I will say that I haven't been here in quite awhile but they have a great Sicilian pizza... The staff has always been helpful and very friendly... You can call in your order for pickup or you can order at the counter... They also sell slices a a well as the whole pizza... There isn't any table service... If you haven't been here you should give them a try... You'll be glad you did... read more

Been going to Kate & Al's Pizza since I can remember even going to Columbus to shop the flea market outside and inside. They've got a signature way to make their pies, and it leaves you with a delicious, crunchy yet chewy crust all around. The sauce isn't super sweet, or over the top savory, just right in the middle is perfect for the swirls of mozzarella cheese all over the surface. My mouth is watering already. My in laws are a five hour drive away now, and can't get this beloved pizza any more, unless we grab one or two large boxes of joy and deliver them ourselves. If you visit the flea market, make sure you stop in for a read more

First time- dough is flavorful, sauce is perfect, plenty of high quality pepperoni. We had it yesterday and all I keep thinking about is going back today! read more

This is now on my regular rotation when I'm in the mood for thicker crust. The sauce is flavorful and can stand on its own. It's a thick layer but the crust holds up to it. It's not your typical pizza but more of a tomato pie with chunky sauce. Little bit of cheese. The crust isn't as thick as Sicilian and very light and airy. Has a nice yeasty flavor. You have to call well in advance because the wait is usually an hour. Don't forget it's cash only!! read more

I have been eating pizza as my favorite food since I was a little girl. I will be 74 in May. I can tell you that the BEST EVER PIZZA OF ALL ACROSS THE USA is Kate and Al's Pizza! Thank you for staying in business and keeping your quality the same as back in the day! You REALLY ARE THE BEST! read more

The pizza is similar to Pete's but I like the pizza here because it's a bit more saucy. The customer service is friendlier here hence the 5 stars. Definitely will be back! read more

We were little Kids when our parents took us to Columbus on a Friday night. We always had a slice and a soda before heading home. Now we are older actually in my late seventies and everyone of my sisters and brothers asked for the pizza when they visit. Now it is just us three, but I am going to get their pizza and send it my baby sister for her birthday. I will get a pie for us too. I also remember the Ferris wheel we would ride on when we were little. read more

This pizza joint has been around the Columbus Market,.. I believe since the beginning of time! But don't quote me on That. We decided to venture out in the heat today and have a slice of Happiness, but It ended Up with a nice stroll though the market and having a Happy ending lol Biting into this Pillowy slice of Deliciousness, You will be Met with the Buttery crisp CRUNCH... of their Crust! We laughed at lunch today, because trying to Write an Accurate description, H of our "Experience" sounded like more more like an Excerpt from a "Best selling Food Porn" Cookbook... lol We ordered a whole pie with half mushroom and half Pepperoni! The cheese Pull was Great and satisfying. The slices were just about Overloaded with sauce but in each bite, you are Left with plenty of sauce in each mouthful. It truly is the Perfect combination and we relaxed under the cool AC breeze at one of their tables. I Must remember to Not allow so much time to pass by before we return again to enjoy their pizza slices. Super nice people making up their pies and Remember they only accept Cash! #CashIsKing read more

Kate & Al's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, New Jersey

So I won't lie the location of the pizza place didn't give me the most hope because it's most definitely not a modern appearance... but don't let that sway you... the pizza was phenomenal...it's also CASH only so be prepared for that! The prices seemed a bit on the high end... we paid $34 for a large pizza... but yanno ... inflation... We ordered a large pizza with pepperoni, bacon and sausage! It was perfectly cooked, hot, and honestly mouth watering . I have to address that they had accidentally made an extra order and they offered 2 extra pizzas to us so that they wouldn't go to waste! We were able to feed two extra families in our neighborhood which I thought was amazing! I love that they asked if they would go to a good use instead of the trash! Overall.... This place lives us to the hype!!! I will be a repeat customer! read more

Kate and Al's Pizza is an absolute gem! Their pizza is undeniably the best in town. The secret sauce they use is a burst of flavor like no other, making every bite a delicious experience. The Sicilian pizza's fluffy texture and rich flavor left me in awe. Despite waiting an hour for our order, the taste was well worth the wait and there is plenty of things to do while you wait. I have been been coming here since I was a kid and have always loved their pizza, I'll keep coming back for more. The staff is so friendly and the pizza is unmatched, if you're looking for the best pizza around look no further, come in and dive into a delicious slice of Kate and Al's pizza. read more

Kate & Al's Pizza - Kate and Al's pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, New Jersey

See all

This pizza is amazing; always hot and fresh, just absolutely delicious! You can also call ahead to place your order too!

Seriously incredible pizza. Just the right amount of crispiness and thickness in the crust with delicious sauce and a soft cheese pull. Top notch!! read more

The best pizza around. Seriously one of a kind (other than Pete's which is in the same farmers market but down the hall). I prefer Kate & Al's at Columbus Sale! I ask for crispy and its delicious and cooked perfectly every time. Seriously cannot explain with words how delicious this pizza is. I crave it all the way from Florida! Get a red cream soda to pair with a pizza pie! yum yum yum Call or check hours before you go in! read more

Kate & Al's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, New Jersey

You know the saying "less is More " Well their Pizza is simple but Great!!! People have planned their vacation around the area just to get this Pizza. read more

Delicious pizza. Sometimes a somewhat long wait but they keep on making fresh pies. Located inside Columbus flea market.

