings had a fantastic sauce. And the pizza was fantastic. So happy we finally stopped in. Will definitely be back. read more

Hell No! They use pre-packaged pizza shells, wrapped in plastic! Domino's pizza is a better choice than having stale, pre-packaged, warmed over slop. No thank you! read more

I never see the owner anymore and the food and service have really gone downhill. Ordered a pie on the way home from work allowing plenty of time for it to be prepared and cooked only to get there and watch the hired help make the pie before my eyes and put it in the oven. Thirty minutes later I had my pizza and it wasn't what I ordered. It was a combo of sausage and margarita and I just wanted sausage. Anyway, it was pretty lousy. Now the only thing left there for me is Sammys Signature Wings which are really good. Another thing lately: they've been closing insanely early. What's up with that? read more

With a name like Pizza Barn I didn't really know what to expect. I guess it makes sense because it's a fairly rural area with a lot of farms around. They have a good deal where you can get two slices and a 16oz soda for $4. Can't really beat that. read more

Best pizza closest to me,wife and I loved Sammy for years!!

It was so disappointing to see that when I walked in, nobody had a mask on, even those in the kitchen. The owner's large family was also there..all without a mask. Then I tasted the food. I got the Thai Chili wings. Sounds delicious, right? Except the wings were burned to a crisp and then they just poured the sauce on top. I also got half margherita, half Hawaiian pizza. It looked like they gave whatever scrapped they could find and put it a box. I think this is the worst pizza I've ever gotten. This place got two stars because so far, I'm not on the toilet. read more

Amazing! Both the pizza and the service, they were very friendly and the pizza was the perfect ratio of cheese to sauce! 10/10 would recommend read more

I recently ordered a large cheese pizza and a sicilian with just sauce. Both were made thin and prices were great. Both were good, average tasting. Nothing spectacular. I havent tried the wings that I see reviewers are raving about but will one day. Location is off 206 with a parking lot in a little shopping center that includes Dunkin donuts. People are friendly. read more

I was trying to make this place my number 2 place because I love jobstown pizza but I got 3 hoagies and each only had 1 turkey slice and one cheese slice. Pictures are included. Mario and Franks or Jobstown Pizza are better read more

Pizza Barn - 1 slice of turkey and 1 slice of cheese - Pizza Near Me - Mount Holly, New Jersey

Pretty good thin crust pizza. Ask for it crispy for a nice crunch. Price isn't terrible either.

In my hopes of finding a great pizza place in the area, I found Pizza Barn and gave them a try. The pizza was OK. Definitely not the best I've ever had or even the best in the area. That being said, I would give them another try if I was in the mood for pizza close to home. I also tried their fries with their "famous" cheese sauce. The fries were sorta soggy and the cheese sauce was so thin it just sorta slipped right off the fries. The cheese sauce did taste good. This place is definitely worth a try. I will be back. read more

I have nothing to say but great things about this place. I absolutely adore the baked gnocchi, made from scratch. They are quick to resolve problems with an order; in my case tonight, one of the meals was dropped as well as the salad, on the ground, and I got them restored within 15 minutes fresh again. My favorite place in this area. I hope the owner is reading this, he knows me as the one who orders baked gnocchi with the vodka sauce and balsamic glaze dressing for the salads. Thank you for being quick to resolve issues, and always being within reason. My respects to you and your restaurant. read more

It has become our tradition to stop here after Six Flags. Best serves and awesome pizza

When I lived in NJ, I ate here once a week. The pizza is good. I prefer the thin crust Brooklyn for the classic NY style. The take out dinners are great, especially the chicken parm and Chicken vodka penne. This is one of the few pizza places that doesn't use sauce on it's pasta that tastes like an old tin can. Not too tart or too sweet. If you're watching the game with friends. Order up a pie and grilled wings combo. read more

Pizza was Okay and chicken was Okay if you like spicy food you have to try their buffalo chicken.. garlic and cheese was not that impressive. .. garlic bread was also okay... but overall a good Jersey Pizza place and prizes are good... read more

Only been here twice but both times were completely different. The first time, everything was wonderful. Nice thin crust, perfect amount of toppings, flavorful sauce, etc. Second time, sauce was bland, wrong toppings and crust was too thick and dry. I'm going to try again though bc the first time was so good! I must say they have great service, which I feel is always worth going back for!! read more

Sammy's Signature wings are the bomb! They also have gluten-free pizza crust and take great care to avoid criss-cross contamination. My husband and son loved the garlic-bread cheesesteak. read more

The wings are great! They sell pizza by the slice and it great for families. Party of 4 had a variety of things- everything was good. Recommend the Stromboli, pizza, salad, wings and pasta. read more

The only reason I didn't give this place five stars is because the wings aren't that good. They have some of the best pizza in the Mount Holly Pemberton area. Despite being a small shop they still can manage to deliver your pizza in about 30 minutes no matter what time day or where you are located. Pizza is usually pretty standard but I definitely prefer this place. I highly recommend this place to anybody who is looking to see what New Jersey pizza actually taste like. read more

New owners. Place was clean, friendly, and the food was hot. Pasta looked really good. Had the pizza and I liked it. read more

Great pizza, sandwiches, wings. Good prices. Clean. Friendly staff. Nice look inside. Easy to park. Not too busy. Quiet inside.

Hands down my favorite pizza in this area. Great sauce wit a lot of flavor and the tiniest hint of heat. The crust always has a good crunch and ingredients always seem fresh. Staff is friendly and courteous, and overall this is a great place for a slice or some takeout. read more

Absolutely not recommend this place!!! They send coupons in the mail with an expiration day and when you go to p/u they overcharge you and the owner is hiding not to give a directly answer! Being military I travel a lot and try pizza everywhere... But this Business pizza barn is a totally scam!!! I wonder... How old their food is?!? I hope this review will help some people. I wish I would see this... read more

It's not Oma's pizza in Nanzdietschweiler. but so far the best we have had in a long time. They are very accommodating and while they forgot (somewhat weird request) did say they would put an egg on the pizza. The delivery was very fast and so nice. I wish I had more cash on me to tip bigger. We will come back again. Thank you read more

First and last time eating at Pizza Barn. Worst pizza I've ever had. Ordered a white pie with broccoli, tomato, garlic, ricotta and mozzarella cheeses. Ricotta was watery, tomatoes were soggy and there was no garlic on the pizza. Also ordered a half pepperoni, half sausage pie. There was barely any sausage on the one half. My family and I will definitely not be ordering from Pizza Barn again. read more

Now called SAMMY'S Pizza Barn. Excellent Pizza, probably one of the best we have eaten. Dough is made fresh a few times a day. They will build any kind of pizza that you can imagine, so let your imagination run wild! Other dishes are equally as well prepared, salads, wings, and house specials. They have local delivery. Prices are more than reasonable. Service is excellent. I have been back twice already. read more

Wish I could rate it but on my first time ordering from them they gave me the wrong pie. I didn't realize it till I got home. I called to let them know because mistakes do happen and the young girl whom I spoke to was very rude and ignorant for no apparent reason. Her rudeness is not worth my money. read more