This is my first time having 'Kate & Al's Pizza'. I have to say it's very delicious & the thickness is so yummy too. The service was great too. They also have other delicious stuff there too. Go and check it out. & Get Ya PiZZA on. You won't regret it!!! read more

Kate & Al's Pizza - Kate & Al's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, New Jersey

See all

Best NJ tomato pie. Completely underrated. I bring friends from out of state and they say the same thing. The sauce is very flavorful with the right amount of cheese which isn't too thick. The crust is spot on for texture, crunch, and buttery flavor. All of it melts in the mouth for an enjoyable experience. read more

As usual their pizza is #1 Sicilian slices. Their service is the best it gets with so many call in orders you still get your slices promptly. It's the Columbus Sale with past renovation from past fire. There are a few tables of 4 seats. read more

Kate & Al's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, New Jersey

See all

Still say they have the best tomato pie. Been buying 3 pies at a time for 40 years. 1 while you are there, 1 for the ride home, 1 for the fridge when I get home. Still haven't figured out the secret. The best! read more

Truly impeccable. The taste, the crisp and the overall deliciousness was sublime. I love a cheesy pizza so I was initially taken aback by the amount of sauce on the pies. However much to my sweet surprise, it turned out to be one of the best pizzas I've ever had. The wait for 4 slices was 20 minutes and a pie was about an hour. I opted for the 4 slices and would have waited for the pie had I known about the hype. Very limited seating indoors but in nicer weather, there are benches outside, hence my 4 stars. In fact, there were so many people standing around anxiously waiting for their orders. Maybe a large TV could have been good entertainment? Good thing is that they were fully staffed and although swamped still super friendly and treated everyone nicely. Columbus Flea Market was a treat but this place topped the cake! Sorry too delicious to post!! read more

Straight forward take out, one style , square , deep , solid sauce , lightly sprinkled cheese. Almost the same as Pete's across the parking lot, slightly sweeter sauce. Both are delicious and old school. Take 2 home now Or 1 from both and compare. Not to be missed by pizza freaks. read more

They've been making pizza here for 66 years so we decided to give it a try. Cash only spot. Paid $20 for a whole pie. Waited about 25 minutes. Delicious grandma style pie. Crust was airy and crispy. Tomato sauce was perfect. Gooey mozzarella cheese. People were nice. read more

See all

So here's the simple thing to know about this counter pizza place. If you want a plain slice you will get it pretty quickly. If you want pepperoni in it, forget that, they make you buy a 5 slice half pie. Like putting 2 pieces of pepperoni on your slice is at least a 30 minute wait. At least, I think we waited 34 minutes while dozens of plain slices were handed out to whoever wanted them. They take call in orders also so expect to see like 10 empty boxes on top of the ovens with names written on them that they fill one at a time.(Including your half piece order if you ask for pepperoni on a couple slices) Would take them 1 seconds to just add some to a plain slice and toss it in the oven for a minute but whatever. It's hillbilly nonsense going on at this place. The pizza is pretty decent once you get it. Wet and sloppy but that's their style. This place is in a dirt mall type flea market setting so don't expect more than no frills.examole- instead of dollar store toppings shakers they took old empty baby food jars, drilled a hole in the cap and fill them with hot pepper flakes or oregano or whatever. Made it look extra stingy for no reason, like just walk a few stalls down and buy actual shakers in the flea market. Anyway Pres gives them a 7.4, I'm going 7.2 for the 34 minute wait for 5 pieces of pepperoni added to 2 slices. read more

Kate and Al's has a reputation for great pizza. It's not your classic pizza but a unique style of square pan pizza reminiscent of the famous L&B in Brooklyn. The place is located inside the Columbus Farmers market and is takeout only. There are 2 long picnic benches just outside the door where you can sit and enjoy. They primarily sell full and half pies but no matter how you slice it (pun intended) it will run you $2.50 a slice. It's also cash only. The pizza is never greasy and the sauce is made just right and not salty or sweet. I recommend ordering ahead or placing an order and walking around the market because it's typically 45 minutes or more for a pie or half pie. read more

See all

It was worth the drive to the market just for the pizza. Wish it was closer to me so I could have more often read more

See all

we love Kate & Al's. Pizza is Great. Better than Pete's IMO. I have heard the Breakfast pizza is good but haven't gotten there in time to get some. read more

The very best! I'm a 30 year old man who has been eating this pizza for 20 years! It never never waivers away from the same great taste. There's a reason people call their pies in first thing in the morning. It's THAT GOOD. read more

Kate and Als always delivers a a primo tomato pie,been customers for last seven years since we moved here. Never disappoints!

Delicious, doughy, chunky tomato, Trento tomato style pie. You must not miss experiencing this pie. Awesome, as usual. A completely different tomato pie experience. read more

Who comes all the way to a flea market in Columbus, NJ for pizza?? Well apparently a ton of people do - because if you happen to be here on a Friday night there is not just a wait for pizza, but they literally run out altogether! As other Yelpes mention, just get a whole pie. I know what you are thinking, I too was once naive like you and thought, but what if I don't like that strange saucy concoction? What if I need more cheese? Listen, don't be a fool, get the pie - thank me later. I have been to the best places in the world for pizza - NYC, Chicago, Italy and let me tell you - this is great freaking pizza. They make it in cake pans, so the dough is fluffy and light, but with a crispy edge from where the cheese melts. The tomato sauce can only be described as laced with unicorn dust and an old Italian mother's spit - it is so damn good. For people complaining about customer service - this is a literal flea market pizzeria in south jersey - not the Hilton - just order, pay and enjoy. I am only sad that it took me this long to actually come here. read more

I love coming here for their pizza because my boyfriend craves it every time and it makes him happy. The pizza is very fresh and the tomato sauce is so sweet and good. We got the pepperoni and sausage pizza. We called in advance as it can take up to 30 mins for your order to be ready. This makes sense because they have to prepare it fresh so I recommend to call early. The pizza is pretty pricey as the whole box cost about $28 and they only take cash. Lastly, the service is ok. If I'm in the area, I will get the pizza otherwise I don't crave it that much. read more

Kate & Al's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, New Jersey

So, this is kind of difficult for me to say definitively but I think this might be my favorite pizza. If not, it is surely in my Top 3. Let me start by saying that this is nothing I take lightly (I have a pizza tattoo). The only other job I've ever had was working at a pizza place. If I had my way, I'd eat pizza every day. This is one of the most unique pizzas I have ever had and there really isn't much to say besides it is absolutely phenomenal and I would even go as far as to say this should be a pizza destination akin to Santillo's in Elizabeth. I suppose of you don't enjoy Sicilian style pizza the. It may not be for you but if you are discriminating against different styles of pizza then I would ask "Do you even pizza, bro?" The answer is probably no. I think what makes this place so great aside from the fact that it is delicious, is that it embodies a simplicity and consistency that is hard to find elsewhere. I really get the impression that their whole operation is one of constant repetitions like how Larry Bird practiced free throws. I love this pizza and I will eat an ungodly amount of it every time I get the opportunity. read more

Delicious pizza, only issue I have is they act like you are bothering them whenever you try and put in an order. Yes there are two of us, yes we want 6 slices. What is the issue? You sell 1 thing. read more

We've been going to Kate & Al's all my life! Best tomato pie ever! We get it well done, extra cheese and mushrooms! Always an enjoyable treat. Order by phone, it takes an hour or so to cook. Worth the trip, never a disappointment! Five read more

They have the best pizza ever I'm in my 50's that was the first pizza my mom gave me when I was a baby an it's my favorite now Thank U For Being Here read more

My favorite pizza spot! They NEVER disappoint! A 40 min wait but the secret is to call and order and they will give you a time for pickup. Everyone there is super sweet and always friendly no matter how hectic it is. I love that! read more

Kate & Al's Pizza - Large Pie - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, New Jersey

There's a rivalry between people who like Kate & Al's vs. Pete's Pizza. I can't be the judge of that feud just yet. I can't seem to eat at any other stand but this one. Slices are $2.25. I can tell you now, it makes much more sense to buy a pie. It's addictive and you'll be upset for not doing so. This pizza is mind blowingly simple. Tomatoe Sauce, Cheese, Crust. Why is it so good? The old square pans they use, is my thought. This is the only Sicilian style pie that's managed to have a thin buttery crust, pillowy dough, and a layer of sauce with cheese that isn't heavy. I've easily eaten a pie myself. Yes, it's that good. If you're looking to have toppings the only way to snag them is on a pie. Luckily, you can call them up and order a pie before you pick it up. This place does lack in service when they get busy and it's cash only. read more

Kate & Al's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, New Jersey

See all

Holy overhyped mediocre pizza! Made the trip here after all the rave. It's really nothing to rave about. I've had frozen pizza about the same if not better. read more

You look at this pie and think that's the ugliest pizza I've ever seen. It can't be any good. Then you look at the line to get it or the wait to pick up and think we'll its gotta have something to it. Then you taste it and ...well you will be a fan for life. This is hands down the best tasting tomatoe pie I have ever had.Everyone I've turned on to this pie says the same thing. Don't let looks fool you. Go get you sum of this. Lol . You won't regret it. Remember Tomatoe pie. read more

My husband and the kids love the pizza from Kate&Al's. It is kind of like a deep dish pizza, I've tried it as well and it's pretty good. It is tasty, crunchy but soft, it is really good. They are really busy, every time we call we get a weird time to pick up, we are not from the area so usually we would call 1-2 hours before the time we would pick up but they would have 4-5 hours from the time we called. So we decided to call right when they open and put in our order for the afternoon. They do not accept credit cards, so if you are in the Columbus/Bordertown area and want to eat some good pizza stop by Kate & Al's and make sure you bring cash with you. Also, they are located in the flea market area. read more